Ranking Every Rockstar Game From Worst To Best

GTA, Red Dead, Max Payne, Bully...

By Scott Tailford /

Rockstar

From humble beginnings to household names - and a few court cases along the way - Rockstar are by far one of the biggest, most recognisable and proficient developers in gaming history.

Advertisement

Responsible for multiple titles and franchises various generations will call their favourite, you really have to ask yourself: Is there any other developer with such a solid track record? As you'll garner from combing through the following 25 titles, Rockstar - without being too overt about it - really did have some immaculate forethought when it came to developing subsequent releases.

Various game mechanics or frameworks were tested in new IPs before being rolled back into the bigger games, forever ensuring that their marquee releases remain tentpole, landmark events. Literally no other developer save for perhaps Nintendo can lay claim to such meteoric success, nor the fact they've managed to maintain a notable high bar of quality for almost two decades at this point.

Advertisement

Brothers Dan and Sam Houser may mostly keep out of the spotlight, but that allows them to focus on everything their studios put out without fear of bowing to publisher demands or the whims of the public. It gives Rockstar a real feeling of passion and intent - something that makes their finest game one of the industry's very best...

25. Rockstar Games Presents Table Tennis

Rockstar Games

There's no such thing as an abject 'bad' Rockstar game, but when you're up against a pantheon of classics that include genuine medium-defining, world-changing releases, well, "Table Tennis" can only get so far.

Advertisement

Indeed, Rockstar apparently made this random one-off as a test for what would then power GTA IV - the 'RAGE' tech ('Rockstar Advanced Game Engine'). Needed to govern every last part of their next instalment in gaming's biggest franchise, they designed a nicely-playing game with solid character models and physics governing the swing of the bats and the bounce of the ball.

Everything was charming and pedestrian enough, providing just enough furtive steps to lead into an entire recreation of New York City and the ensuing chaos thereafter.

Advertisement

24. Smuggler's Run

Rockstar

Back at the turn of the PS2/Xbox generation, the industry had put a far bigger melting pot of potential on the stove. In Rockstar's case that meant gearing up for the monolithic GTA III, and you can see with both Smuggler's Run and Midnight Club they were exploring the boundaries of what the open-world driving genre feel like in 3D.

Advertisement

Smuggler's Run in particular had some brilliantly bouncy car physics, yet fell down a tad with overly repetitive mission goals and a lack of meaningful vehicle variety. Still it was a huge amount of fun - especially in co-op or head-to-head multiplayer - providing an essential cornerstone and a meaningful foundation for everything that came after.

23. Grand Theft Auto

Rockstar

Hats off to the original GTA - we all remember playing it at one point or another. The awkward top-down view that always got in the way of a blisteringly fast chase, the 'BSTARD' unlock-all cheat code and the feeling deep-down that you were playing something just that little bit too naughty.

Advertisement

Originally born from a glitch in a far more family-friendly title called Race n' Chase, the then-named DMA Design (now Rockstar North) realised that when the police A.I. freaked out and rammed the player, they could fashion an entire game around evading the law and committing all sorts of crimes.

A lightbulb "IDEA!" moment, if ever there was one.

Advertisement

Enter Grand Theft Auto, a game that holds up in every respect as a "Where it all began" archive piece. For 90s gamers grasping the controller with underage hands this was as 'adult' as it got, and though GTA III is the one that really made the world take notice, the franchise had to get its start somewhere.

22. Midnight Club: Street Racing

Rockstar

Released on the exact same day as Smuggler's Run (October 26th, 2000), this was clearly Rockstar testing the waters to see which of their two potential franchises or gameplay styles would take off.

Advertisement

Where Smuggler's Run was entirely routed in cross-country sprints and bounding over hills to snatch victory at the last second, Midnight Club predated the early-2000s rush of car-mods and street racing inspired by Fast & the Furious, but still had all those integral elements.

Picking a ride, dodge-weaving through traffic and avoiding the cops were all here, yet none of these elements were perfected or even focused on enough to make this original instalment truly recommendable.

Advertisement

Most developers put one step forward - Rockstar put both, but as GTA III proved, there was still a lot of work to be done here.

