15 Terrible Mistakes That Almost Ruined Grand Theft Auto

17 years of GTA doesn't come without some close calls.

By Jack Pooley /

The Grand Theft Auto series has come a long way since its origins in 1997 as a low-res, top-down shooter: last year's Grand Theft Auto V, though not quite delivering the online mode we were hoping for, served up the sandbox genre at its most hilarious, intelligent and insane, and there's little doubt that Rockstar are already hard at work planning the sixth game in the series (which will hopefully be set in Vice City). As awesome as the series has been, it's hard to escape the truth that there are several aspects (in fact, 15) of the GTA franchise which aren't so great, and very nearly ruined our enjoyment entirely. This relates to broken promises made by Rockstar, controversial content accidentally left in the game's code, the series' most annoying missions, unexpected and unnecessary full-frontal male nudity, absurd micro-management of your character and plenty more. Whether honest mistakes or attempts to challenge gamers and change-up the gameplay, these aspects of the gameplay fell totally flat and just left gamers irritated. As brilliantly consistent as the series is on the whole, even it isn't free from criticism, and had these 15 issues been rectified, the GTA series would be flying even higher than it already is. Here are 15 terrible mistakes that almost ruined GTA for everyone.

15. The (Continued) Wait For Heists (GTA V)

When GTA Online launched on October 1st of last year, Rockstar made it clear beforehand that it wouldn't be launching with the hugely anticipated heist missions, which would be patched in at a later date. Still, the months passed by and players heard little from the developer on how heists were progressing, and after a projected spring 2014 release date came and went without the patch arriving, players quickly began to lose interest and moved onto other games. It's now almost exactly a year since GTA Online kicked off, and heists are nowhere to be seen, with it being widely expected that they may launch with the next-gen remastered edition of GTA V hitting stores in November (though if this is true, Rockstar is downplaying it). If that date passes and heists still haven't arrived, then Rockstar screwed up even worse than gamers thought: what could possibly be taking them so long to get the mode right? The sad thing is that, now that the PS4 takes pride of place in many gamers' homes, they might not be too keen to get their PS3 out again to play heists when they're finally out, considering that most people won't be buying the remastered edition.

14. Hot Coffee Mod (GTA: San Andreas)

Easily one of the most controversial moments in GTA's history was the discovery of the "Hot Coffee" mini-game in San Andreas. Hackers managed to discover the mini-game, which involves the player controlling CJ as he has sex with one of his girlfriends, by examining the game's code and altering some data: apparently Rockstar could not just erase the mini-game because some of its assets were used in other parts of the game. Instead, they simply hid it and didn't count on enterprising tech wizards discovering it. The release of the Hot Coffee mod, which activates the mini-game, proved highly controversial, and Rockstar got further egg on their face when they claimed that significant changes had been made by the hackers to access the mini-game, though when the hackers were able to patch the console versions to access it as well, this was proven totally wrong. The ESRB eventually changed the game's rating in the U.S. and Canada to "Adults Only", prompting Rockstar to cease manufacturing it and re-release a version with Hot Coffee completely unavailable. Given the poor quality of the mini-game in the first place, it really all wasn't worth Rockstar's hassle, and all they did was attract more negative attention onto themselves, even if it naturally had no impact on the franchise's popularity whatsoever.

13. "It's Roman, Let's Go Bowling" (GTA IV)

One of the most infuriating aspects of the GTA series is the fact that, in GTA IV, it seems like players can't go more than about 15 minutes without protagonist Niko's cousin Roman calling him and asking him to go bowling. More irritating than anything else is that, despite the other activities Niko and Roman can partake in, such as going to a bar or playing pool, Roman most commonly wants to bowl and nothing else, yet given how mundane GTA IV's bowling mini-game is, the usual response is to decline. Plus, Roman always seems to call at the most inappropriate and ridiculous of times: if Niko's just murdered an entire fleet of cops, does he really want to blow off steam bowling? Furthermore, why is Roman so keen to spend time away from his girlfriend, Mallorie? Gamers everywhere wanted to like Roman, but the guy does himself no favours: his desperation is incredibly annoying.

12. Wrong Side Of The Tracks (GTA: San Andreas)

The San Andreas mission Wrong Side of the Tracks involves getting on a motorbike with Big Smoke, chasing a train and allowing Big Smoke to shoot all the Vagos gang members who are on it. Sound simply enough, right? Nope. This is easily one of the most challenging and infuriating missions in the GTA series, as it's incredibly easy to lose the train and fail, at which point you'll be berated by Big Smoke, who will shout, "All we had to do was follow the damn train, CJ!", which has become something of an Internet meme. The frequent likelihood of failure combined with Big Smoke's ridiculous put-down makes this an infuriating mission any way you cut it, and detracts hugely from what clearly should have been an awesome, action-packed set-piece.

