Mass Effect Andromeda Review: 3 Ups & 8 Downs

More satisfying than 3, worse than 1 and 2.

By Scott Tailford /

Bioware

Easily one of the most divisive video games in quite some time - possibly even since Mass Effect 3 - Mass Effect Andromeda is Bioware's attempt to breathe new life into the franchise's formerly pronounced-dead corpse, as it was left back in 2012.

Advertisement

I'm not going to go over just how monumentally deflating and ill-conceived the "Now you're Space Jesus!' ending of ME 3 was, but sufficed to say, Bioware even considering bringing the franchise back was tantamount to madness. As such, they needed every single part of its conception and reveal to the public to be spot on - something that a lack of pre-launch single player footage and a bug-ridden demo most definitely did not deliver.

Now I've spent innumerable hours with it, Andromeda is quite simply a mixed bag of astounding proportions. As ambitious one moment as it is over-marketed into oblivion and filled with all-frills 'humour' the next, EA clearly wanted a return on their investment, leaving Mass Effect Andromeda to exist more as a box to be ticked on a corporate spreadsheet, than a worthwhile continuation of what went before.

Advertisement

That said, this is one of the richest mythologies and franchise lores in entertainment history - something that - miraculously - manages to elevate Andromeda far higher than it would otherwise deserve.

Downs

8. A Lot Of The Original Team Have Left, And It Shows

Bioware

One of the most immediate things you'll notice is how Andromeda is far less Star Trek and way more Guardians of the Galaxy - or rather, it's less the Star Trek of old, and entirely that of Into Darkness and Star Trek Beyond.

Advertisement

Which is to say, Bioware have now 'got jokes', and a good 90% of them fall flat or are totally forgettable. Outside the tonal shift, it's important to note that Andromeda was developed by Mass Effect 3's multiplayer team, stepping up to bat for their first triple-A release.

Such a turnover goes some way to explaining why there are so many issues with bugs and glitches, but in the time between Mass Effect 3 and now, Bioware has lost a number of key personnel who made Mass Effect what it was. Executive producer Casey Hudson, senior editor Cameron Harris, writer Chris Schlerf and senior development director, Chris Wynn - all of these and more were instrumental in the writing and conceptual processes of the original trilogy.

Advertisement

Without them, this former multiplayer team had to make the best of what was left, and although they did get writers Drew Karpyshyn and Mac Walters to carry over, the overall 'feel' and characterful drive of those older games is very rarely present.

7. The Best Story Moments Are Optional Or Hidden

Bioware

This is borderline unfathomable, as one of the coolest parts of playable character Ryder's connection with a unique A.I. brain implant (SAM), is it allows him or her to watch the memories of their father, Alec.

Advertisement

Such memories actually reveal a pretty huge and incredibly important plot point, yet they're forever hidden behind optional 'Memory points' on the various planets you'll visit, meaning unless you put the time into landing, driving to a marker, taking back off and re-visiting the 'SAMnode' computer, you can completely miss them.

This extends to everything outside of the basic 'Fight the evil Archon' setup, as squadmates have multiple specific asks and loyalty missions, yet they're all optional. There's nothing inherently wrong with making the player feel rewarded because they wandered off the beaten path, but when the most essential character-building dialogue and protagonist backstory is missable or gated behind collectibles, that's a big problem.

Advertisement

Speaking of the Archon...

6. The Archon & Kett Are Incredibly Uninspired

Bioware

In almost like an anti-spoiler, there's nothing to reveal about the Archon, because next to nothing is written about him.

Advertisement

Rather than Bioware take the time to craft a multifaceted, brainwashed villain like Saren or a duplicitous foe like The Illusive Man, we get a deep-voiced, monologuing, 'can't-stop-talking-about-how-he-wants-everything-to-BURN' cookie-cutter instead. Even after the credits have rolled you'll know no more about the Archon than before, and a potential plot line delving into how he's experimenting on every single race to create the 'perfect specimen' is totally dropped.

This extends to the Kett, who are literally (in gameplay terms) just armoured humanoids. They brand rifles, they take cover, they talk in grunts - there's nothing to them other than a metaphor for - in the worlds of The Witcher 3 - "Poor f*cking infantry".

Advertisement

I will say this: Andromeda does let you attempt to talk to them peacefully when you first meet - unlike what a lot of coverage has stated - though things go sideways immediately after, and never return. A huge missed opportunity, given humanity's place in this new galaxy.

5. Overwhelming Amount Of Systems & Bad Pacing

Bioware

Within the first two hours of Mass Effect Andromeda you'll be introduced to scanning, assigning skills, assigning profiles (two different things), crafting (both Research and Development), combat percentages, tracking optional side missions alongside your mains - even the tutorial gives you five different map markers on the way to the next cutscene.

