Every Lucasarts Adventure Game: Ranked Worst To Best
From SCUMM to yum.
For three decades, a little gold chap splashing up at the start of the game was a fairly reliable indicator that, yes, these 11 or so floppy disks you'd just spent £40 quid on were going to be good.
Probably damn good.
That little gold chap was the symbol of Lucasarts, the development studio birthed by the bottomless funds and irrepressible creative desire of namesake George Lucas. At least to begin with, the purpose of Lucasarts - originally Lucasfilm Games - was not to churn licensed cash-grabs, but to indulge the talent of some of the industry's brightest minds. If someone thought an idea might be good, it was greenlit. It was a creative paradise.
Of course, by the time Lucasarts shut down, they were pumping out nothing but Star Wars games. The sad realities of a hyperfinanced industry eventually made them the only viable output.
For a time though, the company was synonymous with the point 'n' click adventure genre. Indeed, it was the unjust commercial failure of Grim Fandango which convinced Lucasarts that what had once been their main stock in trade was no longer profitable.
'Not profitable' never meant 'not good'. In total, Lucasarts released 15 adventure games, as they perpetually remained at the forefront of the category. With one or two exceptions, all of them were stellar. But which takes home the little Gold Guy as the best?
15. Labyrinth
In the spirit of the school-yard - "first the worst", and all that - Lucasarts' debut adventure, the 1986 adaptation of muppet-laden Bowie-fest Labyrinth, takes up the tight-trousered rear. (Although by that logic it'd follow that Maniac Mansion is the best. Spoiler: it's not.)
It may be bottom of the pile, but Labyrinth is by no means bad. Preceding the inspired SCUMM system of Ron Gilbert et al., the game - curiously, Lucasfilm's first based on an existing license - instead employed a fairly intuitive context-sensitive 'verb wheel', eliminating Sierra-style guesswork, and with it Sierra-style temper tantrums at instant death.
Unfortunately, despite the pull of Douglas Adams writing, and an accommodating interface, the movie tie-in is just that little bit basic, and that little bit boring. Adams could only work with that he had, and there isn't much room for excitement here.
14. Indiana Jones And The Last Crusade
As a stepping stone between Maniac Mansion and its brilliant sequel Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis, The Last Crusade is an interesting curio. As an adventure game in its own right, it's often an exercise in outmoded frustration.
Though the game made significant strides in cleaning up the clutter of the evolving SCUMM system eventually leading to its perfection in The Secret of Monkey Island, in almost every other area it's an archaic adventure. As with precursor Zak McKracken, mazes are prominent, as are interminable games of 'hunt the pixel'.
These might be forgivable, but the action sequences are not, especially for fans of the genre. The game predates Lucasarts' 'no death' policy, and boy does it show. Countless instant kills at the fists of Indy's belligerent Third Reich pursuers are enough to make even the most ardent pro-fascist hate the Nazis, and whilst the game does break innovative ground by allowing some fights to be bypassed with cunning dialogue selections, it's generally hit before wit.
Committing every cardinal sin of the adventure game bible makes Last Crusade difficult to revisit today. Those picking this over Fate of Atlantis chose poorly.
13. Zak McKracken And The Alien Mindbenders
Though Zak McKracken was the second Lucasarts point 'n' click to use the iconic SCUMM system , the company still hadn't quite perfected their patented adventure game formula.
For one, it's possible to run down a dead-end, a frustrating facet of the genre Lucasarts latterly decided to eradicate for good (but not without some sly digs at serial offenders Sierra). Secondly, as a practical measure to keep disk space low but content high, there's a - heh - mind-bending plethora of mazes in lieu of more locations. It's more labyrinthine than Labyrinth.
Such flaws are a product of its time, but look past them and the hallmarks of classic Lucasarts adventures are clearly emergent. The game's plot is underpinned by an offbeat charm (aliens in discount disguises are mesmerising San Franciscans through the telephone lines), and it's replete with the sort of quirky humour which would become a staple of the genre. Yes, it's not quite 'there' yet - the puzzles are relatively straightforward and the characters have as much depth as Chuck the plant - but Zak McKracken is a still a worthy albeit forgotten title in the big adventure game inventory.
12. The Dig
Inspired by a Steven Spielberg concept, written by science-fiction doyen Orson Scott Card, and enduring a mammoth (not to mention expensive) six year development cycle, The Dig should rank much higher amongst Lucasarts' point 'n' click pantheon. Yet it never quite managed to appeal in the manner of its more-esteemed contemporaries.
The earnestly solemn mood which pervades the game's narrative and otherworldly locale set it apart from the humorous adventures of the day, and many fans of the genre expecting a witty jaunt akin to Monkey Island or Day of the Tentacle were left decidedly unsure by the serious, weighty tone. Perhaps The Dig was a little ahead of its time.