11. Tom Stubbs' Dong (GTA: The Lost & Damned)

Tom Stubbs is a Liberty City politician who The Lost & Damned's protagonist Johnny Klebitz works for throughout the game, though easily the most memorable thing about him is that he appears nude briefly during a cut-scene. Johnny meets him while he's having a massage, and after he sends the masseuse on her way, Rockstar frames the scene so that, thankfully, players can't see Stubbs' genitalia, though are well aware that he's naked. This is teased for the entire scene, but at the end of the conversation, players get an eyeful of Stubbs' birthday suit, as his member flaps around on screen for a whole 15 seconds, complete with a creepy pelvic thrust at the end. Though clearly done for comic effect, did anyone really feel the need to see this? It was just Rockstar trying to push the envelope a little for the sake of shock value, and to their credit, it certainly worked.

10. No Bikes Or Helicopters (GTA III)

The leap to 3D with the series' ground-breaking Grand Theft Auto III caused a surge in popularity and resulted in numerous clones attempting to ape the GTA formula, yet none have managed to better it. Brilliantly innovative though GTA III was, it was certainly lacking in a few areas, with one of the biggest disappointments being the lack of motorcycles and helicopters. Though both of these omissions were due to technological limitations, the lack of bikes was comically referenced in the Liberty City Stories manual, where it's mentioned that motorcycles were banned in Liberty City at this time. Helicopters, meanwhile, do appear during intense police chases, though the player cannot control any without modding the game. Given how much GTA III got right, it's a shame Rockstar couldn't go the extra mile and include something as rudimentary as bikes. Furthermore, as the flying cars cheat and Dodo were already in the game, would it really have been a huge stretch to include helicopters? At the time, it certainly felt like Rockstar were intentionally holding things back to give the next game more of a selling point, but boy, did they deliver with Vice City or what? The sheer joy of riding a bike while gunning down your enemies as Michael Jackson's Billie Jean blares out cannot be understated.

9. Stamina, Muscle & Fat (GTA: San Andreas)

One of the more ambitious additions to the franchise with San Andreas was the concept of character-based stats, and though some of these, such as Sex Appeal, Weapon Skill and Respect were non-intrusive enough, there's three big ones which ultimately proved quite irritating throughout the game: stamina, muscle and fat. Stamina is gained by performing exercise, which will then allow CJ to run for longer, muscle is built up through going to the gym and makes attacks more powerful, while eating at Cluckin' Bell, Burger Shot or Well Stacked Pizza will build up your fat, which will then decrease over time. Though it's cool to have the option to make CJ look notably different, the busy work involved with his upkeep ultimately isn't worth it: it's incredibly bothersome to want to start the next mission but, with CJ's stomach growling every few minutes, you need to take care of that first. Thankfully Rockstar realised how obtrusive to the core gameplay this was and toned it down for the subsequent games, with muscle and fat being left out entirely.

8. Race 'n' Chase

Did you know that Grand Theft Auto was originally conceived as a game called Race 'n' Chase? In addition to this, the game initially allowed players to choose between playing as the criminal or a cop, though through the development process, it eventually morphed into the 1997 title known as GTA. Needless to say, the title and the choice to play as a cop were certainly two terrible mistakes that very nearly ruined GTA for us...but thankfully DMA Design (now Rockstar North) had the sense to change them. For starters, Race 'n' Chase sounds like the sort of video game that GTA would satirically advertise on one of its radio stations, and allowing us to play as the cop would have diluted the demented sense of fun in having no choice but to play as a trigger-happy rogue. Empathy with the enemy is the last thing players want in a game like this, and having this dual narrative would probably have detracted from the iconic status of the series' greatest protagonists like Tommy, CJ, Niko and Trevor.

7. Mute Claude (GTA III)

Talking of series protagonists, there's one main character who's just a bore, and of course, that's Claude from GTA III. Though he helped usher in the 3D era of the franchise, he's also the dullest and most forgettable of the protagonists from that point, largely due to the fact that little is known about his past (despite his making a cameo appearance in San Andreas) and, well, he's entirely mute throughout all of his appearances in the series. After the characterisation of the protagonists took such an upswing in personality in Vice City (where Tommy Vercetti was superbly voiced by Ray Liotta), it's painful to go back to GTA III and watch Claude nodding his head and moving on with the next mission without saying a word. Granted, GTA III was so ridiculously ambitious that Rockstar can be forgiven for not giving Claude a voice, but it completely stripped his character of any charm whatsoever, sorely lacking what the later games delivered in spades.