Advertisement

It really feels like Bioware have looked at how Ubisoft will pepper a map with scores of things to do, and have somewhat replicated it, yet they've retained a narrative focus and notion of seeing a given plot point through, thereby ruining the appeal of deviation.

BioWare

Mass Effect 3 suffered from this too, because why would you want to explore the galaxy and find something like 'missing murder trial evidence' when Earth was literally burning? Here in Andromeda they've remedied the idea of a time-sensitive plot, but in the process, load you up with so many objectives at once, you'll not know what to focus on.

Advertisement

Even the so-called 'Primary Ops' often have MMO-style objectives within them, and many involve terraforming a planet so humanity can thrive - thereby meaning you have to visit the same-looking monoliths, complete the same puzzles, collect the same quantities of items and so on, to do so.

Bioware

The fact of the matter is: When there's so much going on from 'main missions' to exploration to collectible-triggered backstory, there's no sense of pace outside of what you dictate. At any given time you could be unlocking Ryder's past, hunting the Archon, completing loyalty missions and getting to know your crew, acquiring materials to craft better weapons OR slowly terraforming planets to maximise a 'Viability' meter so the Milky Way's races can settle down.

Advertisement

None of these systems are intertwined or reliant on one another, and whilst that may appeal to some, in contrast to how Mass Effect was previously so deft at delivering its story alongside exploration and investigative elements, ultimately, it stands more as a negative.

4. It Repeats One Major Plot Point From The Trilogy

Bioware

I'm going to delve into spoilers for this one entry - not the repercussions of what actually happens afterwards, but the events themselves, because in the moment, I couldn't believe how similar a couple of Andromeda's biggest plot moments are carbon copies of what went before.

Advertisement

First up, like choosing between helping the Krogan and keeping on Wrex's good side on the Virmire mission in Mass Effect 1, Andromeda asks you to make a similar race-related decision involving the Angara, resulting in Ryder having to choose whether or not to help them - the latter aggravating Jaal, your newest squadmate.

Said decision itself is strike two, as it's revealed the Kett are actually just Angarans who have undergone 'Exaltation'; a process where they're transformed biologically and mentally into mindless warriors. This is beat for beat the same twist as Mass Effect 2's 'the Collectors are the Protheans' reveal, though Andromeda tries to go one further by explaining that another ancient race called the Jardaan created the Angarans in the first place.

Advertisement

Sadly, this latter twist only comes up in one exchange with Jaal when he's forced to reconcile that his entire race were born from test tubes, and although this would've made for a neat comparison to how the Milky Way arcs arrived in Andromeda, it's cast aside.

Lastly, although the final mission is an 'all roads converge' explosion of set-piece fun that sees every major character get involved, it's played up like Mass Effect 2's Suicide Mission, where the game really wants you to believe that you're going up against a power that could terraform the galaxy.

Advertisement

Where it shoots and blasts its own foot clean off though, is in telling you before the mission, that you will be able to continue exploring and playing afterwards, somewhat ruining the stakes and making the Archon feel like more of a nuisance than a necessary or imposing antagonist.

3. Dialogue System Is Somehow More Limiting

Bioware

"We're giving you four options", they said. "Paragon and Renegade were too limiting", they said.

Advertisement

Well, sadly, the new 'emotion-based dialogue system' is somehow even more limiting than before, because at no point does it feel like you're affecting the story, or relationships with your surrounding mission-givers. Think about it - at least when you were choosing a fundamentally 'good' or 'bad' thing to say or do, these had obvious repercussions in the moment and long term, as such seismic events that could only go one way or another and were easy to address later on.

By contrast, at best you'll get four emotional responses to any given situation, but they're all variations on the same basic sentiment that keeps the story moving. Even if you vehemently tell people you're not interested in finding X number of items or don't want to do X thing, they'll continue as if you've agreed regardless, or you'll still get the mission prompt in your quest log.

Advertisement

And that was at best - 99% of Andromeda's dialogue options go between two choices: Casual and Professional. Star-Lord or Picard. New Kirk or Old Kirk, completely disregarding the very idea that this system was going to offer more choice in the long run.

Oh, and the 'impulse' choices that meant you could interrupt people and pull off contextual actions like punching, shooting or shouting at someone? I experienced, ooh, about four, in the 40 hours I played.

Advertisement

2. Ryder Being A Defined Character Fundamentally Doesn't Work

Bioware

Outside of the Joss Whedon/Marvel-lite 'comedy' that pervades every conversation if you choose any of the leftmost dialogue options ('Emotional' and 'Casual'), Ryder him or herself is always played as a 'light' character, again rather like Star-Lord or every new Star Trek character minus Spock.

Advertisement

You could play the game choosing 'Confident' the whole time - which will give you very measured, logistical and somewhat Shepard-esque dialogue - yet in certain cutscenes and interactions, Bioware force characteristics upon you regardless. One is where the squad leave without you saying "Dismissed", resulting in an 'awkward' (because it's hilarious) scene where you then dismiss them after a pronounced pause, and another, where Ryder introduces him/herself to the SAM A.I., and notes that they "Like to keep things light", before asking the machine if it has a sense of humour.

