10 Great Albums By Artists People Hate
Wisps of Potential.
It can take bands millions of years to build up hype for their projects. Once you have the crowds eating out of the palm of your hand, you can get some push back from the other side as well, with people coming forward saying that you’re not all that you’re made out to be. Every band has at least one good record in them though, and every one of these acts have come through with some great material at some point.
Before the real anti hype started to come in for all of these bands, some of their earlier work tends to get put up on a pedestal, being heralded as the moment where they had the most potential to capitalize on something. Not all of these are created the same way. For all of their talent, some of these guys ended up getting clobbered right out of the gate with hate from rock fans, only to hone their skills more and more until they came up with something that actually caught our ear.
Keep in mind, not all of these records have to be on the same level as the greatest artists of all time. These guys are still trying to figure out their sound half the time, and seeing them starting to find something that starts to click is much more encouraging than just writing them off. Whether or not they were actually trash to begin with, there’s the slight chance that you’ll walk away with one of your new favorite albums.
10. The State - Nickelback
This might seem like an oxymoron, but Nickelback might actually have been a pretty damn good rock band once upon a time. As much as their brand of butt rock has become the punching bag for a new generation of rock fans, there was a time when Chad Kroeger's monster showed some real promise for being a worthwhile rock and roll band. If you want to see that version of the band, we have to travel back to a time when songs like How You Remind Me never existed.
Before they had even signed with a major label, their first album the State was something a lot more gritty than what many people imagine Nickelback to be these days. While their foot is still firmly planted in the world of post grunge, you can tell that they're taking cues from some of the more interesting bands from around that time, including some softer moments that can give you flashbacks to bands like Days of the New.
This entire project feels like a band that hasn't fully formed yet, but with the right amount of polish and a few more years of experience honing their craft, could turn into something massive. Though we did end up getting way too much polish and some of the most wretched choruses that the rock world had ever known, it pays to go back to this record to just remind yourself of what could have been.
9. Yourself Or Someone Like You - Matchbox Twenty
Though bands like Nickelback may have been mining the same tired bandwagon of grunge that acts like Puddle of Mudd were doing around the same time, there was a bit of a different sound coming from the ashes of Seattle. In the wake of bands like Pearl Jam, there were also a few acts coming to the forefront with a more laid back style and a tighter emphasis on songwriting, which would become known as adult alternative a few years later. Counting Crows may have started things off and Train made the whole thing insufferable, but right in the middle there was a band called Matchbox Twenty.
It's not hard to see why some fans got on their cases though, since Rob Thomas's good looks and rich baritone made him look like the glammified version of what Eddie Vedder could have been. Taken on its own merits though, Yourself Or Someone Like You has a lot more bright spots than you might remember, having a more homespun feel to the songs and some genuine emotional moments like on 3 AM or Push.
Then again, this was never a height that even Matchbox felt interested in reaching again, with the next few records showing them slowly running out of steam and dying off fairly quickly. In the years when grunge was still considered outsider music by the masses though, these guys felt more like the alternative kids that angsty girls could introduce their parents to.
8. Songs About Jane - Maroon 5
For all of the radio hits that they have put out in the past few years, Maroon 5 is probably one of the last bands that should be on any rock fans' mind. They may be one of the few actual bands that can light up the charts these days, but Adam Levine is content to just make this a glorified solo outfit and sell out in whatever way they can, either through pointless features or writing songs that have absolutely no substance to them. Which is a shame because that definitely wasn't the case when they were starting out.
If you go back and listen to the tracks off of Songs About Jane, you'll hear a band that is toeing the line between pop and rock near perfectly, even adding doses of funk into their sound on radio hits like This Love. That's just a drop in the bucket for what this album has to offer, like the heavy (for Maroon 5) sound of album opener Harder to Breathe and closing up shop pretty nicely with Sweetest Goodbye.
And as much as he has become annoying in the past few years, it's not like Adam doesn't have a good voice on here either, like telling the story of this girl that's down on her luck on She Will Be Loved and then basking in the sunrise on the hook of Sunday Morning. This has no place next to the likes of Metallica or anything, but there's still rock buried in here underneath all of that pop frosting.
