No, We Won't Shut Up About Spec Ops: The Line

There's a reason we bring it up again and again to the point of insanity.

By Joe Johnston /

2K Games

Long-time WhatCulture fans and even newcomers to the channel will know by now that we just can't get enough of talking about Yager Development's 2012 military-shooter-turned-murder-simulator Spec Ops: The Line. Fire up any gaming video and there's a roughly 100% chance you'll get to hear about that moment where the Delta Force operatives under the player's control do that really bad thing.

Advertisement

As primarily a video editor for WhatCulture, I recently claimed an edit and groaned as Spec Ops: The Line was wheeled out once again. Time to download that same footage from Chapter 8, same brutal white phosphorus attack, same march through dying servicemen, same dead civilian mother with her face burned off. Walker has committed a war crime! Maybe you're not the hero of this story! I thought to myself, "maybe someone should write a list titled '10 Video Games WhatCulture Needs To Shut Up About'".

Then I saw Spec Ops on Steam for £3 pounds, replayed it and realised that we're still absolutely right to bang on about it. There will obviously be spoilers for the entire game from this point forwards, so go and play it first if you haven't already.

Advertisement

Spec Ops: The Line, Then And Now

2K Games

To establish my history with Spec Ops: The Line, I first picked up the game in late 2012, when a certain critic described it as "the most exciting thing to happen in video game narrative for years". I powered through it and it made me so depressed that I had to play Ōkami for 10 hours afterwards. I was, however, deeply impressed by its unexpected plunge into horror territory and its vocal refutation of the oh-so-prolific modern military shooter genre.

Advertisement

Fast forward to the present day, and we've all been beaten around the head by discussions of Spec Ops' moral conundrums that we roll our eyes every time it turns up on a list. Returning to the game a few weeks ago, I dove in head first with the intent of seeing whether its narrative still held up. Surely, with a decade's worth of games offering more nuanced takes on morality, violence and conflict, this was going to feel trite and on-the-nose, best left as a relic of the shooter boom.

For the three of you who aren't familiar with what Spec Ops: The Line is about at its core, the game follows Captain Martin Walker and his elite Delta Force team, aided by Lieutenant Alphanso Adams and Staff Sergeant John Lugo, as they are sent into a ruined Dubai beset by a devastating sandstorm. Their mission is to perform reconnaissance and attempt to locate Colonel John Konrad, who has led a battalion into Dubai to aid its citizens, and immediately radio for extraction upon finding any survivors. A loose adaptation of Joseph Conrad's novel Heart Of Darkness, things inevitably go south as anyone who has read the book would attest to.

Advertisement

From almost the moment the game begins, a few crow's feet have started showing. Spec Ops: The Line is not fun to play on a mechanical level. Like, not much at all. While not difficult by any stretch of the imagination, the movement feels clunky, enemy AI isn't great and the weapons themselves lack much punch. All this combined makes for a gameplay experience that's less than rewarding, and if Spec Ops was being judged on its combat alone then it would have been getting 6/10s across the board.

The characters grate a little in the early scenes as well. Walker's expository scene-setting monologue is fawning and melodramatic, and feels like it was ripped straight out of a military recruitment ad. Walker's squadmates, Adams and Lugo, also bring back unpleasant memories of the forced and insufferable bon homie seen in Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare and Battlefield: Bad Company. Adams, dry and no-nonsense, scoffs at the wise-cracking Lugo's crass and unfunny jokes, while Walker, steely-eyed and square-jawed, squints into the middle distance.

Advertisement

However it doesn't take long for this veneer of patriotism and camaraderie to start chipping away. Immediately upon entering the stricken Dubai, it's clear that atrocities have been committed by both Arab insurgents and American soldiers, and it's Walker who first opens fire on hostiles who are then confirmed to be refugees.

From here, everything grows increasingly muddy. Walker's squad encounter bombed-out highways, mass graves and execution sites. They then come across a platoon of 33rd Infantry soldiers rounding up civilians, seemingly with intent to massacre them. Walker engages them, and from here on out it's clear the Damned 33rd have gone rogue. The plot thickens when the presence of the CIA reveals evidence of inter-governmental infighting and the monopolisation of the city's water supply, and things swiftly collapse.

