For Honor: 10 Crucial Ups & Downs

Now we're post-launch, how is For Honor holding up?

By Ray Guillan /

Ubisoft's latest action offering is one of the first new IPs of 2017 and, crucially for the studio, is also a refreshing new idea.

Advertisement

First revealed at E3 in 2015, For Honor was on gamers' radars from the start due to the immediately intriguing idea of having knights, samurai, and vikings rip each other to pieces in gloriously gory melee combat.

Since that initial reveal, the game has been built up to include a variety of classes for each faction, bots to mow through, and plenty of player-on-player action. The game enjoyed success in alpha and beta testing, evolving the game as mechanics were fine-tuned and the game modes were tweaked until we were finally able to take to the battlefields in the final product.

But how do all of those details stack up in the final game since release? Have all of For Honor's ambitions been achieved? Well, read on, and discover what Ubisoft got right, what they got wrong, and what parts of the game could use just a little more polish.

8. Up: The Unique Setting And A New IP

For Honor is the perfect chance to settle the age-old argument of whether a stoic knight, disciplined samurai or a ferocious viking is the hardest warrior in history.

Advertisement

Granted, this isn't exactly done with 100% hardcore true-to-history accuracy and is grounded more in the romanticised versions of these warriors, but it's still awesome to see them all in the same game kicking seven shades of steel out of each other.

In terms of narrative, there isn't much explained as to why they're all fighting each other or how they all happen to occupy the same world at the same time. In fact, the game itself even narrates that the factions have been at war for so long that they've all forgotten exactly why they're at war in the first place.

To be fair, it's lazy writing. But that's not why people pick For Honor up. We're not expecting a massive thought-provoking meditation on war and the brutality of mankind, and that's fine.

What we wanted was a glorious skirmish between these three legendary factions, and we got just that!

Another point, that is crucial for Ubisoft, is that For Honor is a new franchise for the studio who have been gaining a reputation for "copy/paste" game design in recent years. They're showing that they are still a force to be reckoned with, and can execute the introduction of a new IP expertly.

7. Up: Classes And Customisation

For Honor does a great job of representing a variety of warriors and classes across their three factions, and they've been designed with great care and attention to detail.

Advertisement

Each faction currently has four distinct classes to choose from, and each of them feel like they make a difference on the battlefield through their highly specialised roles. Not all of them are great in every situation however, with classes such as the Viking Berserker and the Knight Conqueror being a lot more forgiving to players thanks to their large amounts of health and the devastating offensive capabilities they have.

This makes the likes of the Berserker and Conqueror great starter heroes for new players, but they're downright tide-turning in the hands of seasoned veterans.

Now, between these classes and all the players online you might get tired of looking at the same warriors after a while right? Well, not exactly. For Honor has this covered through an extensive set of customisation options that start by having you create your own personal emblem and heraldry (that can be used across all of your heroes) and goes right down to class-specific designs.

These include colours and patterns for individual sections of armour and clothing as you'd expect, but being able to customise each section individually can lead to some interesting designs and is a level of control and personalisation that is really appreciated.

6. Down: Campaign And Story

As mentioned in the introduction to this article that For Honor's campaign isn't exactly a meditation on the savagery of man and the nature of war. If you're looking for that from the campaign on offer in For Honor, you won't find it.

Advertisement

For Honor's campaign tells an often difficult to rationalise story that is best experienced as an introduction to heroes and their battlefield roles than anything else.

All of the characters within the campaign are fairly interchangeable as far as personality and motivations go. They all want to shout a lot and kill a bunch of the enemy for glory, but there's not much more to them than that, or any real stakes.

If your interest in For Honor is purely for the campaign, then it's hard to recommend without at least telling you that the majority of the game's appeal, and the way it has been designed to be played, is through online skirmishes in multiplayer mode.

For some players the story and narrative won't be an issue at all. But others way well be put out by what is, in essence, a weak campaign.

5. Up: The Combat

Combat in For Honor is an intense and bone-crushing affair that changes pace quite often. Being the very meat and bones of the game, it was important right out of the gate that Ubisoft really nailed their melee combat system in order to set their new IP apart from other competitors and any other 'hack and slash' sword fighting mechanics currently out there.

