20 Most Important Gaming Deaths This Decade

They may not have proved satisfying to everyone, but they're pretty much impossible to forget.

By Jack Pooley /

The third and concluding part of our series on important fictional deaths throughout the last decade arrives with a look at the 20 most important deaths over the last 10 years of gaming (be sure to check out our TV and film lists too). Death is a considerably bigger part of gaming than it is either TV or film, given how the primary objective of most games involves killing enemies ad nauseum throughout the campaign. That said, it's hard to pay much attention to all the machine gun fodder, but what about those deaths that actually, really mattered? Whether they're the deaths of the protagonist, the villain, or a beloved supporting character, these 20 character deaths were extremely memorable, sometimes emotional and in a few cases, rather controversial. They may not have proved satisfying to everyone, but they're pretty much impossible to forget: at the best of times they made us feel something deeply, on occasion they challenged our ideas about what the video game medium was capable of, and in other instances we just flat-out raged at what was unfolding before our eyes. Did we miss any vital gaming death scenes this decade? Did any of these deaths annoy or upset you? Let us know in the comments!

20. The Boss - Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (2004)

Arguably Hideo Kojima's most grounded and engrossing entry into the Metal Gear Solid franchise, Snake Eater had us playing Big Boss, who spent the game chasing down his former mentor, The Boss, after she defected to the Soviet Union. Snake Eater climaxes with an outstanding, beautifully-staged final boss fight, in which Naked Snake has to bring The Boss down in a field of white flowers. After the fight ends, the mortally wounded Boss asks Snake to finish her, with the line, "There's only room for one Boss and one Snake." Now, the player is tasked with finishing the job themselves: the game will simply stay on the static shot pictured above until the player pulls the trigger themselves, heightening the emotion and player involvement in the scene. After pulling the trigger, the flowers begin to turn red, and at the very end of the game, we find out that The Boss had not been the defector we presumed her to be, making both Big Boss and the player feel disgusted and deceived. With the help of its genius plot twist, The Boss manages to die a hero, but not one that can ever be celebrated or championed. Tragic and devastating.

19. Malus - Shadow Of The Colossus (2005)

By the time we made it to the sixteenth and final colossus in Team Ico's magnificent adventure game, it truly felt like we'd been on a long, exhausting adventure, even if the game only lasts around 10 hours. The boss fight must be taken on alone, as Wander's trusty steed Agro falls from the broken bridge moments before it begins: this is it, the final encounter. Malus is an absolutely awe-inspiring last boss, a gigantic, statuesque creature who fires huge fiery projectiles at you which deal massive damage. After navigating the route to Malus through a series of tunnels, you'll eventually reach him and have to climb him like the mountainous beast that he is. Whenever you reach one of his sigils, however, he'll try his damnedest to hurl you off, making this easily the most challenging boss fight in the game. After a long, drawn out battle that can easily last close to an hour, killing Malus signals the end of Wander's journey, and the brilliant summation of everything that has led to this point. The feeling of satisfaction at plunging Wander's blade into a sigil one last time has rarely been equaled in gaming since.

18. Emperor Uriel Septim VII - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (2006)

Emperor Uriel Septim VII was a staple character of the Elder Scrolls series up until his demise in the opening sequence of Oblivion, even if this is the only game where he makes a significant physical appearance. The emperor was in the middle of an escape when he was killed, aware that his own life was in danger after three of his sons were murdered. An assassin stabs him to death, setting in motion the events of the game, as without an Emperor of Septim lineage wearing the Amulet of Kings (which is found on Uriel's body), the barrier between Tamriel and the realm of Oblivion is no longer closed, leading to chaos. After learning that Uriel did father an illegitimate heir, Martin, the central quest of the game is to track Martin down with the hope that he can reignite the Dragonfires with the Amulet of Kings and bring peace back to Tamriel. Given his stature throughout the history of the Elder Scrolls narrative, it was a huge moment indeed, and having him voiced by Patrick Stewart of all people was the delicious icing on the cake.

