Red Dead Redemption: Who Should Play Who In A Live Action Adaptation
The voicework in Rockstar's Western is untouchable, but who should play the gang in live action?
It's been over two years since RDR2 (also known as the last game you'll ever need to play) has been released, and with every replay or roam around the frontier, the game just seems to get better and better.
We came for the horse-riding, hard-shooting and train robbing, but we stayed for the amazing story and characters.
The Van Der Linde Gang is the heart and soul of Red Dead, and despite there being quite a few members, players knew each of them personally, and throughout the game even grew fond of them. (Except Micah Bell of course - he can get taken by the Murfree Brood for all we care.)
If the world were perfect, a live action adaptation of the games would be in development this very second, and come in the form of a well-made and carefully crafted television series that would join the ranks of television drama like The Sopranos, Game of Thrones or The Wire. Every character and story arc in the games would be explored in great depth, no stone unturned, and no story aspect dishonourably cast aside.
An epic Red Dead series is but a pipe dream right now, but why not think about who would be the perfect actor to play the ensemble cast of characters from the games? While there are hundreds of characters to imagine actors playing, let's keep it simple with just the main twenty-three members of the Van Der Linde Gang from RDR2.
23. Rev Orville Swanson - James Badge Dale
The Character: Reverend Orville Swanson is the last person you would confess your sins to and while he doesn't contribute much to the game in lure of story or character development, he is unmistakably a valid and insightful member of the group.
At first Swanson is an alcoholic who spends most of his time around camp in a drunken stupor. But as times became more dire, the Reverend sobers up and became more of an aware individual. Interactions with him at Beaver Hollow suggest he saw the disturbing change in Dutch before everyone else. And like a canary in the coal mine, Swanson escapes the gang before any of that harm can be inflicted on him.
Hard to disagree with him, seeing as how things turn out.
The Actor: While Swanson is clearly much older in the game than James Badge Dale, that shouldn't be a hindrance. Instead, we should be looking at actors who have played wiry figures, and can carry off a tremendous moustache in the process.
James Badge Dale has the talent to play a complicated character, and who would be more interesting than a drunken man of the cloth?
22. Molly O'Shea - Katie McGrath
The Character: I feel like we as players never got to know who Molly O'Shea was.
The prissy upper-class Irish girlfriend of Dutch, there is a sense that while she did come to the US in search of adventure, the romance of the idea far outweighed the realism as she shared campfires with vagrants, gunslingers and degenerates.
As Dutch's attention towards her dwindled with each chapter, slight interactions with Molly (Arthur probably showed her more attention than Dutch to be honest) hinted something terrible was brewing. It all comes to a head when the gang takes shelter at Beaver Hollow, and a drunken Molly spitefully reveals she outed them to the Pinkertons. And the rest wrote itself...
The Actor: Irish actress Katie MacGrath still has room to shine in her career with a promising future ahead of her.
Aside from bit roles in Supergirl and Frontier, she's probably best known as the personal assistant who gets viscerally eaten in the Jurassic World reboot.
MacGrath is a fun actress with the roles she's given, and she would absolutely flourish in a role as meaty as Molly O'Shea's.
21. Kieran Duffy - Ebon Moss-Bachrach
Poor Kieran...
The Character: Early on in the game's story, an ambush on Colm O'Driscoll's gang allows Arthur to cross paths with Kieran Duffy.
At first Kieran is taken back to camp to be interrogated (and then possibly executed) for information about Colm's operation. It becomes clear to the player and the later the gang that Kieran wasn't hadn't really bought into Colm's ideology and instead was just looking to survive the dangerous open world.
Kieran is unofficially inducted into the gang and proves his worth as a kind and devoted member of Dutch's little army, and it's a massive shame how things end for him.
The Actor: Ebon Moss-Bachrach might be a little old in comparison to the age of Kieran, but if we were to take age out of the equation, there's some physical resemblance between the two that would translate over brilliantly as Kieran.
Moss-Bachrach's acting ability is on point too, playing anxious in The Punisher, sleazy in Blow The Man Down, afraid in Come Out And Play and a little bit childish in Girls.
20. Josiah Trelawny - Timothy Olyphant
The Character: It's easy to forget about this guy. For most of the time you wander round your camps, Josiah is nowhere to be found.
Less of a gunslinger, Trelawny is a silver-tongued devil and a conman. His appearances within RDR2 come in fleeting moments, but when they do, they are to drive huge aspects of the story forward. He prompts the gang to rescue Sean MacGuire from bounty hunters, he is the catalyst that gets Dutch, Arthur and Bill (for some reason?) in bed with Sheriff Gray, and is the architect of the casino boat robbery in Saint Denis.
The Actor: If the character of Trelawny was treated like a guest appearance, why not go hell for leather and have fun with the casting? Timothy Olyphant's cameo in the second season of The Mandalorian was a delightful surprise to all, and it wouldn't be any different if he were cast as the trickster of the Van Der Linde Gang.
Best of all, Olyphant has a winning confidence and charisma that would lend itself well to a character like Trelawny. It's never a dull or sombre moment with Josiah, and Olyphant is the man to keep that charm alive.
19. Tilly Jackson - Taylor Russell
The Character: One of the youngest members of the Van Der Linde Gang, Tilly's contribution to the welfare of her fellow outlaws comes from providing tips on lucrative places to rob.
When Tilly's past comes back to her, she is abducted and held captive, with Arthur and Miss Grimshaw setting out to rescue her. When the rescue mission is complete, Tilly shows an interesting character moment when she insists on sparing her captor, as opposed to gutting him like a fish.
