10 Hard Rock Bands That Totally Sold Out

Money trumps musical integrity sometimes...

By Tim Coffman /

It's always a great feeling when you discover a new band for the first time. While the biggest bands in the world may be killing the Spotify playlists, the beauty of these acts is that they feel like their own separate entity than the more corporate creations on top. Then the money comes trickling in...

Advertisement

There are countless bands that have been labelled sell-outs from the moment they arrived in the public consciousness. Regardless of what the musical quality is, there's always that breed of fan who refuses to acknowledge their former favorite band for what they see as a cheap cash grab. But is selling out really a bad word? Well...yes and no.

When a band decides to make a turn towards more commercial music, the criticism of their intentions comes down to whether the music that they make is up to the same standard they set for themselves before they got famous. Sometimes it works out for the better, and sometimes it's a look towards darker days for these acts.

Let's take a look at some of the biggest pariahs of the hard rock scene and see if their "sell-out" period is a massive home run or the death knell in their discography.

10. Alice Cooper

Alice Cooper is one of the royal leaders of hard rock and heavy metal. His live shows have gone down in legend as some of the most raucous onstage performances ever created, and his albums of horror-themed rock has given him the official title of the King of Shock Rock.

Advertisement

Though Cooper always had a bit of melodic passages intertwined throughout his records, his music took on a different tinge once he went out on his own. Initially having a home run right out of the gate with Welcome to my Nightmare, the next few albums saw Alice flirting with more pop oriented styles. There were definitely some highlights like the album From the Inside dealing with his time in an insane asylum, but other forays like attempts at disco music left fans itching for Alice to rock again. I mean, there's a song on an Alice featuring lyrics written by one of Elton John's collaborators for God's sake.

Over the years, Alice has continued to pursue the heavier trends of the time, from industrial to hard rock to heavy metal territory. The material he's making today is a far cry from the off-kilter weirdness of his early years, but Cooper has regained his touch for knocking out a good hook at least a few times on each recent release.

9. KISS

KISS were the true freaks of nature in the hard rock community in the early 70's. When these four guys first broke out of New York with black and white makeup and demonic looking stage shows, they created excitement in teenage fans and disdain in disgruntled parents around the world.

Advertisement

The band kept trucking through the 70's with hard rock gusto, but something strange started to happen as they entered the next phase of their career. The band started to incorporate sounds that just didn't fit them, from the conceptual piece Music From the Elder to disco on the song "I Was Made For Lovin You."

With their return to metal on Creatures of the Night failing to reach a massive audience, the band took the biggest risk of their career by abandoning their makeup persona. From there, the band stopped being trend setters and decided to hop on the glam metal bandwagon on albums like Lick It Up and Crazy Nights. The glam rock look was already something the band had honed in their early days, but the idea of run of the mill glam rock coming from one of the creators of the genre left fans with a bitter taste. The band eventually returned to heavier territory in the future, but the 80's are still looked at as a dark time for some KISS fans.

8. Metallica

In the world of heavy metal, Metallica have been the sell out poster children for years. Though their start initially breathed life into the thrash metal scene, there are many hardcore fans who still haven't forgiven them for going mainstream once the 90's hit.

Advertisement

After the bludgeoning fans received on And Justice For All, Metallica suddenly saddled up new producer Bob Rock, who was primarily known for manning the boards for Bon Jovi and Motley Crue. Though the songs had a distinct radio-ready sound, the Black Album still held up as a pretty great album for metalheads. What came later was a different story.

With grunge now in full swing, the band turned into a hard rock band for a while on Load and Reload, and even marked a distinct image change by cutting their hair. The thrash band that we knew and loved from the early days had now been replaced with a hard rock caricature of themselves. This then culminated in St. Anger, whose attempt at trends like nu metal resulted in one of the biggest fumbles in metal history.

Through all the ups and downs though, Metallica have set a standard for themselves to never repeat the same album. The band have since returned to their thrash roots, but that hasn't stopped fans from spitting venom at them for their past crimes.

7. Linkin Park

Linkin Park were one of the few saving graces of the last days of nu metal. After the genre's inception with bands like Kor, the genre seemed to be getting too goofy for its own good. Once this collective from California unleashed their anger on record, angry teenagers finally had a fresh new sound to latch onto.

Advertisement

The band's debut Hybrid Theory sold in droves, but the band may have even topped themselves with Meteora just a few years later. As the years went on though, the nu metal tag seemed to feel more and more dated, which led to the band running as fast as they could away from their more angsty music. On Minutes to Midnight, the band quickly shifted their sound into alternative rock territory.

Many fans may have felt burned by this shift in direction, but the actual material on Linkin Park's post-Meteora work is not as horrid as you would think. The band had created a brilliant concept album centered around electronic music as well as a return to heavy metal on the Hunting Party. Sure, there have been more than a few blemishes on the band's discography, but they have been able to earn their stripes across multiple genres with incredible ease.

6. Def Leppard

The end of the 70's was a glorious time for metal in England. Bands like Diamond Head and Iron Maiden were making waves in their native land that would go on to become the New Wave of British Heavy Metal. Given how much they've distanced themselves from the genre, it's almost shocking to hear that Def Leppard were one of the few bands gaining traction in that scene.

Advertisement

These guys were a real hard rock powerhouse, with Joe Elliot's youthful growl undercut by the massive guitar riffs of Pete Willis and Steve Clarke. As the band moved up the ranks, they realized that there were much greater possibilities if they expanded beyond hard rock. After hooking up with pop producer Mutt Lange, the band went from hard rock on Pyromania to full blown pop rock on Hysteria. The kicker was that it paid off, with most of these songs becoming classics of the genre like "Love Bites" and "Pour Some Sugar On Me."

