Four patches later and Assassin's Creed: Unity still isn't the experience it was advertised as, or should be. Regardless of if you love the world, characters and general core gameplay enough to not let things like frame-rate and graphical hitches put you off, even the most hardcore fans and staunchest defenders would struggle to say it was anything approaching a recommendable title. The series itself has come one hell of a long way since 2007, arriving at a time when everyone was looking for a killer franchise to best exude the new powers of their fancy consoles. Following a bit of a rocky start that critics chastised for having too much repetition, there was enough of a solid foundation for Ubisoft to realise they could begin to roll out an annual model, a new sequel then releasing every year. Black Flag managed to succeed in a slew of areas that you could argue have no real place in an Assassin's Creed title - based off where the franchise came from - and after that tweaked the fan-reception needle back into the positive, Unity arrived and wrenched it back the other way again. With the Victorian England setting of Victory coming again later this year, many are finally saying enough is enough. There's been too much of the same game trotted out year after year, and although that works for sports games that rely on stringent formulas with barely any iteration, Victory needs far more than a slight tweak to something like its traversal system to make it an enticing prospect.
10. The World, Presentation And Lore Needs To Make Sense To Newcomers
Seriously, what the hell was up with the start of AC: Unity? Like seriously, the very start? If you were unfamiliar with the way the franchise has resorted to handling its mythos as a computer program, picking the game you already bought from a menu of others just looks like you're booting into a store menu. To anyone new to gaming in general, it's downright obscure - if you weren't familiar with the whole 'dude-goes-into-his-past' framing device, half of the stuff you see in terms of HUD elements in Unity doesn't have any frame of reference. Ubisoft took one hell of a genius turn in embracing the meta aspects of their game-within-a-game narrative, making you play Assassin's Creed-within-Assassin's Creed in Black Flag (if you can keep track of that), but in doing so they opened themselves up to doing away with the seriousness of the modern day element. This was a hugely important part of the appeal of the series for thousands of players; the sense of unravelling exactly what Desmond and the modern-day Assassin's were going to do to the Templars, and it was riveting stuff. The general consensus amongst fans looked to be that Desmond was being groomed through the memories of his ancestors to bring the pain in the modern time. What's emerged since is a tale of actual Gods warring with one another, and a crowbarred-in point about an impending apocalypse that's also tied to someone losing their husband. It's a complete mess, and in dire need of streamlining if there's any hope of establishing a sense of drive between past and present in-game.
9. 'Anyone Can Be An Assassin' - Different Animations For Different Characters
Part of being an Assassin (assumedly) is to be the all-seeing, all-hidden-bladed badass the world has only heard of in whispers. Most of that comes in every facet of your placement in the world, and it's worth pointing out that Ubisoft have gotten remarkably lax when it comes to who can be an assassin. If you look at someone like Edward Kenway, although he was a fun character there's no reason why he's animating and controlling like the other, far more regimented heroes of the past. It feels like essentially anyone can be an assassin, with Unity's Arno essentially acquiring the requisite skills overnight after spending some time within the same air as an established killer. In the intro to the whole game and the city itself you're asked to scale incredibly high structures with little to no dialogue from Arno or the characters as to why that's an appropriate thing to do - there's no believability and it ends up as a fast-track to just letting you get back to where the previous game left off. Each character should feel like a different personality through and through, with this reflecting on how they take on board the core teachings of the Order itself. Edward Kenway should have been more rough and tumble in his executions, Arno more cautious and slowly more vicious as the story dictated - not all the same for the sake of getting another game out the door.
