WWE 2K Battlegrounds Review: 4 Ups & 4 Downs
A total stylistic shift from WWE 2K20, for better AND worse...
This year's WWE 2K game is a sharp left turn.
Even those whose exposure to 2K Battleground consists of a handful of screenshots or seconds of trailer footage should be able to see this is an entirely different beast from the mainline series, which is currently on ice after last year's launch. Calling 2K20's day one state a nightmare wouldn't be an exaggeration. Plagued by myriad bugs, glitches, and other snafus, the game was so poorly-received that its immediate sequel was panned in April 2020, followed closely by Battlegrounds' launch announcement.
In every sense, this new game is everything 2K20 was not. Released worldwide on 18 September, it eschews the realism and simulation-based gameplay typically associated with the WWE 2K series for straightforward, arcadey fun, drawing comparisons to WWE All Stars, Def Jam: Fight for NY, and other less-than-serious fighting games, wrapped up in a cartoonish aesthetic. It is both stronger and weaker for this approach.
Whatever the case, it's hard to fault 2K's change of direction after 2K20. They have laid solid foundations for would could become a more complete series should future incarnations materialise.
Thanks to 2K Sports for supply a copy of WWE 2K Battlegrounds for review.
Downs...
4. Limited Creation Options
2K Battlegrounds' more streamlined approach meant there were always going to be sacrifices in the customisation department but while the new creation suite's more straightforward approach fits the game as a whole, its limited options are unlikely to appease those looking to flex their artistic muscles.
Players are limited to just five custom character slots at the start of the game. More can be unlocked with progression, though the idea of building your own army of wrestlers loses its appeal the first time you run through the limited parts and customisation options. Again, more are unlocked as you play, but the range of options is limited.
Battleground creation is even more one-note, with users unable to craft much beyond basic wrestling arenas with different coloured ropes, barricades, aprons, etc. Don't enter this expecting to be able to make environments on par with the game's wilder locations.
3. Everyone Wrestles The Same Way
There are five different character classes in 2K Battlegrounds: powerhouse, brawler, technician, high-flyer, and all-rounder. These dictate the wrestlers' core movesets, with little variation in between.
Wrestlers in each category suffer from copy/paste movesets. They all fight the same with, with identical basic punches, kicks, suplexes, and other moves, and while signatures and finishers profit a semblance of variety, there's no individual flavour to differentiate these characters. Hitting the ring with them essentially feels like driving the same car with a slightly different paint job.
Again, this is a consequence of streamlining, and one wouldn't expect a full, authentic recreation of each wrestlers' individual style, though even wrestlers with distinct real-life styles don't stand out in this regard. For the most part, they all fight the same way - and win or lose the same way...
2. Extreme Repetition
2K Battlegrounds shoots for accessibility. It is supposed to be a simple, straightforward game that's easy to pick up and doesn't require hours of working towards mastery in a series of complex systems in order to achieve a level of competency. You should be able to fire it up and have a good handle on how it plays within a few matches.
It achieves this to a degree, though its combat is more repetitive than minimalist. Particularly during the campaign's early stages, players can literally win matches by doing nothing more than spamming the punch button, then pinning the opponent once their health bar has been worn down enough. There's no room for strategising here and while you can chain clunky striking combinations together and hit more spectacular springboard moves, there's little point when you can just button-bash your way to victory. Stipulations provide only a semblance of a difference.
Repetition is a problem elsewhere, too. Several modes revolve around competing in a match to receive some kind of unlockable rewarded, repeated ad nauseam. The campaign will have you fighting the same wrestlers over and over in order to make progress. The grind, unfortunately, is very real.
1. Slave To The Grind
WWE 2K Battlegrounds is riddled with microtransactions.
The game's natural progression is calibrated to be so slow it nudges you towards opening your wallet and shortcutting to the next unlockable, with in-game bucks relatively thin on the ground. This undermines the supposed fun factor of it all. Battlegrounds is marketed as a light, easygoing title, but there's nothing easy going about having to slog through four or five uber-repetitive button-bashing matches just so you can unlock one of Lince Dorado's three attires.