17. Andrew Ryan - BioShock (2007)

Andrew Ryan is easily the most important character in BioShock, a business mogul who built the underwater city of Rapture, initially realised by Ryan as a Utopian existence flourishing amid the notion of Objectivism, whereby the world's elite would be cut off from the rest of society (namely the government). However, this apparently idyllic existence soon began to suffer when Plasmids started to be harnessed, and war broke out between Ryan and the revolutionary Atlas. Ryan meets his grisly end when player character Jack finds him in his office playing golf, where he explains that Jack is his illegitimate son, and reveals that the phrase "would you kindly?" that Atlas has been using throughout the game was a trigger with which Jack could be ordered to perform actions. Memorably, Ryan tells Jack, "A man chooses, a slave obeys", before Ryan hands Jack a golf club and using the trigger phrase, forces Jack to fill him. The combination of the shocking reveal, the cinematic quality of the scene and the sheer brutality makes it a death not easily shaken.

16. Eli Vance - Half-Life: Episode Two (2007)

Eli Vance is (or rather, was) easily one of the most likeable characters in the Half-Life series. Introduced in Half-Life 2, Eli has a tragic back story, where his own wife Azian died in the Black Mesa incident of the first game, and so he is extremely protective over his daughter Alyx. He also has a strong relationship with protagonist Gordon Freeman, and makes amusing hints to Alyx about their potential romantic involvement. However, he finally bites the big one at the end of Half-Life: Episode Two, being killed by an Advisor as both Alyx and Gordon look on, unable to help. As if the sight of Alyx weeping over her father's corpse isn't a depressing enough ending to a game, we're still waiting for a resolution to this, as 6 and a half years later, Half-Life: Episode Three has yet to follow. Eli's death is clearly a crucial turning point in the story, but in typical Valve fashion, their aversion to the number three continues, and fans are left continually twiddling their thumbs without any information about a concluding chapter.

15. Sgt. Paul Jackson - Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007)

Sgt. Paul Jackson is one of the numerous playable characters in the ground-breaking Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, and while his name might not ring too many bells, the nature of his death continues to be regarded as a high-point for both the CoD series and the FPS genre as a whole. After discovering an armed nuclear weapon in Iran, Paul and his squad plan to exit the city to escape the blast radius, though they are too late, and their chopper ends up being downed by the shock wave. What follows is one of the most haunting sequences in any recent shooter. Paul survives the crash, and we as the player then get to stumble around a sepia-tinged map with no HUD for a few minutes as a mortally wounded Paul, who eventually succumbs to a combination of the plane crash and the nuclear fallout. Killing off the player character was an extremely bold and unexpected move by itself, but to do it in such a terrifying way just cemented the game's brilliance.

14. Roman Or Kate - Grand Theft Auto IV (2008)

The end of Grand Theft Auto IV faces the player with a dilemma: perform a heroin deal with sketchy Dimitri Rascalov and make $250,000 (as advised by Niko's cousin Roman), or decide to take revenge instead (as girlfriend Kate suggests). If you take the deal, Roman ends up being murdered just moments after his wedding to Mallorie, causing Niko to go on a violent revenge spree, before the game ends with Mallorie revealing she's pregnant with Roman's child, and Niko promises to look out for him. If you take revenge, Kate is the one who ends up being gunned down outside the church, and after Roman announces Mallorie's pregnancy, they promise to name the kid Kate if it's a girl. Each death was devastating in its own way, and for as much as we might have hated Roman calling us every 10 minutes to go bowling, they were both likeable characters who didn't deserve that grim fate. It was a landmark moment for the GTA series as it introduced a branching narrative and gave the players a choice in how their story concluded.

13. Big Boss - Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots (2008)

After beating Liquid Ocelot to death atop Outer Haven, it seemed like Solid Snake was pretty much done with life. He goes to Big Boss' grave site with the intent of shooting himself, but is interrupted by a miraculously alive Big Boss, leading to a lengthy epilogue sequence in which Boss explains many of the dangling plot threads and essentially ties up Snake's story once and for all. Big Boss' death comes as a result of the new strain of FOXDIE injected into Snake by Drebin, an effort by the Patriot AIs to eliminate everyone in the rival Patriot faction to Major Zero's outfit. Big Boss sits down at The Boss' grave and quietly expires, but not before urging Snake to spend his final days at peace rather than waging war. Cut to black, and that's the end of Solid Snake's tremendous journey. Bringing back Big Boss from beyond the grave was a crazy move for sure, but a shocking and brilliantly-played one which gave fans the closure they so desperately needed, and provided one of gaming's most bada** characters with a fitting demise.

