Assassin’s Creed: 5 Must-Plays & 5 That Suck
Take a Leap of Faith with us, join the brotherhood.
The Assassin's Creed series has gifted fans with glorious reconstructions of lost cities and landscapes to get themselves swept up in.
Offering a slew of engaging narratives carved around vital moments in history, our adventures began with Altair - our first protagonist in a more linear tale - all the way to present day, and the more expansive open worlds of recent titles in Origins and Odyssey.
Innovative movement and engaging storytelling, Assassin's Creed also set the standard for parkour-led gaming.
And such a carefully crafted game deserves a deep dive into what makes an essential piece of any Assassin's Creed storytelling. This also serves as a handy guide as to which of these titles should make it onto your pile of games to get to - we've all got that pile after all - and it only grows and grows.
But not every game can make it. For example, an honourable mention to Assassin's Creed Revelations - a game that, while bolstered by solid mechanics and a sound story, offered many of the same aspects we see in Brotherhood.
Now, take a "leap of faith" and join us on a journey as we let you know what titles you MUST tackle on your play through of the Assassin's Creed games.
10. Sucks: Rogue
We start with some controversy, and who doesn't enjoy a little controversy, right?
Assassin's Creed Rogue was the second release from Ubisoft within 2014. While it arguably was a stellar performance, it was also found wanting in a multitude of key areas.
With enjoyable game play and graphics that were equally tasteful, it was its story that left a lot to be desired. A slog throughout, the switch in focus to having the player hunt down other assassins as opposed to the familiar goal of eliminating Templars was testing.
Some nice additions appeared, such as the rifle - and there were some minor tweaks to the parkour to offer a few fun extras, but not much else leaves us clamouring to return any time soon.
Attempts at innovation in gaming tend to be greeted with a mixed opinions, but this wasn't a change that was met well with fans. Essentially an elaborate expansion pack for Black Flag, it's fair to say that this classes more of a "you won't miss much if you don't play this title" entry to the series.
A pleasant outing in parts, Rogue was a glorified extra that wasn't required by the fandom that year, and one that could have warranted a stronger effort expanding its world before release.
9. Must Play: Assassins Creed
Now, you may argue that the first Assassin's Creed is a game that has failed to age gracefully, is unflattering in how linear it is, and has been ranked as one of the worst in the franchise for a long time, but hear us out on this one.
Assassin's Creed was groundbreaking during its time. It's the opening chapter to the Templar vs Assassin story, breaking the mould for parkour and other open world titles.
Aesthetically Assassin's Creed holds up well in comparison to many titles following in its footsteps. It laid the groundwork for the lore many fans are familiar with now. Despite being a man of few words (or emotions) engrossing yourself in their story arc and the trials and tribulations of Altair is effortless.
They are some clear limitations in the mechanics available, yet the argument to play the original Assassin's Creed is simple; to understand where we are it's important to understand where we came from.
It may not be the most flamboyant title in the series, but what makes it a "must play" is that it's the opening entry into now what is a truly expansive open-world story with depth and character.
We won't mention the ridiculous final battle though...
8. Sucks: Unity
A bug infested mess, Unity drove us all crazy with it's awkward frame-rate and all around glitch-filled mechanics.
The backdrop of the French Revolution offered a beautiful environment to explore - when it was rendering properly of course - and the game in its entirety was an intriguing property for fans.
However shoddy graphical issues, the lack of an option to be a female character and a somehow mundane story leaves nothing but disappointment in those unfortunate enough to play it.
Unity was the first game in the franchise to enable players the ability to upgrade their character. It also introduced some genuinely joyous-looking parkour, not to mention the freedom to play cooperatively online. It's developers clearly had some positive ambitions.
But the final product is something that falls catastrophically short. Tired and frankly all-too generic mission structures, and a sloppy sets of controls, Unity is lumbered with bad vibes all round.
It tries to accomplish what many other entries in the franchise do more successfully, and thus should be avoided during any playthroughs as it offers nothing new or enterprising.
7. Must Play: Black Flag
Seemingly more beloved with age, Black Flag marked a defining moment for the series. Opting to take to the high seas the new game managed to maintain the crisp and free-flowing nature of the previous titles, yet offer a new take on combat for players to master.
Black Flag has tremendous replayability, with a mammoth array of possible battles and quests to take on, it appears almost impossible to complete.
The diversity in the characters you encounter - each with their own unique flair - ensures that no matter how often you captain your ship and take to the seas, you're greeted with something new. With Havana, Kingston and Nassau all lovingly rendered (and littered with intimidating foes) the game is a masterpiece in colour and vibrancy.
That is, of course, without having to mention that you also explore expansive Mayan Ruins, shipwrecks, jungles and countless other set-pieces.
The game also saw the return of Assassin Recruitment. This only serves to aid in the argument that a return to the game is warranted.
Black Flag innovated something rich and diverse, but remains one of the most standalone, lighthearted titles. This means, should you want to, you can switch off your brain from the sometimes intimidating lore and escape to the seas, conquering ships aplenty as you go.
6. Sucks: Assassins Creed 3
From one successful tale of innovation, to one of fraught failure.
Quite possibly the most divisive entry to this list, Assassins Creed 3 was the first to introduce a new titular character from Desmond's story and began a new chapter in the series.
As Connor players were tasked with playing a pivotal role in the American Revolution, a fresh setting for the series and a welcome detachment from its past time periods.