8. The Feel Of Movement
It stands to reason that if you're going to try and be the industry leader when it comes to third-person open-world action, then you shouldn't be able to be completely dethroned by a random newcomer like Shadow of Mordor did last year. Throughout the pre-release all of Ubisoft's developer interviews talked about how they'd built another game engine 'from the ground up', but anyone who'd played any previous title could tell right away that in motion it was going to play exactly the same. All the allusions to new movement possibilities amounted to nothing more than holding a different button alongside the right trigger to descend smoother than before, and with even that barely working as advertised thanks to AC's conflicted scripting in trying to mash together a series of 'autoplay' animations, more often than not Arno wouldn't end up where you intended. Shadow of Mordor by all accounts - aside from the Nemesis system - should've been laughed out the room for stealing so much of its core appeal from Assassin's Creed, but all it served to prove was exactly what Ubisoft have been failing to do for years now. Where Shadow moves like a dream and Talion always feels under your control, Arno is like a wandering attack dog you know has the potential to be devastating, but is impossible to work with.
7. The 'New' Assassination Missions
Hitman brought a much-needed sandbox approach to the stealth trifecta of Metal Gear's epic narrative and Splinter Cell's realism back when each series was finding its feet, and it's something the other titans in the genre have since taken many liberties with. For Unity, Ubisoft tried to incorporate this element of game design and gave you select times where taking out your target would mean a range of approaches could be implemented, although all this boiled down to was Arno somehow listening in to conversations a few blocks away or sabotaging a piece of the environment to clear a passage further in. The idea is solid, as the aforementioned Hitman titles built their name on allowing you to play with the environment just as much as Metal Gear did its guards. However Unity's lack of telegraphing exactly what doing one option would mean for the larger picture made for a lot of cack-handed tinkering and restarts overall. Many welcomed the focus on assassinating a particular target and having a defined run-up to said event, as that was a focus in the first game, but they're over way too quickly. In addition the means by which Arno obtains his information don't even make sense, as he appears to be aided by the Animus, despite surely not being aware of it.
6. Melee Combat
One of the coolest things about what Assassin's Creed used to be was the balance between stalking targets from afar, whilst knowing you could stand your ground fairly well against a troupe of guards if things went sideways. That balance is what makes Assassin's Creed's core gameplay 'feel', and it's been sorely missing since AC III when the developers stated that the enemies "really didn't stand a chance" against that game's character Connor. Where's the challenge if you can just keep bashing the instant-kill button and watching a string of animations play out? Unity tried to make the general challenge of combat harder, but they did through obfuscation; not telegraphing when enemies are about to attack, forever jabbing you from angles you can't see, and doing away with the meaty feel of your weapon. You can argue that makes sense in that no one character should be able to defend against all angles if they're going for 'realism', but you're an Assassin - a warrior trained essentially Batman Begins-style to be able to survive these sorts of encounters. A difficulty curve is a great thing, but it should always feel fair if you're cut down. Getting spotted is one thing, but surviving the resulting brawl by the skin of your teeth as you apply all your training is what needs to come back.
5. Ditch The Multiplayer
Stealth titles very rarely work in multiplayer - just ask Tenchu Z - one of the earliest examples of what Unity was also going for; that idea of a group of ninja-assassins infiltrating and taking out a target, before disappearing like they weren't there. Be honest though, did the idea of a multiplayer component to Assassin's Creed even enter your head when you were playing the first couple of games? Ubisoft managed to crowbar in their optional 'find your opponent in the world'-mode that actually worked remarkably well, but still you'd be hard-pressed to find anyone who's still playing it today, let alone that'd mention it as something to play with friends over a game that focusses on direct competition. For Unity, Ubisoft promoted the idea of playing as a team of four people and all bugs aside, it just isn't enjoyable. Somewhere along the way someone's connection bottoms out, they get spotted or the game engine itself crumples under the stress of running four separate (essentially single-player) experiences simultaneously. The crushing realisation that hundreds of people on the development side all tried to contribute to one vision was all too apparent. Instead of spreading ideas that require intense focus across so many people, Ubi should get rid of everything outside the core Assassin's Creed experience as it was no doubt conceptualised before turret sequences and custom bombs got in the way.
