9 Major Problems With Fallout Nobody Wants To Admit

Admit it, The Brotherhood of Steel are the lamest heroes ever.

By Josh Brown /

Far from a guaranteed success, Bethesda's revival of such an old niche IP back in 2008 wasn't a surefire way for the developers to shift millions of copies and make mega-bucks. Rather than relying on the name value alone however, the studio put in the effort to create some amazing RPG experiences that captured the imagination of players worldwide, transforming this failing property into a global success story, virtually overnight.

Advertisement

Though considering just how thoroughly the franchise took the world by storm, it could be easy to think that the games released so far have done no wrong.

With Fallout 3, New Vegas and 4 all being critical darlings, the franchise seems to be on pretty solid ground. But with public opinion slowly souring after the release of the latest sequel, Bethesda could be in trouble going forward.

Truly, while the games themselves have all received pretty positive reviews, there are some glaring problems with the series that nobody wants to admit. Bubbling under the surface and detracting from the experience for years now, if the developers don't address these flaws then the future of the series might end up being as bleak as the post-apocalyptic wastelands it calls home.

9. The Worlds Need More Variety

After three contemporary releases all focused on exploring the post-apocalyptic wastelands of the Fallout universe, one thing is starting to become clear: they're pretty boring.

Advertisement

The world of Fallout 3 and New Vegas in particular, while having some inspired environments, were for the most part made up of the same repeated rubble-filled expanses and desolated factories and buildings.

Bethesda attempted to give the world more variety in Fallout 4, but even then they only proved that there's only so much you can do with a post-apocalyptic landscape.

There's just no way to capture the sense of wonder that's found in a game like Skyrim, and while you could argue that Fallout is a purposefully more oppressive and bleak experience, its world should still inspire something in the player rather than a crippling sense of familiarity.

8. Dated Graphics Are Becoming A Real Problem

Although Bethesda was cut a lot of slack in the previous generation for not having the best looking open world games around, a lot of the excuses and justifications for their poor graphics no longer hold up today.

Advertisement

Because while previously sandbox games had to sacrifice visual detail for an increased scale, games like The Witcher 3 and Arkham Knight are proof that that's no longer the case.

The Fallout series can look beautiful in certain scenarios and under the right conditions, but more often than not the games look incredibly dated when viewed up close or during regular minute-to-minute gameplay.

Graphics aren't everything of course, but with the franchise moving towards a conventional 'cinematic' experience that puts the focus on the player's created protagonist, bad visuals can detract from its intended impact.

The older games could get away with it because they were closer to text-based RPGs than something like Mass Effect, but if they want to make the recent changes to the franchise succeed, Bethesda need to massively up their game when it comes to visual presentation.

7. It Doesn't Hold Up As A First-Person Shooter

The shooting in the Fallout series has always been shaky, but for the most part the earlier games were able to get away with it because it was never the main focus. Between stealth, speech, and non-lethal mechanics, there used to be many ways to accomplish missions or level up in the previous releases, however Fallout 4 stripped out most of these options when it released in 2015.

Advertisement

Gradually making shooting and action the core thing that Fallout has to offer ever since the third game, the series has taken steps to centre its appeal around its combat. Unfortunately, if that's what the series is going to be judged primarily on going forward, it's just not good enough.

Despite drafting in help from the guys at Id for the fourth title, the shooting still didn't hold a candle to similar games releasing at the time. Hell, it didn't even match up to other titles from Bethesda's own stable.

6. The "Sense Of Freedom" Is An Illusion

Todd Howard is quick to point out that in Bethesda's RPGs, you're only ever limited by your imagination. Selling the idea that you can craft your own personal stories and play the game any way you want, freedom and choice have been at the heart of Fallout's marketing campaign ever since it reappeared in 2008.

Advertisement

While it's true that you can indeed throw caution to the wind, gun down anyone you see and royally attempt to mess up the series' efforts to shepherd you onto the recommended path, it's not a viable way to play.

Although the games do let you go nuts and do what you want, they very rarely account for your actions against the beaten path. Killing key characters for the most part just locks you out of content that you may have otherwise enjoyed, rather than providing you with an equally thrilling alternative scenario.