Nevertheless, it's a stellar - an interstellar - production. The presentation is spectacular, from the sweeping, majestic soundtrack to flawless ILM produced CGI, and whilst the puzzles lean more towards Myst than Maniac Mansion, its mysterious atmosphere and emotional maturity make it worth a look.
11. Maniac Mansion
Where would be without Maniac Mansion? This list probably wouldn't be a thing for starters, let alone Thimbleweed Park.
It's hard to overstate the importance of Maniac Mansion to the adventure genre; ballasted by Ron Gilbert's pioneering SCUMM engine (which takes its name from the game), the B-movie parody practically invented point 'n' click, finally putting to rest the unwieldy text parsers of the past. Whilst failure is possible, gone are the days of a suddenly dying of embarrassment as a result of typing 'take off clothes'. Instead, 'enjoyment' is the watchword, not 'exasperation'.
Maniac Mansion is relatively reduced compared to it successors, spun around an uncomplicated plot of deliverance, but its open-ended nature and multiple protagonists give it a veneer of depth. Typical of Gilbert, the writing is mordantly droll, and it's perhaps the only game in history that allows you to microwave a hamster. You can't put a price on rodent radiation.
10. Escape From Monkey Island
Regrettably, by 2000 point 'n' click adventures were no longer à la mode; though its table was embiggening, the industry seemingly had no place reserved for slow-paced puzzle-solvers in the Lucasarts fashion.
Yet they tried to keep up. The least they could do was move into the third dimension, at a time when 2D games were considered an embarrassing anachronism, primitive artifacts of a growing business grasping for respect.
Like every franchise adding depth in the still-nascent 3D era, Monkey Island's first attempt hasn't aged well, the plastic environments and choppy characters lacking the timeless elegance of the perfected-pixel art of its predecessors. A much less forgiving consequence of the dimensional transition are the controls; Guybrush may be a pirate, but that doesn't mean he should have the turning circle and maneuverability of a galleon.
These problems are the natural effects of the genre's necessity to move with the times, but Escape from Monkey Island's most glaring flaw is quite the opposite. With most of the series' key creative personnel having abandoned ship, the fourth swashbuckler instead relies on recycled jokes and tired cameos to infuse it with a Monkey Island feel, and it comes across as stale as Herman Toothrot's pants. Oh, and then there's Monkey Kombat.
9. LOOM
On the day of his seventeenth birthday, Bobbin Threadbare leaves his guild of weavers to hunt down a flock of swans, one of which may very well be his mother. He does so with nothing but a magical, musical staff, his adventure set to the appropriately cygnine music of Tchaikovsky's most famous ballet.
Needless to say, LOOM is a tough sell - even for a pirate named Cobb.
Long before the 'are video games art?' question was even considered, let alone raised, LOOM was providing an answer in the affirmative. Gone is the traditional verb+object input intimately familiar to Lucasarts players; instead, you interface with your surroundings via small ditties played on the staff - both musical and literal. This proves surprisingly versatile. If, for example, the spell for 'opening' is played backwards, it becomes 'closed'. It's genius, in many ways.
Sadly, the magic doesn't last long enough. LOOM spools just a little short, and though undeniably unique, an inventory-less puzzle system means solutions are inevitably straightforward. It's an experience almost unlike any other, but the coda soon reaches its conclusion.
8. Full Throttle
Tim Schafer's asphalt-scarring Heavy Metal adventure Full Throttle burns its rubber hard, but regrettably fast. Ben Throttle's tale of motorcycle redemption takes place in arguably one of Lucasarts' finest settings, part Mad Max, part Sons of Anarchy - albeit all tongue-in-cheek - but just as you're getting into gear, things run out of gas.
What feels like an opening act turns out to be more or less the full game, and before you know it, you've reached the end of the road. What is there is excellent - the opening area of Melonweed drips with oily atmosphere like a bust jerrycan, the writing is as dry as it is understated, and the voice work hitherto unparalleled - in particular memorable performances by Mark Hamill and the late Roy Conrad. The only real misstep are the highly questionable arcade-action sequences, anathema to all adventure game fans.
Ultimately, Full Throttle is a superb starter adventure, let down by its limited mileage.
7. Sam & Max Hit The Road
If you're dissuaded by old school point 'n' click games' propensity for puzzles only solvable by following the obtuse logic of either the developer or setting, you should probably swerve away from Sam & Max Hit The Road harder than the eponymous dog does in his police DeSoto.
