Ranking Every Silent Hill Video Game From Worst To Best

What's the best Silent Hill game? Silent Hill 2? P.T.? Shattered Memories?!

By Marc Smith /

Few names in gaming can cause people's knees to tremble the same way that Silent Hill can.

Advertisement

When the original game released back in 1999, people had never experienced anything quite like it. The potent atmosphere and heightened emphasis on psychological terror over simple jump scares really shook the gaming landscape of the time and helped push the medium into bold new territory.

Not content to merely rest on their laurels, the creators at Team Silent wasted no time in crafting a handful of excellent sequels that further expanded the scope and thematic territory that these simple horror games would dare to tread.

However as time went on, that magic was lost as different developers set up shop and lost the core ethos of what Silent Hill was all about, resulting in a dizzying mix of quality that few other gaming franchises have ever seen.

We're here today to rank the games in the series from worst to best, so that anyone who has never dipped their toe into the murky world of Silent Hill will know the ideal starting point, and what games they should leave out in the fog to rot.

11. Honorable Mention: P.T.

You could very easily argue that this is the greatest and scariest one of all, but as it was simply a playable teaser for the canceled Silent Hills game, it feels unfair to weigh it up against the rest of the series due to it not being a full-length title.

Advertisement

That said, P.T. is so unbelievably brilliant that it would be a disservice to its genius if it wasn't at least given an honorable mention.

Appearing literally out of nowhere back in 2014, P.T. took the gaming world by storm, giving YouTubers the world over something new to record themselves screaming at, and offering the rest of us one of the most compelling and downright terrifying games we're ever likely to experience.

Not only was it a tour-de-force in the pants-wetting department, but its central mystery and puzzles were so cryptic that the internet came together in spectacular fashion to overcome the game's overly obtuse challenges, which has firmly cemented it in the hearts and minds of many for the rest of time.

There isn't a whole lot to say that hasn't already been said. P.T. is a masterclass in game design and everyone should try it at least once.

Advertisement