Red Dead Redemption: 5 Characters John Marston Should Have Killed

By Stu Whittaker /

Red Dead Redemption was the best game of 2010, if not the decade or of our generation. The game sighted vast, sprawling rural landscapes that offered an abundance of opportunities for gamers to take control of; from hunting animals to killing cannibals, this game had it all. And what helps the enjoyability of a game? The protagonist. John Marston, bandit turned farmer turned bounty hunter for the law. John Marston was one of those protagonists that you become draw to, you care for, he is an honourable man attempting to get his family back and live out the rest of his life in peace. Over the narrative John lays waste to hundreds of people, from bandits and murderers to innocent men, in truth the majority of characters John comes across perish during the story. So what about those who survived, did they deserve to? In this list I acknowledge four characters whom John shouldn€™t have spared, for differing reasons. I also offer up another character that I wish he killed despite the lack of logic. Anyway, spoilers will follow...

4. Herbert Moon

Advertisement
Okay, I will start with a technicality as you can kill the racist general store clerk, it is just the fact that he will reappear within minutes that lets the notion down. Found in Armadillo, Herbert Moon is simply a vile man, spouting ignorance and intolerance when you enter his store. Herbert also poses several conspiracy theories when you meet him in Undead Nightmare stating that, €œThe railroad company is just a front for the Jews€ and that, €œThe Jews killed Lincoln. That's why there is a triangle on the money.€ His pride and arrogance established his catch phrase, €œI€™m Herbert Moon!€ abundant every time he is attacked or robbed; something that was frequent when I had some spare time in Armadillo. Thankfully in Undead Nightmare he falls victim to three zombies whilst John looks on, unwilling to help. Following this, zombie Herbert Moon will rise giving our protagonist the chance to kill him in this form at least. Just tell me how you couldn€™t shoot a man who states: €œI don't like Jews. Or colored folk. Or natives, now that you mention it... I bet you like Catholics. Can't stand them either. Nor women, Fabians, Socialists, homosexuals, Asians, or British.€ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hSEwy8ZORc&feature=player_detailpage ...well worth the bounty

3. Abraham Reyes

Advertisement
Don€™t get me wrong, I thought Reyes was a fantastic character that offered a great duality to the story in Mexico. First encountered when you rescue him from the Mexican armies firing squad, Reyes is a revolutionary, poet who strives for social reform whilst sleeping his way through his female followers. His leadership is defined by his unrivalled ego and charisma, his guerilla tactics and status in the eyes of his followers who are willing to lay down their lives for his vision. Despite his initial image of a man who hides behind his words he personally saves John from De Santa's men before he can be executed, and participates in the assault on El Presidio and Escalera. By the end of the Mexico segment, Reyes (with significant help from John Marston) has defeated the Mexican Army and Colonel Allende and asks John if he will stay and march on the capital to overthrow President Ignacio Sanchez, John declines for he must track down Dutch van der Linde near Blackwater. So why should John have killed him? For me it is not anything that he does during his appearance during the game but what is noted in the Blackwater Ledger later on. The paper tells of Reyes defeating the Mexican President but not introduced reform, rather becoming a tyrant in his own right; executing protesters and delaying democratic elections while building a presidential palace for himself, a similar picture to real post-revolutionary Mexico. This was obvious, that he was going to become a tyrant, from his statements supporting class superiority (seeing those in his army as €œpeasants€) and exercising racism (seeing Chinese workers as €œan inferior race€). He also states that his followers, €œenergy... is like food to me!€ supporting the image of him becoming a power-hungry tyrant in his success.

His treatment of Luisa also comes under scrutiny. She believed that herself and Reyes were to be married, that they were in love yet this is shown to be false for Reyes is using Luisa like all the women he comes across. This is even harder for the player as Luisa is an endearing character, a young, ambitious, teacher who is following a flawed man out of misguided love. Reyes even tells John, who had asked about his marriage to Luisa, of his beliefs: €œMarry a peasant? My dear boy, don't be absurd. I'm going to be the next president of Mexico. My wife will meet ambassadors, kings, other great men. The very thought that I would marry some peasant girl with the hands of a farmer, well I really don't think so. My mother, qué Dios la cuide, will turn in her grave.€ Reyes can€™t even remember who she is, even though she dies trying to save him, to John€™s annoyance and disgust.

