8 Reasons Dark Souls Is BETTER Than Sekiro

Nothing tops FromSoftware's OG masterpiece.

By Josh Brown /

FromSoftware

Even though it's only been a couple of years, the wait for FromSoftware's Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice has been excruciating. After dropping Bloodborne and finishing the Dark Souls trilogy, all eyes were on the studio's next release, which promised to be a major departure from the kind of games the team had spent the entire decade perfecting.

Advertisement

Fortunately, the wait has been worth it, and Sekiro has immediately become one of the major game of the year contenders released so far in 2019. Its emphasis on freedom of movement and switch to a more action-oriented combat system that encourages aggressive play has made for an experience that plays remarkably different from the developer's other releases.

But, at its heart, Sekiro is still very much part of the sub-genre FromSoftware's known for. It's not surprising then that debate is currently raging over whether or not this is the new bar that all other games by the devs need to be compared to going forward. It's going to be a tough battle, as From's latest is damn good, but no matter how great Sekiro may be, the original Dark Souls still has the edge over it in some pretty substantial areas...

Advertisement

8. Enemy Variety

From Software

Sekiro isn't a slouch when it comes to the different kinds of enemies it throws at you, and players will be battling everything from hulking samurais to murderous chickens throughout their journey. The difference is, because the combat system is based on clashing swords, by necessity a lot of the creatures you fight need to be humanoid and work by the same rules.

Advertisement

Dark Souls, on the other hand, doesn't have that same problem. Sure, it too has its fair share of human-esque enemies, but there's still plenty of variation. They might initially appear similar, but the Black Knights, the ghouls and the bat wing demon all look and act radically different.

Each area in Dark Souls comes with its own appropriately-themed baddies to fight, not only awarding the game with a real sense of visual variety (as well as further adding distinction to each new part of the map), but always offering a new chance to flex your combat skills.

Advertisement

You can go from fighting regular guys with swords one minute to dodging dragons the next, and the sheer unpredictability of what's waiting for you around the next corner is something Sekiro doesn't really have.

7. Online Integration Is Sorely Missed

From Software

While it's totally fine that Sekiro opted to drop the multiplayer elements in favour of a more focused solo experience, you don't actually realise how much you enjoyed the multiplayer features in Dark Souls until they're not there.

Advertisement

While PvP and PvE are their own unique beast - and the decision to force players to tackle challenges head on rather than calling in someone to help does arguably make for a more satisfying experience overall - the act of reading messages left by other players adds such a unique element to Dark Souls. The world itself is overbearing and oppressive, but the notes left behind by others make it clear you're not alone.

Not only does it keep the world feeling lived in and that you're part of a larger journey, but it also facilitates exploration. FromSoftware's worlds are purposefully obtuse, and these pointers can usher you down the right path without leaving you running around trying to figure out what to do next.

Advertisement

6. Exploration Is Actually Rewarding

Namco Bandai

Sekiro's world is bold and beautiful and a joy to explore, but sometimes venturing out off the beaten path is more hassle than it's worth. Sure, you might bump into some enemies that net you a little bit more XP and Sen, but there's no real drive to set off and seek out the glowing item in the distance because, more often than not, you'll be disappointed by the reward.

Advertisement

All you're really going get is crafting materials for your prosthetic limb, some sugar, and useless pickups that you'll have plenty of anyway like ash. There's rarely ever something exciting to find out in the world except for more content and boss battles.

And that's fine, exploring Sekiro's map is still fun, but Dark Souls had that incentive and then even more on top. The items littered throughout Lodran were all worth picking up, and it was rare you encountered a drop that wasn't worth the effort to get. That's partly because weapons and armour could be found as well, an element of character building Sekiro doesn't have.

Advertisement

5. More Focused Level Design

FromSoftware

For this entry, I'm specifically talking about the actual layout of the levels and how the player navigates through them. Sekiro's are pretty impressive, more wide open than series veterans are used to and taking full advantage of the newfound freedom of movement. They're still enjoyable, but the need to always have stealth options, as you're encouraged to spread out and use the space available to sneak up on enemies, alongside the grapple hook ability, means there isn't always a focused route through each area.

Advertisement

There are, of course, some inspired layouts, for instance scaling the rooftops to reach Kuro's quarters or exploring underwater in the later game, but for the most part you'll be dealing with the same kind of vertical, spacious levels time after time.

Dark Souls, on the other hand, is labyrinthian and purposeful, with every nook and cranny being specifically built around the player's limited movement (bar a couple of clearly unfinished areas in the final third). Sekiro's levels are fun, but none come close to the meticulously paced challenge of Sen's Fortress, the terrifying descent into Blighttown or even getting a handle on Anor Londo's architecture.