Tilly is not only one of the few characters to make it out of RDR2 alive, but have a genuinely happy ending. That's all we can ask for with her character.
The Actor: Taylor Russell might have a few films under her belt, but what she's probably best known right now for is the Netflix re-imagining of the sci-fi series Lost In Space, in which Russell played the eldest Robinson daughter, Judy.
Russell is superb in the role, and arguably one of the best cast members on the show. A character as headstrong and empathetic as Judy would transition across brilliantly to the young Miss Jackson.
18. Mary-Beth Gaskill - Jessica Brown Findlay
The Character: Mary-Beth is the one member of the Van Der Linde Gang that really shouldn't be there. You can understand how Javier, Bill, John or Lenny fell into such a crazy group of reprobates, but how does someone as kind-hearted as Mary-Beth wound up sleeping two tents down from Micah Bell?
The interesting thing about her character is how caring and bashful she is throughout, and even during the worst of times, she remains one of the few characters clinging on to hope and kindness.
Like Tilly, she gets away from the Van Der Linde Gang before the Pinkertons descend, and in the game's closing credits, she's finally living her dream of becoming a writer.
A happier ending couldn't happen to a better person than Mary-Beth. Well, maybe Tilly.
The Actor: Jessica Brown Findlay has been in quite a few films and series since she first burst into the mainstream in Downtown Abbey many moons ago. Since then she's had pivotal roles in Black Mirror, Brave New World and the Morrissey biopic England Is Mine.
JBF is an incredible actress - one who could carry the innocent and naive charm needed for a convincing Mary-Beth.
17. Sean MacGuire - Domhnall Gleeson
The Character: The fun-loving, whimsical Irish member of the gang arrives midway through the second chapter after he is sprung from captivity from bounty hunters.
As a cheerful presence around the camp, Sean is a delight within the confines of the Horseshoe Overlook and Clemens Point chapters - for what little time he is around. It feels like we barely get to know him before he is the first proper casualty when the Gray family ambush members of the gang in Rhodes.
Like many other character deaths in the game, it's a quick and surprising moment players barely get a chance to process as immediately after ensues a raging gun battle.
The Actor: Domhnall Gleeson already possesses physical attributes that fit Sean MacGuire perfectly. Coupled with the fact that he has an incredibly diverse acting range, it would be neat to see Gleeson take on the role of swashbuckling tearaway with a skip in their step.
Much like the suggestion of Timothy Olyphant as Trelawny, Gleeson's casting would be a brief one that (sadly) would be over before we get acquainted with the character. But what fun it would be while he was around.
16. Simon Pearson - Tony Way
The Character: While (as far as we saw) never taking arms and riding into a gun battle with Dutch, Pearson served as one of the most important members of the Van Der Linde Gang - the man who made sure everyone got fed.
Simon Pearson might be the butt of jokes in the gang, but like Rev Swanson, his moods throughout the game greatly parrot the decline of the Van Der Linde Gang's morale. Once the gang relocates to the Shady Belle mansion, his weariness about the group's circumstances bode an uneasy foreshadowing for the events to come later in the game.
Thankfully Pearson gets away - deemed a coward and a traitor by Dutch, which is really ironic coming from him.
The Actor: Tony Way might be one of the UK's biggest low-key great actors.
Never too far away from a comedic role, he's emboldened a lot of great characters over quite a long career. But his stint in more serious roles also proves he's got an earnest side to him, and a great contrast of funny and sombre would fit perfectly in the role of Simon Pearson.
15. Leopold Strauss - Colm Feore
The Character: Another member of the Van Der Linde Gang who doesn't wield a gun, but Leopold Strauss' extensive vocabulary and immaculate appearance doesn't make him any less dangerous.
The loan shark missions within RDR2 are fun if a bit samey, but as we later find out they're actually of key importance. As players (and Arthur) soon realise that Leopold loaned money to those he knew would never be able to pay back, Strauss is outed as a mild-mannered parasite, and possibly one of the worst members of the group. (Barring Micah, obviously!)
The Actor: A character actor with an extremely diverse career, Colm Feore has popped up in a number of films and TV shows throughout the last three decades. And while you might not recognise him by name, you're sure to recognise his face whenever you see him.
In the Netflix series The Umbrella Academy, Feore plays Reginald Hargreaves - a cruel man with callous disregard for the children he takes under his wing. It's a mannerism that would translate over to Strauss perfectly. And if that doesn't sell it, shave away Hargreaves' beard and you have Strauss manifested in a physical form too.
14. Uncle - Jeffrey DeMunn
The Character: If there was one character in both RDR games that didn't have much development or nuance, it was Uncle.
Sadly, the moonshine-swilling lumbago-ridden member of the gang didn't display his usefulness and he appeared to carry over that gumption to Beecher's Hope.
There were some redeeming qualities about Uncle though; he was fun to have around the campfire during sing-a-longs, and even when morale hit an all-time low at Beaver Hollow, he provided enough sass and quick wit with Arthur to warrant admiration.
The Actor: Remember Dale from The Walking Dead? That character from a hundred years ago who tried his best to be the moral epicentre of the group? Well, grow that dude's beard out a couple inches more and stick a bottle of Guarma Rum in his hand and you've got yourselves an Uncle.
Jeffrey DeMunn is a character actor whose recent role in Billions is a great demonstration of how he can play self-absorbed and emotionally cruel characters, and even if Uncle doesn't necessarily lend himself to the latter, he certainly does to the former.