The illusion of choice is there, but when it comes down to it, you can follow the select few options the game gives you, or miss out on everything else on offer.

5. Bugs Can (And Will) Ruin The Experience

Bugs in Bethesda's games have become something of a running joke by now, but it's easy to forget just how much they actually drag the developer's titles down.

Advertisement

Sure, booting up New Vegas and having the head of the first character you meet start twirling around is pretty funny, but realising later on that you can't get into the Vegas strip without the game crashing on you isn't as much of a laughing matter.

Even disregarding the few game-breaking bugs or glitches that lock you out of specific quests though, the basic instability of the Fallout series is a major problem in and of itself.

An enemy's A.I. freaking out makes the game's shooting feel even less challenging than it already is, while nothing sucks the fun out of supposedly epic moments more than having the game tank to ten frames per second just as they're about to happen.

4. Its Main Quests Are Terrible

It's long been accepted that Bethesda are much better at creating side missions than crafting a well-told main narrative, but its shortcomings in this area were really put on display in the latest game.

Advertisement

Attempting to create a more immersive and interesting main quest line that personally involved the player, Bethesda clearly invested way more time and effort into the central narrative of Fallout 4, but that extra work didn't exactly pay off.

Sure, the plot was more grandiose and expansive than ever before, but it still fell into the same, familiar patterns of the previous games. Once again you were only treated to binary choices and siding with a faction or two, being forced to kill off the others even if you didn't have any beef with them.

It was forced and contrived, and once again proved that Bethesda have no idea how to create genuine moral choices that are worth a damn.

3. Factions Have No Depth

Despite key factions turning up repeatedly throughout the Fallout series, very few of them are memorable. The Brotherhood of Steel is probably the most instantly recognisable group from the whole franchise, yet fans would be hard pressed to pick out a defining trait of theirs that isn't just "likes technology".

Advertisement

It's not just them either though, but the other factions from previous games like the Railroad, NCR and Enclave can also be summed up in about one sentence.

Groups and guilds in games like Skyrim and Oblivion don't have much depth to them either, but at least they're interesting and contribute to radically different missions and gameplay styles.

The factions you meet in Fallout however, are virtually just re-skins of one another, each with only slightly different goals and motivations. They all want you to accomplish the same kinds of things, and don't have anything valuable to offer that you couldn't just find on your own scavenging in the world.

2. There's No Real Way To Impact The World

The Fallout series has always been full of little narrative decisions to make on your journeys through the wasteland, but they rarely ever have any lasting impact on the state of the world.

Advertisement

Going down different paths or making different choices could result in the player deciding whether a character lives or dies, but these scenarios are almost always self contained, and their consequences are never brought up again.

In a way it's like they never happened at all, as the only person they have an impact on is you. Outside of a major couple of scenarios, your decisions rarely matter in the grand scheme of things, and you only have to consider the consequences in the moment.

The closest players got to truly influencing the world of the games was in New Vegas, where there was a surprising amount of variation in the endings and the state of the strip. For the most part though, despite the amount of carnage you can cause and people you can meet, your effects are rarely ever felt on the world, and there's no real meaning to your actions.

1. It's Lost Its Identity

Once over Fallout was known for its immersive storytelling and focus on player choice, and while those aspects are still present in the most recent games, they've been buried under a myriad of new features, mechanics and systems.

Advertisement

Trying to juggle every game design idea from the past ten years, Fallout these days is equally about resource management, crafting and settlement building as much as it is exploration and adventure. While these systems in isolation aren't bad, and some like the crafting and looting are actually pretty great, together they make for an experience that lacks focus.

Consequently, although Fallout 4 is technically an RPG, you wouldn't be able to tell at a glance. The title's priorities are all over the place, sometimes focusing heavily on settlement building while other times focusing primarily on making decisions and role-playing in the main narrative.

The problem is that these different focuses are always kept separate from each other, never interacting to make for one cohesive experience. Going forward Fallout needs to decide what it wants to be rather than trying to be everything at once, and it might just find an identity in the process.

Advertisement