Ranking Every Battlefield From Worst To Best
Battlefield set the standard for combined arms multiplayer, but which release is the best?
As DICE's premier franchise, Battlefield has made a lasting impact on the first-person-shooter genre over the years. With its excellent technical presentation, dynamic gameplay sandbox and focus on both on-foot and vehicle based combat, the series has been a regular fixture in online gaming.
Over the last decade it has also lead the way for many other franchises under EA's banner, running on the powerful Frostbite engine.
While it's mostly regarded nowadays as a franchise EA keeps on pressing DICE to make, its impact on the wider multiplayer scene can't be understated. As clichéd as it sounds, the massive battles that take place in every game are rarely matched in other FPS franchises. Whether it's landing an awesome multi-kill in a jet or teaming up with your squad to take the objective, Battlefield has always offered an entertaining
We're leaving out expansions and side entries like Battlefield: Vietnam and Battlefield: Modern Combat and focusing on all ten mainline entries from 2002 to present. From failed experiments to immaculate design, here is every major release ranked from worst to best. Move out soldier!
10. Battlefield: Hardline
It may have its fans, but there's little doubt that Battlefield: Hardline is the worst entry to come out of the franchise. It was an effort to get developer Visceral Games involved with the series, ensuring that it would have an entry for 2014 to compete with its nemesis, Call of Duty.
The premise must have seemed like a good idea at first; taking the Battlefield formula and transplanting it into the police scene. It's worked incredibly well for titles like Payday and with the franchise's powerful engine, it could have been an interesting direction.
What players got in 2015 was a grossly unimaginative expansion pack masquerading as a full-priced product. Cynically sold at full price by EA, Hardline was a shallow re-skin of its predecessor from the 2013 with the same multiplayer and hardly any originality paid to its cops and robbers setting. The campaign was just as bad, with a painfully clichéd story and minimal changes to gameplay.
Technically, the game functions well enough, but what's so aggressively disappointing about Hardline is that Visceral Games was a great developer. Their work on Dead Space allowing the series to branch out into spin-off territory. Instead they went for bargain bin territory and the series has never returned to other sub-genres
9. Battlefield 5
Poor Battlefield 5...
The latest entry in the long-running franchise took some cues from the competition and went back to World War Two for the first time since its debut. With the WW1 themed Battlefield 1 being a big success previously, it should have been a straightforward effort. Unfortunately, DICE and EA became rather irate with their fans and ended up killing off the game's chances of success before it even released.
It started off with the marketing, which threw out historical accuracy while chastising the player-base for their critical feedback. The phrase "Don't like it, don't buy it" became a crushing blow that caused poor sales at launch in 2018.
But it didn't stop there. The planned road-map and content updates trudged along and players started to abandon the game in droves. The development of the firestorm battle royale mode didn't help either, as it came off as a desperate attempt to cash in on the latest genre trends.
Battlefield 5 still boasts the same high-tier gameplay that makes the franchise so popular. It's a competently made title, massively let down by its poor marketing and questionable direction. The title is now a dead release, with painfully low player numbers, leaving DICE to lick their wounds before the upcoming Battlefield 6.
8. Battlefield 4
Following the franchise's biggest push into the mainstream, DICE wasted no time getting to work on the follow-up.
Battlefield 4 aimed to be the biggest and most extravagant entry in the modern combat setting yet. Upon its E3 demonstration, things were looking good, but when the game arrived in October 2013, a wave of anger from the fanbase erupted. The game's online mode was almost completely dysfunctional from day one, causing many matches to disconnect and end in game crashes.
On paper, it was Battlefield 3 on a grander scale, but its poor launch keeps it from ranking higher. It appears that EA decided to push the game out the door in a bid to get one over Call of Duty: Ghosts, which launched one month later. Its single-player campaign also wasn't much of an improvement over what had come before. Once DICE fixed the bugs and game crashes however, Battlefield 4 eventually became a strong entry in the series.
The game's greatest claim to fame with its "levolution" system, dynamic level changes such as a skyscraper collapsing or a damn flooding a city, dynamically switching up the pacing of a given match. It brought over all the gameplay components that made its predecessor great, but a rocky first impression soured its overall .
7. Battlefield: Bad Company
For the follow-up to both Battlefield 2 and Battlefield 2142, DICE once again changed gears. To the dismay of the PC community, Battlefield Bad Company did not launch on the platform, as DICE instead opted for a console only release.
It's also the first game in the franchise to offer a fully-fledged single-player campaign, which was mostly a worthwhile outing for 2008. Players take control of Private Preston Marlowe of the titular B company, a unit often sent in as cannon fodder.
Throughout the campaign, levels are more wide open and explorable, often designed to take advantage of the game's proprietary Frostbite Engine. DICE believed the next step in the franchise was to implement destructible environments and it went on to become a major selling point, not to mention a crucial component of later entries.
Apart from the Red Faction and Far Cry franchises, very few shooters had fully realised collapsible scenery and it was Bad Company that laid this groundwork.
Of course, the multiplayer also continued the franchise's pedigree, giving players a taste of affecting the map in their team's fa. In short, Battlefield Bad Company was very much a bridge title; one that proved the series could work well on console while also setting the stage for the future of the franchise.
6. Battlefield 2142
After Battlefield 2's massive success, DICE decided to continue expanding the franchise's frontiers with something more experimental. Released in 2006, Battlefield 2142 is a surprisingly enjoyable take on the series, with the only sci-fi effort in the series delivering some unique game modes.
More advanced equipment and multiple variants on conquest were enticing for many players, but these modes were quite literally dwarfed by the titan mode. It's up to soldiers to destroy a gargantuan flying behemoth by taking over missile sites and even better, infiltrating the monstrosity from the inside and taking out the power core.
