16 Biggest Video Game Plot Twists Of The Decade (So Far)

Five years of mind-shattering rug-pulls and table-turning reveals - which one totally blew your mind?

By Scott Tailford /

So far the newest generation of consoles hasn't been the best at putting all that graphical might into creating intricately designed plots purpose-built to pull the rug out from under you at the last second - but it's definitely something gaming can arguably do better than film when the appropriate amount of care is put in. Being that you're the one behind the controls and it's you who's dead-centre as things kick off either in-game or cutscene, it makes for some hugely impactful and resonant moments you'll carry forever - especially when they centre around loveable characters like Final Fantasy VII's Aeris', for example. In looking at the best of the decade so far, there's been some fantastic games, some immensely disappointing ones and a bucketload of fantastic moments across scores of titles that made for many a discussion across forums, classrooms and work spaces worldwide. What of those glorious plot twists though? There's nothing quite like having your world turned upside down at the last second, especially when a developer has managed to string you along in exactly the right direction. They say you author your own experience in video games thanks to being able to get through and interact with levels in a myriad of ways, but when the best creative minds are behind the puppet-strings, you won't see what they've got planned until the very last second. Note: Naturally, spoilers will follow.

16. Ramsay Snow Kills Ethan Forrester - Telltale's Game Of Thrones

The most recent on the list - and one that hopefully won't annoy too many Thrones fans, as chances are if you're a G.R.R. Martin obsessive, you've already picked up and played through at least the first episode of Telltale's latest dialogue-driven adventure. As soon as the former Walking Dead-developer announced they'd be relocating to Westeros for this string of episodic titles you could tell there were going to be plenty of shocking moments and grey-area choices to make. However one of the most shocking comes at the close of the first episode, where after going toe-to-toe with Cersei in the throne room, you must then attempt to negotiate a deal with Ramsay Snow (essentially known as 'The New Joffrey' in terms of how much people love to hate him). It's not until Ramsay attempts to leave that you have the option to get in the way of him dragging one of your sisters alongside, and it's then that he counters by stabbing young Ethan right in the neck, his last moments also being the end of the pilot episode. Gruesome. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-HXu-aFiaY#t=415

15. Reznov Isn't Real - Call Of Duty: Black Ops

Black Ops' story is actually one that's pretty remarkably effective, especially for a Call of Duty game. Co-written by the Blade franchise-killing David S. Goyer, Blops (as it's known) elected to tell a tale of one agent Mason, your protagonist who kept being asked about a series of numbers yet couldn't place what they were - instead all he remembered was a series of missions and one Viktor Reznov who appeared in all of them. Some say the twist that Reznov continues on as a figment of your imagination is obvious if you're paying attention to how any NPC only ever greets Mason despite him being present, but for the vast majority of people when the trippy ending sequence started playing out and Mason's memories clashed with the expository "All is not what it seems" nature of the script, this was a fantastic new direction for the franchise that sadly petered out with the bangs n' whistles of Blops 2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3tk4zVuhy-I

14. It's All In Your Head - Hotline Miami

Well, most of it is anyway, as throughout Devolver Digital's fantastically ultra-violent tale of what appears to be one man answering encrypted phone calls, only to then butcher rooms of people at a time - it's all revealed this is inside his mind. It's quite the mind-blowing twist - literally - as when character Jacket find out, his mind does actually pop, giving you a very visually-arresting shot, before the game resumes with you in a hospital bed. From there you'll do a couple of levels in the real world, finding out the origins of those mysterious phone calls that set everything in motion (meaning your character entered the coma halfway through the game) and eventually letting you solve the mystery, providing you'd amassed some secret collectibles that open up a different dialogue option at the very end. Fans to this day debate what's really going on in Hotline's final few scenes, but either way you slice it the whole 'it was all a dream' ending hasn't been done with anywhere near this much weight and purpose in decades.