Battlegrounds is less Pay to Win and more Pay to do Absolutely Anything, as new characters, creation parts, slots, and attires are all hidden behind its virtual currency. Play for long enough and you will unlock them eventually, but the gameplay isn't rewarding enough to justify this as a defence.
In the end, Battlegrounds, unfortunately, goes down as another title that has sacrificed meaningful progression in the name of farming as much money from its player base as possible. It is a transparent and predatory approach that sadly isn't going anywhere soon, and the other option (burning hours in campaign mode) is too sluggish for the microtransactions to be handwaved as a concern.
Ups...
4. Unique Presentation
2K Battlegrounds' aesthetic grabbed gamers' attention from the first trailer and aside from a handful of dodgy character models, it looks great.
This is a bright, colourful, and vibrant cartoon world. Wrestlers look more like action figures than realistic human models, which is in line with the game's general approach. Their proportions are all over the place, and that's a good thing: everybody looks unique and distinct. Also, you can set your fists on fire with the flick of a button. That rules.
Battlegrounds' levels are just as bold. Even the basic Raw arena looks more interesting than what you'd usually expect from a WWE game, though the swamps, subway tunnels, and more are were Battlegrounds really shines.
Much thought has clearly gone into crafting this world, and while some of the characters need fine-tuning, how this game looks is one of its biggest selling points.
3. The Campaign Is Functional
Story mode begins with Paul Heyman pitching a new brand to Vince McMahon, saying he wants to gather newcomers from around the world and have them compete in their native environments. He appoints Steve Austin as a talent scout and recruiter and it's with 'Stone Cold' that your journey starts, as the game's first protagonist, Bolo Reynolds, literally bumps into the legend while cycling in New York City, leading to his recruitment.
Seconds later and young Bolo is fighting Baron Corbin in a subway tunnel. Later, Reynolds is replaced with all kinds of wacky characters, including a Floridian alligator wrestler.
Though it falls to repetition at times, the campaign works. Its story is beautifully presented through a series of comic book panels and while occasionally cheesy, it is mostly solid, serving as a functional bridge from point A to point B. Players go from match to match, unlocking new components along the way, and while it's not something that'll hook you for hours on end, it's fun enough to hook you for a while.
2. A Decent Variety Of Game Modes
Battlegrounds allows you to play in a number of ways, though basic exhibition options are relatively limited. An electrified steel cage match, Royal Rumble, and gauntlet matches, along with more standard match types, are the only special stipulations on offer, with no intergender bouts to compensate for the relatively limited pool of characters (77 at launch).
The other game modes are sound. Tournament is an online ladder system in which you play a series of matches against other humans, advancing to rewards at various tiers. Battleground Challenge is your primary source of upgrades for created wrestlers and plays out similar to the campaign, only without the story, with the progression slow.
King of the Battleground is the game's USP, though. This is 2K attempting to cash in on the popular battle royal format, framing it similarly to a Royal Rumble. Four wrestlers start in the ring with a pool of four more waiting to enter on the outside. Said pool is replenished endlessly, and players score increasingly lucrative awards depending on how many people they eliminate before they are thrown out themselves. It's a nice twist for a wrestler game, and perhaps the purest experience in 2K Battlegrounds.
1. Big Silly Fun
Pivoting away from wrestling simulations was a wise move on 2K's behalf, particularly after the 2K20 debacle. A 2K21 game would have almost been poisoned by association, regardless of its quality, and while 2K Battlegrounds is far from perfect, that the game revels in its silliness makes it a breath of fresh air when it all comes together.
You can literally feed your opponent to an alligator, okay. What more do you want?
2K Battlegrounds' lighter tone means it excels as a party game. It is straightforward enough for new players to pick-up within their first few matches, so it's great for social gatherings between friends who don't necessarily have the time to dedicate to mastering more complex systems. Similarly, it is likely to hold huge appeal for younger games as well.
Disengage your brain, cut loose, and you'll likely have fun with this game in bursts. It doesn't lend itself to extended sessions like the old 2K series, but it doesn't necessarily aim to either. This is as pure an arcade experience as you'll get from a modern wrestling game.