Battlefield 1 Open Beta: 5 Ups & 5 Downs

Flawed, but ludicrously entertaining.

By Jack Pooley /

EA DICE

The long-awaited Battlefield 1 is currently in open beta on PC, PS4 and Xbox One for all who wish to try the game out for themselves ahead of its October 21st worldwide release.

Advertisement

It's a DICE game, so of course, the beta raises a number of issues that may or may not get fixed by release day, but at least the core gameplay itself proves that the latest entry into the FPS franchise brings more of the brutal beauty and addictive gunplay that has made it what it is today.

There's still a lot that DICE need to answer for moving forward, but the beta should at least give you a better idea as to whether or not the end-product's going to be worth your hand-earned cash on release day. It's definitely a bit of a mixed bag, but when it's awesome, it's really, really awesome.

Advertisement

Here are 5 ups and 5 downs from the Battlefield 1 open beta...

--

Advertisement

Downs5. Conquest Mode Is Too Fast & No Longer Has Tickets

EA DICE

Arguably the biggest complaint for Battlefield purists is that the much-loved Conquest mode has undergone some significant reworkings that arguably aren't for the best.

First of all, Battlefield 1 touts a somewhat faster (some might say "casualised") pace, with a greater emphasis on getting back into the action as fast as possible, and a 20-minute time limit per round.

Advertisement

The faster speed means that even 64-player mayhem is typically over before you know it, and the fact that the timer often ends games before a point victory means that you'll likely struggle to come across many of the famously prolonged, epic battles from previous games. Hopefully the time limit imposed in the beta won't carry across to the final game.

Furthermore, the "ticket bleed" mechanic that governs Conquest in previous games is gone and has been replaced with a more conventional, Domination-esque point-based scoring system which just strips some of the tension away, especially given how the ticket bleed was linked directly to how many objectives or bases were held by a given team and allowed for some incredible comebacks.

Advertisement

This just makes Conquest feel more conventional than ever, which is a real shame.

4. Horses & Tanks Are Grossly Overpowered

EA DICE

The whole point of a beta test is to check things like game balancing, and so it's none too surprising that there are absolutely some elements that require a nerfing ahead of release.

Advertisement

Firstly, though horses are ludicrously entertaining to use, they're also laughably overpowered, such that you can sink round after round into them from an extremely powerful weapon and they'll still survive. It looks silly, and while the horses need more health than a regular player character to be of use, it still needs to be scaled back quite a bit.

Then there's tanks, which can turn the tide of a match so aggressively because they're difficult to destroy (especially without anti-tank weapons), and once you gain control of one, there's not a lot stopping you driving from objective to objective, capturing them and melting anyone who dares get in your way.

Advertisement

These are undeniably fun elements, but they just need to be toned down a little for the final game.

3. It's Glitchy As Hell

EA DICE

Again, not massively unexpected, but frustrating all the same given that the game comes out in less than two months and DICE don't exactly have a great track record for improving their games beyond the betas.

Advertisement

Some of the more egregious and prevalent bugs include horses being able to leap over walls they absolutely shouldn't be able to, environmental objects such as boxes getting blown up and lingering around in the air, the player's clipping through the turret on some vehicles, and getting snagged on the environment and being unable to move, such that you're forced to wait for the sweet release of death to get back into combat.

While some of these nagging issues will be remedied before release, it's probably best to expect a few to linger around for a while, which is a damn shame. Given how polished the game is in some areas, it feels woefully lacking in others.

Advertisement

2. The Terrible Announcer Voices

EA DICE

There's a lot to be said for a multiplayer announcer that pumps the player up and makes them want to kick as much a** as possible: the likes of Quake 3 Arena and Unreal Tournament remain the best examples from the genre.

Advertisement

It's clear from the beta that Battlefield 1 has announcers so utterly uninspired that DICE shouldn't have bothered at all. The default female voice is robotic and bland, and you'll probably struggle not to laugh as she calls out "Operation Butter".

Even if you change your voice to the male equivalent, it still sounds immensely dull and clashes somewhat with the intense action you're watching unfold on-screen. It really needs to be a case of go intense or go home, but at least the game does give you the option to disable the announcers altogether (which causes your character to announce things organically in-game instead).

Advertisement

1. There's Only One Map To Try

EA DICE

Of course, the final game will have a ton of maps to blast through, but it's a shame that this beta test only features the Sinai Desert one.