Advertisement

The Scene You've All Been Waiting For

2K Games

Of course the story's true gut-punch twist comes from the infamous white phosphorus scene which occurs in Chapter 8: The Gate. The gameplay is eerily reminiscent of COD4's Death From Above mission, and may well be a direct response to it. As such, it's necessary to first talk about Death From Above. In that mission (interestingly also the 8th mission of the game), the player is in command of an AC-130 gunship, and is tasked with clearing a path for Captain Price and his SAS unit to reach an evac point.

Advertisement

When I first played COD4, I was impressed by the unglamorous presentation of that mission: the eerie near-silence of it all, underpinned by the drone of the gunship's engines and punctuated only by matter-of-fact orders from the fire control officer, all viewed by a grainy black-and-white CRT monitor. It felt more like watching a piece of upsetting newsreel footage than an exciting set piece and to its credit, that's an effective bit of presentation.

However, when compared with Spec Ops' take on this, we come to realise how uncritical Death From Above was. It's implied that not a single civilian was hurt in the aerial bombardment (likely impossible due to the sheer amount of munitions rained down on the Russian countryside), and once Captain Price et al are evacuated, the player is whisked off to the Middle East for another round of terrorist-shooting, with nary a glimpse at the burning landscape left behind.

Advertisement

Death From Above's aforementioned near-silence only emphasises our detachment and literal distance from the horror unfolding on the ground, a consequence-free massacre from a position of untouchable superiority. Walker's bombardment, in contrast, happens from just a few dozen yards away, and is set to a cacophony of terrified and agonised screams from the targets below. While the player engages in the strike, tasked with prioritising heavy artillery and anti-air weaponry, Walker's face can be seen in the reflection of his monitor, staring coldly back at us like a dark mirror image of we the player.

Once the area is secure and the smoke clears, we're not afforded a quick cut to the next exciting confrontation. Instead, we're confronted with the aftermath of our actions. We wade through the charred, dismembered bodies of our victims, clinging to life, blinded and pleading for help, while toxic glowing particles hang in the air. The final kicker, which we've discussed countless times, is that the large group of entrenched enemies furthest from us was in fact a group of civilians being evacuated by the 33rd.

Advertisement

The image of a mother, fruitlessly attempting to shield her child from the incoming devastation, is one of the most haunting and now iconic pieces of iconography in video game history. Bathed in an almost too-perfect spotlight, a distinct lack of other bodies around her, she is composed chillingly like a Renaissance depiction of Madonna and Child. While Walker looks on in stunned silence, Lugo screams "This is your fault, god damnit!" whilst pointing not at Walker but the player themselves. Turning back to his men, Walker coldly remarks: "We need to keep moving", a statement that will echo throughout the game's runtime.

Must We Really Keep Moving?

2K Games

"We need to keep moving" appears to be Captain Walker's mantra: a weak and hollow phrase he continually repeats to justify and rationalise his increasingly destructive actions. We first hear him say it after the first firefight with the Damned 33rd. He says it again after the team fail to rescue their apparent CIA ally, resulting in the likely deaths of more civilian refugees and eroding the trust of the men under his command. The third utterance occurs after the disastrous white phosphorus strike. He repeats the phrase several more times over the rest of the game. Ostensibly, it's an instruction to his men to keep them moving towards their objective, but it is in reality a reassurance to himself and by extension the player: that no matter how questionable and damaging his and our actions, the ends will eventually justify the means.

Advertisement

This is something the Call Of Duty series is frequently guilty of - trying to give an impression of nuance by presenting the characters' actions as morally questionable and complex. Unfortunately this rings hollow on almost every occasion. Whether detonating a nuclear device over Washington DC, subjecting adversaries to intense torture or carrying out no-knock raids in civilian neighbourhoods, valuable intel is gained or enemy forces are pushed back. The ends always justify the means, and our heroes remain the heroes of their stories. Nothing questionable about it.

Walker's decisions to keep moving, to make himself the hero of his own story, brings no such success. Every decision he makes only serves to inflame the situation further: opening fire on the Damned 33rd results in their failure to evacuate the civilians they were rounding up; his attempt to save CIA agent Gould is a failure; the decision to deploy white phosphorus on the outpost at the gate results in dozens of civilian casualties. Unlike what Call Of Duty would have us believe, pressing on no matter the cost will not go the way we think it will.

Advertisement

Even in those opening moments, less than a minute after we take control of Walker, a stop sign appears before the city skyline. It seems that sign was more than just a piece of set dressing.

