8 Dumbest Video Game Decisions With The BEST Rewards
Go against your gut and get BIG rewards.
The risk-reward dichotomy is at the very foundation of video game design - take a big risk, get a big reward.
But sometimes an act isn’t so much a risk as a straight-up stupid decision on the part of the player that, by any traditional metric, would result in sure disaster.
Yet video game developers absolutely love toying with players and soundly subverting their expectations, enough that those who pick up the idiot ball and run with it just might end up with a big, fat reward at the end.
In real life things certainly aren’t always “fair” - asinine behaviour is frequently rewarded - and so it follows that video games, as art created by human beings, sometimes reflect that.
And so, these 8 video game decisions all seemed primed to lead players to a Game Over or bad ending and nothing more, yet actually ended up gifting players an awesome surprise instead.
These can range from cute secrets to literally game-changing items, but each nevertheless served as an hilariously unearned treat after so recklessly endangering yourself and potentially others, too…
8. Let Meryl Die, Get Stealth Camo - Metal Gear Solid
Would it be a Hideo Kojima game without a game design decision that seems totally antithetical to conventional logic? And we love him for it, of course!
In the original Metal Gear Solid, there comes a point where Solid Snake is captured and forced to endure electroshock torture at the hands of Revolver Ocelot.
The player is tasked with button-mashing their way through the sequence, but if they fail, they don't get a Game Over screen - it's simply noted that they submitted to the torture.
Well, that and all the consequences it has for the rest of the game.
Y'see, submitting to the torture results in Meryl's death later on, which while since proven not remotely canonical, is still a massive bummer.
However, there's a huge incentive to let Meryl die given that submitting to the torture also unlocks the best, most useful, and straight-up most fun item in the entire game - the Stealth Camouflage.
At the end of the game, Otacon will give Snake camo which renders him invisible to most non-boss enemies for all future playthroughs. It's awesome, and also serves as a rather strange reward for... throwing in the towel and letting Meryl die.
Hell, if you actually resist the torture and make it through the sequence unscathed, the reward is comparatively pretty lousy - a Bandana which grants you infinite ammo. Oh, and Meryl surviving the whole ordeal, of course.
Nah, I'll take the camo thanks. Sorry, Mer.
7. Make An Idiot Savant Build, Get Random XP Boosts - Fallout 4
One of the most vital choices in the Fallout series is how players decide to balance their character's build, and in the case of Fallout 4, that means deciding how your attribute points are distributed among the pillars of Strength, Perception, Endurance, Charisma, Intelligence, Agility, and Luck.
Conventional wisdom dictates that you don't want any one of these attributes to be too low, yet there is one exception - the Idiot Savant build.
The Idiot Savant is created by investing nothing in Intelligence but everything in Luck and Strength, allowing you to deal damage and land regular critical hits.
But the pièce de résistance comes by activating the Idiot Savant perk, which will randomly grant you 3x XP for any activity in the game. The lower your intelligence, the better your chance at triggering the perk, and so keeping Intelligence at 1 will ensure you'll regularly benefit from it.
As the perk ranks up, the multiplier even increases to 5x, ensuring that despite your character's eminent stupidity - a seemingly risky way to be in a post-apocalyptic wasteland - you'll level up much faster than your "smarter" fellow explorers.
6. Kill Yourself, Receive Eridium - Borderlands 2
Borderlands 2's late-campaign mission "Kill Yourself" is nothing if no succinct and to-the-point, with Handsome Jack quite simply tasking players with jumping from the nearby suicide spot Lover's Leap into the fiery abyss below, for which he promises to pay a "king's ransom," whatever that means.
If you decide to ascend Lover's Leap, you'll even get to see an NPC swan-dive into the molten drink before you, as if to hang up a neon signpost that says, "Nothing good will come from this."
But this being Borderlands, of course something good does come from shuffling yourself off your mortal coil. Take the leap and you'll be rewarded with 12 Eridium, which can be used to upgrade your character.
Given that Eridium is a vital resource in the game, that's a pretty damn neat chunk o' the stuff for the mere act of topping yourself.
In the event you decide to "wuss out," as Jack calls it, you'll get a little XP instead, but hurling yourself into the flames is clearly the most fortuitous outcome - a sentence that could only make sense in Borderlands of all things.
5. Press The "Do Not Press" Button... Again, Get Health & Power-Ups - Blasto
Conventional wisdom says that any time a video game tells you not to press something, the results will be pretty dire if you do - a cruel prank by the developers to test players' restraint, basically.
And in the not-so-classic PS1 shooter-platformer Blasto, you'll encounter a Big Red Button in the very first level, with a gigantic sign insisting you do anything but press it.
But of course, gamers being gamers, how could they resist?
Doing so results in the inevitability of bad decision-making swiftly catching up with you, as Captain Blasto is promptly shot and turned into a pile of ash. Oops.
