10 Bands That Ditched What Made Them Famous

That was then, this is now.

By Tim Coffman /

As a musician, one of your biggest aspirations is to find your own artistic identity. Many bands can spend their entire career trying to create their own unique sound or gimmick that will etch themselves in the minds of fans for years to come. On the other hand, gimmicks can run out pretty quickly.

Advertisement

Instead of just riding the wave of their initial star power, many bands have a tendency to drop what made them such a draw in the first place. This could take the form of a new look, new sound, or just a new mindset to creating music. Whether it's for a one-off musical experiment or a fully-fledged course correction, these artists were not afraid to leave their old selves behind for something much more interesting. While it's definitely debatable as to whether these shifts were in the "correct" direction, you certainly have to admire these artists' bravery in dissecting themselves and forging ahead down a much different path.

Even though it may be fun to do the same thing over and over again, it's even more of an artistic challenge to add other elements into the mix to see how they pan out. Here are the bands that refused to rest on their laurels and pulled their ideas out of left field.

10. Genesis

If you were into any stripe of prog music in the 70's, Genesis sealed the deal with their extravagant soundscapes and manic musical movements. Under the watchful eye of Peter Gabriel, the band pushed the boundaries of typical rock music and turned the standard 3 minute rock song into great musical passages with complex chord changes and complicated time signature changes.

Advertisement

Once Gabriel left the band though, things began to turn in a different direction. After finding the perfect replacement in drummer Phil Collins, the band began making music that strayed away from their complicated songcrafting. By the time the band had reached the 80's, they were making full-blown pop rock with songs like "That's All" and "Invisible Touch."

Up until then, the band had a very niche audience with their zany prog stylings as their calling card. This led to an overwhelming backlash from the fans who preferred the more classic prog sound of the band. While many cried "SELLOUT" at this point in the band's career, the members never seemed to express cynicism towards their more commercial sound. Instead of using their later period to absent-mindedly cash checks, the pop crossover of Genesis seemed like the natural progression after years of sonic experimentation.

9. Fleetwood Mac

When the blues boom erupted in Britain in the late 60's, there was always a certain amount of respect paid to Fleetwood Mac. With rock luminaries like Peter Green and Bob Welch providing guitar work for the band, the group were one of the most interesting acts of the blues-rock genre, with admirers from The Beatles to impressionable players like a young Kirk Hammett.

Advertisement

As the band were working their way through the 70's, the blues was brought to a halt when they found themselves without Peter Green. Desperate for a new guitarist, the band enlisted Lindsey Buckingham, who brought along his girlfriend Stevie Nicks to provide vocals. Once the five-member outfit was secure, the band's sound shifted drastically.

Rather than having the bluesy blasts of energy from the old days, the band's new material seemed to be more in line with folk rock and even pop music. While members like John McVie had a few reservations about the new sound, the band went on to great success with albums like their eponymous record and Rumours. The music may be a far cry from the blues, but there's certainly no complaining to be had with songs that are this infectious.

8. Panic At The Disco

The 2000's were ripe with pop-punk bands, each turning their own form of melodrama into furious power chord thunder. Of all the bands on the more emo side of the spectrum, Panic! at the Disco were always the most theatrical, as they made more extravagant compositions all while clad in elaborate costumes that seemed to hearken back to the 20's.

Advertisement

With the band having established their footing, guitarist and songwriter Ryan Ross used the next album cycle as an opportunity to flex his songwriting muscles. What manifested was Pretty. Odd., whose folksy sound and classic rock pastiches made the album title certainly apt. While everyone was still banging their head to "I Write Sins Not Tragedies," the band was pumping out sugary ballads like "Northern Downpour."

Though most fans ate up this new style, others were very stand-offish, with many people calling the band a victim of the sophomore slump. In a desperate form of course correction, the band then fractured, leaving Brendon Urie to lead the band into their next era as they returned to a more pop-centric sound. Pretty. Odd. may have been a contentious record at its outset, but it remains an interesting snapshot of one of the greatest pop acts of the modern era.

7. Metallica

There is probably no singular act that is as beloved and reviled in metal circles as Metallica. When the band broke out of the San Francisco metal scene in the early 80's, their sound would become the blueprint for all thrash metal going forward.

Advertisement

Though most fans would tell you any of the band's 80's output is mandatory listening for metalheads, the next few decades saw the band toying with their usual style. While the band reached for the gold with their self-titled album in 1991, the hardcore metalheads felt somewhat betrayed by the shift in sound. That betrayal seemed to be kicked into overdrive once the band unleashed Load and Reload, with songs that had more to do with blues rock and alternative music than metal. All this experimentation eventually reached a boiling point with St. Anger, with the band trying to become heavier and falling flat on their faces.

In recent years, the band seemed to be back in full force, with albums that never fail to bring back memories of the group's metallic glory days. Even if the band sounded less like themselves in the 90's, the music they created still holds up as some of the greatest hard rock of all time.

6. Blink-182

Blink-182 were some of the most lovable brats to come out of the pop-punk scene at the turn of the century. With albums like Enema of the State and Take Off Your Pants and Jacket, the band perfectly toed the line between adolescent songwriting about diarrhea and poignant compositions that spoke to the young teen demographic.

Advertisement

By 2002, the band were heading into the studio for their latest record, with fans prepared for some more adrenaline-fueled pop punk bliss. Instead of getting reruns of songs like "All the Small Things," fans were treated to a more alt-rock approach as the band focused on blistering guitars and more mature subject matters like divorce and the loss of human connection. The record was massive, but the dynamics within the group caused the band to break up shortly afterward.

