Ranking Every Silent Hill Video Game From Worst To Best
What's the best Silent Hill game? Silent Hill 2? P.T.? Shattered Memories?!
Few names in gaming can cause people's knees to tremble the same way that Silent Hill can.
When the original game released back in 1999, people had never experienced anything quite like it. The potent atmosphere and heightened emphasis on psychological terror over simple jump scares really shook the gaming landscape of the time and helped push the medium into bold new territory.
Not content to merely rest on their laurels, the creators at Team Silent wasted no time in crafting a handful of excellent sequels that further expanded the scope and thematic territory that these simple horror games would dare to tread.
However as time went on, that magic was lost as different developers set up shop and lost the core ethos of what Silent Hill was all about, resulting in a dizzying mix of quality that few other gaming franchises have ever seen.
We're here today to rank the games in the series from worst to best, so that anyone who has never dipped their toe into the murky world of Silent Hill will know the ideal starting point, and what games they should leave out in the fog to rot.
11. Honorable Mention: P.T.
You could very easily argue that this is the greatest and scariest one of all, but as it was simply a playable teaser for the canceled Silent Hills game, it feels unfair to weigh it up against the rest of the series due to it not being a full-length title.
That said, P.T. is so unbelievably brilliant that it would be a disservice to its genius if it wasn't at least given an honorable mention.
Appearing literally out of nowhere back in 2014, P.T. took the gaming world by storm, giving YouTubers the world over something new to record themselves screaming at, and offering the rest of us one of the most compelling and downright terrifying games we're ever likely to experience.
Not only was it a tour-de-force in the pants-wetting department, but its central mystery and puzzles were so cryptic that the internet came together in spectacular fashion to overcome the game's overly obtuse challenges, which has firmly cemented it in the hearts and minds of many for the rest of time.
There isn't a whole lot to say that hasn't already been said. P.T. is a masterclass in game design and everyone should try it at least once.
10. Silent Hill: Book Of Memories
When making a new installment in a psychologically driven scare-fest, your first thought should of course be to turn it into a multiplayer dungeon crawler, one that's entirely devoid of any actual horror or stakes.
Bearing very little resemblance to anything remotely Silent Hill related, this game eschews survival horror in favour of a communal experience that sees you tearing through hordes of enemies with friends by your side - you know, the core ethos of what Silent Hill is all about?
Yeah, unsurprisingly this one tanked.
It's completely understandable that after so many years, the developers would want to shake up the franchise in a bold new way, but turning it into a mindless, button-mashing dungeon crawler was not the way to go, and the game's scathing reviews and ice-cold reception from fans are certainly reflective of this.
Book of Memories was also a commercial failure, which many would attribute to its exclusivity as a PS Vita title, but there's no doubt in our minds that it was this game's entirely misjudged premise that caused its demise.
As of the time of writing, this is the final Silent Hill game to be made - I can't think why?...
9. Silent Hill: The Arcade
From one misjudged title to another, Silent Hill: The Arcade was another attempt at shaking up the series' formula that sadly fell flat on its face.
As opposed to mind-numbing dungeon-crawling, this game instead gives you a massive firearm and tells you to go crazy gunning down as many malformed monstrosities as possible whilst you saunter through the foggy vacation town.
A fun game in its own right but woefully out of place in terms of the Silent Hill canon, this on-rails shooter feels like your run-of-the-mill arcade game with a Silent Hill filter hastily slapped onto it. Think Time Crisis, only instead of doing battle against international super-villains and low-ranking goons, you've got Pyramid Head stalking you and creepy marionette monsters baying for your blood.
That may make it sound more appealing than it actually is, but make no mistake when we say that Silent Hill: The Arcade is painfully generic and really has no right being a Silent Hill game. The iconography is there, but the soul is truly lacking and this one remains a curious oddity for hard-core fans only.
When all is said and done Silent Hill: The Arcade is fun in small doses, but ultimately worthless.
8. Silent Hill: Homecoming
Maligned by many for its combat-heavy approach to gameplay, there are very few out there that will truly champion Homecoming as a great Silent Hill game, and rightly so, as narratively it's very flimsy and shoe-horns in as many references to the older games as it can.
Players are put in the shoes of Alex Shepherd, a Special Forces soldier who returns from overseas, only to discover that his father and younger brother are missing. As is the way with these games, Alex soon finds himself within the foggy confines of Silent Hill and must unravel the mystery whilst fending off the horrific entities that prowl the streets.
Sadly Homecoming falls at the first hurdle by putting the emphasis on action over horror. Sure, there is the odd spooky moment and disquieting experience to be found, but Alex's skills in battle do a good job of empowering the player to such a degree that the horror is lacking as a result.
That being said combat is pretty decent enough, and it's a much more visceral experience overall. Though had this just been another survival horror game without the Silent Hill moniker, there's no doubt that it'd be looked back on more fondly.
7. Silent Hill: Downpour
2012's Silent Hill: Downpour was the last major console release for the series and saw it bow out with a whimper, rather than the bowel-churning death rattle we'd hope for.
Downpour tells the story of Murphy Pendleton, a prisoner who manages to flee captivity after survive a nasty bus-crash whilst he was being transported to another penitentiary. As luck would have it, the bus just so happens to crash outside of Silent Hill, and Murphy is soon plunged into a waking nightmare that forces him to face many of his own repressed memories and reflect on the crimes he has committed.
Which as far as Silent Hill plots go, is a pretty darn good one.
However, despite a great premise, this game is pretty lousy all around. With bland combat, uninspired monsters, and a whole lot of aimless wandering, this title failed on all fronts to capture the spirit of Silent Hill and has since been forgotten.
