9 Video Game Fan Theories The Creators Completely Rejected

Ditto a failed clone of Mew? Guess again.

By Simon Gallagher /

Niantic

Expecting video game makers to answer every little question you have is just plain ridiculous. They're busy people and they have a difficult enough time as it is having to deal with GamerGate's "intelligent debate." So no, you'll probably never definitively know the true secret of Monkey Island. Or how Kirby got his name. Or why Valve seem more content to make jokes about Half-Life 3 than actually making the f*ckng game.

Advertisement

Occasionally though, the game industry will do a JK Rowling and respond to specific fan theories. We already know, for instance, that Nintendo legend Satoru Iwata has confirmed that Super Smash Bros' characters are just toys and that Mario creator Shigeru Miyamoto says Super Mario Bros 3 is indeed a play. It's all there in their own words.

But game creators have also been just as vocal in smashing some theories to bits as well...

Advertisement

9. Zero Went On A Crazed Killing Spree - Mega Man

Capcom

The Theory

According to one popular theory, Maverick Hunter Zero - who turned up first in Mega Man X after being created by Dr Wily - has a dark secret. He apparently went berserk and killed the original Mega Man (as well as the rest of the original cast). Heavy stuff.

Advertisement

The Rejection

Well, not according to Keiji Inafune, the father of Mega Man forebear, Rockman, who took the opportunity of one session answering Capcom-Unity Member's questions to bat the theory away.

Advertisement

One fan submitted the question asking whether Zero had killed "the family" after the events of the Classic series and his response was: "No, Zero did not kill them. According to the way I created him, Zero is not such a person - it is not in his profile." And who would know better than him?

8. All Of The Main Characters Had Their Legs Removed - Star Fox

Nintendo

The Theory

Advertisement

Ever wondered why it appears that Star Fox cast of characters have metal legs? There's an answer to that thanks to the game's fans: apparently, the team all had their legs removed to stop them having blood flow problems that would cause them to pass out in flight.

That would be why Slippy Toad doesn't have the usual amphibian legs and tell-tale webbed feet and why Falco Lombardi doesn't have claws. Grim, but functional.

Advertisement

The Rejection

Game creator Shigeru Miyamoto revealed that Miyamoto revealed in conversation with The Game Theorists that the theory is nothing more than fancy. Less glamorously (and less grotesquely, perhaps too), the legs were a stylistic choice to make the animals look more human-like.

Advertisement

In other words, they have their legs still, they just wear boots that hide the fact.

7. Tingle Is Gay - The Legend Of Zelda

Nintendo

The Theory

Advertisement

Tingle is a divisive figure among The Legend Of Zelda fans and is infamous even beyond the limits of that committed group, thanks to how flat-out odd he is. He's obsessed with fairies - to the point that he dresses like one and loses his mind when he meets Link in Majora's Mask and sees he comes with a fairy - and that was apparently enough to inspire fans to speculate about his sexuality. For some reason.

One pervading theory suggests that his penchant for fairies was a reflection of him being gay.

Advertisement

The Rejection

Why it would a problem is anyone's guess, but it's not true. So says Zelda producer Eiji Aonuma who went on the record to say outright that Tingle is "not gay" and that in fact he's just "really weird".

Advertisement

6. Gogo Is Really Darill - Final Fantasy VI

Square Enix

The Theory

Advertisement

Found within the stomach of the Zone Eater on Triangle Island, Gogo is a playable character in Final Fantasy VI whose true identity has always been a bit of a mystery. Fans have posited that he could be either Emperor Gestahl, Banon, Famed Mimic Gogo from Final Fantasy V or, most famously, Darill, Setzer's old friend.

It's very much a case of an answer springing forth into a vacuum.

Advertisement

The Rejection

According to director Yoshinori Kitase, Gogo actually has no secret identity nor a backstory: there's basically only mystery there because there's no story to tell.

Advertisement

He responded to the theory specifically in an interview to debunk it and to explain why:

“That’s probably not true. I don’t think there’s any background setting like that. If that’s true, then because Darill had that beautiful ending, if [she] ended up being Gogo, that would just destroy all that.”

At the same time, he confirmed that neither Gogo nor Umaro had any sort of backstory:

Advertisement
"They were just there for you to select if you want them to be in battle.”

