Battlefield 1: 10 Problems From The Beta That Must Be Fixed

Is being a Medic supposed to be as hopeless as it was back then?

By Martin Harp /

EA

Battlefield 1's betas was one of the more highly anticipated in some time, as fans were finally going to be able to play a shooter that wasn't set in the future, and on next gen graphics to boot.

Advertisement

Naturally, with early access came the typical bugs and problems you'd be expected to see, and Battlefield 1's beta also had its own server issues to deal with, thanks to a DDoS attack which left everything unplayable for most players on the first day.

Other than these issues, problems about the game's core gameplay came to light as so many longtime fans were able to play and test every last new feature. It must be said that betas are rarely perfect, and it's understandable when problems arise. A freshly polished multiplayer was not expected, and running into some problems didn't kill the experience.

Advertisement

That said, for the game to be successful in the long run, there are some very evident problems that need to be fixed before release. From simple presentation mechanics to game balancing, these are some of the things if left unchecked, could cause Battlefield 1 problems at launch time.

--

Advertisement

10. The Ever Present Problem With Vaulting

If there's one thing it seems DICE can never get a solid grasp on, it's the vaulting mechanic in their games. Going to vault over an object only to just jump into the wall - or vaulting halfway to inevitably fall back down -are some of the major issues. Battlefield 3, Battlefield 4 and even Hardline had problems with it, and Battlefield 1 is no different.

Advertisement

You can thank the map selection for this problem coming to light as well. Sinai Desert, with it's many uneven rocky structures, forced you to vault on numerous occasions, and usually ended with sheer frustration or an unwanted death as you were stuck on the world geography rather than getting out the line of fire.

There's been enough Battlefield games where this has been a problem in some way or another. Even Battlefront, which doesn't feature a vaulting mechanic, had players getting stuck in the geography constantly. At this point, it should be fixed, and hopefully Battlefield 1 can be the point where it actually happens.

Advertisement

9. Too Many Hidden Features

EA

Did you know you could change the voice of the announcer from female to male, or that you could turn it off entirely? Or that you could change the color of your crosshairs and the color that pops up when you get a headshot in-game? It's no surprise if not, as these are but a few of the many features tucked away behind countless menus, and there are plenty more.

Advertisement

Thanks to the very simplistic look Battlefield 1 is going for, a lot of usual HUD mechanics players may be used to have been turned off by default. Like the kill log for instance: If you're one of the many players who look to this to find out when squad mates around you've died, you'll need to turn it back on.

And if you'd like to be able to see your gun and equipment on screen at all times, you'll have to turn that back on as well. I can't tell you how many times while first playing as a medic, I accidentally took out the syringe instead of throwing a health pack because I simply didn't know which button did which. It wouldn't be a shock if some players didn't know you can customize your class before you spawn, or that you can choose what vehicle you spawn into.

Advertisement

A simple solution would be upon start-up, asking the player if they'd prefer a more simplistic style or the traditional multiplayer presentation. At least that way, you'd know these options are even there.

8. The Inability To View Squad Members On Spawn

Advertisement

Being able to see squad members before you spawn has been present in past Battlefield games, yet was removed for Battlefield 1. It more than likely has to do with the fact it fits with the time period, as intel like that just wasn't available at the time (or something).

What we seem to forget here though, is this is a video game, not real life. Some features are there not because of realism, but for convenience of the player. Spawning in on a squad member at times can be risky business, as there's no real warning as to whether or not they are in trouble. The only thing that happens is when they are shooting or under fire, their arrow on the map will blink, and you're unable to spawn on them for a certain amount of time.

Advertisement

However, too many times I would spawn in on a squad mate who was at a flag in Conquest or an objective in Rush, only to be immediately sniped, run down by a machine gun or even worse, a tank. There's no definitive way to know what danger you're getting yourself in to, and it will cause more frustration than anything else for players. The problem may actually be more prominent in Rush as well, as combat tends to be a lot closer with enemies more bunched up around a lot more chokepoints. Factor in Rush's ticket bleed mechanic, and senseless deaths that could have been avoided hurt even more.

7. The Awful Voiceover

EA DICE

What were they even thinking with this voiceover?

Advertisement

I'm not talking about including the use of terminology like 'Apples', 'Butter' and so on, as this is historically accurate - those were parts of the British Army's phonetic alphabet from that time. Fans moaned about how the game needed to be true to its time period, and we got it - no matter how silly "We're losing objective Apples!" may sound.

Rather, it's the actual voice that is so bad, it's funny. It sounds like a futuristic voiceover you'd hear in some sci-fi movie, not something from the gritty WWI time period. It doesn't even help if you change the gender of the voice - they both sound just as bad. Also the urgency in the voice doesn't change no matter what is happening. Hearing a sense of urgency while losing an objective would just add to the already awesome atmosphere.

Advertisement

We've already seen games realize a bad voiceover and fix it - remember the Peter Dinklage fiasco from Destiny?

Having something like your General, Commander or otherwise superior officer yelling at you as you lose and gain objectives would fit FAR better than yet another robotic and calm voice, be it be male or female.

Advertisement

6. The Post-Game Scoreboard Is Far Too Glitchy

EA

So you're having the game of your life. You've been playing the objective and you're holding what seems like the best K/D you've had in awhile and you've got to be at the top of the entire game's scoreboard.

Advertisement

The match ends and you're looking forward to seeing how much you've progressed - and how much better you did than everyone else. However, upon completion, everything ends you're thrown directly into the next match with no results.

Sometimes you'll even be thrown into the next match to pick your spawn, only to be taken out to see the post-game results. It's finicky and very annoying. There were multiple times where I'd be in a party of friends, and half of us would be shown the post-game scoreboard while the other half was out flying planes in the next match.

