10 Most Underrated Metallica Songs
Undiscovered games from meta's biggest band.
It's really hard to consider anything that Metallica does to be under the radar. Throughout their long career, the band have created some of the most celebrated metal anthems of all time, along with some of the most reviled tracks metal has to offer as well. Though to be fair, even some great stuff falls by the wayside with the biggest bands.
From ballads to hard rock bangers to all-out metal assaults, there are many songs from the band that for one reason or another never got the attention that rightly deserved. However, given the band's reputation of making either big hits or big misfires, these tracks have had to stand beside both the worst and best of the band's catalog, and have been wiped under the rug as a result.
While the bands hits are hits for a reason, almost none of the band's tracks could really be listed as merely filler tracks (with the exception of maybe St. Anger.) Regardless, here are just a small sampling of the gems of Metallica's catalog that you don't hear nearly as much on the radio.
These might be lowlights in mainstream circles, but for the diehard fans, this is still Metallica at their best.
10. Mercyful Fate
This song is far from being the most original of Metallica tracks, but it definitely worth mentioning. After the questionable territory the band went down on Load and Reload, Garage Inc. was seen as a pretty mixed bag by most fans, with the band covering artists as varied as Black Sabbath and Nick Cave. Right in the middle of the action came this track of Mercyful Fate cuts, which is one of the greatest arrangements Metallica have ever made.
Starting concurrently with the New Wave of British Heavy Metal scene, Mercyful Fate were one of the most vicious metal acts to emerge, complete with the theatrics of King Diamond. The guys were such big fans of the band that this track is actually a medley, encompassing 5 different into a single musical piece. While it's hard to praise a song that the band didn't even write, their real genius comes with the way they arrange these tracks.
The way that songs like "Curse of the Pharaohs" bleed effortlessly into "A Corpse Without a Soul" and "Evil" is something that can only come from masters of the craft. The song takes you on such an amazing journey that you can easily forget that it goes on for no less than 11 minutes.
9. Devil's Dance
Whenever Metallica fans line up to bash their 90's output, it normally comes down to its lack of heaviness. I will meet some of the detractors halfway and say that the all around stomp of these tracks pale in comparison to the sweeping epics of the band's early material. However, the band still knew how to make a juggernaut of a track when they wanted to.
Performed in a dropped tuning, "Devil's Dance" possesses all the darkness of a classic Metallica track while also showing their swaggering hard rock side. The sinister nature of the lyrics is juxtaposed perfectly by the bluesy guitar bends in the riff itself. One could argue it's not the most original idea to have a metal band talk about Satan, but it's a subject Metallica never tackled too often in their lyrics. Instead of sounding overdone or tired, this more demonic theme is a welcome change of pace than the band's normal discussions of war and introspective pain.
It may not have had much of a shelf life after the band's initial tours, but they did think enough of the track to give it the full orchestral treatment on S&M. While it may not be the thrash you're looking for, Metallica makes up for their punishing speed with a slow tempo and a mountain of attitude.
8. My Friend Of Misery
While Metallica's musical ventures are known as a group effort most of the time, no one denies that James Hetfield is the one that steers the ship. The man is an absolute phenomenon who creates classic riffs at the same rate most of us breathe. The songwriting prowess is definitely secure, but that didn't mean they couldn't recognize great riffs from other members.
On the back half of the band's highly acclaimed Black Album, Jason Newsted brought one of his bass showcases to the table as a potential idea. The band loved the cascading chord progression, but were unsure of where to go beyond that. Though the band wanted to release it as an instrumental, Bob Rock kept pushing the band to turn it into a full-blown sung track.
As a result, "My Friend of Misery" is one of the most brilliant displays of musicianship on the entire record. The vocals are actually the weakest part of the song in this case, with the fantastic bassline complimented on the other side by atmospheric clean guitar by Kirk and one of James' most impressive harmony guitar features on record. The song may have missed its calling as an instrumental, but the results are still a great palette cleanser in between the darker cuts.
7. The House Jack Built
Load was the make or break moment for a lot of Metallica fans. While fans of the Black Album found it easier to transition into the band's new style, hardcore thrash fans felt like their favorite metal band had suddenly started to cater to trendy production. Regardless of the change in sound, there was a lot more personal stuff to unpack on "The House Jack Built."
The song is much more downtempo than a lot of the band's material, with long drawn-out chords setting the scene in the intro. The entire song plods along like a dirge, almost like the singer is lamenting the loss of a friend. However, the inner workings of this tune are a lot more upsetting than you would expect.
At the time of recording, James was dealing with his alcoholism issues for the first time and using his lyrics as a means to work through his temptation. As opposed to veiling it in a character, this song is James laying everything out on the table about how much he depends on his drinking to get him through the more stressful parts of his touring life. This might not be the most pleasant thing to hear from the Metal God, but the details are too captivating to resist.
6. Motorbreath
Metallica's trademark has always been the result of four minds working together to create musical skyscrapers. Regardless of whose names are in the credits, each track would not sound the way it does without each member leaving their mark on it. On the other hand, even when James Hetfield was left to his own devices, the results were still pretty damn good.
In the early days of the band, much of what ended up on Kill Em All came as a result of James, Lars, and ex-guitarist Dave Mustaine jamming in their practice space. While the band would string all these ideas together, "Motorbreath" was the one song that James presented to the band which was completely finished. Sure, the song may only revolve around a single riff, but the youthful energy shown on this track is exhilarating.