5. Tails Was Supposed To Be Sonic's Girlfriend

Sega

The Theory

Advertisement

One long-running and weirdly popular Sonic theory suggested for years that Tails - Sonic's twin-tailed side-kick - was originally intended to be female and would have been introduced as a love interest for Sonic. This apparently came from the time a games magazine mistook Tails' chest hair as breasts and misgendered him.

The theory also suggested that the song "Sweet Dream" by Dream's Come True was to be dedicated to their relationship.

Advertisement

The Rejection

Sure, it sounds romantic, but it's just not true.

Advertisement

Tails' creator Yasushi Yamaguchi - who won a design competition to get the character into the game - shared a celebratory image on the occasion of Tails' 25th birthday that included some information on the character debunking the theory.

The image included confirmation of how the theory came about and proclaiming that Tails was always intended to be male.

Advertisement

4. Albert Wesker LIVES - Resident Evil

Capcom

The Theory

Advertisement

As always seems to happen when a popular, main character from any franchise dies, fans were reluctant to accept that Resident Evil's Albert Wesker was indeed dead after Resident Evil 5.

A pro-life group of fans theorised that he actually survived and would be returning. Because there's nothing quite as indignant and stubborn as a fan who feels like they've been wronged emotionally. And to be fair, he was a great character.

Advertisement

The Rejection

Unfortunately for fans holding out for a return, Resident Evil series producer Masachika Kawata is having none of it: "Even if you want Albert Wesker to come back, there's no chance he's coming back from that."

Advertisement

3. Bob-Ombs Turn Into Boos When You Kill Them - Super Mario Bros

Nintendo

The Theory

Advertisement

There's always a bit of an obsession among gaming fans to find the origin of characters, particularly when there's an element of mystery behind them. For instance, why would a world as colourful and cheerful as the one the Super Mario Bros inhabit be positively chocked-full of ghosts?

There must be some sort of major trauma in that world's past, surely? Well, according to one theory, the ghosts - or Boos to give them their real name - are actually "born" when Bob-ombs explode. Which would fit, since the little bomb guys have faces and legs and apparenrtly souls in some opinions.

Advertisement

The Rejection

All it took for this one was a slightly amused shake of the head from Shigeru Miyamoto, who appeared in a Nintendo video to dispel the myth once and for all:

Advertisement

2. Squall Actually Dies - Final Fantasy VIII

Square Enix

The Theory

Advertisement

Another Final Fantasy theory suggests that Squall Leonhart - the protagonist of Final Fantasy VIII - actually dies at the end of disc one when he's stabbed by Edea's ice spear and the rest of the game's story is in fact just his dying dream.

The Rejection

Advertisement

Yoshinori Kitase, the producer of the Final Fantasy series laughed this one off, which is not all that surprising:

“No, that is not true. I think he was actually stabbed around the shoulder area, so he was not dead. But that is a very interesting idea, so if we ever do make a remake of Final Fantasy VIII, I might go along with that story in mind.”

So, it's not a fact now, but maybe we'll get to see it in future? Then again, imagine the outrage if they messed with the game that much for a remake...

Advertisement

1. Ditto Is A Failed Mew Clone - Pokemon

Nintendo

The Theory

Advertisement

Thanks to some shared details between Ditto and Mew (like their exact same weight of 8.8lbs) and the fact that Ditto only spawns in Pokemon Yellow in two locations linked to Mewtwo (the Pokemon mansion, where Mewtwo was cloned from Mew and Cerulean Cave where Mewtwo lives), fans have taken to believing that Ditto is in fact closely related to Mew and Mewtwo.

How closely? Well, how about the idea that ditto is in fact a failed clone of Mew? Which is why it looks as it does.

Advertisement

The Rejection

It's a nice idea, but it's apparently not true, according to Pokemon art director and producer Junichi Masuda who was asked whether the theory is true. His response was a pretty big no-sell:

Advertisement

"That’s the first time I have ever hear that rumor actually... In terms of how Pokémon are designed, they are each their own unique living being. The unique thing about Ditto is that it’s a Pokémon that can change forms, but each Pokémon we create with its own unique element, so we just make sure that they are all individual life forms of their own."

That's about as close to a complete denial as you're likely to get, even despite the "evidence."

Advertisement

Which other video game theories have been disproved by creators? Share your picks below in the comments thread.