12. No Russian - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (2009)

Easily the most controversial mission in any Call of Duty game to date is No Russian, a level so gratuitously violent and disturbing that Infinity Ward made it optional, and those with a weak stomach could simply skip it. The player controls American soldier Joseph Allen, who is undercover with Vladimir Makarov's outfit as they assault Zakhaev International Airport. Though the player is under no obligation to pull their own trigger and fire upon civilians, even if they don't, the four other gunmen will waste pretty much everyone in the airport, as you all slowly waltz through the place. Later, the authorities show up, and similarly, whether the player acts or not, they will end up being killed by Makarov's men. At the end of the level, Makarov murders Allen, aware of him being a spy, and confident that leaving his body at the crime scene will help suggest that the U.S. was behind this attack. It's an unsettling level and one that made players question their complicity in video game violence. Was the controversy blown out of proportion? Absolutely, but props to Infinity Ward for making such a ballsy artistic choice with MW2.

11. Jason Mars - Heavy Rain (2010)

Jason Mars may be the butt of a lot of jokes due to the game's pretty awful "Press X to Jason" sequence, but he's a vitally important character in Heavy Rain, and establishes the troubled back story of his father, protagonist Ethan. When the family visit a mall in the game's prologue section, Jason becomes separated from Ethan, and after panickedly searching for him, Ethan finds Jason about to cross the street without looking, while a car barrels towards him. Ethan jumps in front of the car, as we cut to black. It turns out that Ethan ends up in a long coma, but despite him absorbing most of the damage, it is Jason who dies in the accident, causing Ethan severe psychological problems and also ruining his marriage. Later, his other son Shaun goes missing, feared to have been kidnapped by the infamous Origami Killer, and so Ethan must overcome his crippling issues to save the life of his one remaining son. Jason's death has a major dramatic bearing on the rest of the story, and despite the poor voice acting and overall silliness of Jason's death (a 10-year-old should know better than to walk blindly into the street), it adds considerably to Ethan's character and gives him even more of an impetus to save his other son.

10. John Marston - Red Dead Redemption (2010)

One of the finest protagonists in any Rockstar game, John Marston was a loveable outlaw who was easy to get behind, especially as he had to deal with the double-crossing, yellow-bellied Bureau of Investigation and the corrupt Edgar Ross. Even after carrying out every dirty deed he asked, Ross just couldn't leave Marston alone, and at the end of the game shows up at his ranch with a fleet of men. John sends his wife Abigail and son Jack on their way while he steps out of the barn to hold Ross and his men off. At this point, the player has to quick-draw as many men as possible, but the outcome is inevitable and unavoidable: John ends up violently peppered with bullets, and soon dies, much to the pleasure of Ross. Tragic and heroic though John's death was, the player thankfully gets an opportunity for revenge, even redemption, in the game's epilogue, as they take control of an older Jack, as he hunts down a retired Ross. Rockstar always does endings well, though Red Dead arguably outdoes even the cinematic climaxes of the Grand Theft Auto games with its bittersweet emotion and level of satisfaction.

9. Prophet - Crysis 2 (2011)

Crysis 2 begins in explosive style, as the USS Nautilus is destroyed by Ceph insurgents in New York City, apparently killing everyone on board. However, Force Recon Marine "Alcatraz" narrowly survives, being rescued from the water by the protagonist of the first game, Prophet. He takes Alcatraz to dry land, gives him his nanosuit and then commits suicide, as this is the only way that the suit will be able to adjust to Alcatraz's mind and body. A shocking move considering how the first Crysis painted Prophet as the Master Chief-type character for the Crysis franchise, Prophet nevertheless still hung around in spirit, given how Alcatraz experiences some of Prophet's memories from within the suit, as well a number of messages he left behind for him. It's suggested at the end of the game that Prophet's spirit has somehow been maintained within the suit, leading to Crysis 3, which sees Alcatraz being completely assimilated by Prophet's personality, essentially causing Alcatraz to be braindead. One great rule of sci-fi: if someone dies, it never has to be forever.