It's certainly not as terrible as most claim it to be, as the story is fairly good and subsequent patches have fixed many of its glaring bugs, but Downpour is still a mere shell of what a Silent Hill game should be.
6. Silent Hill: Origins
Certainly the black sheep of the Silent Hill franchise, Origins has the distinction of being the last of the classic era Silent Hill games before the series veered off the deep-end and lost its distinctive charm.
Starting its life as a PSP exclusive, Origins quickly garnered a decent following for offering handheld players an authentic survival horror experience that didn't compromise on quality like so many others. This game put players in the shoes of Travis Grady, a trucker that finds himself trapped in the titular town prior to the events of the first game.
With Travis being the burly-type, Origins has a greater emphasis on melee combat, allowing the player to wail on monsters with his fists or by using a whole host of breakable melee weapons that gives the combat a little extra flavour. Although outside of the meatier action this one was pure Silent Hill at its core.
It did lean a little too heavily on its predecessors, not pushing the series forward in any meaningful way. That's not entirely a bad thing as Silent Hill: Origins is yet more classic Silent Hill, and at this stage, we'd settle for that over nothing at all.
5. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
The last Silent Hill game to really put the emphasis on horror, this game's deviations from the traditional formula did alienate some fans, but for those who were willing to see it through to the end, this game was a spine-tingling experience that won't soon be forgotten.
A drastic re-telling of the original game's events, players were once again in control of Harry Mason as he desperately tried to find his daughter Cheryl, who had become lost within the harsh realm of Silent Hill.
An overhaul in basically every department, Shattered Memories is a completely different beast that aimed to terrify players in new and exciting ways. Most notably by stripping away all of the combat elements, meaning you had to rely on your running shoes to get out unscathed.
The lack of player agency in combat does make this one of the more intense games in the series, but such a deviation does detract from the creeping atmosphere as at any given moment, you may be forced to abandon what you're doing and flee from enemies.
Shattered Memories is one of the series' most interesting outings and definitely one to seek out if you love the feeling of being helpless in a horror game.
4. Silent Hill 4: The Room
After three highly successful and critically acclaimed entries, the devs of the fourth Silent Hill game were under intense pressure to deliver yet another knockout product. They were faced with a dilemma: should they deliver more of what people loved, or throw caution to the wind and offer a brand new experience that could possibly alienate their fan-base?
Thankfully they chose the latter and this resulted in Silent Hill 4: The Room, a truly strange and nightmarish experience that stands apart from its predecessors, yet still embodies all of the hallmarks that make a Silent Hill game both terrifying and impossible to resist.
This does come with something of a caveat, however, in that The Room is a little bit sloppy in the gameplay department, offering up the clunkiest of clunky combat and an over-reliance on escort missions. These elements do make it one of the most divisive games in the series, but there's no denying how outright terrifying it is in places.
A much darker story and a heightened emphasis on the surreal make this the most 'out-there' game in the series, which given how incredibly strange Silent Hill is in general, makes this one well worth playing through in spite of its flaws.
3. Silent Hill
Ushered in by the success of the original Resident Evil, the first game in the Silent Hill series took the groundwork laid by Capcom and thrust survival horror into new and exponentially more traumatising territory.
Eschewing Resi's late-night B-movie thrills in favour of brain-tickling psychological terror, Silent Hill was a watershed moment in gaming that proved that the medium was capable of so much more. Offering players a thoroughly mature and cerebral experience that prioritised mood and atmosphere over anything else.
The actual gameplay is pretty par-for-the-course, but everything else about the game works in tandem to create a truly unique feeling of unease as you press on in your mission to save your daughter - one that will make every save point feel like an oasis in the desert.
Yes, the graphics have aged like milk and the controls can be incredibly cumbersome, but beneath its dated qualities lies one of the very best survival horror games ever made.
It may be more than twenty years old, but I dare you to sit in the dark and play this game. It will undoubtedly get under your skin and stay there for weeks.
2. Silent Hill 3
Shifting gears from the more somber tone of Silent Hill 2, this third entry in the series went balls-to-the-wall in the gross-out horror department, with each area positively dripping with all manner of viscera and twisted imagery.
A direct sequel to the first game, players took the reigns of the series' first female protagonist, Heather Mason. A feisty young girl that without warning ends up journeying to Silent Hill, must battle her way through all manner of creatures and psychotic cult members to get to freedom.
Narratively speaking, this is perhaps the most lore-heavy entry in the series, and greatly expands upon the world in both interesting and disturbing ways, but those who aren't familiar with the original game may find themselves a little lost.
Decidedly much harder than its predecessors and sporting a younger, and arguably more relatable protagonist, Silent Hill 3 is a definite high point in the franchise that in the eyes of many was the last truly great Silent Hill game.
It contains all the right ingredients, but its unforgiving difficulty and overall lack of innovation from previous titles mean it falls just short of the top spot.
1. Silent Hill 2
Arguably the finest horror game of all time, Silent Hill 2 has lost none of its tenacity, tension, or terror in the almost twenty years since its release.
Telling the immensely depressing and disturbing tale of James Sunderland, a widower with numerous skeletons in the closet who embarks on a journey to Silent Hill after receiving a letter from his wife Mary, saying that she'll meet him in their special place. A prospect that would sound rather wholesome, if it wasn't for the fact that Mary has been dead for three years.
To recount all the reasons why Silent Hill 2 is so good would require a list of its own, and we likely wouldn't be saying anything that hasn't been said before in regards to its quality. Sure, it may suffer from some of the technical hitches that were commonplace for the era, but when everything else about the experience is so expertly crafted, it's easy to let such minor quibbles go.
Even in the face of some wonky controls and a somewhat unruly camera, Silent Hill 2 is still pound-for-pound the most finely tuned horror experience that the medium has to offer and you owe it to yourself to experience it.