7. Purple - Stone Temple Pilots
As much as the grunge community seemed fairly laid back in the early Seattle scene, they weren't prone to a bit of gatekeeping here and there. Once Nirvana started to blow up and every other band in Seattle started to hit the big time, there were more than a few fans getting a little snobby about who was making this kind of angsty music to just piggyback off of grunge's success. Stone Temple Pilots may have been pegged as posers coming from California, but they had the tunes to back it up on that second album.
Even though their debut Core is a perfectly fine alt rock record, you can definitely tell that Scott Weiland was deep into his Eddie Vedder phase, with many people mistaking a song like Plush for the new Pearl Jam single. When they came into their own as songwriters though, Purple was a much different affair, taking pages from the world of classic rock and even a few glam rock touches here and there to create their own sound, which Scott's lower register fit a lot more comfortably on.
Outside of the actual sounds of the record, there's a bit of an eclectic mix throughout most of these songs as well, like the psychedelic touches on a song like Lounge Fly, the acoustic musings of Pretty Penny, and settling with a straight up ballad on Big Empty. Some fans may have been rightfully worried that these guys were just looking to crib off of the success of grunge, but there's a good chance that some of the best bands in Seattle couldn't make something like Interstate Love Song if they tried.
6. Parachutes - Coldplay
Most of the best rock bands out there today don't seem to bother themselves with the charts that much. Even though acts like Maroon 5 claim to be flying the flag for rock in the charts, their brand of pop rock has been centered more on the pop side for the better part of a decade at this point. While Coldplay is one of the other bands that have traded in their rock accolades at this point, their beginnings were a lot more atmospheric than even some fans probably remember.
When Parachutes was actually being worked on, this was in the waning days of the Britpop movement, with acts like Travis still finding air time on the charts. Whereas songs like Yellow may still be highlights of the band's career to this day, the rest of the album is a lot moodier than that, with some songs sounding like long lost Radiohead songs. Before Chris Martin adopted his eternal optimist persona, hearing songs like Trouble or Spies felt like the follow up to OK Computer that most Radiohead fans wanted but never actually got.
Granted, it's not like this is the biggest rock statement of the '00s or anything, with most bands like the Strokes and Radiohead themselves reinventing what the genre would become in the next few years. For Coldplay though, this was an impressive look at what the post Radiohead era of rock and roll could have sounded like.
5. Crazy Horses - The Osmonds
For all of the other bands that have occupied spots on this list, this is really where we started crossing a few lines. Even though there can be some forgivable moments from Nickelback and Maroon 5, The Osmonds were practically a cartoon band, playing the more wholesome version of what pop stars were supposed to be like in the '70s. These guys were kids, but every band has to grow up some time, and Crazy Horses wasn't something that many of the housewives of the world were expecting them to make.
In lieu of the normal bubblegum pop songs, there are more than a few songs on here that get dangerously close to hard rock territory, including some incredibly strange musical choices. From the title track alone, the inclusion of the organ and having one of the older Osmonds taking vocal duties makes this feel like a long lost Deep Purple song, especially with the climbing guitar lick that keeps going throughout the song.
That's barely scratching the surface though, touching on everything from the Beatles to even some guitar grooves that manage to sound like a decent Led Zeppelin cut in some places. This may be considered under the radar these days, but even some rock stars had to fess up to liking these songs back in the day, with the title track being praised by Joe Elliot of Def Leppard and the entire record being a favorite of Paul Gilbert of Mr. Big. There's still no chance that any self respecting rock fan would call themselves an Osmonds fan, but for this one album, it's nice knowing that the kids have some decent taste in rock and roll.
4. Cracked Rearview - Hootie and the Blowfish
The '90s were as good a decade as any to not have a gimmick playing a guitar. Not many of the grunge gods were necessarily looking to become rockstars, and a lot of their stage presence came from just being moved so much by the music that they were creating. There was a bit of a middle ground for the mellow side of rock and roll, and Hootie and the Blowfish may have been at the right place at the right time.