However, if you don't mind that - and most adventure gamers don't - and are looking for a scathing pastiche of kitsch Americana, replete with quotable non-sequiturs galore and, um, a few rather crap minigames, then look no further. Hit the Road is almost the perfect marriage of subject and genre, the above-lamented vagaries of adventure game design being an apt vehicle for the eccentric world of Steve Purcell's original comic strip. Using the magnetised severed hand of Jesse James on the World's Largest Ball of Twine to fisk a mood ring might sound like Adventure Game Hell 101, but the conceit - even if it's hard to fathom it - just works in this tourist trap iteration of the USA.
On a technical side, Hit the Road does a few new things as well. SCUMM is refined into a more direct, latter-day Sierra style series of icons, and this was also the first Lucasarts adventure with full voice acting. And get this: it's not dreadful!
Most won't have the patience for Sam & Max's journey, but those who stay on the road to the end invariably look back on the trip fondly.
6. Indiana Jones And The Fate Of Atlantis
For almost as long as they've wanted a fresh film in the franchise that didn't feature intergalactic aliens or the titular archaeologist escaping nuclear meltdown in white goods, Indiana Jones fans have begged for a video game adaptation which does the character justice. Most don't realise that one has existed since 1992.
Fate of Atlantis - not to be confused with the Assassin's Creed expansion of a similar theme - sees Barnett College's coolest prof hunt down the legendary lost city, following a tip off in an unearthed Plato manuscript. Along the way, he's joined by sham psychic Sophia Hapgood, and naturally pursued by those no-good Nazis. It's so congruous with the source material that, until 2008's Crystal Skull debacle, it wasn't uncommon to hear it canonically referred to as 'Indy IV'.
What makes it such an ideal Indy game, then? There's a perfect balance of adventure, action and humour. Puzzles are significantly more grounded than any other Lucasarts adventure - there's no 'use monkey on pump' here - but it never becomes po-faced; one memorable sequence sees Dr. Jones help fake a séance for the benefit of his charlatan companion. There's also the occasional punch-up - it just wouldn't be Indy unless he got his hat a little dusty.
Though difficulty modes did exist in other Lucasarts games, they largely cut content 'for the sake of magazine reviewers'. Fate of Atlantis had a novel approach, splitting into three distinct paths - Brain, Brawn and Team - given the game something rare to the genre: replayability. It's just a question of whether, having solved Atlantis' mysteries, you'd necessarily want to.
5. The Curse Of Monkey Island
The Curse of Monkey Island is an astonishingly produced adventure game from top to bottom. The puzzles are both appropriately thematic and devious without ever becoming frustratingly opaque. The animation, though it suffers today from a native 1997 resolution, has the charm and vivacity to rival the best Disney efforts. The writing, even without the collective pen of Ron Gilbert and Tim Schafer, doesn't grasp for wit, with Dominic Amato's interpretation as Guybrush allaying IndyIV-inspired fears of the series' first step into the talkies. There's even an utterly phenomenal musical interlude, with gaming's best ever scurvy-related punchline.
So what's the problem? Simple: Curse of Monkey Island, nominally or not, just isn't Monkey Island. The departure of creator Ron Gilbert following the second title meant that, whilst in more than capable hands, the third game has a completely different tone, more fantasy parody than mordant satire. And that's without mentioning the terrible, terrible things it does to help explain Monkey Island 2's controversial ending.
Does this make it a bad game? No. But for Monkey Island die-hards, it's still a tough vichyssoise to swallow.
That song though...
4. Day Of The Tentacle
Tim Schafer's time-vaulting romp Day of the Tentacle - a loose sequel to SCUMM-starter Maniac Mansion - is an exercise in adventure game design perfection. Nearly every puzzle follows a definite and consistent train of logic, though each has a twist as its final step, allowing the players to solve the basic equation before rewarding their ingenuity in pushing it over the line.
Here's an example. The game's trio of protagonists find themselves separated across three time periods, one of whom, Laverne, ends stuck up a tree after being hurtled into the future. Hoagie, in the past - and at the signing of the Declaration of Independence - can quiz George Washington himself on his famous, apocryphal cherry-tree chopping exploits. The inaugural pres. would be happy to prove the doubters wrong - if only there was a cherry tree around.
There isn't. But there is a kumquat tree. Paint the fruit red, and the American Fabius has no choice but to cut it down - making it disappear in the future, and freeing Laverne. It's devilishly simple, with just enough hints to guide the player along.
And how many other games let you egg on George Washington? Day of the Tentacle's outlandish humour simply doesn't let up, from exploiting a suggestion box for the US constitution to ensure all American homes have a vacuum cleaner in their basement, to microwaving a frozen hamster to thaw it out after two centuries in a freezer (this time, it doesn't explode).
The only possible criticisms - and what keeps it out of the top spots - are a setting that feels a little claustrophobic, and a zany narrative more a series of sketches to serve the open-ended design than a compelling story.