8. Cole Phelps - L.A. Noire (2011)

Cole Phelps is the protagonist of Rockstar's divisive L.A. Noire, a fast-rising hotshot Detective in the LAPD, motion-and-voice-captured by Mad Men's Aaron Staton. Phelps meets his surprising demise at the end of the game as he tries to escape a flooding river tunnel. After helping Jack Kelso and lover Elsa out of the tunnel, there simply wasn't enough time for Phelps to escape before he was overcome by a giant wave of water, a second after telling Kelso, Elsa and Herschel Biggs a simple "Goodbye." The final scene of the game has everyone attending Phelps' funeral, in easily one of the most downbeat endings Rockstar has ever made. Most of the criminals involved in the Suburban Redevelopment Fund have not just avoided prosecution, but are speaking in Phelps' honour at his funeral, as the ultimate slap in the face to his memory. Had Phelps' death at least felt like it were for something grand and important, it may have been more satisfying and epic, but alas, as we learned in L.A. Noire, that's not always how life works.

7. The Joker - Batman: Arkham City (2011)

The Joker is such a reliably entertaining villain for Batman that he's rarely killed: he normally lives on to fight again another day, though in Rocksteady's Batman: Arkham City, the Clown Prince of Crime's luck finally ran out. It turns out that the Titan formula Jokes overdosed on in Arkham Asylum is slowly killing him, and right at the end of the game, Batman considers using the antidote on him, but before he can decide, The Joker attacks him, causing the vial to smash, ruining any chance of him surviving the formula's effects. The game concludes with The Joker dying, and Batman carrying him out of Arkham City, much to the shock of his cronies outside. Commissioner Gordon quizzes Batman about the incident, but he simply dumps Jokes' body on a cop car and leaves. It's a turning point for the Arkham video game series: given how crucial a component The Joker is, for him to be unable to appear in the upcoming Arkham Knight is a pretty brave move on the part of Rocksteady. Can they make Scarecrow as viable a threat as the Caped Crusader's most iconic ally? We'll have to wait and see...

6. The Illusive Man - Mass Effect 3 (2012)

The Illusive Man is the leader of Cerberus in the Mass Effect series, and is largely responsible for Commander Shepard's resurrection in the second game. Shepard works with him when the threat of the Collectors looms, and depending on the choices the player makes throughout the game, they will either have an extremely uneasy partnership with the Illusive Man, or come to agree on his notion of human supremacy, taking the Collector technology for all it is worth. In Mass Effect 3, the Illusive Man turns his focus towards the Reapers, while his general behaviour becomes more erratic and risky, eventually appearing to have become indoctrinated by the Reapers through nanotechnology upgrades. Shepard pleads with him to allow them to stop the Reapers, but the Illusive Man remains resolute that they can be controlled by him. The Illusive Man's death either comes at his own hand after Shepard talks him down, or when Shepard shoots him in self-defense. An iconic and ambiguous icon of the franchise, the Illusive Man's demise was a hugely important milestone, and with a velvety voice performance from Martin Sheen, who couldn't love to hate him?

5. White Phosphorus Attack - Spec Ops: The Line (2012)

Spec Ops: The Line may not have been a AAA blockbuster like the Call of Duty franchise, but it more than made up for this with its intelligent, character-driven approach to a war-time scenario, complete with all of the unpleasantness that this implies. The game's most memorable scene comes as three Delta Force soldiers, protagonist Walker alongside teammates Adams and Lugo, arrive at a location called The Gate where the rogue squad the Damned 33rd are holed up. Despite resistance from Lugo, Walker insists that they must use white phosphorus to attack the 33rd, at which point the player has to control a drone which fires down a rain of the explosive, skin-searing material onto the white dots which scarcely resemble people. When the fire clears, you walk through to see several dying, severely burned people crawling around in their final moments, begging for help, before Walker and co. realise they've burned to death a large number of civilians. The most haunting image is unquestionably that of a woman with half her face burned away, cradling her young daughter who also has most of her skin seared off. Clearly, all three men are shell-shocked by the incident, even as Walker tries to rationalise what they've done and move ahead with the mission. This is a rare moment in a military shooter where players have been asked to consider the nature of blindly saying yes to orders, paralleling our position as gamers wanting to reach the end of a game with the "ask no questions" mentality of soldiers in the army. Had we unknowingly had a choice not to fire the white phosphorus, then this moment would have been even more powerful and telling.