Advertisement

In group confrontations with enemy AI soldiers, it's massively satisfying to stride boldly into the fray, clearing enemies with every swing of your weapon as if they were nothing. Engaging 'lesser' enemies is always important as it can effect "the push" of your own forces, making it easier to secure objective points or hold vital ground from your enemies.

Combat against other heroes, whether player or AI controlled, is where the combat of For Honor becomes slower, more focused, and uses the "rock/paper/scissors" method of matching and mismatching your opponent's stance in order to block or land strikes respectively.

This might put off players who want a faster experience from the melee, but the slow methodical approach certainly gives confrontations with other heroes real weight and meaning. Testing an opponents defence as they try to find a weakness in yours, and exploiting errors in positioning, stance, or ability use. It's thrilling to come out of a one-on-one hero duel as the victor, especially after performing an execution kill.

4. Down: Soundtrack And Sound Design

As awesome as For Honor's heroes, environments, and combat are, the game is severely let down by its soundtrack, with the only memorable part being the musical sting that endlessly repeats while browsing the game's menu.

Advertisement

An epic score would have been great to go alongside the on screen action of For Honor - but, unfortunately, all we get is a handful of stings and loops that cut (not fade) in and out at the start and end of combat.

Not very epic, and not very engaging to say the least.

The game's sound design in general could have used more work. The clashing of weapons and armour is pretty convincing, but the limited grunts and moans of the heroes will eventually grind on players a bit.

3. Up: Environments And Atmosphere

As well as the immediately recognisable look and sound of each faction's warriors in For Honor, their individual styles of architecture and cultural differences are also massively diverse when looking at real-world examples.

Advertisement

This has been carried over in to the game as well. The maps in For Honor feature adornments, buildings, or environmental settings for each of the factions, and these have been given the same care and attention to detail that the hero classes themselves benefit from.

In the ongoing "Faction Wars" portion of online multiplayer matches, these adornments and fixtures even change on each map depending on which faction holds that region. That in itself is a small difference, but it's a level of detail that players certainly appreciate as they fight for dominance.

2. Down: Menu Design And Visual Polish

For Honor has a pretty distinct visual style, and with the rest of the game's assets drawing inspiration from all three factions in the game and using them to create an impressive amount of detail, it's puzzling that the same cannot be said of the game's bland and boring menus.

Advertisement

Everything is presented as function over form, with plain white text littering the screen, and dark boxes housing information while that damn annoying musical sting repeats endlessly in the background. This comes across as similar to Star Wars Battlefront where players joked that the design team must have forgotten to put a menu in the game and, last minute, dropped some still images and boxes on to a white background and set it to some Star Wars music.

OK, it's not quite that bad, but it is an area of the game that also feels like an opportunity for something awesome has been missed.

1. Down: Gear, Progression, And Longevity

So, this last point is a really divisive one amongst players. While some have concerns about the game's gear and progression systems, others quite like it, and others don't mind it either way.

Advertisement

After matches have concluded, players earn salvage that can be spent to upgrade gear, or scavenge for better equipment - or, at least, the chance of it.

New gear is essentially a random roll on an invisible table, with the stat boosts attached to gear even having the chance of varying a little. The part that is really rubbing people the wrong way is that duplicates can occur. Now, these duplicates can always be 'sold' back, but this is always at a loss.

Of course, microtransactions rear their ugly head at this point too, as salvage can be bought for real world money, as can other gear and currency, but that just seems to cheapen the whole mechanic.

Aside from some legendary and reputation-based armour sets, there's also not a real need to fully progress each hero after unlocking all of their abilities, or at least the ones you want. So fully leveling every hero isn't exactly a must-do task unless you really want those high tier skins.

And finally, the longevity of the game could be an issue. Are people enjoying For Honor? Yes, absolutely. Will we all still be playing it months from now? It's hard to be sure. Faction War, which lets you place war assets for your chosen faction after each match during a 'season' is pretty cool - but after a few of these seasons, players could lose interest and move on.

Matches are fun, brutal, and more heroes are on the way via DLC, but the game also needs to establish and run an effective content pipeline to, not only stay relevant for the remainder of 2017, but in to 2018 and in the run-up to the sequel that we'll no doubt be receiving.

--

How have you found For Honor? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement