10 Biggest Feuds In Rock Music History

What happens when the music stops.

By Joshua Cooley /

Feuds between musicians are as much apart of rock music as guitars and cocaine.

Advertisement

With all the fragile egos swirling around in a haze of booze, adultery and media tabloids, it is inevitable that the big names in music are going to end up rubbing against each other in a less than cordial manor.

Sometimes these feuds are merely the result of a rabble-rousing journalist taking something out of context, printing it and letting the chaos unfold. Other times, rock musicians find themselves fighting over rights to music and fending off accusations of plagiarism, but more often than not, musical spats occur due to the easily offended egos that so many rock stars attempt to conceal behind a pair of dark tinted sunglasses.

For the most part we wouldn't have it any other way, there's something tantalising about the biggest and best names in rock exchanging verbal fisticuffs, in a way reminiscent of a couple of toddlers arguing over who stole the others toy.

However, sometimes these arguments lead to the dissolution of the biggest acts of the genre, leaving fans despairing at the sheer level of immaturity that these apparent adults possess.

10. James Hetfield Vs Lars Ulrich

Metallica have never been strangers to inner band strife. Back in 1983, they famously fired Dave Mustaine for his hectic and rowdy antics that made him difficult to make music with.

Advertisement

The 2004 documentary Metallica: Some Kind of Monster, gave fans the opportunity to see Mustaine and Urlich try to resolve their issues, but it also shone a light on the ongoing struggle for control between James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich.

The band had recently lost their long time bass player Jason Newsted, but not ready to trade in their devil horns, the remaining members attempted to dive back into the studio to record their eighth studio album. But, the combination of conflicting work schedules, James Hetfield's admission into rehab and Lars Ulrich's over righteous ego, left the band on the edge of breaking up.

The documentary gave an insight into how the dynamic of the band played out at the time. Hetfield and Ulrich bickered and moaned like two bitter parents who have long since stopped loving one another, leaving the childlike Kirk Hammett stuck in the middle, unsure of what was going on.

Despite the bands struggles, they managed to put aside their differences with the help of a band therapist. With many of these interactions included in the documentary, the film ended up feeling more like a Spinal Tap reboot rather than a tale about one of the biggest bands in metal.

9. Anthony Keidis Vs Mike Patton

The 1980s and '90s were full of acts blending different genres into new and intriguing sounds. With Beastie Boys, Rage Against the Machine, Faith No More and The Red Hot Chili Peppers, all fusing rap and hard rock into an exciting sub-genre.

Advertisement

But the similarities between the early Chili Peppers sound and Faith No More's, far from being unifying, caused a rift between the two lead singers.

After the release of Faith No More's music video for Epic, Anthony Kiedis accused Mike Patton of ripping off his dance moves, which to be fair to Patton seems like a bit of a spurious claim, how else is someone supposed to bust a move to rap rock, other than over exaggerated arm and head movements?

The animosity was further exacerbated in 1999, when Patton's new band Mr. Bungle had their album release date pushed back due to concerns the title California would be confused with the Chili's album Californication.

Mr. Bungle reacted by mocking the Chili Peppers, performing a number of their classic hits, while dressed as the band and referencing the death of the Chili's previous guitarist Hillel Slovak.

That only caused Keidis to flex his influential muscles, however, by getting Mr. Bungle removed from a number of upcoming festivals.

8. Pete Doherty Vs Carl Barât

The love hate relationship between Pete Doherty and Carl Barât generated some of the most era-defining music of the 2000s, but ultimately led to the dissolution of a band everyone thought was going to save British rock music...

Advertisement

Like two star-crossed lovers, the affection the two indie rockers had, and still have for one another, undoubtably runs deep. Even with their more recent live shows, the displays of love are evident with sweaty embraces and tender pecks on the cheek.

But, during the bands hay day, Doherty's penchant for heroin, drove a crack-rock shaped wedge between the two, causing unbridled animosity. Much of the tension played out in the public eye, with both members frequently posting their raw and untempered feelings towards one another on various band forums.

The nuances of their strained relationship were immortalised forever, with their single, the aptly named Cant Stand Me Now. Despite the band's quick rise to national recognition they disbanded in 2004, citing unresolvable creative and personal differences.