Into The Heart Of Darkness

2K Games

Everything crumbles before the player as Spec Ops continues. The city of Dubai slowly collapses, its buildings levelled by sandstorms and gun battles; its infrastructure destroyed as its water supply is cut off and the survivors are left at the mercy of starvation and dehydration. The level design is constructed in such a way that the player is constantly descending; ziplining rappelling or outright tumbling down to lower and lower levels even when it doesn't appear to make sense geographically. It is, in effect, a gradual descent into hell itself.

Advertisement

During their descent, Walker's squad crumble themselves, both physically and mentally. Along with their increasingly battered uniforms and grisly injuries, Adams and Lugo gradually lose their resolve and the trust in their captain slowly drains away. From Chapter 8 onwards, Walker hallucinates frequently and his reliability as a narrator becomes increasingly dubious.

Even the game's interface itself feels like it's breaking down later on. Loading screen messages evolve from innocuous tips such as "To avoid fire while on the move, take cover while sprinting" to "If you were a better person, you wouldn't be here" and the now infamous "Do you feel like a hero yet?". The title screen, depicting a sniper watching over the city, gets more and more grim depending on how far the player has progressed: he becomes more watchful and alert, and his corpse is eventually seen being picked apart by ravens. The background skyline begins to burn and several of its buildings are razed to the ground.

Advertisement

These touches, both in the narrative and the meta, make for an experience both unnerving and disorienting, and it may take several replays to fully grasp all the moments of foreshadowing and subtle psychological manipulation - though you can't be blamed for being reluctant to relive it ever again.

An Evergreen Narrative

2K Games

Spec Ops: The Line was especially powerful in part because of when it released. 2007-2012 could widely be considered the era of the modern military shooter. COD4 had seen huge success, both critical and commercial, and its two sequels followed suit (though to a lesser degree). Battlefield's Bad Company titles eagerly capitalised on the format, and 2011's Battlefield 3 is still widely regarded as one of the best games in the franchise. Medal Of Honor also saw a shift to present-day combat, though these games were markedly less well-received. In fact Medal Of Honor: Warfighter, released the same year as Spec Ops: The Line, was poorly received across the board for its shallow gameplay and complete lack of self-awareness in its narrative.

Advertisement

Spec Ops was released when these shooters were at their most popular, and its marketing presented it as another one for the pile, albeit with some interesting environment mechanics and and an unforgiving setting. To pull the rug from unsuspecting players and vociferously condemn not only the genre, but the player themselves and the very nature of warfare itself, was one hell of a bold move, and an impeccably timed one at that. The subgenre saw a decline after 2012, with the various franchises moving either into futuristic warfare or returning to their historical roots. Can we therefore credit Spec Ops: The Line with driving a stake through the heart of that dreadful shooter scene? Probably not, but it's a nice theory.

While Call Of Duty isn't quite the critical phenomenon it was a decade ago, it still rakes in profits for publisher Activision, with a revenue of over $3 billion in 2021. 2019’s Modern Warfare reboot marketed itself on presenting its players with uncomfortable realities tough moral dilemmas. In reality, it actually seemed to double down on its war crime apologia and cowardly historical revisionism. Its multiplayer even included a brand new killstreak reward. That reward? White Phosphorus.

Advertisement

As long as entertainment media continues to whitewash and cheapen the painful legacy of war and state-sponsored violence, the discussions presented in Spec Ops remain relevant. Even though it may not have quite the same impact now that the modern military shooter is no longer top dog, and most players go into it knowing its intentions, Spec Ops is still an exceptional piece of work. Sure, there are games with more elegantly written dialogue and more subtle explorations of the issues they want to present, but that's beside the point. Sometimes we need a game that plants its flag firmly and points its finger directly, holding us down and forcing us to re-examine our relationship to media and confront our worst excesses.

I would like to assure you at this point that I am neither pearl-clutching nor moralising about the perceived evils of violent video games. I enjoy violent games as much as the next gamer, and even like to revisit shooters such as COD4 or Battlefield 3 from time to time for a tense, tightly-constructed campaign. But to consume the media we enjoy without ever viewing it through a critical lens is to deny ourselves and other artists the room to grow and progress. There's a hypocrite in all of us, and to acknowledge that is most definitely a good thing.

Advertisement

These points have doubtless been made many times before over the past 10 years by more talented writers than me, but it felt necessary to reiterate why Spec Ops: The Line is still worth talking about. So no, we won't shut up about it. Expect see many more entries in lists from now until the end of time.