Advertisement

Too many times I felt like I had missed the first 30 seconds of a match because I was stuck on the scoreboard. Match after match it just becomes entirely too annoying, and it's a simple mechanic that just needs to be tuned and polished up for release.

5. Class Progression Needs To Actually Work

EA

Now this is something that didn't affect everyone in the beta; some players were virtually unable to level up their classes no matter what they tried. Levelling up your basic rank was never a problem, but class ranks just didn't work. And it became even more of a nuisance when class rank determined if you could buy new guns, equipment or melee weapons. A workaround was eventually found where you'd have to switch servers after every single game to level up, but even that didn't work for everyone.

Advertisement

I was personally one of the many affected by this, and it's one of my biggest gripes with the beta. No matter how many games I played on the Scout class, the Medic class or Assault class, I couldn't level any of them up. Even as I was a level 20 or more, I was unable to try out the shotguns because I simply was unable to unlock them.

This is obviously a huge gameplay mechanic of the multiplayer and it has to be fixed come time for us to play the game again. Thankfully, DICE has acknowledged this problem, so chances are we won't have to worry about the inability to level up, come launch time. Fingers crossed.

Advertisement

4. Tanks Are Too Overpowered

EA/DICE

Tanks had to be an absolutely terrifying thing to see roll across the battlefield back during WWI, so it's understandable why DICE shot to make them so strong.

Advertisement

However, from a balancing standpoint, they are just too much. The fact some players have had problems unlocking weapons and equipment also factors into this, as the AT Rocket Gun makes such a big difference against tanks, but requires unlocking. As so many players are unable to get their hands on it, tanks just run through people. The flak cannons sitting out around the map are essentially the only counter at this point.

There's one more thing that makes tanks a seemingly unstoppable beast out there - the fact you can repair them from inside. So, when the other team actually manages to chip away a parts of its health, all you need to do is retreat and repair yourself back up to 100%. Simply.

Advertisement

Careful maintenance of a tank could keep it around the ENTIRE match. While tanks were certainly a monster of the time, they can't be this ludicrously overpowered moving forward.

3. Stop Making A Medic's Life So Difficult

EA

Go on, think of how many times you were revived, thrown health or even ammo while playing the Battlefield 1 beta. It's a safe bet the number wasn't very high. While it could have been because you were playing with incompetent teammates, chances are it was because your friendly neighbourhood Medic simply didn't know you needed help in the first place.

Advertisement

Teammate health is now represented as a bar around the very tiny circle that pops up above their head, which makes deciding who does and doesn't need health more difficult, as it's very hard to see. When a player does die, you can't see they need a revive unless they manually prompt it - and that almost never happens, as players choose to skip the revive, sending them to pick a spawn location without reducing the respawn time. Skipping the revive period is actually pointless and should simply not be allowed, as it makes medics unable to fulfil their role.

Also, throwing a med pack down will sometimes result in it clipping through the map and disappearing. While this is more certainly a graphical problem, it affects the Medic class directly, and is just yet another thing making their role feel harder to accomplish.

Advertisement

2. Conquest Needs To Return To Its Old Form

EA

When you think of Battlefield multiplayer, there's two game modes that come to mind: Conquest and Rush. Both of which were featured in the beta, but one was nothing but a shadow of its former self. Gone was the ticket bleed, and now it was the first to a set score to win, which at first almost never happened thanks to the time limit in place.

Advertisement

Halfway through the beta's life however, this time limit was removed, allowing Conquest matches to be played out from start to finish. It was the first step in fixing conquest, but some work still needs to be done, as it just feels like a glorified game of Domination.

With deaths and kills no longer affecting the score with the removal of a ticket bleed, death carries absolutely no weight. Constantly storming towards the enemy with zero strategy, just hoping something works out eventually no longer has its consequences.

Advertisement

Yes, you won't necessarily be helping your team, but you won't be hurting them nearly as much as you would have been either. And now that death carries no price, there's zero motivation for players to run the Medic class, other than just wanting to be a "team player." Revives no longer save your team from losing a ticket, it just saves your teammates from having a death on their record.

Of course, there are the arguments these changes made to Conquest are for the better. Now players are forced to play and not sit out with a sniper rifle, or do nothing but go for kills anywhere other than the objective. Understandable, but why not make what's considered Conquest now in Battlefield 1 it's own Domination playlist, and bring back the Conquest Battlefield players know and love as well?

Advertisement

There's really no reason we can't have both, and that way, everybody wins.

1. Everything About The User Interface

EA

Where is there to even start with this?

Advertisement

Nothing, absolutely nothing is good about the user interface. For starters, the main menu is ripped right out of Battlefront. Not necessarily bad, but it would be nice to see a unique menu system and not just a repackaging.

However, when you actually get into a game, it gets even worse. Hitting start simply sends you into a limbo state, as the game will seemingly struggle to load the start menu. Once, I was actually left in said limbo state, racking up multiple deaths I could not control, only to be inevitably forced to quit the beta and restart it.

Advertisement

On top of that, did you know there was a respawn timer?

Indeed, the respawn timer in Battlefield 1 is a small white progress bar above the white deploy button. Thanks to both being the same color and extremely small, it's near impossible to see. A lot of the problems with hidden features are caused by the problems with the user interface.

Advertisement

While it's certainly understandable why the game goes with a minimalistic approach, as it fits with the time period, it just feels too bare. There needs to be a compromise between functionality and minimalism, and at this point, Battlefield 1 just simply isn't there.

--

Advertisement

What did you make of the beta? Let us know in the comments!