It does teach us one crucial piece of advice, mind: if you want to save the world, you got to push a few old ladies down the stairs.
3. The Secret Of Monkey Island
At the end of The Secret of Monkey Island, pirate-wannabe protagonist Guybrush Threepwood muses - to the utter confusion of belle Elaine - "never pay $20 for a video game". It's an immortal line that encapsulates the brilliant, dry wit of Ron Gilbert's masterpiece, self-deprecatingly underestimating the impact the title had on the entire genre.
Monkey Island was a watershed for adventure games. Gilbert, learning from his mistakes in Maniac Mansion, decided point 'n' clicks should no longer actively punish players, laughing at their unpredictable failures, but instead immerse them in thoughtful, rewarding worlds where the only barrier for progress was their own patience. Death was a thing of a past - save for one extremely obscure Easter egg - and it wasn't possible to reach Act V, only to find the game was unwinnable because you hadn't nabbed a chicken egg in Act II.
But it wasn't just a philosophical triumph. Unlikely hero Guybrush Threepwood's inexplicable desire to become a pirate captured many a player's imagination, the majority accustomed to playing the role of unidentifiable action heroes. Monkey Island is utterly transportative in a way today's more technically striking pirate sims aren't: you can practically feel the humidity of the Caribbean night, taste the bitter grog. And in a game where brains won over brawn, it made perfect sense that the key to winning swordfights was not the thrusts themselves, but the razor-sharp insults between them.
The Secret of Monkey Island is Lucasarts' most loved adventure game, then, and one of their finest. But it's the lesser noggin of the company's three-headed monkey of perfection.
2. Grim Fandango
The games industry has taken repeated stabs at capturing the sleuthy, shadowy spirit of film noir, but none have done it quite like Grim Fandango, an art-deco adventure which begins with its principal cast already taking the big sleep.
Tim Schafer's career-making 1998 title sees you step into the cloak and brogues of Manny Calavera, a Grim Reaper/travel agent helping lost souls make their way across the Land of the Dead, as Lucasarts adventures likewise took their first steps into the third-dimension. It's a little awkward at first - Manny has the mobility of an actual corpse - but it's easy to forgive slight technical misgivings for the sake of an absolute aesthetic triumph.
Humphrey Bogart would lose his sh*t in the minutely realised world of Grim Fandango, asmog with the smoke of crepuscular cafés and corruption, set to the strains of Peter McConnell's stunning jazz soundtrack. The setting of the game's second act, Rubacava, is arguably the most richly atmospheric in gaming history, let alone an adventure. You'll feel legitimate remorse when the time comes to move on.
Maybe the four year journey from rags to redemption and back again starts to decompose somewhat around a third in, but make no bones about it: Grim Fandango, tragically a commercial failure, is up there amongst the best games ever made. Like its central character, Grim's true worth has only been realised long after being put out to pasture.
1. Monkey Island 2: LéChuck's Revenge
Monkey Island 2 does not have the best puzzles in an adventure game: that accolade rests with Day of the Tentacle. Nor, merely building on its predecessor, does it have the best setting: who can argue against Grim Fandango's Land of the Dead? Is it particularly original, then? Not especially; unlike LOOM, it sticks rigidly to the SCUMM stylings of its forebears.
Yet it's Lucasarts' best point 'n' click, and - cries of exponents of The Longest Journey and Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers be damned - the best adventure game of all time. You see, though you can point to other titles as exceeding LéChuck's Revenge in individual aspects, none are greater than the sum of their parts quite like Ron Gilbert's swashbuckling sequel.
Everything that made Monkey Island great is here, but so very very. The locations more expansive, more exotic, more open. The humour, in the first dryer than a salted cracker, is now as parched as Robyn Davidson. Guybrush, flush from his last LéChuck-busting adventure, is no longer naively wide-eyed, but trenchant to the max. The puzzles themselves have the same ingenuity as Day of the Tentacle's, but manifest as extensions of the world rather than Rube Goldberg brainteasers. There's also a song! And dancing monkeys!
There is, of course, one major sore spot in Monkey Island 2: the absolute ball-kick of an ending. What makes it worse is that we'll probably never know how Ron Gilbert wanted to end things, or indeed, what the 'secret' of Monkey Island actually is.
There's some hope: the IP lies dormant, and Gilbert has repeatedly expressed his wish to produce a 'canonical' Monkey Island 3 in the style of the originals. But in an age of immediacy, there's a sort of lucidity in this unanswered question; not knowing adds to game's mystique, whereas a conclusion couldn't possibly satisfy everybody, perhaps anybody.
Besides, would it improve Monkey Island 2? Not really: it's already pirate perfection.