8 Nintendo Switch Criticisms That Also Apply To The PS4 & Xbox One

All's fair in love and console war, but keep it fair.

By Scott Tailford /

Nintendo/Sony/Microsoft

If you've spent any time on the internet since the Nintendo Switch launched, you'll be fully aware of its roster of problems, bugbears and technical issues. That's not to say the system is an out-and-out failure, far from it, but the cultural reception outside of 1.5 million units sold (and counting), has been slightly tepid at best.

Advertisement

Contrast this to where Sony and Microsoft are at right now (though it feels as though the latter have fallen down a well), and there's a demonstrable difference between hardware specs, available bodies of titles, exclusives and everything in between. It's a gap so great, the vibe surrounding the Switch is one of isolation - Nintendo are clearly happy to operate on their own little island, not caring one jot about truly competing with the 'big boys', despite the Switch having better third-party support than the Wii U ever had.

Granted, all's fair in love and console war, but this rush to damn the Switch out the gate, proclaim it "dead" or completely unable to stand toe to toe against the PS4 and Xbox One is facile. 4K functionality and units shipped do not equal abject quality, and that's before you realise pretty much every major complaint levied against Nintendo's new baby, is - or was - easily applied to what's already on the market.

Advertisement

8. Lack Of First-Party Titles At Launch

Sony

What first-party game did you play on your PS4 at launch? Was it Knack? Perhaps Killzone: Shadow Fall? Both those and Resogun were the only exclusive offering going at the time, and I guarantee you've not returned to either since, if you played them at all.

Advertisement

On the Xbox One front, things were much better, with Microsoft throwing out a new Forza, Dead Rising 3, Ryse: Son of Rome and Killer Instinct - all games you couldn't find anywhere else. Time has sufficiently buried all four, but at least Microsoft were charging out the gates with purpose.

In camp Nintendo it's The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, Snipperclips, Fast RMX and a timed-exclusive unveiling of new Shovel Knight content. All three consoles had copious amounts of third-party games to back up the exclusives and first-party stuff, but the point is this:

Advertisement

Neither Sony or Microsoft wowed up front at launch, and they didn't have Zelda being revered as one of the greatest games of all time, either.

7. Bad Battery Life

Sony

Microsoft can sit this one out, as it's the DualShock 4 that still remains a pathetically short-lived controller when playing any game. Seriously, you'll get around 4-5 hours at best before it needs another charge, which would be quite the substantial complaint if PlayStation fans or consumers in general didn't let it slide on by.

Advertisement

For the Switch, whilst its battery life isn't being raked across the coals, the system is able to provide a portable home console experience for that same 4 hours, and that's only if it's playing something as processor-intensive as Breath of the Wild. You'll get far longer out of the machine by playing pretty much any other game.

Even if you take the individual Joy-Cons needing charging as a marked negative, at least they draw power from the tablet itself whenever you're in handheld mode, so if you're going between docked and portable frequently, this just isn't an issue.

Advertisement

Contrast to the DualShock 4 which will need a rest in the middle of the afternoon, and Sony fans can't honestly point fingers without also looking in the mirror.

6. Frame Rate/Performance Issues

Ubisoft

Do you remember 2014 in gaming? I.e. The first year for all these new systems? It was a grade-A tire fire of the stinkiest variety.

Advertisement

Yes, The Legend of Zelda has the occasional frame rate hiccup when it's attempting to render a dense forest area coupled with light rays and wildlife, but Assassin's Creed Unity's faces couldn't even stay on.

Day one servers were always offline, games we'd bought PS4s and Xbox Ones to play were being delayed, the ones that were released turned out to be absolute toss. There was simply a lack of polish across the board that genuinely made people think the entire generation was going down the pan. Flash forward into 2015 (especially 2017), and the arrival of something like Metal Gear Solid V, The Witcher 3, Rise of the Tomb Raider, Bloodborne and Halo 5 meant we finally had a smattering of titles that didn't burst into the flames at the sight of a willing consumer.

Advertisement

Point being: It takes time for developers to get used to new hardware. Yes, you can argue Nintendo should've held off unto Breath of the Wild was beyond perfect (though some would say it already is), but to say the other systems also started out on better footing is madness.

If anything, they were demonstrably worse.

Advertisement

5. "It's Being Sold On Gimmicks"

Sony/Microsoft

"Portable home console gaming? Nobody'll do that". "Taking it to a friend's house? Yeah, right."

Advertisement

Obviously at this stage, we're yet to see exactly how much the Switch infiltrates your average social scenario, but even that isn't the thing I take issue with, because, well, remember the Kinect? I'll bet you Microsoft does, even though they'd rather both they and you forget.

Needless to say the Xbox One of today has about as much to do with voice-activation and motion controls as Hideo Kojima does with subtlety, but that didn't stop Microsoft attempting to shove it down our throats for two years straight.

