Silent Hill: Every Playable Character Ranked Worst To Best

Which Silent Hill characters emerge from the fog on top?!

By Michael John-Day /

When it comes to forming the Mount Rushmore of horror gaming, a tonne of notable names will likely be brought up. Franchise classics like Resident Evil and Castlevania will probably get a mention, but one universal name you will hear is Silent Hill.

Advertisement

The story of Silent Hill's development is an utterly inspiring one, as Konami established the group that would become Team Silent out of a set of employees who were deemed under-performers.

Together, they were requested to make a Resident Evil clone. However, without much supervision, or the company's support, they ended up with far more creative freedom than expected. Thanks to this, the wild, scary and overwhelming creative world of Silent Hill was born.

One of the most notable successes from the series were the protagonists. Each one faced off against some horrifying events, and brought something entirely new to the table. This list intends to sort them from the worst to the best by looking at their place in the franchise, personalities and general receptions.

It will only focus on the mainline playable protagonists. Therefore, phenomenal characters like Maria and Cybil will have to make do as honourable mentions here.

SPOILERS AHEAD!

7. Murphy Pendleton

Murphy Pendleton had the whole world against him, not only regarding his character but also the state of the game he was in.

Advertisement

Downpour was a thoroughly lacklustre title, with a shockingly short runtime, giving you almost no time to get invested in the game, let alone the protagonist.

There seemed to be deliberate efforts to keep Murphy's personality ambiguous, as his violent tendencies were designed to juxtapose his mild-mannered demeanour. But this failed because it made him a black hole of a character.

It was impossible to become invested in his journey because he simply gave you very little to invest in. His distinct search for vengeance lacked any nuance, as it made him seem less like a flawed character and more a violent villain in training.

Additionally, the use of a convict in Silent Hill made sense, as the series is supposed to reflect the traumatic/guilty pasts of the protagonists and delve into what brought them to the titular town. However, with Murphy, it was simply too on the nose. His dark past, aggression, and quest for vengeance lacked likeability, which was an essential part of getting you on the playable leads' side.

6. Travis Grady

When it comes to calling out which Silent Hill games are the worst, there is often a lot of debate between Origins and Downpour. While the quality of the games themselves is arguable, the edge for the better protagonist just about slides in favour of Travis.

Advertisement

Travis was a lonely truck driver with a dark past who managed to stumble upon Silent Hill from seemingly pure chance, with nothing specific calling him towards it. This acted as a really interesting idea about the town's pull towards those with traumatic backstories.

Travis's life before the events of the game are very interesting and give him a concise reason to be compelled to travel to Silent Hill, whilst also leaving his past open to interpretation. However, the origins aspect of the title meant the focus was on setting up Alessa and the original game, causing Travis to fall a little to the wayside.

His slightly unimportant status wasn't helped by the fact that he's not the most complicated character. While he has moments of heroism, he still felt rather bland.

5. Alex Shepherd

Alex gets a place above the others, not because of any distinct merits but simply from the fact that he does everything perfectly fine.

Advertisement

There's nothing too outstanding about his personality, presentation or attitude that gives him a memorable edge, yet there's also nothing about him that is particularly poorly handled. He's ultimately a relatively empty and hollow "broken" protagonist.

In typical Silent Hill fashion, Alex is a character with a tragic past who comes into the game searching for his family. His presentation as an ex-soldier is interesting, and the surprising twist associated with it does give him a compelling narrative. Sadly, his character doesn't reflect this nuanced story, as Shepherd mainly revolves around the typical "tough guy with a good heart" clichés that are often employed for leading roles.

The concept of his family's legacy being a big burden on him and the connection to his brother Joshua is solid, but nothing comes along to make him feel truly nuanced. His sinful past seems more connected elements that weren't entirely in his control, and it doesn't necessarily make him feel like a perfect candidate for Silent Hill.

While the final reveal is shocking, there's no tangible decision from him involved in it, as it's clearly presented as an accident.

4. Henry Townshend

Henry is a huge outlier in the Silent Hill series, not just because of the circumstances of his narrative but also due to his personality and presentation.

Advertisement

It's easy to see how his position on a list like this could fluctuate amongst different players, but there are some solid reasons why he deserves a slightly higher place.

Firstly, Townshend has the distinct luxury of being one of the only characters in the series who doesn't have an overtly tragic backstory driving him towards the town. Instead, he's an outsider who is drawn into the supernatural events thanks to his unfortunate living situation in the haunted apartment 302.

This does take away some of the cathartic justice that fills the lore of Silent Hill, but also gives him a unique place in the line-up as just a "regular Joe", which is not often explored in the series.

Additionally, his introverted personality and slightly darker tendencies - especially including that peeping hole in the wall - make him slightly unnerving despite his nice demeanour. He also comes across as likeable though, thanks to his altruism and poor luck in being involved with the titular locale.

He's not particularly exciting, but his place as a Silent Hill protagonist is unique.

3. Harry Mason

Although he is sat at the upper end of the list, it might be a little disappointing for some to see this iconic video game character at the number three spot, as he did a lot, not just for the franchise but also for gaming as a whole.

Advertisement

Harry was a great example of the levels of complexity and nuance you could cram into a playable protagonist, and for that, his legacy will last.

One of the most endearing things about him was his loyalty and devotion to his daughter, Cheryl. There's no question about his safety, as once she is lost in Silent Hill, he bravely ventures to find her. However, while finding his daughter is a big deal, the narrative doesn't feel all too personal. Everything happens to him, as opposed to manifesting his dark past, which brings him down a little.

Despite this, Harry deserves a tonne of praise for his iconic status with the franchise, as many players can easily remember him over more generic protagonists. He came along and made a significant impact, becoming a leading reason why the series was allowed to continue, and he did so by being a relatable/loveable father.

2. Heather Mason

Heather was a genuinely stunning protagonist, and she helped to ease a lot of people's anxieties with the direction of the third game.

Advertisement

While it's not considered fully up to par with its predecessors, Silent Hill 3 - and Heather, by extension - riskily decided to continue the original game's narrative whilst tying to involve the concepts brought up in the second. It wasn't perfect, but Heather helped combine the idea of a personal hell with Silent Hill's cult rather well.

There's a lot of merit to Heather outside of this as well, as she's thoroughly well written. Despite her age, the character is wise beyond her years and very quick-witted. This makes her incredibly believable as a survivor in this world, and her carefree attitude compliments this by making her quickly loveable.

One of the most important aspects of her character is age, as being a younger protagonist changes the stakes completely. When playing as her, you feel trapped by the pressure of youth, and this is reflected by the monsters who all resemble anxieties about puberty, self-consciousness and growing up.

This character was phenomenally relatable, as her care-free attitude and temperament made the player envision their self in her shoes.

1. James Sunderland

The first Silent Hill title became a classic and is still heralded as one of the greatest horror games ever made, but its sequel is considered by many to blow it out of the water.

Advertisement

One of the main attributes that inspire this preference is the complexity and brilliance of the leading man, James Sunderland.

Silent Hill 2 departed from the occult narrative of its original and opted instead to focus on a deep character study of grief, pain and trauma. It did so by taking James Sunderland and sending him to the town of Silent Hill after receiving a letter from his dead wife.

Everything within the game - including the monsters - acted as a manifestation of James' troubled past and the climax of his marriage. This made the game a profoundly personal experience, as the stakes all revolved around James fighting his inner demons.

All of this came together to make him an important and empathetic hero, as you essentially fought to save his sanity. The reveals of his various sins were sublime, and the balance between ambiguity and exposition was so strong that Sunderland felt like a stranger and a long-term friend in equal measure.

Advertisement