Advertisement
Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

2. Dutch van der Linde

Advertisement
During the campaign you quickly become aware of John€™s past and Dutch€™s gang and as John shoots his way through his old gang he gets closer and closer to his former leader. Dutch had been an ideologist, Robin Hood type figure whom despised the changing world around him. Whilst running his gang he gradually descended into madness, causing the disillusionment of his gang members, before disappearing with only theories as to his whereabouts, one claiming he perished in a fire whereas Javier Escuella believed Dutch resided in Columbia. Despite this, Dutch appears in the West Elizabeth region once John has dealt with Bill Williamson and Escuella and Edgar Ross tells John that it is his obligation to finish off the gang. When the two finally face-off, Dutch tells John that they are a dying breed in a changing world before committing suicide by dropping backwards from the cliff. Don€™t get me wrong, I loved the idea of Dutch committing suicide because €œ time has passed,€ rather than giving in to the authorities, an action John hoped would see his family set free. Dutch€™s death, to the player, feels just a bit hollow, was have killed all the former gang members (your choice over the fate of Javier Escuella permitting, if you capture him it is implied that he was hanged) with Dutch as the last, the leader of the gang, and once I was on the top of that cliff I was expecting a big, final showdown to end the game (not expecting the story to carry on after Dutch€™s death). Dutch did deserve to die, no doubt, if not for his attack on the police then the murder of the bank clerk, in €˜Great Men Are Not Always Wise€™, where he callously shot the hostage in the back of her head.

I thought that it had to be set in stone that our protagonist would prevail over the final member of his old gang, instead we are given a suicide and most disconcerting, Agent Ross shoots the body of Dutch with John's pistol, claiming it will look better in the report. It was a fantastic twist though and I would have not changed Dutch€™s death for one in which John killed him, yet, John should have definitely taken his shot. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1n8LhuDE27Q&feature=player_detailpage

1. Edgar Ross

Advertisement
I think everyone knew this was coming. Edgar Ross is the antagonist of the game andthe director of the Bureau of Investigation. Having kidnapped Abigail and Jack Marston, he forced our protagonist into his journey, killing his former friends Bill Williamson and Javier Escuella. Once this is complete, Ross tells Marston that Dutch has reared his head around Tall Trees and it is John€™s job to bring him to justice as well. Once Marston has completed his tasks, Ross is unimpressed with John€™s inability to have shot Dutch himself, taking John's pistol and shooting Dutch€™s body, stating that, €œIt looks better in the report.€ Finally Abigail and Jack are free and John can return to a peaceful life... Until Ross brings an army to kill John Marston! Thus Dutch€™s gang would be completely wiped out (Ross not considering Abigail as a gang member I€™m guessing). The all-out assault on the Marston ranch ends with John being unceremoniously executed in a firing squad fashion, as Ross lights his cigar and watches the last few agonising seconds of John€™s life.

Although Jack gets the job done three years later, it isn€™t as satisfying an ending compared to if John would have been his slayer. Ross spent the entirety of the game antagonising John, forcing his journey away from his family. It would have only been right for John to defeat Ross following the completion of eliminating his former gang members, although it would have plunged him into being pursued by Bureau of Investigation until death. And onto the one we wish he had killed...

The One We Wished

Jack Marston

Advertisement
Would it ever have happened? No. Is it controversial? Again, no. Jack €œWhy d€™you treat me like a kid?€ Marston is the bane of most gamers experience during Red Dead Redemption. The arrival of the whiny, troubled child who has €œ up without a father,€ marks a complete change in the storyline as finally John has succeeded and can live the life he has pined for. But Jack resents his father for their kidnap and long incarceration, seeing that the player has battled to free them does not compute with the boy. Probably a factor which heightens his annoying persona is that you have rode through the story putting the world to rights, defeating criminals and taming the West just to get them back only for the player to be given menial tasks like herding cows and hunting elk rather than criminals. The very fact that you are forced to play as Jack at the end of the game, especially if you still have stranger side missions to complete, is utterly annoying. You have spent the game fighting for John to succeed and live happily and yet, you are left in the wilderness playing as Jack. Jack€™s voice can just grain upon gamers with, €œWork, ya damn nag,€ imprinted into my memory. Jack is no John, not by a long shot. John was an enjoyable character who imbedded humour alongside humanity and an endearing sense of morality. Jack is seemingly depressed and revenge driven, once Ross is dispatched he often replies to NPC€™s with dejected statements, such as, €œI've got nothing else to live for.€

I know John Marston would never have killed Jack, who did everything in his power to save them including sacrificing himself. I just wish, as a young Jack compromised himself in one instance when he attempts to hunt a grizzly, that John maybe could have turned up a few minutes later and saved us the pain of playing as the arrogant young disappointment and putting up with his whiny cries for love.

Advertisement
Is there anyone I€™ve missed? Let me know who you want John to take on.