13. Scott Shelby Is The Killer - Heavy Rain

Providing you could get past the French-cast-does-American-accents nature of the voice work, David Cage's Heavy Rain let you engage in a fantastic murder mystery tale that actually had a whole slew of multiple endings and scene branches, depending on who or what you interacted with. One such thing that didn't go down with the majority though, was the reveal that playable character - and Private Detective on the case - Scott Shelby was actually the Origami Killer all along; meaning he'd been on the trail of his own handiwork the whole time. Fans have theorised that he was helping parents of the victims to see if they remained changed people for the better following what he'd done to the victims, but it's up to you whether or not someone right under your nose being the killer is either jaw-dropping or cheap - it's gone down as very memorable either way. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nhdfBIh4XFQ

12. Everyone Dies, Shao Kahn Wins, Fatality - Mortal Kombat (2011)

This is getting an entry as even though the 'plot twist' is right at the start of the campaign, it's a total doozy that got developers NetherRealm out of a tight spot when it came to their story at the close of MK: Apocalypse (that is to say, everyone looked to be roadkill). Instead, future Raiden essentially pulls a Days of Future Past/Ultron-style manoeuvre and transports his consciousness (or enough of it to make some decisions anyway) back into his younger body, essentially letting the developer 'reboot' their older levels and character designs whilst telling a story that was rooted in looking forward. It was a genius move, as not only did fights and cutscenes all blend into one to provide a brilliant pace throughout, but you got to see all the older, originally 2D-designed fighters brought up to scratch. How MK X's plot is going to top that is the question every fan is looking to be answered come April. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7ZFxfb-j7Y

11. The Boss Is An A.I. - Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker

Part of devoting so much time and effort to making sure a portable MGS could stand toe to toe with the big boy console versions was also to write a suitably ridiculous story alongside, and thankfully creator Hideo Kojima didn't skimp out. As any who have played MGS 3: Snake Eater can attest, The Boss is a brilliant character who's ramifications in the lore set many pivotal things in motion, not to mention her death scene being one of the most moving in gaming history. So it was a bit strange then - to the player and Snake himself - to hear her talking again on a recording at the start of sequel, Peace Walker. This eventually turns out to be nothing more than a very elaborately programmed A.I., custom-built to replicate The Boss' mind in order to delve further into the motivations she had for defecting during MGS 3. The whackiest part comes when the A.I. (essentially The Boss mk.2) gains sentience of some sort thanks to being imbued with the same patriotic tendencies of its subject (just go with it), and ends up drowning itself whilst playing The Carpenter's "Sing" to prevent further destruction.And they say Metal Gear has gotten too crazy for its own good.

10. Haytham And His Order Are Templars - Assassin's Creed III

AC III was the first major misstep in a franchise that was already starting to outstay it's yearly-appearances with AC: Revelations, and it didn't help that after all the advertising showing you'd be playing as a bow n' arrow'd up badass Connor amongst the American Civil War, instead there was a good hour or so devoted to embodying Haytham Kenway - a very regal Englishman who appeared to be an Assassin. Obviously 'appeared to be' was the choice phrase, as this was the game where Ubisoft decided to open the floodgates and essentially say that anyone could be an Assassin - so close was the fight between both they and the Templars, that the latter had taken to adopting their practices in combat to the point where they moved and operated exactly the same. Cut to before you find all this out and the game's way of breaking it to you is to throw up an Achievement called 'How D'ya Like Them Apples?' right after you presume you're watching a new member of the Assassin's order being welcomed. It's a brilliant scene and marked a high point for Ubisoft's writing when it came to establishing these two world-dominating forces - just a shame there's not been anything as memorable on a narrative level since. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tXIc5KSZrH4

9. "There's Another One In My..." - Metal Gear Solid: Ground Zeroes

The jury's out on whether the new, far more serious and controversial direction Kojima is taking Metal Gear Solid is too much considering the tone of the previous games, and if you want a fast-track to having an opinion on whether some things just shouldn't be made real - it's the idea of an explosive forcibly inserted inside a woman's lady-parts. See, the story of Ground Zeros and Phantom Pain is going to focus a lot on torture and the gratification it can bring to the person enacting it - something GTA V attempted before falling flat on its face. So in GZ, not only do you have the fact that character Paz was raped by another called Skull Face (who presumably placed the bomb inside her afterwards) but the scene where this is revealed actually starts with Snake and his crew having to remove another explosive from in between her intestines - the camera getting in as close as possible. Sexual abuse, torture and rape are about as sensitive as subjects come, and if you stick a pin in how 'appropriate' these things are handled by Kojima and co. in game, the very fact that it all plays out so harshly still leaves quite the imprint on your psyche afterwards. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZmb6oQuTjY#t=432