Advertisement

Then, of course, there's the fact that Dark Souls' environment loops back into itself, creating one geographically-cohesive world. It might not be fair to mark From's new game down for not having this, but a lot of Sekiro's levels feel like, well, levels. Ones you go through once then never think about again.

4. Environments Are More Creative

FromSoftware

This one is a little bit more subjective and probably will come down the kind of world you prefer, but the environments in Dark Souls have way more variety when it comes to how they look, and across art direction in general. For instance, the rooftops of Undead Burg give way to the previously mentioned depths of Blighttown, which further descend into Hell with the demon ruins. No two areas in the game look the same.

Advertisement

You always feel like you're venturing to places where humans don't belong, going from areas that look vaguely familiar in their layout and architecture, to Lovecraftian hellscapes that are gorgeous to simply stop and look at.

Sekiro, on the other hand, while beautiful, has a lot of areas that look similar. Ashina and its surroundings are lovingly detailed and rooted in Japanese culture, but by taking a more "realistic" approach to the design, a lot of the map inevitably looks a little familiar.

Advertisement

There are few surprises, like the illusory monkey world, but they're few and far between. Worse still, some environments are ripped straight out of FromSoftware's cheat book, with yet another poison pit and mystical forest showing up. It's still awesome, but lacks the variety that made Dark Souls' world resonate so deeply.

3. There Are More Surprises

From Software

Perhaps by virtue of its story being so weird and the fabric of the world being on the verge of completely coming undone, Dark Souls is full of left-turns that you have no way of seeing coming. It offers so many mysteries to the player that, without a guide, there's no chance you'll be able to figure out everything for yourself. From the Painted World to travelling back to the Undead Asylum, there was always some huge secret for you to uncover that offered new gameplay opportunities.

Advertisement

Granted, Sekiro still has its fair share. The first time a certain boss comes back to life or calls in his friend to help will see you punch the air in satisfaction, but they're never as totally mind blowing as those found in Dark Souls. That game had such a pervasive sense of mystique to it, the idea that you can't trust anything even if you've already played through it once, twice, or ten times before.

Even worse, and yet again, a lot of Sekiro's more imaginative beats recycle those found in other FromSoftware games. A leap of faith revealing a hidden new area, NPC moral choices hiding in plain sight and a mysterious blood disease have all featured in one form or another before.

Advertisement

It's not that they're bad, just that the devs needed to switch things up to really continue to surprise players.

2. Deeper Character Building

Namco Bandai

One of Sekiro's main aims was to streamline the core Souls experience, and one of the biggest casualties of that approach was the player's freedom to tinker with their character. While opting for a defined protagonist inherently meant that customising their look was out the window, the lack of armour options and the near total removal of RPG systems was tougher to swallow.

Advertisement

In Souls, each kill in the world adds to experience points, which are used to upgrade a whole host of stats at bonfires. Contrarily, Sekiro only uses experience for specific traits and moves, and you're not at a huge disadvantage if you don't unlock all of them. Instead, you gain more vitality, health and posture by simply killing bosses and exploring.

It's not a bad system, but it kind of strips away the risk/reward element that dying brings in these games. Being able to unlock new talents or keep Sen does bring its benefits, but it's not as integral to getting more powerful as your core attributes are in Souls. The developers seemingly understood this, and the Dragonrot system instead functions as a harsher punishment for death than purely losing resources.

Advertisement

This is all on top of the lack of other features as well, like the aforementioned armour and weapon systems which add even more choice and freedom to Souls.

1. The Boss Fights

FromSoftware

If there's one thing that FromSoftware is virtually unrivalled at, it's boss fights. Throughout each and every one of their games, they've delivered bouts that match their insane difficulty with unbelievable spectacle, and Sekiro is no different. Already, so many players have their own story about the joy they felt overcoming the pain of Genichiro at the peak of Ashina, or how their jaw dropped when the second phase of Guardian Ape's battle kicked into gear.

Advertisement

On the whole though, the amount of bosses in Sekiro leaves something to be desired. For the most part, the game relies on mini-bosses to make up the bulk of its major fights, which, admittedly, can become quite samey. Even when these enemies aren't repeated in their entirety, the focus on sword combat makes a lot feel familiar even if their attacks are technically different.

Bosses in Dark Souls, though, are always radically divergent, both in their attack styles and their appearance. Going into one of these boss areas and looking at a huge beast, only to carve him down to size, awards you with a sense of satisfaction that From's original game delivers over and over again.

Advertisement

Sekiro's greatest bosses can imbue you with the same feeling, but there are only a handful of really notable candidates littered throughout.