Advertisement

While DICE stated that the beta was largely to stress-test the servers above all else and therefore shouldn't be considered a demo as such, it still seems rather stingy that players weren't able to get the feel for a second map, which might make the game seem more worthy of a purchase.

It's a double-edged sword in reality: if DICE added another map and players hated both maps then they've lost sales, but a second map could also convince those who were on the fence after playing Sinai Desert.

Advertisement

It's a fun map, for sure, but given that this is a lengthy beta, some added diversity would've gone a long way.

And now let's look at what really works in Battlefield 1's open beta...

Advertisement

Ups5. It Feels Like Classic Battlefield

EA DICE

One of the greatest things about Battlefield 1 so far, is that it feels extremely distinct from the last few games, and in many ways (more than its period setting) hearkens back to the nostalgic glory of the earlier titles, specifically the original Battlefield 1942.

Advertisement

The more down-to-Earth weapon and vehicle types and more simplified air combat make the game feel more focused on the thrill of combat rather than the bells and whistles that were introduced with each passing game (fun though they are), and that's definitely something to celebrate.

The aesthetic and "step backwards" won't be to all tastes, but for those who have been plugging away at the series since its inception, this is a welcome return to its roots, albeit with all the accouterments of contemporary gaming.

Advertisement

4. The Graphics Are Awesome (Of Course)

EA DICE

It's one thing seeing a glossy trailer for a new game, but there's nothing quite like experiencing it for yourself to figure out whether the final title will live up to all that snazzy marketing.

Advertisement

The trailers weren't lying: Battlefield 1 is unquestionably a beautiful-looking game, even if we're given just a small glimpse of one very, very sandy map here. The character models, terrain, weapons and vehicles all look wonderful, and perhaps most surprising of all is that Battlefield 1 seems largely well-optimised for consoles.

Yes, the resolution and frame-rate both take a considerable hit compared to PC, but even when handling 64 players it plays surprisingly slickly for the most part, and the addition of an FOV slider to allow even console players to customise their aesthetic experience is a major bonus.

Advertisement

Battlefield 1 was always going to be a work of beauty on PC, and it's reassuring to see DICE not resting on their laurels when it comes to the "lesser" versions too.

3. It Has A Server Browser

EA DICE

A major criticism of the Battlefield franchise over recent years has been the total lack of a proper, in-game server browser on PC, with players instead being forced to use the clunky, web-based Battlelog system to find matches.

Advertisement

Then, to just about everyone's frustration, last year's Star Wars Battlefront didn't feature a server browser of any kind for reasons unknown.

Thankfully, all versions of Battlefield 1 feature a server browser that makes it incredibly easy to find the type of match you want, rather than forcing you into a map rotation you don't really care for.

Advertisement

Want to play Sinai Desert 24/7? You can do that, and it's something worth celebrating.

2. The Incredible Sound Effects

EA DICE

Again, it's a staple of the Battlefield franchise at this point but no-less praise-worthy: this is an incredible-sounding game.

Advertisement

From the diverse array of gunfire to the crisp explosions and purr of your vehicle, it'll all make the most out of your speaker set-up and probably make you wish you had a better one.

The "War Tapes" audio setting is particularly fun in so much as it trades realism for sheer, balls-to-the-wall awesomeness, pulling sounds from both near and far and mixing them into one intense wall of noise that's nothing if not extremely immersive.

Advertisement

As beautiful as the game looks, arguably nothing will give you a more adrenaline-fueled experience than pumping the volume up loud before letting rip with your mounted machine gun. It's glorious.

1. The Terrific Weapon Selection

EA DICE

There was a lot of worry from Battlefield fans that the new game might be lacking awesome weaponry considering that a) it's taking a step back time-wise and b) it follows Battlefront, which had a fairly lacklustre selection of weapons, most of which felt like they fired the same.

Advertisement

Thankfully, that isn't the case here at all: the diversity is exceptional, from the pistols, machine guns, shotguns, sniper rifles and anti-tank weapons you'd expect, all the way through to lethal flamethrowers, a ludicrously powerful rocket gun, swords and even a damn shovel.

While much of the final loadout is restricted in the beta, the customisation options (where you use war bonds earned in-game to unlock weapons) seem much more comprehensive than in Battlefront, proving that its widely-maligned lack of variety hasn't "infected" the Battlefield franchise.

Advertisement

--

What do you think of the Battlefield 1 open beta so far? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement