Fallout: Where Bethesda Went Wrong
Where did it all go so wrong?
Let’s face it: The Fallout franchise hasn’t held the same level of prestige amongst fans since the disastrous launch of Fallout 76, and the comedy of errors that proceeded it. From the infamous Bag Gate scandal, huge patches that caused game-breaking bugs, and the introduction of a paid subscription that gives players an unfair advantage, it’s easy to see how this game has become the target of ridicule.
It would be far too easy to go through every issue that has tarnished this spin-off - as they are the main reasons that caused the downfall of Bethesda’s post-apocalyptic franchise - but the problems with Fallout started to rear their head long before 76 hit shelves.
No, something was amiss with the release of Fallout 4 in 2015.
This isn’t to say that Fallout 4 is a bad game in any way (in fact it scored well with both players and critics). Contrarily, Fallout 4 had the misfortune of being the follow-up to New Vegas, which showed players what the Fallout series could – and should - be.
Before proceeding any further, it’s worth going over a brief timeline of the series to understand the bigger picture
The Beginning Of A Series
Prior to Bethesda taking the reigns, the first Fallout game initially launched on PC back in 1997 curtsey of Interplay Studios.
Set to be the spiritual successor of 1988’s Wasteland, the first instalment was a turn-based RPG adventure that took players to the post-apocalyptic, retro-futuristic wasteland setting that would become the foundation of future titles. With an in-depth narrative that focused heavily on dialogue and player choice, Fallout saw players explore this desolate world as the Vault Dweller in search of a computer chip that would fix his vault’s water supply. It was received well on release and resulted in sequel Fallout 2 coming out the following year.
Much like the first game, the sequel was praised for its rich dialogue and focus on narrative as players once again took to the nuclear wasteland, this time as The Chosen One (a direct descendant of the original protagonist).
Unlike the first game, though, a rushed development meant that development team had to think of content to fill the desolate world. This resulted in dozens of bizarre pop-culture Easter Eggs populating the map. And thus, another classic characteristic of the series was born.
But then, things changed...
The Road To Fallout 3
Following cancelled projects, the failure of spin-off title Fallout: Tactics, and various production problems that led to the cancellation of a sequel to Fallout 2, the series would eventually fall into Bethesda’s hands after they acquired the Fallout IP from Interplay in 2004. And after Interplay failed to produce an online Fallout game (that’s right, Fallout 76 wasn’t the first attempt), a legal battle would see Bethesda gain full control over the future of the Fallout series in 2007.
Enter Fallout 3.
Moving from an isometric camera to a fully 3D world that players could freely explore, Fallout 3 heralded a new chapter in the series under Bethesda’s banner. Fully immersing players into a post-apocalyptic Washington, the latest game contained many of the notable characteristics and quirks that made the previous titles so endearing from its retro-futuristic aesthetic, reoccurring factions, and a laser focus on roleplaying and player choice while its shift to real-time action and gunplay marked this entry as something new.
For many players, this was their introduction to the series and, given Bethesda’s earlier success with Oblivion in 2006, they were for all intents and purposes the undisputed champions of RPG games at this time.
The series only got better with the release of Fallout: New Vegas two years later, a game that’s frequently hailed as the best Fallout game ever made.
New Vegas Reaches New Heights For Fallout
Set in the arid Mojave Desert. New Vegas initially sees players set out across the wasteland to find those responsible for shooting you in the head and leaving you for dead at the start of the game.
However, it doesn’t take long for players to become sucked into the three-way struggle for control that’s gripped the area, with you being placed right in the middle of it. Which factions you choose to side with and how they will impact the world is down to the choices you make along the way.
Throw in a selection of exceptional DLC that arrived over the next year (especially New World Blues) and it’s easy to see why there was plenty of anticipation and excitement for what could come next for the series. Unfortunately, though, Bethesda made their first big misstep with Fallout 4.
