Watch Dogs: 10 Reasons The Haters Are Wrong

Do graphics mean everything for a game that offers so much more?

By Scott Tailford /

So did we all expect this level of hatred to be levied at Watch Dogs when it finally dropped? Of course we did. What else is the mass public going to do other than point fingers at a game that had the impossible feat of simultaneously convincing hundreds of early-adopters that their glorified Netflix-machines were worth more than that, as well as providing a completely new gameplay experience that would drop jaws and hold them there? The thing is though, outside of all the bandwagon-hopping hatred and vicious lambasting of the game as 'one of the most disappointing of all time' - or that it's a shamelessly cobbled-together attempt at cashing in on all of Ubisoft's older properties with a shiny coat of paint - it's nowhere near a categorically bad game. Instead, if you give it a chance and cast off the graphical-downgrade shackles, it's pretty damn spectacular - albeit in isolated chunks, with the baseline of the gameplay remaining a frantically fun romp through a next-gen city replete with a laundry-list of gadgets, cars and weapons. Far too many people are jumping all over the comparisons to GTA V, but you have to wonder exactly why that is, as outside of the two sharing the basic aspect of an open world, they have nothing else in common. And if we're going down the iteration route and bashing a lack of innovation as a lead-in to saying a game isn't worth playing, let's be completely clear about GTA V: It was a perfected version of the GTA III template, where the only new mission type were the heist missions - of which their were only six (with one being a simple vehicular smash n' grab) featuring hardly any of the customisation we'd been led to believe in the buildup save for a couple of differing paths when playing them out. GTA V is obviously a remarkable achievement through and through, but outside of comparing the scope of GTA's San Andreas and Watch Dogs' Chicago the latter has to be looked at what it achieves on its lonesome, to which you may be surprised if all you've been exposed to is the tornado of vitriol spewing from every orifice on the internet; is quite a lot.

10. Driving Is Just Like Sleeping Dogs

Remember GTA IV's driving, and how its incredibly floaty nature lead to your car chase spilling over into a group of pedestrians rather than you being able to grip the wheel and burn away through the apex of a corner? Well, United Front Games' Sleeping Dogs took full note of this and made their driving incredibly arcady, bolting your car to the road unless you were doggedly determined to go hurtling through a barricade at high speed. The result was an in-car physics system that most recently had been somewhat taken on by Franklin's special ability in GTA V i.e. being able to take corners at breakneck speed by bending the laws of the universe and then keeping on going at full tilt. Thus for better or worse, Watch Dogs takes this approach too, not worrying one iota about portraying realistically weighty car models or anything too close to a focus on driving outside of some fun side-missions - the cars exist to get you from one point to another as fast as possible, and with the emphasis on insta-hacking various obstacles for your opponents along with blaring through traffic at lightspeed, Ubisoft went with the idea that we didn't want another physics-based open-world driving sim; and it's all the better for it.

9. Gunplay Is Brilliant

Try and think of one game since the proliferation of Call of Duty that doesn't do its combat as 'Hold left trigger, shoot with right trigger', just try and think of one. What's that? Deadly Premonition?! Surely you cheated! Anyway, the point is that in today's gaming climate the very tactful feel of aiming your weapon and firing has become utterly homogenised across any title that would begin to be described with the word 'action', meaning that the hefty amount of missions that involve - or are reduced to - shooting your way through/out of somewhere, are handled perfectly. Since you can't take many hits without having your balaclava blown off, it's paramount to pick and choose headshots carefully, and thanks to a perk that levels up how fast you can switch between weapons, you'll be jumping across to some proximity-based explosives to rig a roadway, before equipping a grenade launcher to take on a group that's already arrived, only to switch back to an automatic weapon to finish off any stragglers. It's sublime, and although there is a good number of weapons available - from sniper rifles to pistols, shotguns and more - it would all fall apart if it weren't for a stellar cover system...

8. Combat Options Are Robust

Taking a chapter out of the latest couple of Splinter Cell games' books, Watch Dogs features the same 'look at something to make the icon appear, then go there' mechanic, which is absolutely perfect regardless of whether or not you're taking the guns blazing approach and wish to snake around the side of a group of aggressors, or sneak in undetected altogether. Yes you can go in firing off rounds into all and sundry as you deftly fling grenades into the background to prevent reinforcements arriving too soon, but if you switch gears completely Watch Dogs becomes a very competent stealth game, featuring not only the quintessential 'one-button-kill' animations necessary to procedurally dispatch a group of enemies, but also in opening up the toybox of gadgets for each encounter. Say you're approaching a scenario and you know one of the guys inside is the man you need to keep alive, it takes but one button-press to zip up into the surveillance system and use the string of cameras around an area to tag everyone within, allowing you to then decide how to proceed. From there you could elect to cause a short blackout for that entire city block, which depending on what time you're tackling the mission will result in panicked enemies lost in the dark that are much easier to pick off. And that's not to mention the various context-specific prompts you'll get if you spy a high-pressure pipe or explosive gas main, the likes of which you can easily detonate after luring a guard towards, thereby freaking out their cohorts as you remain in the shadows in a manner not dissimilar to the phenomenal Batman: Arkham series.

