FIFA 20 Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs
A game of two halves... again.
Every year the football season returns and every year it brings the new FIFA game with it. You know the drill by now: no sooner has the first international break ruined all your excitement for the new season, or you’ve played your fantasy league wildcard in a panic, are your mates queuing around the back of your local Tesco for the latest installment from EA.
It’s been a rough old time for the franchise though, with PES allegedly closing the gap year-on-year and the seemingly endless political discussions over the lootbox mechanics in Ultimate Team. Most of us just want slightly better ball physics and our team to be properly rendered, but the developers have considerably more to worry about. This probably makes the 2020 version of FIFA the most high-pressure release in a generation.
With a core fanbase casting impressed glances over to their rivals and parents the world over begging for an excuse to not buy it, they needed to produce the must-have sporting video game of the year.
Have they? Has anything major changed between FIFA19 and FIFA20 beyond simply the name of the girl we ask to buy it for us? Let's have a look.
UPS
10. The Overall Look (Up)
Bare minimum really for a video game in 2019 to look visually stunning, but so much of FIFA's appeal is in the presentation that it's worth scrutinising all the same. Thankfully, they've massively delivered again, and the results are great.
Given the PR disaster of losing Juventus (and I mean, how do you lose one of the biggest football clubs in the entire world, they're not a set of car keys) the headlines now will likely be far more positive. Whatever the league, whatever the team, whatever the weather, the game looks every inch the professional presentation you're expecting.
Clothing seems to hang more naturally this year and there's a lot of extra effort been put into the camera transitions and variation of angles, which adds to the authentic viewing experience. In one incredibly nice touch, the crowd now seem to react to the ball being punted into the first couple of rows.
9. The New Speed (Up)
The most noticeable change to the game comes in the form of players physical attributes - specifically, that they feel far more like playing with the stars they're supposed to represent.
We've all been there, after spinning a journeyman fullback with Mo Salah or Raheem Sterling, you charge down the wing only to find that the defender has, somehow, managed to stay with you. In real life they'd have left him in the dust but in FIFA they manage to recover. Handy if you're playing a team much better than yours but infuriating if you're the attacking side.
Well, now the discrepancies in speed and strength feel like a big part of the game, with the faster players able to pull away and the stronger ones having a much easier time of muscling players off the ball. As such, matches between the top sides feel like they're being played at full blast, while tussles between "weaker" teams is a noticeably lower standard.
8. A New Spin On Set-Pieces (Up)
Hands up, I am absolutely dreadful at free kicks on FIFA. Like, honestly, I have not banged one in direct for about 5 years now, and every single time I get one anywhere near the box I usually just go for a dummy run and a pass instead. Mercifully, the entire system seems to have been overhauled for FIFA20.
A lot of comparisons are being made with the current system in the PGA games but the thrust is that you literally aim a reticle over your intended area, then manipulate the ball before striking it, adding spin during the run-up. Again, hands up, I still absolutely suck at it, but it definitely feels like I at least might get the hang of this one.
It's a move that might upset a few players - specifically those who've got free kicks down to a fine art already - but it's an element of the game that's badly needed an overhaul for a few years now. Saying that, catch me in FIFA 21 talking about how glad I am that they've scrapped this system because "hands up, I am absolutely dreadful at it".
7. Volta (Up)
OK, so at some stage over the summer, someone told you that the new FIFA had Indoor Mode back in it, just like it had in FIFA '97 - the best version of the game. Well, it sort of does, and it’s called Volta. Sort of a big mesh of indoor mode, FIFA street (remember that?!) and The Journey, Volta consists of a few different modes and massively helps the overall replayability of the game.
The thrust here is short, small, games that emphasize close control and flair in tight arenas. 3v3s and 4v4s full of clever flicks and passes that rebound off graffitied walls, all to a banging soundtrack with really distinctive-looking players. It's insane fun even if, like with the ball physics, it doesn't quite feel like it's finished yet.
The story mode element of it is a bit of a drag though. Far shorter than The Journey it's replacing, it's largely just long-winded cutscenes and match situations you almost feel like you're not allowed to use. Updates for this would be welcome, although a remaking of Nike's famous Scorpion advert would surely be a license to print money.
6. Career Mode (Up)
For so long, so so so so so long, Career Mode has been little but an afterthought for installments of FIFA. Replaced as a novelty by online gaming a decade ago, and more recently by Ultimate Team and The Journey as a development priority, FIFA20 sees it get a little bit more love. Not a lot, but enough.