Announced at Bethesda’s 2015 E3 conference, Fallout 4 was set to be the studio’s most ambitious and biggest game to date as you navigate the ruins of downtown Boston in search of your kidnapped son, interacting with various factions and pulling at a narrative thread that goes much further than you initially think.
Fallout 4: A Streamlined But Flawed RPG Experience
In many ways, the fourth mainline instalment was hugely innovative. The heaps of junk you’d inevitably horde on your travels now played a crucial role in the gameplay loop.
Junk could be broken down into components and used in the revolutionary new crafting system that allowed players to customise their weapons, armour, and even build settlements to make the world and protagonist feel even more like their own. Likewise, refined gunplay and various other quality of life improvements would streamline the Fallout experience, making exploring this world and fighting hordes of ghouls more intuitive and engaging.
Unfortunately, this simplification of gameplay also extended to the dialogue system, which gave players four basic responses in conversations: yes, no, ask more, and be sarcastic.
Consequently, this design choice came at the drastic cost of player choice, a crucial component in any roleplaying game. Especially when compared to New Vegas, Fallout 4’s quests offer surprisingly little room for manoeuvring.
The Problem With Removing Player Choice
Compare the opening quests in each game: in New Vegas players can either choose to help the townsfolk of Good Springs fend off a group of Powder Gangers or they can choose to side with the invaders instead.
Each choice provides players with ample options for how to approach their chosen objective, leads to other quests with other branching pathways, and each choice provides a different narrative introduction to the game. All of which is based on a single choice.
Fallout 4’s first big quest, on the other hand, is nowhere near as flexible. When you make your way into Concord, a group of Raiders immediately become hostile. You fight your way through to the museum and help Preston and his surviving Minutemen win the fight by tacking control of power armour and a minigun before they decide to follow you to Sanctuary to set up shop. No matter what you do – even if you refuse Preston’s plea for help – this is the path you follow.
Stripping player agency in a roleplaying game is never a good option, and unfortunately this is how much of Fallout 4’s quests play out.
Although they're well written and performed, the narrative is a disappointingly linear experience where (save from siding with particular factions later down the road) how you engage with the world around you doesn’t hold the same importance as it did in previous titles.
Fallout 4: It's Just Not New Vegas
Moreover, Fallout 4 just didn’t have that creative spark that Obsidian put into New Vegas. Given that some of the development team worked on the original Fallout games, it shouldn’t be surprising that this spin-off captured the quirky and offbeat tone the series is known for all whilst merging an in-depth roleplaying system with an emphasis on player choice. It really was the best of both worlds.
In fairness, Fallout 4 does have its share of memorably bizarre quests (Devil’s Due, The Silver Shroud, and Kid In A Fridge being some notable examples). However, despite how entertaining and well-written they are, each of these quests is also distinctly lacking in meaningful player choice.
In New Vegas, player choice was the driving force that carried you across the desert.
It took you to strange places, introduced you to a cast of memorable characters, and ultimately decided the fate of the world around you. Who you sided with and how you approached objectives was entirely up to you. And no matter your choice, each outcome had tangible and meaningful consequences, no matter how small.
A Hopeful (Post-Apocalyptic) Future
Fallout 4 is not a bad game. It still provides an intriguing and imaginative world that you could explore and make your own. The central narrative still posed difficult moral questions that made us think about which faction to align with. But when the moment-to-moment choices are stripped of agency, the overall effect is an unsatisfying one – or at least not as satisfying as re-playing New Vegas to see how other choices would play out.
The disaster of Fallout 76 was the tipping point that highlighted that Bethesda may not be as competent at crafting immersive roleplaying games as they once were. Something made more evident when Obsidian showed it’s still possible to create a quirky sci-fi RPG where player choice really matters with The Outer Worlds.
Hopefully, Bethesda will learn from their recent mistakes and put player choice back in the heart of the next Fallout game.
With recent news that Microsoft has now acquired Bethesda, putting them under the same roof as Obsidian, the future of the series is looking bright. Especially if this means we could potentially see a fully realised sequel to New Vegas somewhere in the not-too-distant future.