21. Grand Theft Auto II

Rockstar

Taking place in the pretty naff-sounding 'Anywhere City', GTA II felt nigh-on identical to the original, but provided a number of really cool, grassroots mechanics that you can still see in modern GTA.

Advertisement

Sprucing up the world itself so that NPCs interacted with one another, entered/exited vehicles, fought and even stole from you felt revolutionary, and though the actual driving was still hampered by that obscuring top-down view, this was a GTA with a far more 'alive' city to mess with.

GTA 2 also expanded the 'Wanted Meter' into a version better resembling what GTA uses today, seeing a ramp-up in law enforcement from standard cops all the way through to SWAT teams and eventually the army.

Advertisement

It may look like hell and feel more like it is to GTA III what Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake was to Metal Gear Solid, but there's a sense of forward-planning here that instrumentally shaped the Grand Theft Auto franchise.

20. Midnight Club II

Rockstar

Iterating on one of their most cult classic of franchises, Midnight Club II landed slap-bang in the middle of Burnout/Need for Speed/Fast & the Furious 2003 street racing euphoria.

Advertisement

Amping up everything from the feel of speed to car customisation, the addition of bikes and all manner of routes and shortcuts you could take to win, just the base look of the game was leagues above what we'd gotten only three years prior. To this day there's an argument to be made that Midnight Club II is the best of the bunch (though I'll get to part 3 and L.A. in good time).

Still, this fantastic sequel released just half a year after Vice City, once again being ahead of its time by pioneering various features like flashing lights at racers to take them on or launching yourself off ramps to get across the city (both things that get attributed to Burnout Paradise).

Advertisement

Midnight Club was destined to get left in the dust as Grand Theft Auto was quickly becoming bigger than Jesus, but it's humbling to see Rockstar never gave up on those who'd been with them since the beginning.

19. Smuggler's Run II: Hostile Territory

Rockstar

Speaking of being around since the beginning Smuggler's Run 2 came just a year after the original, filling in the most obvious gaps in content left by such an experimental first attempt.

Advertisement

Gone was the threadbare feel of having such arbitrary 'point to point' races and in was far better, doggedly pursuant A.I., more vehicles to hurtle across the various open-world environments and much more level variety. Every single component of the first game was either smoothed over, improved upon or trimmed - this was the experience fans of the first convinced themselves they were playing, and remains a worthwhile Destruction Derby-esque romp if you could even pick it up today.

Smuggler's Run 2 had the unfortunate job of releasing but a week after GTA III, completely obliterating its chances of anybody paying any attention to all those fancy new car physics and that loveably cheesy FMV cutscene tone. A shame, but it was damn fun while it lasted.

Advertisement

18. Grand Theft Auto London 1969 & 1961

Rockstar

Though the first two GTAs certainly had an identity of pure rebellion and being the social outcast, these mission pack releases provided the last quintessential ingredient in making Grand Theft Auto a cultural behemoth: The embodiment of a specific time period.

Advertisement

From just the nuance and charm of tearing around Westminster in a black cab to hearing the appropriately Guy Ritchie-esque score twanging away in the background, GTA London is almost the "true fan's old school GTA".

Coming at a point in between GTA 1 and 2, it once again showed Rockstar growing into the recognisable tastemakers they're regarded as today. GTA's London expansions certainly relied on the original game to exist (you literally needed the disc to 'activate' this new content) but focusing on that almost misses the point: The best GTAs are era-appropriate, and this provided a first look into that way of thinking.

Advertisement

17. Beaterator

Rockstar

Remember that small burst of music creation software that made it onto the PS1 and PS2?

Advertisement

Various other games of a similar ilk have come and gone over the years, but Beaterator always felt like it was directly channeling the likes of Jester Interactive's phenomenal Music 2000/3000 titles.

Taking a similar approach to giving you banks upon banks of samples and composition options, Beaterator went one step further by letting you record your own samples, loops and beats. This way you could actually put together an entire song - all created from your own sounds - save and export it.

Advertisement

For the tiny PSP Go! that was a really remarkable feature, especially for many budding artists who couldn't afford pricier, more professional software.

Sadly, due to cramming so many features that are usually accessible through keyboard and mouse onto just a set of buttons, Beaterator never took off as this 'music wizard in your pocket' idea - though it came damn close, and is a total blast to practice or play with.

Advertisement