Fallout 4: 10 Small Problems That Stop It Being Perfect

So, about that armour system...

By Ewan Paterson /

Fallout 4 review Fallout 4 is by all means an amazing game - it features a compelling narrative, an unrivalled and engrossing setting, and superb gameplay. I'd be lying if I said it was perfect, though. Despite the fact it does so much so well, there are a bunch of tiny (though not insignificant) factors that inhibit the enjoyment to be had in roaming the Commonwealth. Though not necessarily immersion-breaking by any stretch of the imagination, these few negatives do draw attention to some of the more perplexing elements of the title, or rather, the elements that whilst not bad, don't seem to make much sense. These nitpicks range from everything including character customisation and armour to elements that hinder the immersive nature of Fallout itself. As a sequel it serves the franchise well, but there are so many half-baked ideas that just don't translate well to Fallout's world, even if the intention behind them was to make something that complimented the experience rather than take away from it. At the end of the day, Fallout 4's ideas are fantastic, but often the execution isn't conducive to its intention to captivate an audience, especially when compared to its other, more well-rounded aspects. When its enjoyment depends so diligently on the ability to immerse and enthral an audience, sometimes it's the smallest things that can be the worst of all. Note: Story spoilers will follow.

10. Combat Mechanics Aren't Fleshed Out Enough

Okay, so I think we can all appreciate the level of innovation that went into Fallout 4's gunplay. Both Fallout 3 and New Vegas didn't really have shooting mechanics that could rival other post-apocalyptic shooters of a similar vein, so when 4 came out with the fluid gameplay fans had been requesting it was really neat to see, even if everything doesn't stack up that well together. Whilst the player can now aim more efficiently and dispatch targets with equal ease, movements are the same sluggish ones we've become accustomed to with the franchise's previous entries. Combine that with the fact that enemies can now move a heck of a lot more quickly - as well as there being an inability to pause time with VATS - and it creates quite the headache, especially when you're in the teething stages of the game's early levels and stumble upon a nest of Mirelurks. Like Skyrim before it, it just creates the sense that stealth is the only real way to go. Even if you fancy causing a ruckus and letting out some aggression, stealth attacks are still the easiest way to go about accomplishing any given objective, which is only detrimental to the supposed variety on offer.

9. All The Factions Are Far Too Trusting

Some may point towards Fallout's hilarious bugs and glitches as being the title's main source of comedy, but it is the series' characters that create its funniest aspects. With the exception of the Railroad (who actually show some hesitation in regards to taking in the sole-survivor after they miraculously 'follow the freedom trail' to their hideout), every faction in the game naively assumes that you're dedicated to the cause, whilst also lampooning said naivety through comically self-aware dialogue. For instance, if one chooses to join up with the Brotherhood in order to acquire power armour, Danse will remark how he's "taking a big risk" promoting you so early, and the main power armour technician will plainly state that "most come here for the power armour and leave." I even proclaimed my unrestrained contempt for the BOS through dialogue options, yet still got all this armour bestowed upon me anyway. In that sense dialogue can often feel inconsequential, which makes one of Fallout's best aspects - the journey getting to the end - only cosmetically distinguishable through different playthroughs.

8. Settlements Just Aren't Up To Scratch

This just might be me admitting my own inability to build something as grandiose as an AT-AT or an awesome sky-fortress of sorts, but the actual building mechanics for Fallout's settlements are a bit naff, aren't they? Don't get me wrong, it's really cool building something when it does actually work, but nine times out of ten it just... doesn't. The tutorialisation of this mode is practically nonexistent, which then leads into a UI controlled in first-person that feels extremely counter-intuitive, especially when you're trying to assign specific settlers to specific tasks. In addition, walls don't snap where they're meant to, floors rarely line up and things like the power cables don't travel nearly far enough, which kinda takes away from the whole 'post-apocalyptic Minecraft' vibe they were going for. The ironic thing is that even though I don't really care for the settlement building mechanics of the game, it's something I'll always be interested in investing my time and acquired junk in. After all, it's not completely unrewarding - you get to see your settlement thrive in the wasteland and that's actually rather special - it would just benefit from some further refinement.

7. Infiltration Of The Institute Lacks Risk

Another fallacy of Fallout's intersecting storyline involving three of the game's four factions is that when they all converge at the Battle of Bunker Hill, there's no risk involved. If the sole-survivor has ran into every faction, you won't be engaged by any of them, and when you're attempting to play the Institute for the Railroad, everything loses its difficulty. The point is that when this massive battle happens, the player feels simply as though he is a spectator. Even if you attack all the units involved, they'll never retaliate, and after it becomes brutally apparent that you've sold the Institute out, what does Shaun do? Why, he intends to make you his heir apparent of course! It makes the whole thing feel a lot less gratifying, which is a shame because it should feel as though you're right in the hornet's nest, at least if you're choosing to side against the Institute. This may be a minor gripe if you always intended to side with one of the other factions from the beginning, but there's a distinct lack of risk and consequence right when these pivotal scenes are unfolding.

