8 Times Video Game Violence Went Too Far This Generation

What is it with Outlast and genital mutilation?

By Josh Brown /

Video game violence is far from the controversial topic it once was. In fact, it's hard to believe just how much furore and debate surrounded depictions of violence in games as recent as a decade ago.

Advertisement

Gone are the days of Fox News being loaded with 'experts' talking about how violence in GTA is turning our kids into psychopaths, and it's generally been accepted that the medium's focus on violence is no more harmful than your average action movie or HBO show.

Consequently, with greater technical advancements and a more lax approach to censorship, games have embraced the gore this generation. Fatalities in Mortal Kombat have never looked better or been grosser, and players have enjoyed more imaginative ways to dispatch their enemies in COD than ever before.

Just because the industry doesn't receive anywhere near the attention or criticism it once did though, doesn't mean that some video games don't go too far with their violence. Issues of taste and sensitivity still have to be taken into account when unpacking a new release, and there's no denying that a few games this generation have definitely pushed the boundaries of these standards as far as possible.

8. Rise Of The Tomb Raider's Gratuitous Death Scenes

Over-the-top gory deaths have been a staple of the Tomb Raider franchise since it was rebooted in 2013. Attempting to showcase the brutal new world of Lara Croft, even the smallest mistake in the original game could result in the player having to watch the character being completely mangled.

Advertisement

While it was still gratuitous in that game though, at least there was a believable context for it, as the first title was all about Lara's quest for survival against a punishing new reality. With everything including the very island itself trying to kill her, the constant punishment felt in fitting with the title's themes of overcoming insurmountable odds.

Unfortunately Rise of the Tomb Raider doesn't have that same origin story context, yet the OTT death scenes are still present in full force.

Moving away from the grounded universe of the original and putting more focus on the fantastical themes the franchise was previously known for, Lara's punishment in the second game came across as exploitative and unnecessary, even more out of place than they previously were.

7. Dishonored 2's Extreme Finishing Moves

The original Dishonored was a violent game, but it never went too far with its depictions of gore. The sequel however ramped up the intensity of the combat to 11, allowing players to cut off limbs and completely mutilate foes with a swift flick of the wrist.

Advertisement

While the cartoon aesthetic allowed Dishonored to get away with its violence a little bit though, there's no denying that the ability to brutally dismember and decapitate people was sort of at odds with the world the developers created.

The binary morality system in the sequel often boiled the game down to a pacifist nonlethal play-style and an evil murderous one, but the extreme executions meant that there was no ethical middle ground for players to fall between.

Killing enemies meant that you also had to be a rampaging, bloodthirsty serial killer, which obviously promoted the pacifistic approach as the 'good' way to to play the game.

Extreme gore is a staple of video games, but in the case of Dishonored 2 it wasn't needed, and only took away from its otherwise brilliantly constructed world.

6. The Walking Dead Season 3's Badger Execution

Despite being a cell-shaded game, The Walking Dead has always had the ability to shock. Just like its comic book counterpart, the stylised presentation of the title doesn't make the violence any less impactful, and multiple times over the series the game has pushed the boundaries of video game violence to the extreme.

Advertisement

The third season however features perhaps the most explicitly brutal death in the whole franchise. After finally getting the upper hand on Badger, one of the game's main villains, the player is given the option to enact some sweet revenge by bashing his head in with a baseball bat.

Fans of the series know that death by baseball bat is one of the worst ways to go in this universe, and the game doesn't shy away from showing the carnage that the signature weapon can cause.

While you can stop before completely decimating the guy, you can continue bringing down the pain over and over again until his face is nothing but mulch.

5. What Remains Of Edith Finch

The violence in What Remains of Edith Finch isn't particularly gory or even that explicit, but it's incredibly unnerving. The entire game is made up of the multiple deaths that have haunted the Finch family, with the demise of each family member being presented through a surreal retelling that embellishes some of the details.

Advertisement

One of the Finch's however was only a newborn when he died as a result of drowning, so when you get to his room late in the game, you know that there isn't going to be a happy ending at the end of his story.

Taking control of the baby as he's left unattended in the bathtub, players are encouraged to play with toys while classical music plays in the background. Seeing the world though the eyes of the child, everything has a sense of whimsy to it, even as the water starts to fill up to an alarming high level.