7. Melee Animations Are Fantastically Brutal

It seems to be a dividing factor among many third-person action game-lovers, that when it comes to dispatching your opponent up-close, many would prefer some sort of Sleeping Dogs/Dead to Rights/GTA-style melée system, rather than an instant-kill/takedown button. Whilst it's definitely a whole lot of fun braining dudes with your bare fists or an assortment of high-flying kicks in the aforementioned titles, there remains that feeling of being unprepared in many third-person shooters when the action turns to close-quarters. Watch Dogs' approach to combat can go from intense stealth-focussed scenarios, through to all guns blazing in a particular area and back to biding your time again all within a short period of time, and nothing cements that notion of a shadow-striking predator more than having a repertoire of baton-heavy thwacks to incapacitate your foes. It seems that across multiple versions of the game some of the sound effects for said animations aren't landing in time with the on-screen connection of bat-to-face, but it's nothing that can't be patched in, and even until then the vast majority of hands-on time and footage available shows Aiden dispatching entire rooms of goons in a blur of chokeholds and beat-downs.

6. Slow-Burn Narrative Totally Works

There was a time when we didn't care about action movies being over-the-top and throwing out occasionally dumb moments or lines of dialogue that (at the time) were actually regarded as something brilliant, as they gave us a reason to watch them over and over again. Now Watch Dogs isn't going to be winning any awards for scriptwriting any time soon, but it's also not any cause for concern either - it has a perfectly serviceable introductory few hours, before Aiden gets his hands on a much more Batman-esque base HQ, the firing up of which is a great moment in the game as you hack a set of bridges so that only you can enter and exit your island abode. Pearce's razor-throated delivery is a bit old hat after a couple of generations trying to do their best Solid Snake, but like with Deus Ex: Human Revolution there's only so many times you can roll your eyes at what the game isn't doing i.e. portraying relatable characters on a level more akin to Naughty Dog's The Last of Us, and instead just accept and enjoy what we do have - a great fun action-focussed title with some gruffly-delivered hard-man lines, all tied up in a neat revenge-arc narrative. It's something we've paid to see a million times on the silver screen, so why not here? Still, Aiden randomly going to choke Clara as the first thing he appears to do to a woman that opposes him was a bit weird wasn't it?

5. Hacking: What Were You Expecting?

Many have said that they thought the hacking was going to be more complicated based off the initial trailer that showed a circular inventory-wheel to which Aiden then selected to hack into a set of traffic lights or a train, but seriously would anything similar to that actually have worked in-game across the games campaign length? It's highly doubtful. It seems that after the initial reveal and subsequent promotional taglines consisting of paraphrases around the 'everything is connected' moniker, peoples' minds ran amok thinking every single aspect of the game-world would be hand-crafted and intricate to the point where something like hacking a set of traffic lights would have it's own on-screen circuitboard, or mini-game involving the navigation of Matrix-style lines of code - rather than the instant-mastery of your surroundings exhibited by Aiden's one-button-hacks-all phone.

4. Multiplayer Is High-Tech Dark Souls

In the modern age we'd all love it if servers actually ran as fast and reliably as the likes of Microsoft would love them to, but the simple fact is that at the minute it's very rare a game requiring an abundance of server-load power can get it at the right time. And therein is the current 'problem' with Watch Dogs' multiplayer, as during that initial reveal Ubisoft mentioned many potential caveats involving a 'constantly connected world' where we saw the camera zoom up away from Aiden only to settle on an unknown combatant - leading everyone to assume that somehow everyone's worlds were going to be linked and we'd all be perpetually raiding each other's voicemails from across the street. Of course this isn't what the final mode turned out to be - but why would it? Can you imagine how infuriating that would be? Instead what is on offer is a series of modes, one of which is a fantastic inclusion where after you accrue a certain level of notoriety in your own game, a cash bounty is assigned to you that can be claimed by another random opponent when they randomly land in your game, forcing you into a showdown. It all leads to some great one-on-ones comprised of citywide chases as you attempt to evade and take down your killer, both of you hacking everything in sight along the way. These more basic Dark Souls-style encounters are the most common at the moment as Ubi's servers struggle to load the matches with more competitors that see you all frantically blowing each other to smithereens in the name of holding onto a decryption program for a certain amount of time. However the fact remains that the toolset laid out before you is a fantastic one, and should you decide to opt-into these random invasions and online deathmatches, it offers a whole new level of enjoyment to the already worthwhile single-player missions.