When they got back together in the 2010's, their next release Neighborhoods doubled down on the experimentation, with vocalist Tom Delonge ripping a few pages out of his space rock outfit Angels and Airwaves. With Delonge now out of the band and Matt Skiba taking over for him, the band have returned to the fun-loving punk rock sound that made them famous. On the other hand, these records are a great "what if?" story of where the band could be today with Delonge still at the helm.

5. Linkin Park

Nu metal had always been known to be a particularly angry genre. Each band always played loud and had an insistent sonic attack as they spewed their venom across a record. Linkin Park was no exception to this rule, with their debut Hybrid Theory and followup Meteora becoming essential listening for any angsty 2000's kid.

Advertisement

About halfway through the decade, the band had become restless in their traditional sound, which led to them switching up their styles completely. While the band started to focus on more electronic material on their release Minutes to Midnight, it wasn't until A Thousand Suns dropped that fans were greeted with what seemed like a complete artistic 180.

Even though Linkin Park had always had a present ambience to their sound courtesy of DJ Joe Hahn, the lack of guitar crunch in the band's songs led many fans to jump ship. Unfettered by any backlash, the band's releases rode the wave between heaviness and electronic until the untimely death of Chester Bennington in 2017. Though the band's evolution was far removed from their more angsty beginnings, much of the band's later output is still well worth sifting through if you don't mind a little synth mixed in with stomping riffs.

4. Rush

If you ever saw yourself as a prog enthusiast, Rush was the answer to your prayers. Across the band's impeccable run in the 70's, the band took the complexity of a band like Yes and incorporated the blunt power of Black Sabbath to create a relentless sonic assault. Though their audience had gotten used to their mind-blowing riff crafting, the band never intended to stay in that lane for too long.

Advertisement

From the band's beginnings, they always had a mantra that no genre didn't fit within the Rush aesthetic. As the band finished writing their masterpiece Moving Pictures, the band's focus shifted from unstoppable riffs to a sound dominated by keyboards. Suddenly, guitarist Alex Lifeson found himself in competition with Geddy Lee's synthesizers.

While the band were having some disagreements, what is commonly known as the band's "synth" period still has some stellar material, from the heartbreaking survival story of "Red Sector A" to the borderline pop rock of "Time Stand Still." The synths eventually dissipated with the band continuing to tinker with their sound until their eventual end in 2015. In bucking the trends of other similar bands, Rush proved to be the most progressive of the prog rock bands by reaching for any influence at their disposal.

3. Radiohead

Radiohead had the world at their feet once they reached the end of the 90's. Whereas many bands were getting bogged down in warbly post-grunge and edgy nu metal, Radiohead's unique brand of sonic bliss seemed to point the way forward for rock music in the new millennium. However, Thom Yorke was thinking of something miles away from their trademark sound.

Advertisement

Once the band finished the tour for their critically acclaimed album Ok Computer, Yorke packed up his guitar and brought out the synthesizers. Upon first listen, fans were just delirious as to what they were hearing on the band's next record Kid A. Here were songs that didn't have the trademark guitar sound of Jonny Greenwood and in its place were ominous piano songs and chilling ambient noise.

This type of pivot from a band could have been career suicide for any other band, but Radiohead turned this new direction into their next artistic masterpiece. Slowly sidestepping any kind of backlash, the public were left amazed by the band's unique soundscapes and the yearning melancholy of Yorke's voice. Instead of meandering in different styles and falling flat, Radiohead showed the rest of the music world that they only just begun to amaze us.

2. U2

As the 80's were winding down, U2 had settled into their place as one of the kings of rock music. Not only had they made strides for social change at Live Aid, but they also released what many consider to be the best album of the 80's with The Joshua Tree.

Advertisement

With fans itching for more of the band's ethereal sound and bombastic performances, the lads from Dublin had other plans for their musical direction. Instead of reaching for the mantle of kings of rock, the band circumvented their usual image by immersing themselves in post modern irony. Suddenly, Bono went from being the most captivating frontman in the world to a more cynical caricature of what a pompous rock star looked like. While it still made for great entertainment on the live stage, the ethos had turned a corner.

Fans were even more shocked when the band put out Achtung Baby, with songs that incorporated more electronic sounds along with a subdued writing style. Though fans may have been scratching their heads, this change of pace was exactly what the band needed, as it made them fit right in amid the new alternative rock scene coming to fruition. The time for rock was over. The era of The Fly was born.

1. KISS

Whether or not you cared for their music, there's no denying that KISS made an impression when they broke onto the scene in the 70's. With each member dressed to 9's in heels and clad in horrifying black and white makeup, the band presented a stage show that brought the typical rock performance to circus-like proportions.

Advertisement

However, as the band transitioned to the 80's, they found it harder to find a footing amidst the shifting rock landscape. In an effort to shock their audience, the band decided to do the unthinkable and shed their trademark makeup. To say this was a big deal for fans was an understatement. From the time the band hit it big, the biggest draw of KISS was not knowing what these four badasses actually looked like underneath the makeup.

After completely exposing their mugs live on MTV, the band persevered through the 80's, adopting the glam metal look that they helped pioneer in their 70's glory days. Though the band has put the makeup back on since their 80's period, the initial decision to shed their iconic stage skin stands as one of the most gutsy moves a shock rock band of their caliber could have done.

Advertisement