10 Artists Who HATE Their Own Albums
When artist becomes critic.
Putting an album together is no easy feat. From one track to another, you have to bring together a bunch of songs that stand on their own, while also working great within the context of a single listening experience. Oftentimes, artists have to put their heart and soul into what they do, but that doesn't always mean they will be satisfied in the end.
Across every single genre of music, there are albums that artists have looked at with disdain in retrospect. Whether it's because of the intense period in a band's development or just the raw feelings still present in the music, these songs can often be hard for some of their creators to look back on.
Other times it may just come down to the fact that the music is uninspired, but these artists haven't minced words about their personal hatred towards their work.
What makes these arguments even more insane is when you realize that some of these records are among the best work the artist has ever put out. Though these songs may have left an impression on legions of fans over the years, no song is safe from the harshest critic of them all: the person who wrote it.
10. Relationship of Command - At the Drive In
Anyone remotely interested in heavy music owes it to themselves to listen to Relationship of Command by At the Drive In. Blending all the abrasive soundscapes known to man, the riffs of Omar Rodriguez Lopez make for some of the most caustic sounds that post hardcore has ever seen. The whole record is a blast to listen to, but Lopez himself has not brought himself to listen to it in years.
Make no mistake, Lopez is still incredibly proud of the work he was able to accomplish on this record, but the main reason he hates it has more to do with the mix than the actual songs.
When speaking about the production of the record, Lopez has stated that the entire album was much more chaotic than it became, and instead blames engineer Andy Wallace for making the record more radio-friendly.
This is a bit of a strange complaint to have considering the album that we ended up getting was some of the most brilliant displays of anarchy in the entire rock world. While he doesn't outright call the mixing terrible by any means, Lopez has said that Wallace's mix of the record is much too glossy for its own good. There's a lot to love about Relationship of Command, but this might be the one record that Lopez loves to hate.
9. Pablo Honey - Radiohead
Radiohead have pretty much become staples of art rock at this point. While originally known as some of the biggest stars of alternative rock, the band's work in the '00s from Kid A to a Moon Shaped Pool in 2016 has made for some of the most interesting sonic detours any mainstream band has taken on. However, many forget that this band was dangerously close to being labeled a one-album wonder.
Though the band had an outright classic with their third record OK Computer, the band's first step up to the plate with Pablo Honey is still something that the band doesn't really enjoy revisiting. While most of the album is pretty much the standard angsty alternative rock of the day, much of the band's frustrations comes down to the one lead single from the album, "Creep."
Even in the studio the band hated this song, with guitarist Jonny Greenwood intentionally trying to screw up the song in between takes. As Radiohead has gone on, "Creep" still remains a classic of the '90s, but the band have almost kept it completely out of their touring setlists for years now. It's one thing to just dislike an album, but Pablo Honey (and "Creep" specifically) is the one thing that Radiohead pretends doesn't exist.
8. Be Here Now - Oasis
The Gallagher Brothers were never ones to mince words about how they felt about music. Whether it was other bands or their own work, the founders behind Oasis have had more than their fair share to say about how one band is garbage and how they are part of the greatest band in the world. As time goes on though, Noel Gallagher has accepted the utter crap put forth on Be Here Now.
Out of all the band's classic material, Be Here Now is the most misguided effort in their catalog, with very questionable song lengths and turning songs into grand epics that go absolutely nowhere. After the band regrouped in the early '00s, Gallagher has owned up to the fact that the album is the sonic encapsulation of rock stars drunk on their own egos.
Rather than coming from an honest place, Gallagher has stated that most of the songs are just the product of him being high on cocaine in the studio and getting completely burned out. Even when talking about the band's more celebrated efforts like Definitely Maybe and Morning Glory, Noel has said how he had an inspired period of writing songs, with the Be Here Now tracks being just leftovers from that period. Be Here Now isn't going to make anyone's favorite albums list necessarily, but it's no secret that the harshest words have come from the one man present in the studio.
7. Dirty Work - All Time Low
For a mid-period pop punk act, All Time Low were miles better than they had any right to be. As opposed to the more insipid rockers like Simple Plan or Good Charlotte, the songs these guys had going for them packed a lot more punch and were far more lyrically diverse than the typical angsty sounds of their counterparts. However, things ended up going to hell on Dirty Work.
Being their first big showcase for a major label, this seemed like the band's chance at reaching for legendary status, only to see them playing to the absolute bottom of the barrel. Whenever this album is brought up in conversation with the band, they have minced no words about the more commercial sound they were chasing, down to the co-writers littered throughout most of the song credits.
Even the fanbase has lined up to bash this thing alongside the band, which came out in full force once they hosted the Alternative Press Awards, where the band's teleprompter left nothing to the imagination when talking about the bland reception of the record.
The band has since moved back to their old label, and while everything might not be firing on all cylinders, the pop punk act we know and love is still all accounted for.
6. All Hope is Gone - Slipknot
Given all of their antics, it's a miracle that Slipknot ever found themselves on the charts to begin with. When these masked freaks started out back in 1999, their sound was far more abrasive than the Linkin Parks of the day, yet still dominated the rock landscape. While the band's heaviest offering on Iowa reached #3 on the Billboard Charts, their first #1 ended up being the most lackluster experience for the band.
Taken on its own, All Hope is Gone is still intense as hell, with songs like "Psychosocial" and "Sulfur" earning a permanent spot in the band's setlist, but what you're actually hearing is the sound of a band fractured.