Armed with new moves such as running through trees and a collection of other attacks, it appeared to be on the right track. However it's a shallow outing at best.
Connor's story is difficult to latch on to, as his character itself is terribly one dimensional. While the game aesthetically is more than pleasing, the story lacked a sense of gravity, and the characters themselves offered little to resonate with.
Promising fans a cutting-edge title, three fails to fully realise it's potential, and in truth, can be classified as a dry run for something better.
It also took hours - tangible HOURS - to get into being able freely begin your assassinations among the world. We don't want to have to go through that again, and neither do you.
5. Must Play: Origins
One word: beautiful.
At the time of its release, Origins had the unfortunate task of shining a new light on a series that for many had become stagnated. Each entry, while enjoyable, offered nothing groundbreaking or innovative to the point of standing out from the pack.
What makes Origins a must play is that beyond it's stunning set-pieces, gorgeous character models, wealth of Egyptian folk tales and charming titular character, it showcases Ubisoft's ability to deliver an open world that feels alive. It's gigantic map allows players to explore the vast majority of areas early on in the game, and the rewards seem fair enough to encourage you to keep coming back for more.
Opting to flesh out the opening times of the Assassin's Creed Brotherhood, Origins serves as a title that you must add to your list of Assassins games to complete.
Utilising the now infamous Ubisoft levelling-up RPG system, you can build your character in your own way for large parts - with some fabulous kicks, attacks, weapons and kill methods at your disposal.
While sections can become repetitive, the majority of the game is spent battling mythical monsters and enemies spoken of in spooky Egyptian folk lore, which is nothing if not engaging.
4. Sucks: Bloodlines
Attempting to bridge the gap between the first two games in the series, Bloodlines for the PSP never really got any footing.
An ambitious endeavour, the technical limitations of the handheld console left developers the unenviable task of converting a game with the scope of Assassin's Creed to the device - and suffice to say, there were issues.
Granted, it's actually a graphical success given the sheer lack of power the PSP has, but that's where the successes end.
Lumbered with terribly foolish and predictable AI, the game also offered little in terms of extras. Eagle vision - by now a staple of the series - was not included, and the open world felt lifeless and unappealing.
There isn't much to say on this one; it lacks a worthwhile narrative, takes a needless amount of effort to adapt to controls wise, and lacks many beloved features of the series.
This is one to avoid, or to look at from afar simply to appreciate what we have now by comparison.
3. Must Play: Assassins Creed 2
Potentially the greatest game in the franchise, Assassins Creed 2 arrived at the peak time of the generation and with a wealth of upgrades to boot. It's astonishing progression from the first game sees this is unquestionably the most highly acclaimed in the series.
With a likeable lead in Ezio Auditore - complete with his relatable, thrill seeking, natural story arc of boy to man - players were treated with a believable protagonist.
Stunning visuals, glorious reconstructions of Venice, The Vatican and Florence, and effortless combat meant that the game still stands out amongst its peers.
The title set the stage for each iteration seen thereafter, and established the bar that others should strive to reach.
The timing-based combat can feel a little limited at times, but otherwise it's a fun, charming, artful and purposeful journey from opening to close. The pacing is splendid, with little filler to deter away from the main action, which does somewhat hinder later games. You constantly feel that your actions are meaningful, and leading to the next phase of the story.
Add in tremendous voice acting, great character models and one Leonardo Da Vinci (and his aeroplane), and it's clear this game is something special - for fans of the series, and for those who've never played a single one.
2. Sucks: Liberation
Having the honour of the first female protagonist, one of colour no less, is genuinely fantastic. Having a wonderful New Orleans to explore is as equally fantastic.
However, Liberation is without question the most forgettable outing in the AC franchise.
Irrespective of the limitations to the Vita, the game offers little to explore, a linear and uninteresting narrative and bugs that frustrate even the most dedicated of players.
Unprecedented gaps in the story leave players feeling as if they have missed key developmental plot points, or have been left wanting more.
Players are never allowed access to Aveline's past, and aren't afforded the chance to explore how she became the person she is. The daughter of a freed slave born into the Brotherhood sounds fantastic, but you never have this fascinating tale fleshed out.
Despite HD remasters, this game still comes up lacking.
There are aspects worthy of attention - the ability to switch between personas of Slave, Assassin and Lady to blend with different crowds for example - but it doesn't perform well enough to make this engaging.
You can avoid Liberation in the knowledge that going through the pain to play it won't leave you missing out on anything of import.
1. Must Play: Brotherhood
A stunning realisation of Rome that can be traversed so effortlessly was always going to be a winner.
The locale feels alive, dense and rich with colour and vibrancy. The characters you encounter all appear to have a meaning or a purpose to the developing story at large.
On a similarly positive note, utilising the faster-paced parkour the game offered means you can spend countless hours simply exploring the city.
Assassin's Creed 2 was not going to be easy to follow, but Brotherhood does a respectable job in doing so. Adding the recruitment tool was a welcome introduction, adding a new dynamic to the series in that players could have help from their peers or could simply earn more cash.
Brotherhood is a must play because it's innovations became staples in later titles and it can not be denied that it's a fast-paced, well-rounded festival of Assassins Creed goodness.
Once you consider that the game has a wildly underrated multiplayer mode, the potential for replays is through the roof.
Easily one of the most "pick up and play" titles in the series, it's a linchpin in the franchise that much of the success of AC can be attributed to.