Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Unsolved Mysteries That Will Freak You Out
Pickled princesses, UFOs and vampires in the streets... it’s all going on in Red Dead Redemption.
Red Dead Redemption 2 is a massive game, with one of the most realistic and in-depth open worlds ever created. Though the focus on reality and setting can sometimes be to the detriment of the pick-up-and-play atmosphere of Red Dead Redemption and Grand Theft Auto, it all pays off in the end.
Not only does the game serve up one of the most touching and heartfelt narratives in video game history, it offers so much content around the map that even after 100 hours, you’ll barely have scratched the surface.
Yes, there’s the collectibles and the animals and the mini games, but if you want to truly dive into what Red Dead Redemption has to offer, you need to go off the beaten track. Some of these entries come during side quests, but for most, you’ll have to track them down all on your own.
Red Dead keeps a lot of secrets hidden for those who truly explore the game, and some them are guaranteed to give you chills. From the bizarre to the creepy to the downright terrifying, there’s a lot more to uncover in Red Dead Redemption than just Arthur’s story.
10. Marko Dragic’s Robot
Marko Dragic can be encountered in Saint Denis first, asking you to test out his little remote-control boat on the lake in the park. He’s a clear riff on Nikola Tesla, and if you don’t continue his story any further, he’s just another slightly off-kilter Rockstar side character. If you follow the A Bright Bouncing Boy storyline though, it gets very weird, very quickly.
You find him up in the valleys at the top of the map, just as a thunderstorm is brewing. He’ll ask you to help set up his robot, which involves some Frankensteinian lightning rod work. This is all to power his new invention: a living robot.
The experiment will ultimately be an encouraging failure, and Arthur wanders away a little confused about the whole thing.
However, if you return to the lab in a few days time, you’ll find Dragic dead and robot nowhere to be found... or so it seems.
If you use Dragic’s lantern to guide you, you’ll find the robot sat sadly in the snow, alone.
9. The Arm In The Swamp
Fishing is one of the most relaxing pastimes in Red Dead Redemption 2, with Arthur’s charmingly innocent side coming out of him as he stands on the bank and casts his line.
If you’re committed to completing the game, you can spend hours upon hours travelling and fishing at the various lakes, swamps and rivers trying to catch every single fish and legendary fish the world of Red Dead has to offer. It can be a grind at times, but it never feels as time consuming as other challenges.
It’s fishing; it’s supposed to take time.
However, you might get a bit more than you bargained for. Over in the swamps outside of Saint Denis, it’s possible to hook a severed human arm out of the water while fishing. It’s only been documented as having happened with John, but there’s no reason to think Arthur can’t discover the strange occurrence too.
Feeding Angelo Bronte to the crocs is a major plot point, showing us the first time Dutch becomes truly unhinged. It’s a fairly reliable way of getting rid of a body, so it’s likely the rest of the poor soul you fish up is stuck in the belly of a crocodile.
8. The ManBearPig
The ManBearPig is the name given to a manmade mutant found within the game, a grotesque creature made up of various animal body parts stitched together and hung in a Christlike crucifixion position on the back wall.
The name comes from a similarly freakish creature in South Park dubbed the ManBearPig, and the name has stuck for this monstrosity to. In an abandoned house near the Van Horn Trading Post, you can only gain access by climbing in through the window, when you’ll find this ugly mug staring back at you.
There’s another link to the creature too, covered in a later entry, which suggests it may be over a decade old and would therefore have been stuffed and mounted.
Within the house, you can find various items and letters which suggest that several other failed experiments were made before this ‘masterpiece’, although you’ll find no trail to follow to track its creator down.
The creature might just be the most disgusting thing you can find in the game, and that’s really saying something. This freaky dude is enough to give you nightmares, but it’s a shame there’s not more of a mythology to dive into.
7. Francis
Francis is the focus of probably the hardest Stranger quest in the game, Geology For Beginners. Once you find him and finish his fairly straightforward quest line though, things start to get... weird.
To finish the quest, you must head to a shack, where you’ll find pencil drawings of famous landmarks around the world, such as the Great Pyramid of Giza and the Empire State Building. The only issue is the Empire State was built in 1930; decades after the game is set.
The theory that he’s a time traveller is pretty much handed to you by the game; before you leave, a woman will enter holding a baby. This child has Francis’ red hair, his birthmark and she’ll even tell you his name is Francis.
What’s a little more interesting is that Francis is mentioned in Grand Theft Auto as well. The Epsilon cult in GTA V records that someone matching Francis’ description is a possible descendent of Kraff, the devil they all fear.
It mentions that people with red hair are ‘unsaveable liars’, suggesting that they too have witnessed Francis’ time travelling and have learned to distrust him.
6. The Lost Colony Of Roanoke
The lost colony of Roanoke is one of the earliest American mysteries (at least of those still surviving today), and has been tackled previously in pop culture by American Horror Story and Supernatural. If you wander through a certain part of the map though, you’ll see Red Dead Redemption take a crack at the mystery too.
The Roanoke colony was formed of new settlers in the USA, with one of these settlers - John White - leaving in 1587 to bring supplies over from England. However, with the Anglo-Spanish War raging on, he was unable to return until 1590. All he found in Roanoke was a single word carved into a tree: Croatoan.