In an interesting turn, the percussive attack of Hetfield's vocal gives the track yet another hook, which feels like a demonic nursery rhyme. Kill Em All might be a bit spotty for a debut, but the ramshackle approach works wonders for this track about living life on 10. This might pale in comparison to the band's later epics, but the tune is still a jam that you won't be able to get out of your head once you hear it.
5. Damage Inc.
Given its status as one of the greatest metal albums of all time, it's really tough trying to find anything underrated about Master of Puppets. From the blistering title track to the stomp of "Battery," almost the entire track listing has been praised as some of the best thrash metal has to offer. At the same time, "Damage Inc." doesn't seem to get nearly the love it deserves as one of the best album closers in metal history.
When it came to the experience of an album, Metallica always knew the importance of starting and finishing strong, with this record being no exception. After a few bass strains coming from the late Cliff Burton, the track goes from sweeping elegance to thrash metal rager in the blink of an eye, as Hetfield leads the charge to pummel you into the ground.
The intensity of the track is made all the more apparent when the chorus kicks in, where Hetfield's voice goes from a scream to a subtle whisper of the song's title. The song continues on with great riffs before one last charge of the chorus, where the band brings the track home with stomping power chords. And just like that, Metallica have quickly pulled the plug on their own album, leaving you beaten, exhausted, and dying to play it again.
4. Trapped Under Ice
Whenever fans bring up the best of Metallica's catalog, it's pretty much a safe bet to put anything the band released in the 80's as their greatest work. While fans flock to their personal favorites, James Hetfield has mentioned that his favorite album out of them all is Ride the Lightning. Though it's easy to respectfully disagree given the band's many triumphs, their second effort is something special given the strength of its lowlights.
On first glance, "Trapped Under Ice" isn't anything too out of the ordinary, with much of the track being the thrash metal most bands were becoming known for. However, the relentless groove of the track along with the manic lyricism is enough to keep any fan of heavy music engaged. The entire track is based around waking up only to find yourself cryogenically imprisoned in ice. The sense of panic that comes from the main riff and Kirk Hammett's solo just add more fuel to the instrumental engine.
For all its great moments, the band have never talked about this track that much and have very seldom performed it live. The band themselves may think of it as just a filler track, but this by-the-numbers thrash track is more than many bands hope to achieve throughout an entire career.
3. Minus Human
Metallica had taken a very bold step when they decided to create the S&M concert with Michael Kamen. Given metal's reputation as a dirty genre, it was something special to see some of the band's work accented by the sounds of an orchestra. While the band's classics sounded great and the new single "No Leaf Clover" got some attention, "-Human" was yet another impressive highlight of the record.
Like "No Leaf Clover," this track was specifically made for the concert, with the arrangement being more in tune with what you would hear from an orchestral suite. As opposed to the other tracks on the record, this one feels like Metallica's instrumentation is providing backup to the orchestra rather than the other way around, but that's not a bad thing at all.
To get greater depth out of their instruments, this tune was tuned down to drop C#, which was unheard of by Metallica standards at that point. James' performance on this track is absolutely hypnotic as he goes between tunefulness and a deep-seated growl.
The song may not have had a proper solo, but the feel of this song is so brutal that any flashy playing would take away from its groove. S&M may seem like a vanity project by some, but tracks like this show just how much thought and care was put into these epic tunes.
2. The Unnamed Feeling
In terms of all of the great Metallica tracks, St. Anger seems to be the one album where all metal tunes go to die. The album has broken many metalheads' hearts over the years, as the band's attempts at a more raw sound resulted in a production that could produce headaches. That didn't mean the album was short of saving graces though.
On the back half of the record, "The Unnamed Feeling" comes on and gives the listener the closest thing to a ballad that this iteration of the band could cook up. With James fresh out of rehab, the song's lyrics perfectly capture the temptation of addiction, with the proverbial "feeling" acting as a monkey on your back.
What's even more gripping than the lyrics is James' vocal performance, which, while flawed from a technical standpoint, is the purest form of anger he spits on the entire record.
With the typical one-note tone of the record, this song also has a good sense of dynamics, as it goes from tough verses to soft choruses in the same way the band had done with "The Unforgiven." This one good track may not been enough to save St. Anger as a whole, but it did show that the band we knew could still deliver a few decent tracks even at their lowest point.
1. Of Wolf And Man
The Black Album is known as the one record that divided Metallica fans right down the middle. Even though the band were bigger than ever, many diehards could not forgive their more commercial direction on songs like "Nothing Else Matters" and "Enter Sandman." Though the band may have toned things down a bit, they could still create something spectacular on "Of Wolf and Man."
Appearing right after "Nothing Else Matters," this song puts the listener back in the metal mood from the very start, with a riff utilizing the more crunchy guitar style the band were so great at delivering. The song structure may be incredibly solid, but this may be the most unusual lyrics that Metallica has ever attempted, and dammit if they don't succeed with flying colors.
As opposed to their usual depictions of war, this track goes more elemental as Hetfield describes a man who turns into a werewolf whenever the night comes. The backing track does a fantastic job at sounding primal, but is also able to bring the track to a peak in the chorus, almost as if they're sonically capturing the process of shapeshifting into an animalistic beast.
By switching up the lyrical style, this was the type of song that both gave fans something new while staying rooted in the thrash metal the band had perfected.