With the sequence only getting more surreal as the child goes under, the death scene continues to be unnerving precisely because of how idyllic it seems to be on the surface.

It's not explicit and it's definitely more metaphorical than any other entry on this list, but being in control of a stylised version of a baby's drowning certainly leaves a bad taste in your mouth once it's over.

4. Hotline Miami 2's Staged Rape Scene

Despite its overhead, cartoon presentation, the original Hotline Miami prided itself on being as bloody and as gory as humanly possible. When it came time to craft a sequel then, it was accepted that the developers would try to shock players even more than they did the first time around.

Advertisement

Creating an opening scene that cast you as a deranged killer about to murder a room full of goons, initially the beginning of the second game seemed like business as usual. The title played its hand at the end of the level though, making the player press the action button to begin sexually assaulting a female character they'd just wounded.

It's quickly revealed that what you're actually playing is part of a movie production rather than happening in real life, but it doesn't make the moment any less impactful. If anything it makes it worse, as it becomes clear that sexual assault is only being used as a cheap way to shock the audience.

Fake or not, making the player live out a rape scene in the game's opening soured Hotline Miami 2 for many before it had a chance to properly get going.

3. Hatred's Depiction Of Mass Shootings

Hatred became the number one target of critics long before it came out. Ridiculed for putting players into the shoes of a mass shooter and letting them live out their most murderous fantasies, the title remained in the public eye right up to its release.

Advertisement

When players finally got their hands on it however, they realised Hatred wasn't as controversial as it could have been, and that a lot of the fears leading up to the game turned out to be unfounded or blown out of proportion. Trying hard to paint the main character as a laughable parody, it was clear that players weren't supposed to be onboard with his mission, and that the title was a far cry from a glorification of mass shooters.

Still, just because players weren't supposed to sympathise with the killer or take their side, it didn't mean that the violence committed was any less uncomfortable. Despite its stylised presentation, the title still hit a bit too close to home, and its themes remain as sensitive today as they were in 2015.

Hatred wasn't quite as distasteful as many thought it was going to be, but that still didn't detract from the fact that making a game around a remorseless mass shooter probably wasn't what the world needed.

2. Paz's Impromptu Surgery In Metal Gear Solid: Ground Zeroes

One of the most controversial scenes in the entire Metal Gear Solid franchise, Paz's surgery at the end of Ground Zeroes is surprisingly grim and harrowing for a series that often revels in comic violence and camp.

Advertisement

After saving her from Camp Omega, Big Boss and the rest of the team begin their escape via helicopter when they're informed that the injured Paz has been surgically implanted with a bomb.

Calling in the medic, Boss decides to cut her open there and then, with the game forcing players to watch as the team rake around in the character's stomach while she screams in agony.

When the punishment is finally over and the bomb has been found though, they're told that a second explosive was also hidden in her body, which then detonates.

The scene would have been horrifying no matter who it was happening to, but the fact that it's the child-like Paz who has to suffer only makes the moment even more uncomfortable.

Not only does she look incredibly young, but she had also been a survivor of sexual abuse, making her one of the most tragic characters in a series built on tragic characters.

1. Outlast: Whistleblower's Mutilated Science Projects

Known for indulging in gore and horror to its furthest extremes, the Outlast franchise is home to plenty of violent moments that have pushed the envelope, but none have come close to matching the excess found in the Whistleblower DLC.

Advertisement

A side-story set during the events of the original game, one lengthy section has players attempting to escape from the clutches of Eddie Gluskin, otherwise known as 'The Groom', an inmate trying to find himself a wife in order to start a family.

The problem, however, is that the Mount Massive asylum is an all-male institution. Not letting that stop him, the surgeon has captured dozens of test subjects to try and carve himself a makeshift bride, forcibly making them undergo a gruesome sex-change surgery.

The procedure is more twisted than that though, as not only does the good doctor constantly boast about his work, but the player is invited to marvel at the madman's results in all their glory.

One failed attempt goes completely overboard however, acting as a horrifically demented take on a birthing scene. Depicting a fully-naked victim tied to a bed with their genitals removed and a head sticking out from the wound, Outlast conjures an outrageous image that has to be seen to be believed.

Advertisement