6. Preston Garvey And The Constant Threat Of Settlements

How many times have you felt as though you've just about accomplished something decent for the Minutemen, when the next thing you know you get an extra piece of dialogue saying "...there's more"? Because honestly, it's as if Preston Garvey believes that the sole-survivor is entirely capable of managing the Commonwealth by himself. It might be a little comical after the first few times it happens, but when it happens again and again? It can really feel as though you're making no new headway into the game. Every settlement you save suffers a kidnapping, or an attack, or raider trouble, and it's all up to you and you alone to fix it, despite supposedly having an entire militia to accompany you in your attacks. The quests are repetitive and tedious, but the one good thing is that you don't have to do them - actually discovering that for yourself however, is another thing entirely.

5. Changing Your Companion's Weapons Loadout Is Difficult

Another nitpick, but I can't be the only one still struggling to get their companion to use a desired weapon I've handed over. Allies will still use the same terrible firearms they have to begin with, even if you give them something fantastic, which is an odd deviation from Skyrim where you could modify pretty much every aspect of your companion's inventory. It gets a bit silly when Valentine is packing a weak little pipe pistol and you're wielding a ridiculous gatling laser to fend off hoards of super mutants. There's not a whole lot of logic behind it either, especially as you can change all of your companions' apparel whenever you see fit.

4. Mirelurks Are More Threatening Than Deathclaws

Deathclaws are at their most ferocious in Fallout 4, but even when they fall under a legendary tier, they still don't instil the same sense of dread that a nest of Mirelurks does. These things are absolutely unrelenting - they spit at you, they charge at you, they claw at you, they spray at you, and that's all before you even think of the Queen that does all of those things in one. They're fast, cover pretty much every base imaginable and take a ridiculous amount of time to deal with - not to mention they're shielded from the front, draining your VATS meter as you attempt to deal any damage. At least with a Deathclaw you can hide and stealthily chip away at its health. With Mirelurks? Your best option is to scream and fire.

3. The Main Story Barely Explores The World

The main quest-lines of Bethesda's RPGs have always been their least compelling, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but they should at least try to show as much of the world off as possible. Exploration has always been the name of the game with the likes of Fallout and Elder Scrolls, but all these previous main stories managed to work the world's map into their plot. With the franchise's fourth main instalment it can feel as though you're just circling around the centre of the map, with the odd excursion to the south occurring at intermittent intervals. It's a shame considering just how beautiful the world is, and whilst I don't doubt my own ability to complete its many, many side-quests, it would've been nice for Bethesda to have shown off more of the game world for those who may not be able to invest that much time in the experience. It may not be as beautiful as Skyrim or indeed Tamriel as a whole, but the Commonwealth isn't without its own charm - it's just a shame the main story didn't explore it more.

2. Giving The Player A Voice Ruins Immersion

This gripe is a little bit more divisive than others, but I am firmly of the opinion that giving the player a voice was a regressive addition to the series. I understand that it can add drama and that it does work sometimes, but the fact that it's the same voice every playthrough vastly limits the ability to roleplay like in past titles. I honestly love the sass that the sarcastic responses bring with them, but I'd be willing to part with them if it meant I was able to better hone and personalise my experience to me alone. A voiced protagonist has worked in Mass Effect (well, at least if we're talking about Jennifer Hale's performance as Shepard), but it just doesn't translate well to Fallout and won't with other Bethesda RPGs.

1. The Armour System Makes No Sense

The Commonwealth seems to occupy itself with one rule - you can either die fabulous or live ugly - it's your choice. I can understand some of the thought process behind layered armour, but in reality it makes no sense as it just restricts the player's ability to really hone their look to them and them alone. You can't put armour over awesome outfits like the duster jacket or the Longshoremen's garb, but instead have to make due with the vault suit and some really tattered rags to ensure the best defence possible. The game itself has so many of these clothing items that don't allow armour over the top, which leaves the player with a tiny selection of clothes to choose from - lest they visit Tinker Tom in the Railroad's hideout and chance their luck getting some armoured suits instead. It's a bit weird, especially since the game operates under the logic that armour can only be equipped on the basis of how 'thin' clothing is, yet won't let players place it underneath a coat. It completely impedes a person's ability to individualise their character to the best of their ability, and by restricting the ballistic weave to the Railroad alone funnels players to that faction each and every playthrough. Whilst these problems may not quite ruin Fallout 4 entirely, they are irritating for their immersion-breaking nature. It's still an absolutely fantastic game, but I fail to see the logic that compelled these elements into its final build, particularly when its predecessors of the same ilk had managed to evade them in sequels, spin-offs and more for years. Are there any other minor flaws that keep Bethesda's return to the franchise away from perfection? Sound off in the comments below!