4. Open Up The Possibilities For The World
One of the most ridiculous omissions noted in Metal Gear's Ground Zeroes is the ability to knock on a wall and distract a guard towards your position. It's something that's been with the series since the beginning, yet for some reason Hideo Kojima and company decided they didn't need it any more, forcing you to run up on guys or wait until their patrol patterns put them in your midst. For some reason this was also the case in Unity. Instead of being able to play with guards and generally getting a sense of cat-and-mouse gameplay many stealth games rely on for the core enjoyment of the genre, it was removed and you had to use an item to get someone's attention. Lining that up with the corner-kill animations was then a task in itself, but it's a small thing that's emblematic of the larger problem with the series - a lack of gameplay options. The coolest weapon to come along in a while was the rope dart - something that let you strangle and hang guards from above, Predator-style. Now, although AC needs to remain separate from the Arkham franchise, there's something to be said for how much fun you can have just exploring the environment and dominating a number of foes from the shadows. Every AC mission tends to play out the same way - get to the target or goal as fast as possible. By fleshing out the abilities of whichever new protagonist makes an appearance and giving players a genuine reason to experiment, it could fundamentally change the way you get through levels.
3. The Tower-Unlock System And Map
One of the most long-in-the-tooth things that's come out of the rut Ubisoft have programmed themselves into, is the reliance on a foggy game-world slowly unlocked by procedurally going to a series of locations to reveal it. In the first AC it made a lot more sense, as you were exploring each location and gathering data for the Animus, synchronising it back to the present day to compile the world itself. It was a whole new world in more ways than one, and you felt like you were exploring it along with Desmond in the chair in the real world. Since then that mechanic has been used in everything from Far Cry to The Crew (yes, even The Crew, just drive up to the tower...) and it's become something that - although is signifying of an Ubisoft title - just isn't remotely fun to do any more. Unity was a mess of this approach to a world map, as alongside the need to pepper it full of icons to facilitate things like the companion app and 'hidden' chests, it started out being relatively full of things to potentially seek out and after a sync turned into a hilariously over-the-top amount of icons all packed into one place.
2. Take The Modern Day Elements Seriously
Let's be honest, Desmond met his maker far too early in the series, as Ubisoft made a judgement call to relegate the focus of the tale to the parts they put the most effort into - realising specific cities from the past. That would be all well and good, but as alluded to in an earlier point in doing away with something that was a core tenet of the franchise it's alienated something that could've been remained an identifying feature of the games overall. Ubisoft need to double down on making sure AC is representative of the many miles its already travelled, if they want to push forward. With Desmond gone it leaves a plethora of questions as to the real state of the Assassins and Templars, and although plenty plot points were referred to in AC: Rogue, they need to be included in the game Ubisoft is putting their hefty PR budget behind instead.
1. It Needs To Actually Work
For the most part gamers are too nice. We get another instalment in a franchise we've spend a good chunk of our lifetime with already, and we actively look for the things that work, disregarding the parts that don't. It's sometimes painful to admit that something you want so desperately to be acceptable is actually a smouldering wreck of a once-was, but Unity is that tipping point. It's the collective work of a few hundred separate board room meetings from across the globe, all converging to create a game that takes you for granted, banking on the love gamers have in general to try and find the signs of life amongst the wreckage. Would a film be deemed acceptable if it hung on a single frame for half an hour? How about if one in every four pressings made the projector itself burst into flames? Sure you could've liked what you'd seen so far, and you may sit around patiently waiting for a new projector to be installed - but the bottom line is that such things shouldn't be tolerated in the first place. Games are far more expensive now already, but nobody is asking Ubisoft to crank up their production to levels where they need to deploy insidious micro-transactions in-game to recoup their budget. Assassin's Creed II is still a much better game even today, because the gameplay is spot on. The AC series has become one of those that you talk about reservedly, Unity is essentially a guilty pleasure despite providing the best visuals of the entire generation, and Ubisoft's biggest challenge is to right the ship, focus their resources and deliver a title that is top-to-bottom a truly great game. Anything less than that, and they might as well give up. Are you going to begrudgingly buy Victory anyway? Let us know in the comments what you need to get overhauled, or whether you're done with the franchise altogether.