This may have been the first album done in their home state of Iowa, but the actual recording process was much more slipshot, with drummer Joey Jordison playing every single song by himself. Even Jim Root expressed concerns about the record, saying that the band never properly jammed before going into cut the songs.
Out of all the band members, Clown has been the most venomous towards the record, saying that it seemed like a joke that it got so popular, considering he couldn't give anything of himself to the project. Though this record ended up becoming the last album to feature Paul Gray on bass, it's still got a lot of great moments that any Slipknot fan would be proud to headbang to.
5. Trilogy - Green Day
After the turn of the century, Green Day started to get much more grandiose than people expected. While the rootsy sounds of Warning was definitely a departure, American Idiot and 21st Century Breakdown felt like historical events in the rock canon, with both becoming some of the most celebrated albums of the band's career. It looked like they could keep going up from here, but there is such a thing as too much too soon.
When coming together for their next project, the band really over-extended themselves on Uno Dos and Tre, each of which presented some of the blandest Green Day cuts they have ever made. Each record may have had its own agenda, but aside from a few songs, none of them stood out as anything too spectacular. It could have just been a fluke, but when the documentary of the album shows fans who are annoyed that the band is playing new material, that's a really bad omen.
After the disastrous tour and Billie Joe Armstrong's trip to rehab, it seemed that the lead singer had come to terms with the trilogy, saying that it was overblown just for the sake of being grandiose. There are a few shining moments across these records, but they become a little harder to justify when the man himself has washed his hands of it.
4. David Bowie - David Bowie
Not everyone knocks it out of the park with their first album. Oftentimes, even some of the best artists have to find their signature sound a few albums into their career. It's one thing to look back and cringe at your early work, but no one hates their first steps as much as David Bowie did.
Released on the same day as Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, David Bowie's self-titled first album is a real sore thumb in the catalog of a man destined to be one of rock's great eccentrics. Instead of the more experimental material Bowie would pioneer in later years, much of this album caters more towards lush arrangements and a taste for the baroque side of pop.
While the rest of the man's catalog flirts with the very idea of what rock could be, this is probably one of the only Bowie releases which could be accurately described as "safe."
And to say Bowie hated this is almost an understatement. Just a few years later, Bowie ended up releasing his second album self-titled, as if to reintroduce himself to the world. Even when combing through Bowie's discography, the man himself never really considered this album an integral part of his proper body of work.
More than just hatred, this first outing from Bowie feels like watching one man's quest to nullify his own album from existence.
3. Pinkerton - Weezer
Pinkerton by Weezer has got to be one of the most emotionally potent albums of the '90s. While that decade wasn't short on more poignant musical affairs, each of these songs feel like the sound of Rivers Cuomo finally achieving rock star status and not enjoying it once he earned his dreams. It may have felt honest back then, but the initial backlash from this record has made Cuomo rethink his entire approach to the music he plays.
Upon first release, this album was heralded as one the biggest fumbles in rock history, but as time went on, it has become one of the defining staples of the genre. However, that first taste of hatred led Cuomo to quickly backtrack on his initial feelings, going so far as to call the record outright hideous.
Though Cuomo's mood has softened in recent years, he still likens Pinkerton to one of the most embarrassing things he has ever released, as if it was responsible for the death of the alt rock movement.
Ever since then, Weezer has remained consistent, but nothing has ever been able to equal the genius of Pinkerton due to Cuomo's hesitation. There's a lot to admire about Weezer's early work, even if Cuomo has made it a point to run away from that sound as quickly as possible.
2. Nevermind - Nirvana
There's most likely an entire legion of rock fans who can tell you where they were when they first heard Nevermind. Not only did this record launch Nirvana's career, but also signalled an entire rock movement that culminated in the colossal sound of grunge.
The album may be a classic, but it was always a sore subject in Kurt Cobain's mind.
Granted, Cobain always had a bit of a complicated relationship with his own art. For as much as he loved more pop-friendly acts like Cheap Trick and the Beatles, he always envisioned Nirvana as having a punk rock attitude, with little regard for mainstream success. Once the band were launched into the stratosphere though, Cobain pretty much started his own hate train by throwing insults towards the production of Nevermind.
No matter what circumstance you found him in, Cobain found himself incredibly critical about the mixes of the record, which he thought felt more in line what a Motley Crue record than a punk rock album. Cobain may have felt a bit jaded regarding the mix, but this album's sound feels a lot more down to earth than anything Vince Neil and co. would ever hope to make.
Even if Cobain didn't really see the appeal of his own work, Nevermind is still able to inspire any teenager who has ever smelt teen spirit.
1. Sgt. Peppers - The Beatles
You pretty much can't go wrong across any album in the Beatles' catalog. From the fun-filled ride of A Hard Day's Night to the masterstroke of Abbey Road, every single one of the band's releases set the foundation as to how a rock band's career should go. However, if there's one record that really shows each member at the height of their powers, it has to be Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.
More than just an album, this entire record was a gamechanger in the world of pop music, with some of the most wild sounds coming from the perspective of this imaginary band on the cover.
While this idea is still seen as brilliant today, the harshest critic of this was John Lennon, who expressed to never liking the actual concept of the record. Hell, even in interviews, Lennon went so far as to say he wrote the song "Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds" just so he could be represented on the album, which he felt was dominated by Paul McCartney.
While the band might not have seen eye to eye on the conceptual work, the songs at hand are still a great time capsule of the '60s and a distinct movement towards newer sonic ides in the world of rock. Lennon may have been a bit cynical about his work, but this album will continue to be lauded as a masterpiece so long as we still have our ears open.