Why Apple Arcade Will Win The War Against Google Stadia

Google claims Stadia will change gamIng, but is Apple Arcade a better bet?

By Theo Tucker /

Apple/Google

Google announced its Stadia gaming platform earlier this year and initially, it looked very promising. However, it soon became apparent that, with the Founder’s Edition costing £119, costs would soon add up. There's an alternative though, and it'll cost a lot less. Because Apple Arcade is set to take the gaming experience to a new level on the devices you already own.

Advertisement

Arcade is easily the most promising of the two ‘revolutionary’ services. Both companies have marketed their new service as the future of gaming, but they both envision the future completely differently. And with some betting that Apple Arcade will be victorious in the battle of the next generation of gaming, there's a train of thinking for some that if Google Stadia is the future, that’s bad news for the gaming industry.

Luckily, there's a good change Arcade is going to win the tech war...

Advertisement

4. Google Stadia’s Mistake

Google

To be successful, Stadia had to demonstrate its ability to keep up with conventional gaming systems. Not only does it fail to compete in terms of graphics, but its Internet-based streaming premise also affects sound quality as well. It is difficult enough to play Xbox when it is being streamed to a Windows 10 PC on the same network, due to occasional lag. Imagine attempting to do a similar thing but on a much slower mobile network!

In addition, it will be very difficult for Xbox users to become used to the PS4-style controller. The idea of taking a system that allows offline gaming and making it exclusively online would appear to be a step backwards, as it limits where we can game.

Advertisement

So what can Apple bring to the table that's different?

3. How Apple Arcade Differs

Apple

Apple’s approach to Arcade is a substantially better one; they say use the device you already have to play the games, with offline play and family sharing.

Advertisement

As usual, Apple’s approach is a far more intelligent one. Unlike Stadia, no controller is required, but your existing Xbox One S or PlayStation DualShock 4 controller will be designed to work with them. With family sharing for up to six members, Apple again have made a more inclusive platform for multiple people sharing one subscription.

Apple Arcade, unlike Stadia, doesn’t aim on replacing consoles or gaming computers, but rather gives the community another style of gaming to play with. Also, Arcade follows a subscription style service, so you can play all the games available for a monthly fee, without having to buy a game to see if you like it or not.

Advertisement

2. Why Apple Arcade Is More Promising

Apple

It is obvious that Apple have spent more time designing out potential flaws that Google have not acknowledged. The service, much like every other Apple subscription, is expected to be £9.99 per month including the games, whereas Stadia requires you to purchase every game before you can play it.

Advertisement

The requirements for Google Stadia also portray Arcade as a clear favourite, with 720p gameplay requiring at least 10 Mbps. Furthermore, at release, Stadia will be able to stream to Chromecast enabled TVs, Pixel 3 and 3a and laptops, whereas Apple Arcade will support all devices that can run macOS Catalina, iOS 13, iPadOS 13 and tvOS 13, and substantially broader range of products.

Apple Arcade also doesn’t rely on a strong internet connection to work. Granted you need to download the games on all the devices you want to use them on, but that is nothing in comparison to the recommended 35Mbps internet speed required to fully take advantage of Stadia.

Advertisement

So why might Stadia struggle?

1. Why Stadia May Struggle

Google

To truly understand the potential realistic requirements of Stadia we need to look at another game streaming service. Nvidia’s GeForce Now software recommends at least 35Mbps internet, with real low low latency and a 5Ghz network. Stadia, by aiming to provide a similar service over mobile data, is setting itself up to fail.

Advertisement

In addition, it is worth noting that GeForce Now is a FREE service, so if you’re comparing Stadia to GeForce Now, you’re getting a very expensive controller! If you are planning to use Stadia on you’re mobile network, you’ll either need to be prepared to pay for a hefty bill or play in horrific resolution and have even worse frame-rate.

On a different note, Google haven’t got the best history when it comes to privacy and data control. You can be sure that every game you play, every message you send, and any search you make will be sold to third-party companies, a reason many stay away from Google products. Apple, however, have been keen to stress how they don’t collect any of your personal information because, you know, it’s personal. That is a big selling point for Apple, and an influential factor when it comes to choosing the best service to use.

Advertisement

---

Fundamentally, Apple Arcade is a better option when it comes to the new gaming experience. Stadia might seem tempting on the surface, but deep down it could take gaming back a step and all you’re paying for with Stadia instead of Arcade is a controller and permission for all your data to be sold.

Advertisement

It may still be too early to discard Stadia as a revolutionary gaming service, but the preliminary evaluation doesn’t look favourable. It may be the outrageous requirements, or the history of Google’s data abuse, but something raises a red flag with Stadia, for now at least.