FIFA 21 Review: 6 Ups & 7 Downs
A 'Career' renaissance or an 'Ultimate' disappointment?
EA's approach to FIFA 21 has been heavy on "Dual Entitlement" pomp.
Buy this year's game on PS4 or Xbox One, they say, and you'll get to play a souped-up edition on next-gen hardware soon. Admittedly, it's a dangling carrot some gamers won't be able to resist, but current-gen versions still need to be solid. Last year, FIFA 20 launched with some glaring bugs - such moments are PR nightmares in the age of rampant social media use.
EA didn't want another disaster quite like it, so they made sure to take extra care over 21 pre-release. Spend even a few hours testing out all the various modes and that attention to detail shows. It might not be popular to say when these titles are (without question) meagre annual updates, but FIFA 21 is a very enjoyable football game at heart.
Tinkering with some core gameplay elements has livened up attacking, and minor changes to Career Mode show that's finally heading in the right direction after years of being pushed aside for FUT. Of course, in typical EA fashion, there's a negative around every corner too.
Is it all bad though? Not at all...
Downs...
7. Volta Still Isn't Different Enough
It's hard to know who Volta is aimed at.
The old FIFA Street crowd noted that last year's debut wasn't nearly different enough to standard 11v11 matches elsewhere. The 3v3 format and funky backdrops, whilst certainly appealing visually, kinda' break down when you're actually playing. That's a problem.
Volta either needs to become speedier and even more arcade-like, or dress itself up as some skill-based sprint that relies on trickery. Right now, it's neither. In fact, it plays out like a less-fun version of the main game, and feels largely untouched from last year.
The short-but-sweet story mode does offer up some neat surprises when it comes to iconic players from the past, but it's over in a flash. You'll fiddle around with this for an hour or so before growing bored (unless you loved FIFA 20's original).
6. Goalkeepers Are Prone To Flapping
Anyone who watches top-level Premier League football could tell you that goalkeeper is often a troubling positions for managers. They can't legislate for mistakes that cost valuable points, but that's part of the sport's beauty. Still, it must be agonising for keepers, teammates, gaffers and fans alike.
FIFA 21 has some of the worst goalies ever.
They always want to punch or slap the ball away rather than catching it, and that's true even when they're under zero pressure from attackers. Honestly, it's annoying as f*ck to watch a world class keeper like Alisson refuse to hold the ball, or see him miss a punch completely.
This is something EA need to patch out, and soon. Goalkeepers should not be this erratic or bumbling. Even the best in the game often act like they're some division three nobody who's way out of his depth and has hands like sieves.
5. You Still Can't Play As Real Managers
There are Career Mode improvements (check out the 'Ups' section for that) this year, but those hoping to live vicariously through the eyes of Jürgen Klopp or erm...Sean Dyche will be disappointed to learn that they can't. FIFA 21 doesn't include the option to play as actual real-world managers.
This feels like a missed opportunity.
True-to-life managers have been in FIFA for years now. Pick a Premier League opponent and you'll see the likes of Klopp, Pep Guardiola and others prowling the touchline and kicking every ball. That immersion seems a bit broken when they're not playable and never move clubs independently.
Of course, licensing is a stickler there; Liverpool probs don't want to let Klopp manage Man Utd, for example. Understandable? Yes. Irritating? You're damn right. This is 2020, and gamers should be able to customise the FIFA universe to their own liking, or at least step into the shoes of their favourite coaches.
4. Several Real-World Elements Are Missing
This won't bother some, to be fair.
FIFA 21's matches always play out in front of a packed stadium of screaming, cheering and happy fans. There's no bleak reminder of the empty arenas seen on television mid-pandemic - again, some may point out that EA should always celebrate normal football culture rather than showing off empty stands.
However, it'd be nice to have the option for the sake of realism. The same could be said of the ever-controversial VAR. It's totally absent in FIFA, and that's slightly concerning for a product that aims to fully replicate the real-life stuff. EA surely have to bring in some VAR good/badness at some point.
If they're worried about how to implement it, then they could be upfront about experimentation and let players switch it off entirely. These minor touches would go a long way to making FIFA an even more realistic experience.
3. The Licensing Battle With Konami Robs Players
Speaking of realism.
The glorious San Siro/Stadio Giuseppe Meazza (depending on whether you're playing as AC Milan or Inter) looks incredible in FIFA 21. Pick either Milanese giant, pursue trophies in Career Mode with them and you'll find a lot to like. Then, you'll come up against Piemonte Calcio, see CR7 in a fake strip and roll your eyes.
Like it or not, EA's series has always relied a lot on licences to mask flaws elsewhere. This year, like last, the licenses they don't have stand out and cause FIFA's once-mighty grip on real-life football to wobble. Make no mistake - the only ones losing out during this never-ending battle between EA and Konami are gamers themselves.
Juventus are simply too big a club to be missing from a game like this, and it sucks. No amount of carefully-crafted generic kits, badges and stadia can avoid the truth: EA need to get Juve back in the game somehow. It's no use to play as made-up teams.
2. FUT Has Strangled The Series
If you're anything like the guy writing this, then you've long-since tired of Ultimate Team's dizzying mix of microtransactions and grinding. A mode that once seemed like a nice complement to others has become EA's focal point. There's one reason and one reason only: MONEY.
EA are a business, sure, but there's something so hollow about FUT. It's a titan that's been not-so-gently strangling the franchise for years now, and that won't change whilst it still rakes in mountains of coin. At this point, it'd be a blessing if EA released FIFA Ultimate Team 21 as its own game and dumped other modes in a separate, budget-priced release.
21's mode is much the same as before. You either pay real money for card packs to unlock the best players, or you slog through endless matches in the hope of maybe snagging someone good for a few games. The pressure to pay even more money for a product you've already bought is wearying.