3. Side-Missions Are Great Fun

Yes they can get too frequent in terms of how many times you'll get a prompt telling you a potential crime is about to unfold, but as your Minority-Report-style preventions are completely optional they're not something that gets in the way of the main story, instead serving to populate the world around you and get across that idea that you're just one man. One who - although he has access to an omnipotent God-phone - cannot be everywhere at once, and has his own problems to deal with. Unlocking towers is a great excuse to drive around and breathe in the world, and the many gang hideouts that can be tackled in a variety of ways only help to serve that idea the 'city's protector' vibe Ubisoft were striving for. Okay the likes of the mini-games are mostly distractions, but that's entirely the point - they add a sense of dynamism and role-playing to your time in the game world, punctuating the louder moments whereby you're detonating all manner of IEDs underneath criminals' behinds with a spot of chess or a game of poker in some random bloke's basement. Are you going to be spending hours playing these games? Most probably not (although many forums have mentioned getting lost in just sitting on the waterfront playing chess against a smattering of random opponents), but when the game encourages you to dabble in these side activities for the sake of advancing your character (increased chess proficiency gives you longer slow-motion gunplay), they're never forced on you in any way that actually takes you away from pursuing the core story if that's all you want to do.

2. Graphics Are Still Amazing

Sure they're not as shiny and 'wet-lycra-looking' as that initial reveal, but honestly does that matter when you grab a sports car and take a spin round one of the richer parts of the city? As you drop the camera and the depth of field expands to make all the skyscrapers tower above you, only for a 'Gang Hideout' prompt to pop up and take you up the side of one of them, there are hardly any issues with the graphics whatsoever. Plus, the elephant in the room for those electing to stick on the graphics debate is the screen-encompassing mussel flash that firecracker'd its way out of Aiden's gun throughout the initial demo, as although we might not like to admit it, the overbearing lens-flaring of everything in the next generation is getting completely overwhelmingly intrusive, and if that aspect of the combat had remained it would have been something people would no doubt be complaining about anyway. And that's not to mention the more recent scandal that came out about certain windows not reflecting that which is opposite them, but really if you're at a stage where a certain piece of fence not being reflected properly is stopping you from enjoying the game... well it speaks for itself doesn't it? Tiny glitches like these have been in games since time immemorial, and whilst that's not an admonition of that fault, it's just something to simply laugh along with and carry on - as last we checked Watch Dogs does not place any particular reliance on pressing yourself up against windows for the sake of its gameplay. From some sumptuously gorgeous bodies of water that you can carve through either on-boat or through swimming, to the nearest the final game does look to that initial reveal i.e. the nighttime scenes when everything is pouring down with rain, Watch Dogs is still a spectacular achievement.

1. Gameplay-Wise It's What Was Shown In 2012

If you want to buy a game for its graphics, go grab a copy of Infamous: Second Son, or Metal Gear Solid: Ground Zeroes. For the rest of us who remember when interlaced lines didn't matter - and a game could be tackled and completed for the sake of partaking in the medium itself - Watch Dogs is a bevy of great missions set within a fun city comprised of drastically different districts, and a set of powers that not only match up to the E3 2012 demo, but far exceed them. Some of you may already have seen the popular Videogamer.com comparison video where one staff member played through the retail build of Watch Dogs and attempts to replicate the actions therein, to hilariously bad effects. But it must be said the way the game is being played at puts this retail build at a huge disadvantage - the main reason being the newer version of the game is not in-mission, and the only way to get the likes of the traffic lights and bollards to work in the way the demo presented, is to time them perfectly with an on-screen indicator that appears when an enemy is near, and not a moment before or outside a mission. Even mentioned therein is the aspect of the game where you can elect to help citizens out of their cars, which many gamers have said they didn't see the prompt for, even though following an accident or a firefight such a thing will pop up on the map for you to interact with, along with a swathe of citizen-animations playing out as people rush to talk to those involved in the crash, or drivers argue with one another. Is the entire thing as polished as what we saw? In terms of graphics no of course it's not, but there's also no way that the full city was rendered back in 2012, meaning the section that was shown off could be rendered much higher instead. It goes without question that you shouldn't show off a game in an initial state if you cannot deliver on it (Sony learned that thanks to Killzone 2's initial CG-reveal), but when the only thing holding back your enjoyment of a title is "Well it's not as shiny as I thought it was going to be", surely you need to re-evaluate why you're playing the game in the first place. Sharpen those torches and pitchforks and head into the comments below, or perhaps put them down and enjoy an immensely fun open-world hacker's dream. Either way let us know what you think in the comments!