When the two finally reconciled, The Libertines reformed in 2014 and although they never recaptured the glory of their former days, the two enigmatic frontman seem to have put their issues aside

7. Axel Rose Vs Vince Neil

The feud between Axl Rose and Vince Neil was a media godsend, featuring heavily in the press during the late '80s and early '90s.

Advertisement

It all started when Guns N' Roses guitarist Izzy Stradlin supposably assaulted Vince Neil's wife during a night of rock star excess.

Unsurprisingly, when Neil got wind of the incident he wanted revenge. Waiting backstage at the 1989 MTV Music Awards, Neil clocked Stradlin in the face after he came off stage, resulting in the temperamental Axl to do what Axl does best and become embroiled in the feud.

Axl has never been one to let a slight to his honour go unchecked, and over the next few years the singers would exchange insults, in no small part encouraged by the media who seemed to bring the feud up during every interview... damned pot-stirring journalists...

Despite all the talk, the two never actually came to blows. At one point Neil challenged Axl to some kind of televised, rock star wrestling match, but alas, the world was never to know the answer to that burning question, who would win in a fight, Axl Rose or Vince Neil?

6. Jack White Vs The Black Keys

Despite Jack White's status as one of the more celebrated and unique blues-rock musicians, it would seem he's fairly insecure when it comes to other people playing music vaguely in the same realm.

Advertisement

If anything, The Black Keys and The White Stripes would make have made for one hell of a line up. Both performed a version of the blues, pumped full hard rock energy, both bands consisted of two members, and hell, they even came up at a similar time, fighting the good fight, when many rock musicians were succumbing to the commercialised trappings of pop-punk. But here in lay the problem.

It all started when a private email of Jack White's was leaked, containing a series of exchanges with his former wife Karen Elson, in which he made mention of his resentment towards Dan Auerbach, for (according to White) ripping off Jack White's whole shtick.

The Black Keys Drummer, Patrick Carney initially took the moral high road, telling Rolling Stone "We’ve all said fucked-up s**t in private, and divorce is hard.” going on to denounce TMZ for leaking the private emails.

But, White continued to reference the Black Keys in interviews, before apparently squaring up to Patrick Carney one night at a bar. The confrontation was shared on Twitter by Carney, but after a few online exchanges the feud seemed to resolve itself when Carney revealed that he had spoken to White directly and cleared the air.

5. Trent Reznor Vs Marilyn Manson

Marilyn Manson is one of he more controversial figures in rock music. During the '90s and early 2000s he was the scapegoat for all things wrong with America. Particularly, after the tragic events of the 1999 Columbine Massacre when it was falsely reported the two killers wore Marilyn Manson t-shirts.

Advertisement

But, despite the perhaps unfair negative attention Manson received back in the early days of his career, recent accusation of abuse by a number of women have cast his character into question.

Trent Reznor might have been the perfect man to produce the twisted gothic sound of Marilyn Manson, but he began to distance himself from Manson after a difficult working relationship in the late '90s. Stating to MOJO magazine “He is a malicious guy and will step on anybody’s face to succeed and cross any line of decency,”

Much of this animosity resulted from Manson's 1998 biography, which contained a story of how he and Reznor had assaulted a women, which Reznor vehemently rejected at the time.

After the recent allegation against The Beautiful People singer, Reznor issued another statement saying "I have been vocal over the years about my dislike of Manson - As I said at the time, the passage from Manson’s memoir is a complete fabrication. I was infuriated and offended back when it came out and remain so today."

4. Blur Vs Oasis

Was there ever a more entertaining rivalry between two bands, than that of Blur and Oasis battling it out for chart supremacy during the mid 1990s?

Advertisement

The Britpop era was defined by floppy hair cuts, catchy guitar jingles, cheeky British swagger and of course "The Battle for Britpop".

The feud between the two bands was in no small part fuelled by the British media's insistence on bringing it up during every interview, knowing fine well that Liam Gallagher would say something inflammatory.

But before it all began, Blur were actually supporters of Oasis, mentioning them during their 1995 acceptance speech at the Brit Awards. That all changed when the swaggering Liam supposably got in Albarn's face to gloat when Oasis reached number one - in what we can only imagine was a fine display of Gallagher modesty.

