6 Video Game Fan Theories The Studios Actually Confirmed

Two of your favourite shooters share more than the same developer...

By Mark Langshaw /

Fan theories aren't limited to movies and TV, and as video games have grown more sophisticated, many of them have challenged players to draw their own conclusions about their narratives, character arcs and deepest mysteries.

Advertisement

Some of these theories are plausible enough for developers to address. The idea of Fallout taking place in the distant future of the Elder Scrolls series was thought provoking - until Bethesda came out and debunked it.

In truth, most fan theories have all the merit of tin-hatted conspiracy ramblings, and while these can be entertaining, the chances of them being accurate are about as high as a mere mortal playing through Dark Souls 3 without dying once.

Every once in a while, though, players devise ideas about their favourite games that are right on the money, so shrewd and inspiring that the developers confirm them.

This is far more common in the mediums of film and television, but it isn't unheard of in gaming, and here are the times the studios were forced to concede that their fanbase was really onto something...

6. Zelda: Twilight Princess Is A Sequel To Majora's Mask

For several years, Zelda: Majora's Mask was viewed as the black sheep in the family, a dark departure for the series which stands alone, outside of the mainline continuity as a glorified side quest of sorts.

Advertisement

This all changed when Twilight Princess arrived on Wii in 2006 as eagle-eyed players spotted subtle references to the N64 title. The layout of two games' maps are uncannily similar, but the biggest piece of connective tissue concerns the Twili.

There's a reference to the villainous race being banished to a "shadow realm" in Twilight Princess, and the fans were convinced this meant they were exiled to Majora's Mask's doomed world, Termina, which would make the Wii release it sequel of sorts.

Nintendo endorsed the connection between the games when it published the book Hyrule Historia, which came complete with an official Zelda timeline. The diagram placed Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess beside one another in the same reality, which essentially makes Termina the equivalent of Dark World in A Link to the Past.

Confirmation that Majora's Mask is connected to Twilight Princess confirms what many fans suspected all along: the N64 game is much more than a non-canon spinoff.

5. Michael Jackson Composed Music For Sonic 3

Fans had pointed out similarities to Sonic the Hedgehog 3's soundtrack and Michael Jackson's music for years, and if you want to hear it for yourself, listen to the game's end credits tune and Jacko's Stranger in Moscow in quick succession.

Advertisement

Many speculated that the late King of Pop was an uncredited musical contributor on the title, and this was never as outlandish as it might sound. There is, after all, prior history between Jackson and Sega, the publisher of the Moonwalker games for Mega Drive and Master System.

The gaming giant has always downplayed the collaboration, but in a 2016 Huffington Post article, three of the six composers who worked on Sonic 3, and a former Sega executive, acknowledged that Jackson provided music for the game.

Jacko was one of the biggest artists at the time, so why all the secrecy surrounding his involvement with the Mega Drive sequel?

Some have claimed the singer was unhappy with the sound quality and removed his name from the credits, while others believe the child molestation allegations he was battling at the time made Sega think twice about making the partnership public.

4. Super Mario Bros 3 Is A Stage Performance

Super Mario Bros 3 is one of the greatest and most influential platformers of all time, but some fans were always convinced that what they were playing wasn't canon to the Nintendo series.

Advertisement

The evidence that the whole thing was a play staged by the main characters was overwhelming. A curtain raises to reveal the title screen and each level ends with the scenery giving way to a dark abyss, not unlike a poorly lit backstage area.

So, it was only slightly surprising when Mario's creator Shigeru Miyamoto confirmed that Super Mario Bros 3 is actually a stage production, during a video called Mario Myths, hosted on Nintendo's official YouTube channel.

From here, the Mario series gets seriously meta since Bowser's kids and a bunch of other enemies found their way into later sequels. Does this mean they escaped from the fictional world, or are other Mario games plays as well?

3. Doomguy Is A Descendent Of B.J. Blazkowicz

Wolfenstein 3D is the granddaddy of all first-person shooters, so it seems appropriate that its protagonist might literally be the grandfather of the main character from its spiritual successor series, Doom.

Advertisement

Fans have pointed out the physical similarities between B.J. Blazkowicz and the so-called Doomguy from the very beginning, and developer id Software confirmed the connection in its 2009 mobile game Wolfenstein RPG.

The role-playing spinoff told the origin story of the Doom series' Cyberdemon, revealing how B.J. defeated the creature's original incarnation and it swore to return to battle his descendants, which presumably includes the Doomguy.

Doom's lead programmer John Carmack developed Wolfenstein RPG, so this history lesson is coming right from the horse's mouth, although it should be noted that both franchises have since undergone reboots of sorts and are yet to share connective tissue in their current forms.

2. Final Fantasy X-2's Shinra Founded The Shinra Company

The Final Fantasy series has always played fast and loose with continuity, taking place across several alternate universes with little connectivity between them.

Advertisement

But the fans have long speculated about strong links between Final Fantasy X-2 and Final Fantasy VII, given that the former features a character called Shinra and the latter a mega corporation of the same name.

During an interview with Kotaku, Final Fantasy producer Yoshinori Kitase addressed a number of popular fan theories and debunked the lot of them... apart from this one.

The Square Enix executive stopped short of confirming that X-2 and VII take place in the same world, but did reveal that Shinra's creator envisioned the character as the future founder of the Shinra company.

"Shinra in FFX-2 was created by [Kazushige] Nojima, the scenario writer, and when he thought him up, he thought it might be good if people would imagine that after a few years after the story of Final Fantasy X-2, that person Shinra will grow up and start the Shinra company."

You can take this as at least quasi-confirmation of a connection between Final Fantasy X-2 and the fan-favourite Final Fantasy VII.

1. Mary's Body Was In The Car All Along (Silent Hill 2)

Silent Hill 2 has a number of possible endings but the harrowing 'in water' conclusion, in which tortured protagonist James drives to a watery grave with his wife Mary's body in the car, is considered definitive by many.

Advertisement

Hard-hitting though it may be, not everything about it adds up, as the location of his wife's corpse at the beginning of the game, and why it suddenly materialises right at the end, remains shrouded in mystery.

The fans have had their say on this, and many believe Mary's body was in the trunk of the vehicle the whole time. It turns out they were half right, as designer Masahiro Ito has confirmed on Twitter that the cadaver was always located in the back seat of the car.

"Mary's body is in the back seat of James's car, not in the trunk, if I remember correctly."

Masahiro's comments could have inspired a dozen more conspiracy theories about why the body is never visible in the back of the car, but he had an answer to that too.

Apparently, James has repressed his wife's fate so hard that he no longer even sees the corpse in front of him, which is as convenient as it is chilling.

Advertisement