It's an automatic 'Down' every time.
1. It's A Standard Annual Update
FIFA 21 doesn't do much to reinvent or rethink EA's standards.
There's no avoiding the truth that it's a standard, annually-released sports game. There are new strips, transfers, gameplay tweaks and Career Mode enhancements, but this is hardly a million miles away from the product EA shipped out 12 months ago. It's good to know that going in.
Do not fool yourself into thinking the PS5/Xbox Series X "Dual Entitlement" stuff means they've changed everything. If anything, EA will likely wait to use some fresh bells and whistles on the next-gen versions. FIFA 21 on PS4 and Xbox One is very much a modded reissue of FIFA 20.
99.9% of FIFA players knew that'd be the case anyway, to be fair. Some don't have a problem with that, because they love the updated squads, kits etc, and they're fine with a handful of small changes. Even so, EA will have to offer more next year.
Ups...
6. The Pace Is Spot On
Time for positives, and there are lots of them this year.
EA decided to make attacking less about pure pace and more about guile in FIFA 21. That comes at a slight cost, because it means you can't just bulldoze your way through a defensive back four every single time. That can still work, just not 10 times out of 10. It's something to keep in mind if that's your preferred play style.
Being honest, the new pace helps game flow tremendously. EA's product has always been more arcade-like than Konami's PES/eFootball, and that gives games an end-to-end, ice hockey-ish feel. Seriously, some matches play out like you're in the bloody NHL.
This can be modified in the menus, but it's oddly engaging (if a little bothersome to those who love a clean sheet). Gameplay is zippy enough without taking away weight when tackling. EA has struck a nice balance here.
5. Customising Your FUT Stadium Is Fun
It's not all doom, gloom and microtransactions in FUT. The ability to customise your own stadium for use in the mode is an idea that has legs, and it'd be great to see EA bring this over into other modes eventually. Yes, there are still those clamouring for 'Create A Stadium' in Career Mode.
For now, being able to decide how your home games should look is a hidden thrill. It nearly makes Ultimate Team worth exploring for those who traditionally hate it, and that's something EA should be proud of. One can spend serious time mucking around with all the available options and upgrades.
If EA enhance this, then they'll be onto something special. Putting statues at pitch side, altering how crowds act, splashing colour around the place and even deciding which banners your fans hold up can be an absolute gas.
It's the kind of customisation FIFA needs more of.
4. Heading Finally Feels Balanced
Try to head the ball in FIFA 20 and you'd take out some poor bugger's Bovril in Row H behind the goal. Lord only knows how many neck bridges those players were doing, but they had the ability to head the ball harder than they could strike it. Or, they'd weakly glance it into a keeper's arms like they had the strength of a toddler.
The good news? FIFA 21 has fixed this heading hell.
Crossing is finally a dangerous weapon when hitting teams on the break again. In fact, it's maybe a little too over-powered for now (EA will patch this over the next few months to try and find more harmony between headed goals and shooting) and results in a stunning goal a bit too often. Enough moaning, 'cause it's an improvement.
Headed goals can be some of the most rewarding in real-life football, so it's sweet to see EA bring that glory back into the FIFA fold. Feel free to leap up with confidence, and watch as your players actually direct headers on target.
3. Collisions Look More Natural
It's uncommon for FIFA to launch without some game-breaking glitches or hilarious collisions between players on the pitch that end in a tangled pile of limbs. FIFA 21 seems to have less wonky robots flailing around, which is nice. Collisions now look way more natural than ever before.
It was touched upon in a previous entry, but there's more weight to the player models this year. That makes slide tackling a pure joy - there are few things more satisfying than destroying a move by timing your slide perfectly. The fact the ball doesn't then laser-guide itself back into danger like before is also good.
Now, you can smash into players without taking out your own teammates. It might result in fouls, but it's positively delightful to target opponents directly and know you won't clip straight through them. That was an issue before.
Tackle and jostle freely, people.
2. Retraining Positions Is Powerful But Risky
One of the better changes EA has made to Career Mode is the ability to retrain a player's position. Basically, if you think that James Milner should drop back from midfield into defence as a CB, then have at it. Be warned though, 'cause this isn't a foolproof feature.
It can go terribly wrong and actually worsen a player's overall rating.
That's a good thing though. It means there's a risk and reward tension - you could, in theory, destroy a player's career by trying to make them something they're not. Try to turn Messi into a wing back, for example, and you'll be hearing from his legal team. Probably. Maybe not.
The thing is, it should be this risky. You'll have to keep an eye on a player's attributes (or train them up) before deciding where to best deploy them on the pitch. On the plus side, it's possible to exponentially improve a youngster by retraining them.
1. Interactive Match Sim Is Seamless
Start celebrating.
Simmed matches in Career Mode are no longer dicey affairs that often result in away draws or losses just because you're not the home team. FIFA 21's 'Interactive Match Sim' option means you can take immediate control of the game at any point.
Losing 2-0 after 30 minutes and want to put things right? Do it. Locked at 1-1 after 85 minutes, but want to bring on your new striker for a morale-boosting winner? It's your right. This is nothing new to sports games (Madden has been doing it for years), but it's fresh in FIFA. That's enough to make it the best addition to EA's series in some time.
There appears to be less chance of a red card in simmed games too, and there's a Football Manager-lite sheen to the system overall. This is something that should extend Careers beyond the first couple of seasons. It's seamless, well-implemented and means you'll avoid end-of-season losses.
What do you think of FIFA 21? For more on the game, check out FIFA 21: 10 Best Young Wonderkids You Need To Sign and FIFA 21: 10 Fastest Players!