4. Lee Everett - The Walking Dead: Season One (2012)

The emotional lynch-pin of Telltale Games' brilliant graphic adventure series has been the relationship between player character Lee Everett and Clementine, a young girl who is desperately trying to find her parents. Over the course of the five episodes, the pair develop a clear father-daughter bond, which of course makes it pretty clear that something horrible is probably going to happen to one of them. Late in the day, Lee wakes up to find Clem missing, and in the ensuing search for her, ends up being bitten by a walker. At the end of the game, it's up to the player to decide their own fate; they can ask Clem to shoot them before they turn, or they can allow themselves to turn while telling Clem to leave the scene. It's one of the toughest recent dilemmas in a game, and if you're not quick enough deciding, the game will simply decide for you on the basis of the decisions you've made so far. Either way, the Lee we knew is gone, and as the first season of the game comes to an end, Clem is left wandering the wilderness.

3. Sarah - The Last Of Us (2013)

Talk about an emotionally intense opening to a game, and one which has players invested in the protagonist right from the outset. The prologue section of The Last of Us initially has players controlling Joel's daughter Sarah, 20 years before the main events of the game, as the initial Cordyceps outbreak begins, and all hell breaks loose. After a brutal car crash, the player now has control of Joel, as he frantically tries to carry Sarah to safety. However, they are eventually confronted by a soldier, who subsequently opens fire on the pair, mortally wounding Sarah before Joel's younger brother Tommy can dispatch the soldier. As Sarah screams in pain, Joel frantically tries to comfort her, but it's not long before she dies in his arms. It's a devastating and extremely well-acted, gorgeously presented moment that's easily on par with the opening to any great movie. It also has major implications for Joel, as when he meets Ellie moments later, it explains his growing paternal bond over her and his controversial actions later in the game: he's already lost his daughter, and feels some sense of vicarious redemption if he can keep Ellie safe.

2. Paz Ortega Andrade - Metal Gear Solid V: Ground Zeroes (2014)

Paz was first introduced to the MGS franchise in the game Peace Walker, and she showed up once again in the prologue to The Phantom Pain, Ground Zeroes. Despite being feared dead at the end of Peace Walker, it transpires that Paz is very much alive, and is being held at Camp Omega for interrogation. As Big Boss, the player must rescue both her and child soldier Chico, but once you make it onto the chopper, they quickly realise something is wrong: cuts to Paz's stomach suggest that a bomb has been placed inside her. Emergency surgery is performed to remove the bomb, much to Paz's anguish, but before long, she reveals that there's a second bomb concealed inside her, with the implication being that it's been shoved into her lady parts. In order to save everyone on-board, Paz decides to jump out of the helicopter mere moments before she explodes, sending the chopper into a tailspin as the game comes to a close. The shocking nature of Paz's death as well as the controversial audio tape obtained earlier in the game, which appears to depict Paz's rape, asked questions about what maturity meant in video games. Many thought that Kojima had simply gone too far, while others praised his bold attempt at taboo-breaking.

1. Reggie Rowe - Infamous: Second Son (2014)

Reggie Rowe is the brother of Infamous: Second Son's protagonist, Delsin, the Sheriff of Salmon Bay and the only character who seems capable of keeping his Conduit brother in line. Though he is disturbed by Delsin's abilities, family still comes first, even if he can't help but think of his kind as so-called Bioterrorists. Just as Reggie begins to see the Conduits as human beings, however, his time runs out: the game's antagonist Augustine attacks the pair, leaving Reggie dangling from a bridge, with her concrete powers about to consume both him and Delsin, who is desperately holding onto his brother. Reggie then decides to sacrifice himself to save Delsin, falling into the ocean depths as Delsin looks on in horror. Infamous: Second Son might not have quite been the killer app for the PS4 that we were hoping for, but the combination of this sibling bond storyline and the superb facial animation made it one of the more believable gaming relationships in recent memory. Plus, Reggie's death gave us even more motivation to harness those awesome powers. Did we miss any important deaths from the last decade in gaming? Let us know in the comments!