The speculation over what Croatoan means and where the settlers vanished to leans into the supernatural, and Red Dead Redemption seems to play into this too. If you ride through Roanoke Valley at night, you’ll hear the ghostly wails of the settlers.
One woman will screech and cry that she wants to go home, while another will ask what that terrible noise is, and a third voice can be heard laughing in a deranged fashion. Truly creepy stuff.
5. The Skulls
This one is probably the smallest freaky occurrence here, in that it’s just a visual Easter egg rather than coming as part of any wider mystery to be uncovered. Still, it’s very strange, and the complete lack of any explanation only makes them more compelling.
In Lemoyne, you’ll see a pile of skulls, which is itself a little eerie. On its own though, it’s just an example of how dark and dangerous the world of Red Dead Redemption can be; not too dissimilar from the pile of bodies found in Tall Trees. For what it’s worth, the prevailing theory on the pile of bodies is that it’s the missing Blackwater athletics team.
Back to the skulls though. There’s two different types in the pile, one human and one... altogether something else.
They have large fangs which resemble a bear’s skull, but the shape of the rest is completely wrong. They seem to be primate skulls, but then they’re too large, suggesting much bigger or swollen brains than the average chimpanzee or even gorilla.
Even if they are intended to be apes of some kind, how and why did a pile of ape skulls end up in Lemoyne?
4. The Strange Man
The Strange Man had a much bigger role in the first Red Dead Redemption game, visiting John Marston at various times in the storyline. He’d usually have a fairly cryptic conversation, loaded with symbolism that John might miss but which would be picked apart and analysed by the player base.
Various theories suggested that he might be God, the Devil, or a similar deity interacting with John to try and shape or influence his destiny.
In Red Dead Redemption 2, you’ll have to search him out a little more, but his story is much freakier this time around to make up for it.
A deserted shack in Lemoyne features a silhouette on a canvas, but if you return there after seeing it once, it will reveal itself to be the Strange Man again. He’ll also appear in the mirror behind you, though when you turn around he’s not there.
If he is supposed to be a deity, why would Arthur and John both see him take the exact same form? Well, his clothing is similar to a more polished Dutch Van Der Linde, and the two men may be seeing God (or indeed the Devil) take the form of the man they admire most.
3. The Vampire Of Saint Denis
Saint Denis seems like one of the more peaceful towns in the game, but did you know there’s actually a vampire lurking in the streets at night?
At several spots around the city, you can find chalk scrawlings which reference Nosferatu and the idea of feasting on flesh and blood. They’re very sinister, almost as if the creature is bragging about their kills, using the walls of the city as a diary.
Speaking of diaries, Arthur will scribble each note in his own journal, and only once he’s collected the vampire’s five notes will he know where to look for the creature: right next to the cathedral, which seems ironic.
Once Arthur heads here between midnight and one, he’ll find the vampire down an alleyway, draining a fresh kill. Once you get closer, he’ll spring out at you with a knife, and one slash is all it’ll take to put you down.
If you draw fast enough though, you can kill him, and free Saint Denis of the blood sucking menace once and for all. Why he’s even there in the first place though is anybody’s guess.
2. The UFOs
While not the creepiest, arguably the out and out weirdest mystery in Red Dead Redemption 2 is the presence of aliens. Though you never encounter the little green men, there’s plenty of evidence that they have indeed visited Earth.
This evidence comes in the form of two UFO sites and a handful of rock carvings.
Of the two sites though, Hani’s Bethel’s cabin in North Hanover is definitely the creepiest, as it appears the group gathered there committed a mass suicide for the UFO. Whether this was to please, appease or simply offer themselves as sacrifice depends on your reading of the note.
Amongst other things, it says ‘We cast off our mortal shells so his vessel can take our spirits to the promised realm’. With one corpse sat at the head of the table, it appears to be a Jonestown reference.
The whole of the cabin in coated in a discomforting green glow too.
The second UFO is hovering above the peak of Mount Shann, glowing that same shade of green and flashing with red lights. It’s smaller than the Hani’s Bethel one, but with no concrete location in which to search for clues in, there’s no explanation for why it’s there.
1. Princess Isabeau Katharina Zinsmeister
In Van Horne, there are posters offering a $100 reward for the return of the Princess of Luxembourg, Princess Isabeau Katharina Zinsmeister. That in itself is a mystery, with no confirmed cases of her being found within the game, but theories on where she may be will definitely freak you out.
Her personal belongings can be found at the Van Horne fence, but that still doesn’t explain where she herself actually is.
Remember that shack with the ManBearPig taxidermy creature? Princess IKZ is speculated to be linked to this.
There’s several weird and wonderful things in a Lemoyne shack (well, not so much wonderful as bizarre), including a pickled head. It’s hard to discern any distinguishing features on the head, but it fits the basic description of the girl, and after dedicated players have trawled every inch of the map, it’s the only real plausible option for Princess IKZ.
She might be somewhere else hidden, of course, but chances are some trace would have been found of her. She might also have just been a red herring with no solution, but given Rockstar’s extensive world building, that seems unlikely.
It appears Princess IKZ was killed and her organs harvested, meeting a very grisly end indeed.