6. The Torture Controversy (GTA V)

Easily the most controversial mission in GTA V is By the Book, in which Michael is tasked with assassinating a man the FIB claims is linked to terrorism, while Trevor is made to torture Mr K to discern the man's whereabouts. As Trevor, the player is able to water-board Mr. K, beat him with a wrench, give him electric shocks and remove a tooth with pliers, which can cause him to go into cardiac arrest, at which point the player must deliver an adrenaline shot to resurrect him. Eventually Mr. K will direct players to a beach house, where Michael must use Mr. K's description of the man's appearance to assassinate him. The mission proved hugely contentious because of the perceived glamorisation of torture, and even though the mission is clearly a satirical swipe at the American government's own attitude to torture (especially considering it's heavily implied you end up killing an innocent man), it needlessly rustled up tired controversy about the series' approach to violence that every gamer has heard 1000 times already. It's not a bad mission by any means, and the Conservative media are more to blame than anyone, but it's only provocative in the most lazy and cynical of ways. Does the satirical content compensate for the brutality of the mission? You decide.

5. GTA Advance

The only GTA game to date not to be developed by Rockstar, Grand Theft Auto Advance is a rather limp attempt to shove GTA into the handheld market (though 2009's GTA: Chinatown Wars achieved this much more comfortably), and releasing it on the same day as San Andreas was a move that, if nothing else, totally backfired. Returning to the top-down view of the earlier GTA games, it's permissible that the game was never going to have stunning graphics, but even so, they look insanely rudimentary for a 2004 GBA game, the driving controls are especially infuriating, and the music sucks. Sure, the gameplay is still fun to a point, but Rockstar's lack of input is painfully apparent throughout, resulting in an unpolished final product that squandered its serious promise, ensuring it's easily the worst game in the franchise. The game does have its fans, and the reviews weren't totally awful, but in comparison to everything else in the series, it seems lazy and cheap.

4. No Planes (GTA IV)

GTA III introduced planes into the franchise with the notoriously difficult-to-pilot Dodo, before Vice City and San Andreas added planes that didn't crash shortly after take-off. Curious it was, then, that GTA IV didn't allow players to fly any planes whatsoever, despite the code apparently existing within the game to do so. Rockstar commented that Liberty City's map was just too small (which is a whole other problem in of itself) to facilitate the flying of a plane, much to the chagrin of just about any GTA nut. With the series making its seventh-generation debut, fans couldn't wait to get their hands on some jet-planes to surge through a shiny new Liberty City at lightning speed, but players had to settle for piloting a helicopter to get their picturesque views of the metropolis. Given how the map still wasn't exactly tiny, this felt like a cop-out on the part of Rockstar, who at least saw the error of their ways and made a big deal out of planes in GTA V.

3. Manny Escuela (GTA IV)

There is no character in the GTA franchise more irritating than Manny Escuela, an ex-con apparently devoted to cleaning up Liberty City, though in actual fact he turned out to be an opportunist looking to make a name for himself by having a cameraman film his do-gooding throughout the game. Almost every character he comes across, including Niko, appears to find him obnoxious and irritating, and given how he couldn't go about 5 seconds without saying "the streets", there was a deep player desire for him to meet a grisly end. Thankfully that comes to fruition when Manny attempts to humiliate drug kingpin Elizabeta Torres, yet after snorting a line of coke, she nonchalantly shoots Manny and his cameraman Jay in the head, before paying Niko to take their bodies to a black market organ trader. Hilariously, Niko finally remarks of Manny, "He'd been trying to help the streets his whole life...maybe he'll be actually doing it now." After presenting such an annoying character to players, Rockstar owed it to them to deliver a suitably grisly, comical end for Manny, and quite that they delivered.

2. GTA Online Was A Huge Disappointment (GTA V)

A year later, how many people who dipped their toes in GTA Online are still playing it? The answer: not many. After the server woes of the mode's launch in its first week, players finally signed into the game hoping that Rockstar's much shouted about online offering would live up to its insane promise, and found themselves tremendously disappointed at the shocking lack of content. In addition to most of the missions being overly similar and boring, hackers made minced meat out of the game's mechanics, the party system sucked, the game essentially punished players for shooting others, and making any significant progress was a dull grind. That's without even mentioning the lack of heists... In fairness, GTA V would have easily been worth the money even if there was no GTA Online to speak of, but when Rockstar hyped it up so heavily and failed to deliver, it somewhat knocked consumer confidence in the developer. After measuring up almost every time they went up to bat, for the online mode to fall so flat and still not function properly a year later was extremely disappointing, and a reminder that even the mightiest talents are capable of abject failure.

1. Supply Lines (GTA: San Andreas)

Regarded by the majority of hardcore GTA fans as the hardest mission in the history of the franchise, Supply Lines is a mission undertaken for RC Zero, in which CJ pilots a miniature plane to destroy five courier vans belonging to Zero's enemy Berkley. What makes the mission so challenging is that fuel is extremely limited, and if you run out, the mission is failed, so players must think about the quickest route to each of the couriers, and also attempt to glide wherever possible to avoid wasting precious fuel. Thankfully the mission is optional, but if you're absolutely dead set on scoring 100% completion, this is easily the most infuriating thing standing in your way. Anyone who's played through it has probably spent at least an hour or two trying to beat it, and if not, well, you're probably lying. Are there any other hiccups which nearly ruined GTA for you? Shout it out in the comments!