Both continue the problem Mass Effect 3's flashbacks and genuine concern for the young child at the beginning had - which was that if you were playing Shepard in a specific way beforehand, he/she simply wouldn't of cared about one loss amidst a warzone.

Advertisement

In Andromeda, you can be a forthright, "Let's get this done"-type leader, but the game will occasionally knock you back to 'bumbling newcomer struggling to get things right', because that's what we've seen sell on the silver screen.

1. The Lack Of New Races, Technology Or Anything Warranting A New Galaxy

Bioware

How do you come up with such an awesome reset button for a franchise as culturally and racially diverse as Mass Effect, then completely squander it?

Advertisement

Bioware have literally gone, "Right, let's move away from the Milky Way entirely and start afresh. It's been five years, let's see what we can do!" - or at least, that's what the opening cutscene makes you think is going to happen, as you're then met by many of the same races from the original trilogy.

Across the entire game, you'll meet the Angarans (the cat-faced squid people), the Kett (faceless bone-armoured warriors), the Remnant (a machine 'race' that are almost entirely three variations on gun turrets) and the Jardaan, who only get mentioned in a couple of dialogue lines.

Advertisement

Aside from these 'new races' (of which only two have faces), the fanciest thing you'll come across geometrically are... wait for it... floating rocks - something literally every sci-fi game, TV show, movie and book has done. Hilariously, Andromeda even has multiple characters remark "Hey, did you see those rocks?!" just to elbow nudge you back awake.

It's pitiful.

Advertisement

Ups

3. There Are Some Occasional Moments Of Excellent Writing

Bioware

Remember how Mass Effect as a franchise was this wondrous combination of intergalactic alien wonder, planetary discovery and interracial space politics? Andromeda has all of those things, they're just buried and scattered amongst your inventory like specs of dust across the cosmos.

Advertisement

There's a great beat when you first get to Angara and realise that the Nexus (your hub ship) has set up a community messaging program, allowing Angaran citizens to voice their concerns about your presence as the first extra terrestrial they've ever met. The postings are 'human', for want of a better word, and more memorable moments come from Cora and Vetra's loyalty missions, which expertly highlight why we love Mass Effect - that ability to operate on a macro and micro scale simultaneously, pairing the scope and scale of sailing through the cosmos and saving the stars themselves with a contrasting tale of someone asking for help to find their sister.

These moments remind you immediately of everything the franchise once stood for and did better than literally everybody else.

Advertisement

It reminds you why Bioware were such a momentous name in the industry, and whilst I think this particular 'Up' is enough to overshadow almost all the other 'Downs' so far, the structure of Andromeda ensures hardly anyone will ever actually see this content.

2. The New Open-World Loop Can Be Very Engaging

Bioware

Once you get your head around how to craft weapons and which powers you enjoy deploying - perhaps even completing some loyalty missions or getting romantically involved with a character or two - everything will start to click.

Advertisement

You'll deploy down to a planet just because you want to, knowing that the 10+ side missions you've racked up will all have their respective markers on the map. You'll summon the Nomad and tear off across sandy dunes, ice-covered lakes or low-gravity mountains, bounding from place to place, collecting, killing, conversing and being rewarded in turn.

When it's firing on all cylinders - i.e. when you get out of the tutorial or after you've felled the Archon and can just take in the galaxy and its requisite systems - there is a LOT to love about being the 'Pathfinder'; Andromeda's version of a Spectre from the original trilogy.

Advertisement
Bioware

Amidst so many systems and distractions, it does work in Mass Effect Andromeda's favour, in that you feel as though you're an immensely important part of the Andromeda Initiative and the galaxy itself - one who's slowly turning the cogs of everything around you with each and every step.

1. It's Still Mass Effect (For The Most Part)

Bioware

Mass Effect Andromeda is one of the only games I've played with so much potential buried away deep under multiple surface layers, it takes hours for everything to slide into place. Off-kilter humour and facial animations don't even register when you're sending enemies flying into space with the combined help of a Krogan shoulder-barge and biotic throw.

Advertisement

There's something about being an integral part of a story that moves forward with the aid of these select races - Krogans, Turians, Asari - that even in the face of all the bugs and glitches, all the maligned UI problems and overwhelming mechanics, manages to actually come together.

It's entirely subjective, but if you've considered yourself an active Mass Effect fan since 2012 and didn't let the franchise fall away after That Ending, you'll find a home in Andromeda alongside your crew and everyone else they brought along.

Advertisement

It really is a shame this is the best Bioware could do, but all the same, it's good to have Mass Effect back.

--

Advertisement

Have you picked up Mass Effect Andromeda? Let us know in the comments!