As such, when another do-not-press button appears in the second level, it makes sense to give it a wide berth and continue on your merry way through the stage.
But those who've never heard the phrase "fool me twice, shame on me" might be tempted to press the button anyway - a profoundly stupid decision which, in a brain-breaking paradox, nets tremendous rewards.
Indeed, hitting the red button on the second level will cause the area to be festooned with plentiful health and power-ups, giving you a huge leg-up for the battle ahead.
4. Give The Final Boss Your Gun, He Shoots Himself - Rule Of Rose
Nothing says dumber-than-dumb like willingly handing over the only weapon you've got to the Big Bad, yet in cult survival horror game Rule of Rose, it's the only way to get the good ending.
In the game's climax, player character Jennifer is forced to face off against the malevolent entity known as Stray Dog, and moments before the boss battle they're handed a gun, with which they're told they can stop him once and for all.
The key word here being "stop," not kill, yet all the same, players can't be blamed if they instantly start pugging away at Stray Dog with the gun and attacking him until he dies.
However, this actually ends up triggering the game's bad ending, whereby Jennifer ends up alone and has failed to save everyone.
To unlock the good ending, where Jennifer comes to terms with her past, you need to do the most counter-logic thing possible - give the gun to Stray Dog.
This will trigger a closing cutscene where a guilt-riddled Stray Dog takes the revolver and shoots himself in the head.
Given that players typically expect their games to end with an epic final showdown, willingly giving up your only advantage seemed like a non-starter to most, even if it's ultimately the only way to truly triumph. Wild.
3. Jump Off Bard's Leap Summit, Get A Big Speech Boost - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Have you ever been high up somewhere in real life and gotten a sudden urge to jump despite having no suicidal tendencies whatsoever? It's a psychological phenomenon called "The Call of the Void" - a common intrusive thought that's apparently completely normal. Phew.
And the wonderful world of gaming allows you to indulge this morbid urge in considerably safer fashion, as is perhaps best evidenced by the Bard's Leap Summit in Skyrim.
This gorgeous towering waterfall practically screams "Jump off me, go on!" to anyone who stumbles across it. I mean, it's called Bard's Leap for Christ's sake.
And while it's a totally stupid thing to do in terms of progressing the game and, y'know, keeping your character alive, it does actually bear some surprisingly fertile fruit.
Despite the fact that leaping hundreds of feet from a cliff edge into a pool below would almost certainly shatter your bones and result in your drowning death in reality, in Skyrim the water provides a gentle cushion for your impact.
After this, you can swim to the surface and reach the shore, where you'll be greeted by the ghost of the bard Azzadal, who wasn't quite so lucky when he took a dive there.
Nevertheless, you'll get two princely rewards for your self-endangering act - Azzadal will play a lovely song for you on his lute, and then your Speech skill will increase by two whole levels.
2. Dive Into Vines, Receive Shotgun & Uzi Clips - Tomb Raider III
There isn't a single gamer among us who hasn't spent an embarrassing amount of time making Lara Croft leap acrobatically to her demise. We all know the stakes - dive foolishly into an unknown expanse and you'll receive a crumpled pile of Lara for your troubles.
Yet the first level of Tomb Raider III, Jungle, toys with this in a cleverly sneaky way. At the very beginning, you're supposed to slide down a massive slope to reach the bottom of the area, because there's seemingly nothing in your immediate vicinity worth interacting with.
Certainly not those totally inert vines, right?
But dumb/inquisitive players who decide to leap into the vines on the left-hand side of the screen will find themselves landing on a secret ledge containing two very handy pick-ups - a Shotgun and some Uzi ammo. Shibby.
Given that the rules of the game suggest it's totally daft and pointless to leap into vines that are purely decorative - especially on a perilous sloped area like this - it's fair to say that most players figured this one out by accident while carelessly flinging Lara around. Or, you know, they used a guide.
1. Touch Nitro, Get The Purple Gem - Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back
One of the ultimate truths of the Crash Bandicoot franchise? Stay the hell away from those twitchy green Nitro crates, right? Get within a whisker of them and you'll be forced to witness everybody's favourite digital marsupial get burned to cinders.
Except, that is, in Crash 2's level "Bee-having." Mid-way through the level, you'll come across a collection of Nitro crates arranged in a stairway formation, but logic being logic, everything should tell you to stay well clear and use a Nitro Switch Crate at the end of the level to detonate them.
But not this time.
Go against everything your gut's telling you, jump onto the Nitro and climb them like a set of stairs, and you'll be transported to the level's bonus area, where you can pick up the Purple Gem.
For masochistic Crash players seeking 100% completion - which without the Purple Gem is impossible - this level was infuriating, given that everything you've ever learned over the course of the series tells you to do anything but touch the Nitro crates.
There is, mercifully, one cheeky giveaway that these crates are harmless, though - unlike every other Nitro crate in the game, they don't bounce and nervously jitter around, instead staying totally still.