And so the battle began. The rivalry became symbolic of the British class divide, with the northern Oasis lads representing the working classes, and the southern boys from Blur representing the privileged middle class. The culmination came when the bands released their singles Country House and Roll With It on the same day. Blur ultimately won the battle in terms of chart sales, with one final dig coming in the form of Blur bass player Alex James sporting an Oasis t-shirt on Top of the Pops.

Noel Gallagher would later remark he and Damon Albarn met in a pub to fondly reminisce over their heated feud...

3. David Gilmour Vs Roger Waters

The long enduring grudge held by Roger Waters and David Gilmour is rooted back in 1985.

Advertisement

After the firing of original Pink Floyd frontman Syd Barrett in 1968 - due to his erratic behaviour brought on by his excessive consumption psychedelics - the band brought in Gilmour to bless the world with his heartfelt guitar solos.

Although this period of Floyd manifested some of the bands most critically acclaimed work, the battle for creative control ultimately resulted in Roger Waters no longer wishing to share the stage with Gilmour.

A bitter lawsuit ensued, with both parties fighting for the rights to the name Pink Floyd, leaving the two former band mates consistently bad mouthing one another in the press.

Despite the bad blood between Gilmour and Waters, they put aside their difference during a 2011 performance of Water's rock opera The Wall Live, when Gilmour joined his former band mate to play some of his signature guitar riffs.

In 2020 Waters shared a post on Twitter, again bringing up the bad blood and lambasting David Gilmour for not allowing him to share his recent music projects on the official Floyd website, stacking yet another brick in the wall of resentment between the two former band mates.

2. Axl Rose Vs Kurt Cobain

Surprisingly, it was Kurt Cobain who started the back and forth between these two rock icons.

Advertisement

Axl and Guns N' Roses might have been the kings of heavy guitar led rock, but when Nirvana came along they shattered peoples perceptions of what rock music should represent.

In many ways, Nirvana and Guns N' Roses were the polar opposites, Guns embodied rock star idolism, clad all in leather, totting big hair and existing in a realm of excess, strippers and top hats. Nirvana on the other hand, were all about nonconformity, acceptance of the loner mentality and the rejection of trying to present a "cool" image to the public.

So when Axl requested Nirvana join Guns on tour, Kurt Cobain was less than enthusiastic, referencing his distaste of Guns in several interviews. Eventually the slights became too much for Axl, who embarked on one of his famous rants during a concert in 1992, calling Cobain "a f*cking junkie".

The most famous altercation occurred at the 1992 MTV Music Awards, when Courtney Love made a passing comment to Axl, prompting him to yell at Cobain to silence his partner. To which Cobain sarcastically turned to Love and said "Shut up B*tch". After Nirvana's performance that night, Dave Grohl would taunt Axl from the stage.

After Cobain's death the bands had something of a reconciliation, with Dave Grohl - in a gesture befitting his reputation as the nicest man in rock - lent Axl his famous throne after Axl injured his leg in 2016.

1. Noel Gallagher Vs Liam Gallagher

Why couldn't these two just pull it together and keep fans happy?

Advertisement

The 2016 documentary Supersonic examined the strained dynamic of the two brothers relationship, highlighting among other things, the resentment Liam felt when Noel began singing more of their tracks live.

The rivalry between the two brothers presented itself in a plethora of ways. Liam wished he possessed Noel's ability to write universally accessible rock songs, and Noel was jealous that Liam was constantly in the limelight, despite him being the true mastermind of Oasis.

But really, what it ultimately came down to was sibling rivalry, and when you throw in an unlimited supply of booze, narcotics and girls, it's only going to add to the already volatile mix.

In recent years, it seems the usually unruly Liam has been the one extending the olive branch to his older brother Noel. Often reflecting in interviews, the regret he feels about the breakdown in communication.

Come on Rkid, get it together. Glastonbury 2022 is just around the corner, and possibly the only thing that could put all the worlds wrongs to right, would be seeing the two Gallagher brothers strutting across the Pyramid Stage to perform their quintessentially British brand of feel-good rock.

Advertisement