Advertisement

Then there's the one-two swing-n'-a-miss that was PS Vita integration and PS VR for the PS4. The first was used as a way for Sony to half-arsedly address the dual screen functionality of something like the Wii U, yet I bet you can count the amount of people you know who own a PS Vita on one hand. PS VR, whilst being a solid proof of concept, is way too overpriced and devoid of worthwhile experiences to truly catch on, relegating it to the novelty bin unless Sony pull their finger out - which they almost definitely won't, as the two previous models of the PSP proved.

The cherry on top is social media functionality, the 'one button share' concept being the only notably distinct console function that separated the PS4 and Xbox One from that of the PS3 and 360. Complainers want to talk about how the Switch's portability is a 'gimmick'?

Advertisement

It's the only worthwhile hardware feature we've seen this entire generation.

4. "Pointless Controller Features"

Nintendo

Speaking of hardware features, yes, the Switch retains its motion controls, introduces an IR sensor and the potentially pointless 'HD rumble', but it does so with at least one dedicated first-party game in mind: 1-2-Switch.

Advertisement

Hop across to the PS4 and Xbox One, and what do we see? The Dualshock 4's touchpad, which to this day has not seen a single worthwhile use since 2013. The topmost LED light, who's only purpose appears to be draining battery life even faster, and on the Xbox front, "all-new" rumbling triggers, which despite giving off the impression they'd make us "feel like we were cornering in a racing game", vibrate like your phone before it has a meltdown.

Sony/Microsoft

All of this speaks to Nintendo's approach to designing hardware, which is to say, they'll assemble a number of different hardware innovations, before letting developers do whatever they like after the fact. Such a continuation of off-kilter features is definitely not the norm, but to act as though Sony and Microsoft didn't also do the same is just incorrect.

Advertisement

For a laugh, let me know your favourite touchpad uses in the comments below. I'm going for Until Dawn's "swipe to twist-crack a glowstick".

3. Expensive Optional Controllers & Accessories

Microsoft

Are the Nintendo Switch accessories overpriced? Very much so. But are they optional? Oh yes.

Advertisement

You literally do not need a handheld charging mount when the Joy-Cons charge off the tablet itself. Either they'll pull from the tablet when you're playing in handheld, or just slot them onto the tablet whilst it's in the dock to get a full battery the next day.

Sony

The Pro Controller too, whilst you could make the argument it should've been included out of the box for something like Zelda, is more in-line with Microsoft's Xbox Elite pad or the Razer Raiju and Nacon Revolution; Sony's licensed 'pro controllers'. Such options are entirely that: Optional.

Advertisement

The Switch's base Joy-Con works just fine when slid into the standard housing, and besides a screen protector or plush carry case to encourage portability, there's not one Switch accessory that feels as though it definitely should've shipped with the system.

2. "No Pack-In Game"

Nintendo

This one is just cold, hard business. I mean, did the PS4 or Xbox One come with a company-mandated free game, despite the sales pitch being either strongly focused on single player or multiplayer? Of course not.

Advertisement

Nintendo gave everyone Wii Sports, because they were completely breaking the mould. They needed the notion of motion controls to work, and took a gamble on how much they'd lose selling a copy with every unit, versus not. On the Switch, there's no such conceptual 'sell' to make, and Nintendo have thus decided to continue with business as usual.

This doesn't excuse the idea of just being kinder to consumers and giving them something to play out the box, but retailers have been quick to offer their own bundle deals regardless, as was the case with the PS4 and Xbox One. Yes, a collection of minigames baked into the system or included as factory standard would've been ideal, but the "no pack in" complaint is just as easily levied at the competition, too.

Advertisement

1. Relying On Older Characters & Franchises

Nintendo

"Where are the new characters?" they cry. "Where are the new franchises?!"

Advertisement

It's a worthwhile comment to make, but make it about the industry overall, not just the Switch being sold off the back of Zelda, or the fact Mario Odyssey is one of the most tantalising upcoming exclusives.

Because let's take stock: Who are Sony's PlayStation mascots right now? Nathan Drake and just this year, Aloy... kinda? Back at launch the PS4 was being paraded around with the sentient shed that was Knack. Knack and... 'the Helghast guy'. Really iconic characters there, Sony.

Advertisement

On Microsoft's end, well... they have no one. Not a single character other than Master Chief or maybe Marcus Fenix, and they've got a combined age of 27 years between them.

At least when Nintendo fall back on their time-tested icons it's to do something truly great with them. Breath of the Wild addresses the very idea of a 'Legend of Zelda' head-on across its story, coming complete with a great cast of characters, and Mario Odyssey is daring to take the rotund fireball-throwing plumber into an actual bustling city for a change.

Advertisement

Say what you like about reusing these guys, but as the PS1, N64, PS2 and Xbox 360 proved in abundance, a system is so much more when it comes with a pretty face.

--

Advertisement

Have you picked up a Nintendo Switch? Let us know in the comments!