Resident Evil 3 Remake: 10 Reasons Why It Sucks
A whistle-stop tour of Raccoon City isn't what we wanted.
As a massive fan of the series, this is a bitter pill to swallow.
It pains me to admit it, but this year's remake of Resident Evil 3 really, really... falls short of expectations.
Alright, not going to beat around the bush: It sucks.
It's disappointing because it had so much potential to expand on what last year's remake offered us. You can hardly say it was rushed, either. The groundwork's been there for the last twenty one years.
Whilst it may have retained the more action-focused gameplay of its original, it comes at such a massive sacrifice. Massive parts of the original have either been tweaked or just flat out removed.
Iconic locations? Gone.
Puzzles? Gone.
A massively addictive unlockable minigame? Non-existent.
That snazzy Regina-from-Dino-Crisis unlockable costume? You'd better believe that's gone.
Instead, we've been given a narrowed down, linear experience with all of its unique charm from the original removed.
A much shorter runtime, bare minimum of endgame content, not to mention any real threat from the big nasty titular creature makes for a lacking experience.
And no, Resistance doesn't make up for any of it.
So come along and share my disappointment as we look at why this year's Resident Evil 3 remake is a massive letdown.
10. The Nemesis
The defining thing that made the Nemesis terrifying in the original is his penchant for turning up at unexpected times, sometimes following you through doors to add more terror too.
The problem was, this mechanic was utilised for Mr. X in last year's title, stepping him up from his planned routes in the original.
So had they done the same with the Nemesis, fans would complain he was the same as Mr. X was, albeit occasionally armed. Yet why would that have been a bad thing? Mr. X was a constant, lumbering menace. Having that ramped up with a faster Nemesis would have been perfect.
Instead, we just got predictable set pieces and easily spotted "jump scares" in its place. The power station is a prime example: see that massive brick wall and open space on your way there?
Yeah, you guessed it.
The real fear of the original was hearing a door open and the music swell, as he catches you unawares.
Having a big, obvious wall or open area always gives the game away.
9. Too Many Chase Sequences
Which, following on from the last point, has in turn made a lot of the encounters with the Nemesis into easily navigated chase sequences.
Granted, the initial introduction to the Nemesis and the subsequent fleeing is fine. That sets the tone of the game up perfectly: it's tense, you've gotta keep on your toes, etc.
But then another happens...
And another...
And they become more predictable as the game goes on.
There are a few occasions that you can stand your ground and fight the big'un. And yes, like the original game there are some rewards for stunning him. But outside of the few handgun parts you can acquire, the other drops are items you can go without. Shotgun ammo, for one, seems abitrary when you may end using more just to down him.
Having set pieces fly by because you're doing a generic chase sequence isn't horrifying or tense. It's just Uncharted with more tentacles.
Thankfully, we aren't reduced to Quick Time Events, but honestly it wouldn't have made much of a difference if we were.
8. Puzzles Lacking Any Challenge
One of the biggest criticisms of last year's title was the "dumbing down" of many of the series' iconic puzzle moments.
So surely you'd think Capcom, in their infinite wisdom, would have saved or at least modernised the memorable ones from 1999's Resident Evil 3?
Nope.
What's more, they've removed the locales these head scratchers were established in.
The music box puzzle, in which you needed to pick the right tone has gone, as has the clock tower itself (more on that later).
Or for those who thought they'd suppressed it, the water balancing conundrum has been entirely removed. You don't go anywhere near a water plant.
Even the final puzzle, in which you need to mix a vaccine is insultingly easy. No really, I'm not acting like a Mensa candidate, it's a doddle.
Combine two vials, insert into said vaccine machine, hit a few buttons to balance the fluid levels.
That's it!
What makes Resident Evil great is its subtle blend of lateral thinking and extreme violence.
Removing the puzzle element is to remove a core part of what makes the franchise what it was.
7. No Live Selection Moments
Another feature that Resident Evil 3 introduced, besides the dodge and the 180 degree turn, were the live selection moments.
Now, whilst the game was still fairly linear, it did allow for some dynamic changes that mixed up pathways and progression.
It also led to some fight or flight moments with the Nemesis, allowing you to stand your ground and be rewarded for it... if he didn't mess you up big time, that is.
Sadly, they're gone too.
The worse thing is, there was no reason for them to be removed. They could have spruced up the extremely linear game exponentially, giving players more reason to play again and attempt different routes.
No parking garage earthquake, no shoving the Nemesis off of a bridge. It's all gone.
Would it have been that difficult to put in during, for example, one of the boring Nemesis chase sequences, a Dragon's Lair style path split? Perhaps with some different obstacles or obstructions in the way to keep us on our toes?
Apparently so, as nothing remotely similar happens in this version.
6. Mercenaries Retired
Possibly the most egregious removal of all, the Mercenaries minigame at the end of the original was one of the greatest things about it.
As a positive, it went on to inspire a continuation of it in Resident Evil's 4 and 5, before getting its own standalone title on the Nintendo 3DS.