8. Booker Is Comstock - Bioshock: Infinite

Plenty will say they saw this one coming - not because there's anything that necessarily gives it away throughout the game, but because like any series predicated on big plot twists happening in every instalment, it serves to make fans and newcomers alike try and guess the craziest thing that could possibly happen. Well, with Bioshock: Infinite, things got pretty damn crazy. There's plenty philosophical mumbo jumbo and emotionally heavy moments to wade through when describing all of Infinite's many twists and turns, but the main one you need to know is between two specific parallel universes. In one, a major event in Booker DeWitt's life caused him to become a rather large racist, a pivotal moment that eventually leads to him taking off into the clouds in an idyllic version of America, whilst the Booker you play as remained. It's all a bit mental (and there's a good wealth of plot being skipped over to summarise here), but especially in relation to infinite strings of universes all tied by lighthouses and specific people, Ken Levine's final dip in the Bio-pool was one deep enough to keep fans talking for years. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=55SrSqufeH0

7. The Citadel A.I. Controls The Reapers - Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3's ending has been roundly trounced so many times that it's hard to think of new ways to lampoon it, shy of just muttering a collection of consonants and carrying on - so why not focus not on the disappointment of thousands, but what the reveal of The Catalyst/Star Child/Intelligence meant for the ME universe? Coming at the end point of both the trilogy and assumedly all life in the galaxy's time as the Reaper invasion was set to wipe every planet clean one by one all over again, Commander Shepard needed a win, and although the collective might of the galaxy's races was building a weapon called the Crucible, how it worked and what it was going to do was a mystery. So come the final invasion of Earth and the playing out of some final villainous beats from an indoctrinated Illusive Man, you're then greeted not by a gigantic control console with a giant, flashing 'Kill Reapers Now' button - instead it's a chat with a long-dormant A.I. that throws out three drastically different (in theory) ending possibilities. What happens during this conversation and particularly after as the explosions amount to nothing more than a few palette-swaps is what etched ME3 into the gaming history books as one of the worst creative decisions of all time, but forgetting that for a second, the very idea of interfacing with a galaxy-saving A.I. that straight up lays out the controls for all life as you know it is pretty damn huge.

6. There Is No Pilot - The Fall

A hidden gem from last year if ever there was one, indie dev Over The Moon's first game in what will eventually be a trilogy knocked it right out the park, only to lap a few nearby planets and return the shot all over again. The Fall is absolutely encapsulating as both its initial concept, the execution and finally the head-knocker of a final twist that makes you wish both Steam and the console storefronts would promote these kinds of titles more. Gameplay-wise it's hardly as mechanically tight as something like Shadow Complex or The Swapper, but it's the narrative that'll keep you hooked. See, the whole game has you playing as an A.I. controlling a combat suit, your pilot having just fallen from space and who is now unconscious. Following this, the majority of the game is spent trying to get your systems back online - the endgame being to rescue the hapless human within. Except he's not human - there is no such thing, you're just an A.I. trained to think you're protecting one, making for all manner of discussions around the various bits of dialogue that address the world and an eery sensation come the close of the game when your suit has just had its head blown off and you're left wondering exactly what the hell is going on until it all clicks back into place. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gji-J3xdWpk

5. Andy Serkis Is Brainwashing Mankind - Enslaved: Odyssey To The West

Recently showing up in another of the site's lists about the best romances in video games, Andy Serkis and Lindsey Shaw's portrayal of brawler-with-a-heart Monkey and the feisty Trip is one of the last generation's most shiny underrated gem. Not only were some of the set-pieces downright jaw-dropping throughout, but the game's script (having been written by 28 Days Later-scribe Alex Garland) took a pretty unique twist on the post-apocalyptic genre. By going half-Matrix and half-Mad Max in it's disparate final moments, you get a trippy scene come the close of the game where a face-to-face meet with the real Andy Serkis details how all the slaves of the destroyed world before you are actually engulfed in a trance, consumed by memories of what we'd now call the present day. Trip ends up destroying the machine assumedly to force everyone to come to terms with the new world around them, but it's that first reveal where you see the real Serkis on a Fortress of Solitude-sized screen that'll totally blow your mind. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPk-cwMqDSQ