That's not to say they got to where they are just through luck. On the back of their album Cracked Rearview, they became one of the biggest bands in America with some amazing singles, taking the jam band mentality and putting it on the charts with songs that had a lot more rootsy edge to it. If a band like R.E.M. was a little too artsy for the mainstream all the time, this was the record that was for the more pop minded fans, like Let Her Cry painting a pretty clear picture of a relationship dissolving and Hold My Hand being one of the cheesier love songs to come out that decade.
It's not like they didn't realize their strengths either, since Only Wanna Be With You is basically about how well you can do even when your whole ambition is being cheesy. There would be a moment where Hootie were treated like the cornball rockers that they are, but in the age when irony was everywhere, it was pretty refreshing seeing a band being so earnest when they played.
3. Human Clay - Creed
For a majority of grunge fans, Creed was the moment where everyone jump off the bandwagon. Even though many bands were trying to ride the coattails in tribute to what Kurt Cobain had started at the beginning of the decade, hearing Scott Snapp's baritone delivery just felt so much more flashy, as if he was trying to do the hair metal version of what an alt rock band would do. There were a lot more cheesy things to come, but Human Clay didn't get to where it is just because of nostalgia.
Before people start mentioning it, yes this is the album where all the memes started regarding Creed, as With Arms Wide Open became one of the biggest punchlines of the yarl era of rock and roll. Once you get past the actual sound of Stapp's voice though, the rest of the band earns the distinction of one of the biggest bands of the time, with Mark Tremonti actually putting some real crunch behind some of his lead lines and Brian Marshall holding down the low end pretty well.
Especially when Scott takes a back seat on songs like What If?, there's even a few moments where the band gets closer to metal, as if we're seeing the first baby steps of what Alter Bridge would become once the rest of the guys ditched Scott for Myles Kennedy. Human Clay may be one of the more overplayed albums of the late '90s, but if you have the stomach to get through some pretty thick cheese, there are still some good tunes to be found here.
2. Continuum - John Mayer
There's a good case to be made that John Mayer is the reason why people don't want soft rock on the charts anymore. As much as it would be nice to have some rock representation on the Top 40 stations, the smug attitude that John conducted himself with throughout his reign of terror made the cool guitar player seem like the biggest douche in the universe, almost concerned more about his pickup lines with the ladies than the chords he was playing. John did have some legitimate chops though, and Continuum might stand as one of the more perfect pop albums to come since the turn of the millennium.
Having already honed his songcrafting on his last two projects, this feels like the first time where John cut all of the BS out of his sound and just focused on writing concise pop tunes, all while bringing some of the most difficult riffs that he's ever committed to tape. With studio veterans like Pino Palladino helping him out, songs like Gravity and Stop This Train are genuine pop marvels, as John shifts his more dorky singer songwriter approach towards songs about the passage of time and knowing how long you have left.
When the man rips a solo though, he really swings for the fences with lines you can sing along to like the different clean tones he gets out of Slow Dancing in a Burning Room or the pop sensibilities of I Don't Trust Myself With Loving You. It takes someone special to cover a legend like Jimi Hendrix and actually pull it off, but John definitely belongs among that crew.
1. Live Through This - Hole
For all of the head scratching decisions she's made throughout her career, Courtney Love has really been given a raw deal. In the wake of Kurt Cobain's tragic passing, there were many fans who painted Courtney as the villain of the Nirvana story, saying that she drove a wedge between him and the rest of the band and even some people claiming that she married him only for his money. You can call attention to her eccentric interviews all you want, but you can't take anything away from the attitude behind Live Through This.
Even though the actual album title wasn't really well received in light of Kurt's death, the rest of the album is Courtney through and through, taking all of the negative energy that she had inside from the paparazzi being at her doorstep and channeling it into her work, making for one of the greatest riot grrl albums ever made. While there are a few songs that definitely sound Nirvana-esque, you would never find Kurt Cobain writing a song like Miss World, which paints Love as the disaffected girl that is willing to take down the boys' club singlehandedly if she needs to.
As the wounds of Kurt's death started to heal though, time has actually been a lot kinder to this album as well, with Love being happy to fly the flag for the more savage side of alternative rock. There's nothing that's going to end up bringing Kurt back, but maybe he saw the true artist that was lost on all of us who saw the paparazzi photos.