Specifically, the notion of Team Morale now comes into play, whereby matches, results, and season goals will affect the happiness of your players. Most interestingly though, you'll now have questions put to you by the press before and after games, and how you conduct yourself will impact the morale of specific players as well as the squad as a whole.
This isn't a groundbreaking new feature, and certainly doesn't push FIFA towards Football Manager in terms of psychological squad micromanagement, but it's a refreshing new feature that will allow you to get your own personality into the campaign. After all, certain players will just not gel with your management style, and you'll eventually want to assemble a squad who better fit your footballing identity.
5. Other Modes (Up)
A close call on the Up or Down dynamic here as the other features to come with FIFA20 aren't exactly going to set the world on fire. The headlines here are two new modes for House Rules and not a whole lot else, but one of them is so good that it tips the tide of this point all on its own.
First off is King of the Hill, a possession-based match type that gets incredibly old, incredibly quickly. It's not without its charm but once you've played it a few times there's almost no reason to do it again. However Mystery Ball - my god, Mystery Ball - is incredible.
Starting like a normal match, whenever the ball goes out of play a new one replaces it on the pitch. These new balls all carry with them a different set of attributes that they imbue the man in possession with. These might be bonuses to the way they dribble the ball, the speed at which they can run with it, or the power with which they can strike it or, and this is the best bit, one that has all of this combined.
Inevitably the games descend into wonderful chaos whenever the mystery balls enter the pitch and it's this sort of daft fun that can really make a session on FIFA worth your time.
4. The Idea Behind The New Ball Physics (Up)
Straight up, this is a great idea. The ball in FIFA has never quite moved in the way you'd expect it to in real life, at times feeling like a big lead balloon, and others moving like a penny floater. It doesn't hold up consistently in weather conditions, but it also doesn't zig-zag in the air and deceive goalkeepers. It's not a massive issue, but it's a lacking element of realism.
PES2020 has already drawn a lot of praise for the way the ball travels depending on the type of pass. Put too much on a short pass and it'll not only leave the ground and bobble, but also be considerably harder for the receiving player to control. FIFA players fizz 40 yard worm-burners into feet without them so much as skipping off the turf. It's not overly realistic.
The idea here is commendable, and it'll no doubt end up making FIFA a more realistic game going forward. However, the new feature hasn't exactly been universally popular thus far...
DOWNS
3. The Execution Behind The New Ball Physics (Down)
... because they've executed it really, really, really badly. Here are some of the early player reviews:
Rafijoza comments: "This game is totally **** Passes in this game is like 5 years old kids who's playing in school"."Perfect for normies who want to just cross the ball and shoot outside the box and pray for a lucky goal" is Vaisov's view. Cameron, gives us this insight: "PASSING! Absolutely none of my passes go anywhere near where I’m intending, everything gets intercepted and it’s ruining the game."
Crosses, for example, will look as if they're going to fly out of play but then suddenly drop out of the sky. Bounces feel inconsistent and make it hard to judge how best to receive them. Relatively light tackles will occasionally send the ball flying off, while sliding in with force can feel like it's barely touched the thing at all.
No doubt there will be updates to fine tune this, but until then it's going to drive people mad.
2. The Commentary (Down)
Commentary remains the same as last year with Martin Tyler and Alan Smith doing the domestic games and Lee Dixon and Derek Rae doing the European nights.
There's not really too much more to say about it than that but I'd like to express my feelings on this matter through the medium of that really weird tweet Ezequiel Mangala received from a City fan one week. Albeit tweaked slightly to make sense in the current context.
Alan Smith seriously mate no joking please just don't commentate again fifa not suited to u pal your crap no hard feelings just not worked out.
The NBA 2K games have, without question, the greatest commentary in any sports game. Go watch some highlights of that and see precisely how far behind FIFA somehow still is.
1. Microtransactions (Down)
OK, so the bottom line here is that EA have decided they'd rather be forced to fix their game and that they're not willing to make positive changes to an industry that they're responsible for breaking in the first place. Legislation is coming, and with it a likely end to lootbox mechanics, but EA won't be doing the right thing until they're literally forced by the courts to do so.
Or, to put this another way, Ultimate Team 'Card Packs' are still a prominent feature in FIFA20, and players of all ages are free to throw their (or their parent's) money at them to try and get the best players. What are the chances of getting these players you ask? Nobody's got any idea because the odds of this glorified gambling are still not published by EA.
It's a big old shame because they had a massive opportunity to show willing here, and ultimately governments and the courts tend to overreact hugely to problems in the video game industry. Self-regulation would have allowed for a decent compromise but, instead, the hammer's just going to fall and we'll have to deal with the aftermath. Not cool, EA. Not cool.