Though fans may have felt a bit disappointed, the band's creative directions afterward were what really sent fans up the wall. On albums like Slang and X, the band were clearly trying to distance themselves from their roots by chasing trends like grunge and millennial pop. The band's songwriting skills were always top-notch, but the actual sounds produced throughout their career seem to have varying degrees of authenticity.

5. Motley Crue

When Motley Crue first broke onto the scene in the early 80's, there was no one who could touch them. From their crazy theatrics to the offstage exploits, the band quickly cultivated a reputation for being one of the most dangerous bands on the Sunset Strip. The music was always down and dirty rock, but things started to change as the years went by.

Advertisement

The band went through many amazing albums until they hit on the perfect sound on Dr. Feelgood, but that success ended up haunting them. After an album with a new singer in Vince Neil's place, the band's sound turned a corner after the original lineup regrouped. The next few records saw the band playing with different styles that weren't great looks for them, starting with the industrial influenced sound of Generation Swine.

With even some band members not enjoying that record, the band floundered for years and even lost drummer Tommy Lee in the process. Once they returned, their comeback album Saints of Los Angeles seemed to have more in common with what the alt-metal bands of the 2000s were making rather than the gutter-punk anthems of the band's early days. It's understandable that the band should keep evolving, but there's a fine line between following your muse and hopping on someone else's shtick.

4. Ozzy Osbourne

Ozzy Osbourne has been marketing himself as a sinister presence for years now. Down to his nickname the Prince of Darkness, Osbourne has built a legendary career as the leader of metal gods Black Sabbath along with an impressive run of hits in his solo career.

Advertisement

However, this version of selling out doesn't even come down to Osbourne's records. Even with his latest release Ordinary Man, Osbourne still sounds like he always has, with a definitive shout that has become the signature sound of heavy metal vocalists. The way that Ozzy really sold out was in what was happening behind the scenes.

Throughout most his career, Osbourne's legacy has been intact thanks to his wife and manager Sharon Osbourne. That may seem like insider information, but the truth was laid out front and center on the show The Osbournes, where Ozzy was looked at as a more wholesome figure. What happened to the madman who bit heads off bats and peed on the Alamo? Instead of having a dark look into Osbourne's offstage escapades, fans just saw a mellow dad who was content with following his wife's advice for his music career. Ozzy may have tried to prove his dark reputation, but it almost seems comical for him to be scary after fans got a look behind the curtain.

3. Creed

It may seem a bit weird saying this nowadays, but Creed started off their career with a lot of potential. The band's debut My Own Prison is full of dark introspective songs with a more crunchy approach to the guitar riffs. Sure, it might have sounded a bit derivative of grunge, but it had a lot of promise to it.

Advertisement

Once the band reached the major labels though, their sound shifted drastically to include a certain alt-rock polish. Instead of dropping the Eddie Vedder mannerisms of the band's first album, Scott Stapp doubled down on the more yarly vocal delivery and ended up quickly becoming a caricature of himself.

With the band finding a whole different audience with the massive Human Clay album, their follow up Weathered was the point where we realized that the band was officially out of ideas and were looking to make a cash grab. It's almost a shame looking back on these records, with the non-Stapp members of Creed not able to truly showcase their talent like they are able to do in Alter Bridge. It's easy to roast a band who didn't have good songs from the start, but it stings even more when a band had the potential to be something good and decided not to.

2. Aerosmith

Looking back on the 70's hard rock scene, Aerosmith were really the faces of everything great about rock and roll, with catchy hooks and infectious riffs. It may have been a cop out to call the band blues rock wannabes, but their way of combining the sounds of the Rolling Stones, Led Zeppelin, and a healthy dose of funk led to albums that hold up as classics like Rocks and Toys in the Attic.

Advertisement

Though the band had weathered some staggering low points like the departure of guitarist Joe Perry, they seemed to be on the upswing once the original lineup patched up their differences. Thanks to the help of some professional songwriters, the band were back to their hard rock selves in the late 80's. Then things started to unravel...

At the dawn of the 90's, it seemed that the band's reliance on outside writers had led to them sounding more like pop stars than your typical rockers. This was pushed to 10 with their poppiest release Just Push Play as well as Steven Tyler being a judge on American Idol for a while. It may have been a long road to get up to the rock mainstream, but it ended up costing the band some of their rootsy hard rock foundations.

1. Nickelback

When it comes to selling out, there's no greater example of a hard rock band cashing in checks than Nickelback. The band's first independent release the State gave them a good amount of buzz in the early days, with songs like "Breathe" giving the band a definitive edge. Once they garnered attention from a major label though, songwriter Chad Kroeger drastically switched up his writing style.

Advertisement

Rather than writing from the heart and putting effort into making original material, Kroeger went into the band's next album determined to write songs in the mold of other artists in an attempt to break through to the mainstream. That already seems like a bad idea on paper, but it really was a heavy blow to the rock community when it actually worked. Suddenly, these guys were all over radio and filling stadiums around the world.

The actual idea of selling out is not a bad thing if the music is good, but the music and attitude that Nickelback present to their fans feels incredibly disingenuous. The music doesn't so much feel like an extension of the artist but rather a bunch of riffs thrown together in an attempt to get a chart hit. With many 2000's bands making fantastic records back in the day, it was a musical sin that Nickelback were the major voice of rock in the mainstream.

Advertisement