As a negative... why the hell would you remove it from this?!
This would have been the perfect setting for it: smaller fight areas would be able to handle more enemies on screen. Make the route from the subway to the power station a lethal gauntlet to run, or vice versa.
Even the UBCS members actually have a bit more personality this time, why could we not have had some fun with them in their own minigame again?
The other part that completed the Mercenaries mode was its necessity to unlock super weapons for the main game. After all, points win prizes.
Instead, handing that responsibility to Jill and having to grind out points via the Records system is such a massive waste of potential.
5. Removal Of Key Playable Areas
Before anyone gets all up in my face and starts giving it, "But you get to go to the clock tower! What are you talking about?!"
Firstly: Don't.
Secondly: Yes, you do. But you don't get to go into the clock tower. You don't get to explore it, nor do you get to solve the puzzle of the time manipulating goddess paintings. You don't get to test your music intuition and sync a melody up at the height of the tower section.
Instead, you get to look at it briefly before being subjected to a generic arena boss fight.
And generic is putting it lightly. There's no challenge to it anymore. No awkward garden to navigate.
You've got the Nemesis, who's mutated into some bizarre amphibious dog mutant... thing, in a big circular arena.
Even the little things like the press office and the restaurant sections, two once-interactive areas, have also gone.
It'd be nice to know why Capcom decided to trim this areas off, because they were hardly fat the first time around.
4. No Variety
Ignoring the massive whinge over the redesign of Jill's outfit, considering you could have gotten her original as a pre-order bonus if you tried hard enough, there's still little in the way of fun once you've finished the game.
The original Resident Evil 3 had a total of six costume variants (brought up to nine by the time of the Dreamcast and PC versions) to mess around with.
Japanese police officer, white disco suit, as well as Regina's iconic outfit from Dino Crisis are completely absent from this year's edition.
The only costume that's survived any kind of cull is Jill's S.TA.R.S uniform from the very first Resident Evil, which is available in the endgame shop for a relatively low price.
It's just a massive back step when you consider 2019's Resident Evil had, between Leon and Claire, seven outfits each that they could change into.
Although some of them are only available as paid DLC. This is Capcom after all.
But sadly, even with the pre-order bonus of Jill's classic RE3 costume, as well as Carlos' original hair (weirdly), there's still a real lack of novelty once you finish it.
3. Resistance Isn't A Worthwhile Addition
I honestly thought we'd progressed from the unnecessary inclusion of multiplayer into single player horror games.
It didn't work for Dead Space, nor did it for Condemned or Bioshock.
Yet multiplayer-focused Resident Evil games have been done before, in the guise of Resident Evil: Outbreak 1 & 2. The thing is, why not focus on remaking one of those properly, instead of tacking on Resistance in this game?
It's just insulting to give us this as a salve over the aforementioned removed Mercenaries mode.
Yes, it's free, and yes I'm sure it's fun if you can get a team behind you and japes can be had. But on the whole it's degrading after removing so much of the core game to begin with.
And yes, I'm sure it's easy to say, "Well this is for not remaking Outbreak" or whatever, but it feels like a copout on both fronts. Either make a full Resident Evil 3 or remake the Outbreak's as one complete game.
Doing half of each and calling it a "complete Resident Evil experience" is just wrong.
2. Lack Of Bonus Weapons
What made the original trilogy of games fun, for me, was the idea of finishing it quick enough to unlock some sweet firepower in return.
Whilst the game can be finished quickly anyway (but not as a positive), the removal of anything decent as an unlockable reward just cheapens the whole experience.
Instead, there is a shop that you can spend points earned by completing tasks and challenges on. Yet while the biggest prize is an infinite rocket launcher, which is a token of the series, there isn't much else.
No minigun, which could have easily been carried over with assets from the last game.
There's a handful of decent items, like early access to a lockpick and bolt cutters, that can help unlock some early firepower and ammo, for example.
But on the whole it just feels lacking, for want of a better word. Alright, the rocket launcher makes the speedruns easier, but it's not as fun as reenacting that scene from Predator with the minigun against waves of zombies.
Or maybe that just says something about me...
1. A Criminally Short Run Time
The biggest criticism, saved for last, is just how short the run time of the game is.
And I don't mean in the grand scheme of taking your time to explore, because you can faff about for ages. That's your choice.
But for those that are just concerned with getting the story done, an average of about four hours is shocking. Granted, the original was shorter than Resident Evil 2, with its single campaign against four separate ones, but not to this extreme.
A full price game with very little bonus content draws up comparisons to The Order 1886 in terms of length and replayability, something I never thought I'd say.
Yes, it's a more action focused game. One that unfortunately relies on chase sequences over puzzle solving to streamline the experience that it feels like such a rip-off.
Even more so when you consider the lack of endgame content, too. Sure, you can grind some records out, in a similar vein to Max Payne 3, but not everybody wants to do that.
Considering how much was cut from 2's remake, this feels insulting.