This one game mode anchored 2142's place in the series and hasn't made much of an appearance since, aside from the larger vehicles in Battlefield 1. The action was further expanded by its expansion, Northern Strike, which added additional depth to the futuristic action.
With the game's servers having long been shut down since 2014, the franchise's escapades in a future setting are unlikely to resurface any time soon. A shame, considering how it offers all sorts of potential for unique modes.
Futuristic warzones may be in low demand on today's gaming landscape, but DICE should still consider venturing back to them at some point.
5. Battlefield 3
Now we're getting into the mainstream; as perhaps the most well-known entry on the list, Battlefield 3 debuted Frostbite 2 and gave Modern Warfare 3 a real run for its money in 2011. It represented the biggest the franchise had ever gotten up to that point and received high praise for both its graphical fidelity and comprehensive multiplayer components.
There were some criticisms that the level of destruction wasn't as widespread as Battlefield: Bad Company 2, but most players still had a blast with it. Add to that the five DLC packs that followed, there was a ton of content to keep the community active after release. The PC version received considerably higher support with the addition of community servers which are still online
Unfortunately, while the multiplayer was an excellent outing all around, the single-player campaign was very poor.
Coming off of the success of its predecessor, it was very disappointing to see a ridiculously linear story mode with an equally dreadful story to boot. It offered none of the dynamic action seen in the game's online component.
On top of this, the game was also lacking in variety when it came to its cooperative missions, which also felt like missed potential.
4. Battlefield 1
In the latter half of the 2010s, modern military shooters were sinking in popularity; tired of the same linear campaigns and homogenised online modes, FPS developers started to take things in a different direction. Clearly following in the footsteps of Call of Duty: World War Two, DICE chose to take Battlefield all the way back to the First World War and achieved massive success as a result.
Oddly titled it may be, but this older style entry in the franchise is the best release Battlefield has had in recent years. When compared to the likes of Verdun and other more niche shooters, Battlefield 1 is far from an accurate representation of the so-called Great War, but it remains a fine example of just how enjoyable its combined arms warfare can be online.
With its excellent array of modes, specialist classes and gargantuan maps, Battlefield 1 represents a massive step forward from previous entries.
Even the single-player was able to take some steps forward, offering a range of soldier perspectives through its "War Stories" mode. From the trenches of the western front all the way to the desert plains of Arabia, Battlefield 1 contained a surprisingly broad array of perspectives throughout the conflict. It's too bad DICE couldn't maintain this momentum after post-release content wrapped
3. Battlefield 1942
As the game that started it all, Battlefield 1942 is an important part of online gaming history. It was released in 2002 and originally started off as a planned GameCube exclusive. Eventually, the game was retooled for the PC by a team of just fourteen developers; DICE has certainly come a long way since
The key to the game's success was its focus on team-based play; many shooters from the nineties through to the early 2000s were arena-focused, often fostering communities that revolved around individual play in deathmatch landscapes. Battlefield 1942 was one of the first games to change that; taking out the enemy was important, but so too was wider map control, capturing objectives and making use of the many vehicles.
The franchise's debut successfully brought the combined arms warfare sub-genre to the mainstream. It went on to gain a massive following, inspiring other imitators like Star Wars: Battlefront and Planetside over the next few years. On top of that, Battlefield 1942 was the game that powered DICE into the upper echelon of the industry.
After several years making basic racing games and the occasional licensed product, the Swedish developer finally had their premier franchise that they've been heavily commited towards ever since.
2. Battlefield 2
Three years after the series debuted, DICE set about upping the ante for the 2005 follow-up. Beating its competitor to the modern setting two years early, Battlefield 2 set a high bar for online FPS battles at the time. It was a highly refined sequel that massively expanded on the original game's potential.
Battlefield 1942 put the franchise and its developer on the map, but 2 showed just how thrilling an entertaining the online FPS genre could be. When you had a full lobby of 64 players tearing up the game's many maps, it was one of the best multiplayer experiences you could have at the time. Like any great sequel, DICE knew to expand the scope of the action. With seven viable classes alongside the new commander option, the ways to play increased exponentially.
The latter in particular was a great addition that put one player in charge of assets like missile strikes and supply drops outside of the on-foot gameplay. The franchise's community grew rapidly after the game's 2005 release as Battlefield 2 scooped several awards and added more content with the Special Forces and Armoured Fury booster packs.
1. Battlefield: Bad Company 2
Battlefield 2 may have drastically grown the scope of the series, but the best entry by far is 2010's Battlefield: Bad Company 2. It's the height of the franchise's online prowess and a peak that hasn't been reached since. It ranks at the top of the list because both its single-player and multiplayer were equally brilliant.
Picking up from where its predecessor left off, Bad Company 2 boasted a more bombastic campaign and with the advancements of Frostbite 1.5, the level of destruction also rose to match the heightened tension. These improvements were welcomed by the community, but the game's online offering was simply second to none at the time.
What made it so brilliant despite the heightened performance of newer entries? It all comes down to the maps, game balance and overall destruction. The rush game mode became an intensely popular attack/defend romp as players pushed the battle lines across the maps. Each of the maps could be drastically deformed and taken apart, but in Bad Company 2, this offered an enormous tactical advantage.
Players can mow down trees to boost line of the sight to the target, pilot air vehicles to spot enemies from the air, destroy buildings completely to take out a group of foes.
These elements of play are suspiciously lacking in newer Battlefield releases, putting Bad Company 2 a class above its successors and making it the finest title DICE has ever put out
Do you agree with our list? Which Battlefield games were your favourite? Let us know in the comments below.