FIFA 14: 10 Players Who Are Criminally Over-Rated

By Joseph Dempsey /

10. Marko Marin (78)

Chelsea youngster Marko Marin was one of those to receive a somewhat kind rating on FIFA 14. After a very poor campaign at Stamford Bridge last season, that saw the midfielder make just six league appearances, Marin was farmed out on loan to Sevilla for first team experience. Yet despite failing to establish himself in West London, the 24-year-old retained the rating of 78 given to him in FIFA 13, despite the fact he hasn't done anything. This is perhaps made more galling when you consider Victor Moses was afforded a rating of 75 despite featuring a lot more often than Marin and putting in arguably better performances.

9. Ashley Young (82)

Many have also quibbled over the rating of Ashley Young. The Manchester United winger hasn't scored a league goal since 2012 and in fact didn't score in any competition he took part in last season, making just 23 overall appearances. The England international suffered with injuries last term, which goes some way to explaining his mere 19 appearances in the Premier League, but he has been far too inconsistent to deserve his rating of 82, injured or not. Young has only rarely threatened to emulate the good form enjoyed during his Aston Villa days and was absolutely awful in United's recent 4-1 defeat by rivals City.

8. Antonio Valencia (83)

Another Manchester United player who has suffered a dramatic slump in form in real life yet still managed to attain a favourable FIFA rating is Antonio Valencia. The Ecuadorian was rated 83 in the latest iteration of the long-running series, despite the fact he has quite evidently gone backwards since breaking his ankle back in 2010 against Rangers. Since then, the winger has scored one, four, one and zero league goals in each of his last four seasons and is a member of what many consider to be the worst United midfield in years. A source of persistent frustration for his tendencies not to shoot when in a good position, Valencia has only rarely shown glimpses of form that suggest he's worthy of his rating of 83.

7. Samir Nasri (84)

Nasri is another example of a winger who endured something of an indifferent season last term, yet who still enjoyed a positive FIFA rating in 14. The Frenchman was superb during his Arsenal days but upon moving to Manchester City has flattered to deceive, putting in relatively average performances in recent seasons. Last term, his goal haul of two league strikes led to then-manager Roberto Mancini joking that he wanted to punch the midfielder in the face, a sentiment probably shared by a lot of frustrated fans. Nasri was rated 84 in FIFA 14, rather perplexing when you take into account he has the same rating as Neymar.

6. Iker Casillas (86)

The Real Madrid goalkeeper was once considered the best goalkeeper in world football, and perhaps still is, in some quarters. Yet last season, the Spain No.1 endured a wretched time of things, being dropped to the bench by then-manager Jose Mourinho and limited to just 19 La Liga appearances. Instead, Diego Lopez was given the nod over the one-club man, with Casillas still failing to retain his spot in the starting XI even now, after Mourinho's departure, having made just two appearances this season, both in Europe. Fortunately for the shot-stopper, his long spells on the Bernabeu substitutes' bench haven't been reflected by his rating of 86 in FIFA 14.

5. Nemanja Vidic (87)

With a rating of 87, Manchester United's Nemanja Vidic is considered the 15th best player in FIFA 14, the joint-best defender alongside Philipp Lahm and a better player than Vincent Kompany. Unfortunately for the big Serb, none of these things are true out in the real world when the Xbox console has been unplugged. It's actually quite baffling how the powers-that-be over at EA arrived at this rating, particularly when you take into account Vidic has only played 31 times over the last two seasons because of a chronic knee injury. There may have been a time when Vidic warranted such a lofty rating, but at the age of 31, those times are long gone.

4. Luka Modric (85)

Real Madrid enjoyed a reasonably successful season last term, finishing as runners up to Barcelona in La Liga and reaching the semi-finals of the Champions League. It won€™t surprise you then that Los Blancos have eight players making up the top 50, with a certain Cristiano Ronaldo being voted the second best player on the game just behind Lionel Messi. One thing that might alarm you however is the decision to award Luka Modric a rating of 85. The Croatian had a dreadful campaign last season, scoring just three league goals in 33 appearances and subsequently being voted by Spanish media as one of the worst signings of the season following his arrival from Tottenham. Yet somehow, EA figured he€™s almost on a par with the likes of Yaya Toure, Andrea Pirlo and Cesc Fàbregas (all 86). Inexplicable.

3. David Silva (88)

David Silva is a divisive player. He can either be brilliant - with his silky skills, marauding runs down the wing and eye for goal - or indifferent, wasteful and inconsistent. Unfortunately for the Spain international, his performances last season fell into the latter category, with just four goals in 33 appearances being just one of the reasons why City failed to retain their title. His average performances last season scarcely warrant a rating of 88, especially as Juan Mata and Mesut Ozil had far more successful campaigns and deserve to be rated higher than Silva, yet were only afforded 87 each.

2. Gareth Bale (87)

I wrote in my last FIFA ratings article that Gareth Bale was underrated with his rating of 87, but have since had time to revise my opinion. In actuality, all things considered, Bale is perhaps fortunate to receive his 87. Yes, the Wales international had a terrific season last term, with his 26 goals earning him a double swoop at the PFA Player of the Year Awards, but the truth is, that was the only successful campaign of his career. Previous seasons have been blighted by injury and poor form and his goal-scoring record has been nowhere consistent enough over the past three seasons for Bale to count himself among the Radamel Falcao's of the world - both virtual and real. True enough his excellent performances in 2012/13 deserve to be recognised, but the midfielder has a lot to prove and should perhaps not be considered for the 87 bracket until after he has proven himself year-on-year.

1. Franck Ribéry (90)

Bayern Munich had a phenomenally good campaign last season. Inspired by the superb form of Franck Ribéry, the Bavarians won the Bundesliga, DFB-Pokal, Champions League and Super Cup. Which is why you can't really argue with the fact three Bayern players make up the top 10 rated players in FIFA 14. My only quibble is the close proximity of Ribery's rating to Cristiano Ronaldo. The second best player in the game, Ronaldo (92) is rated just two points better off than the Frenchman and two points worse off than Messi at No.1. Are we really expected to believe the difference between Messi and Ronaldo is the same as the difference between Ronaldo and Ribery? There€™s no way Ribery can be considered only marginally worse-off than Messi, either. There has to be more of a distinction between the game's highest-rated player and its third, and in FIFA 14, there isn't. Do you agree? Share your thoughts in the comment section, below.