4. You Get To Kill Edgar Ross - Red Dead Redemption

Although John Marston dying was one of the most shocking moments in recent memory, you could foreshadow something bad was coming the second Rockstar insisted you keep playing out the role of the 'happy farmer' following the end of so many bloodshed-filled missions. Instead after this event plays out, the really incredible thing that sticks in the mind (arguably more) is switching control to John's son, and being able to track down the backstabbing Edgar Ross, whilst also killing his family if you chose to. The best thing about this revenge kick is it's all of your own volition - you choose to journey back to Blackwater under the assumption he'll still be working there, and you're the one who has to get a bead on his location by talking to a string of family members - eventually finding him fishing peacefully by a river. Naturally Ross doesn't pull any punches when it comes to whether or not you should actually go through with the killing, and ventilating him with an entire chamber of your revolver only to watch the body fly backwards in slow motion is easily one of the greatest sequences and plot-resolutions in history - not to mention the realisation of the game's very title right there and then. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VU1vbPbm9r4

3. There Was Always More Than One Joker - Batman: Arkham City

Rocksteady have clearly been watching some Christopher Nolan flicks, as although the Clown Prince's death was included as one of the Best Moments Of The Decade (So Far), Arkham City featured him far less as the over-animated, maniacally laughing psychopath, and more a sputtering near-death husk of a man that occasionally still appeared to be in the best of spirits. It was all a ruse of course, meant to get you questioning how at one moment he could look completely fine and the next be back to coughing his guts up. The answer? More than one Joker, with the second being played by Clayface, seemingly just for the sake of it. The reveal is handled brilliantly, flashing up images of the more incapacitated Joker just as his monologue is mentioning hiding something "Right under nose." Batman realises at the exact moment you do just what's been going on, and from there on in it's a boss battle for the ages, followed by one of the most pivotal moments in Batman history if Rocksteady stick to leaving Joker dead throughout all of Arkham Knight. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6W27Zkh9lng#t=436

2. Konrad Was A Hallucination - Spec-Ops: The Line

Although 2013 felt like the year indie titles really came into their own, 2012's Spec-Ops was one of the first games to take a more indie-tinged focus on narrative choice and apply it to a Gears of War-styled military shooter. The thing with Spec-Ops was it didn't look all too inviting - at face value it was 'just another shooter', although for those that scratched away at the surface they found a brilliant Apocalypse Now-style tale of a soldier behind enemy lines who's slowly lost his mind. However, the big reveal at the close of the game wasn't necessarily about Konrad, the person you were hunting. Instead it's revealed that although he was real, the version you've been in contact with throughout a substantial amount of the game was a manifestation of your own psyche, with Konrad appearing to be more ruthless and hellbent on killing the more you became. Many flashback scenes reveal that the team you were with never came into contact with Konrad, and your character Captain Walker's descent into madness is shown everywhere from the game's loading screen text to the brutality of his melee kills. With Konrad being a hallucination of the worst parts of Walker's determination to succeed despite his mistakes in an intense war zone, the game ends with you choosing whether or not to kill him, one of the following scenes letting you then slaughter the rescue team that arrives, assuming the position Konrad was in before the game had even begun. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lauUirttVhs

1. Joel's The Bad Guy (Or Is He?) - The Last Of Us

The whole 'hero becomes the villain' trope is something that's pretty hard to make believable at the best of times, let alone when you've been embodying a certain 'hero' for hours on end, only to be forced into reanalysing everything beforehand. Luckily TLoU's twist is one you partake in, under the guise of saving character Ellie that you (hopefully) built a strong connection with throughout the course of the game. The great thing is plenty of titles have asked you to save a character from impending doom, but when it happens in Naughty Dog's masterpiece you'll walk up to the 'hostage takers' (surgeons) in question, only for the prompt to violently slice one of their throats, leading to you playing out the final scene slightly unaware of what side of the moral coin you're on. The game flips to cutscene as Joel executes another wounded main character, only to then jump ahead an hour or so with the aftermath of the escape still up for debate. The biggest twist comes here and at the close of the game, as Joel neglects to tell the previously unconscious Ellie of her purpose being the potential saviour of humanity, instead letting his selfish need for companionship (if you view it that way) take precedence over her death. The fact the game just presents you with these actions - half-played and half-watched - is a stroke of genius, and the cut to black solidifies its impact as you're left watching the credits forever wondering what side you're on in Joel and Ellie's context, and what you would've done given the same situation.Are there any other huge plot twists that blew your mind since 2010? Let us know in the comments!