10 Perfect Rock Songs That Got Better Live
From the Studio to the Stage.
The biggest strength that a rock band has in their arsenal is being able to kill it onstage. Outside of the million and one things you can do when you're behind the glass in a studio, making an entire audience surge with energy is one of the single greatest feelings that any rock band can experience with their fans. When you're really going for it though, sometimes even the best bands can go above in beyond during the performance.
As much as some of these songs may have sounded fine in their studio versions, there's something about these live cuts that made everything come alive once they hit the stage. Whether it was some sort of enhanced energy or adding something more to the arrangement of the song, these practically feel like completely different beasts than the ones that we got used to hearing at home.
Oftentimes, bands even manage to pick up some of the more forgettable tracks from their catalog and blow them up to dramatic proportions live, making for some of the most adrenaline-fueled music that has ever come out of the genre. Despite all that goes into making something sound good live, you're going to need to have a good audience to feed off of. The band might be playing the song itself, but the crowd really is the extra member of the band in these scenarios.
10. Better Man - Pearl Jam
One of the highlights of every great live show is being able to sing along to the classics. Even if you have nothing in common with everyone else there, you start to restore your faith in humanity when you get millions of people to come together for a song that you wrote. As soon as Eddie Vedder starts the opening riff of Better Man though, the audience practically takes over for him.
Before he even steps up to the mic, the crowd has actually gone to the trouble of singing most of the opening verse and chorus for Eddie as he plays along with the rest of the track. Compared to the rough baritone, you get legions of people connecting with this sad story of a woman who kids herself into staying in this meaningless relationship (not sure what that says about us all singing along, though).
On each occasion though, Eddie has been nothing but joyful whenever it happens, acting as an impromptu vocal instructor as he almost leads the crowd in the next part of the song with his gestures. Though songs like Even Flow and Alive may have been a lot more chaotic back in the '90s from a live performance perspective, these subtle moments are worth just as much as Eddie swinging from the rafters. Because for just a minute, every one in that stadium becomes an honorary member of Pearl Jam.
9. Deuce - KISS
As stupid as it sounds, KISS looked like they were dead in the water at the start of the '70s. Though they may have been writing the songs that would form the empire and KISS army that we know and love today, the records either went through incredibly bad production or just failed to capture the magic of what the spectacle of KISS was like. That all changed when we got ahold of KISS Alive!, where the circus officially came to town.
Starting from the opening sounds of Deuce, the difference between the live and studio versions of these songs are like night and day, especially when you hear the added energy coming from their performance. Taken from their stay at Detroit's Cobo Hall (a rock and roll haven, by the way), Gene Simmons is on another level in his performance, playing up the Demon Persona to a tee.
There's also a unique difference in the way that Ace Frehley seems to play his solo as well, going for a much more off the wall approach than the studio version while also having the exact same notes intact. By the time that Paul Stanley opens up with his heavy metal preacher schtick, you know what you're going to be in for. All are welcome to the show, but you had better fasten your seatbelts for what's about to come next.
8. Landslide - Fleetwood Mac
In rock and roll, it's normally ten times difficult to translate a ballad to a live setting. After all, this is the kind of song that works best when it's a lot more intimate, so how are you supposed to keep that going when you have thousands of people standing in front of you? As for Landslide though, Stevie Nicks put a lot more experience into this version as the years go by.
That's not to say that the original Landslide recording is bad by any stretch of the imagination. Coming off of Nicks' first record with the band, this is the kind of mature separation song that feels like it's being sung by an old wise sage, almost as if Stevie was trying to comfort herself from a love that had already gone sour.
When you bring that song into a live setting 20 years after the fact, things start to take on a different tone than what she probably planned back in the '70s. Considering this is a woman who went through all of the ups and downs of rock and roll at this point, a line like "time makes you bolder, and children get older" hits that much closer to home. Time can put a limit on some forms of rock and roll, but it doesn't dull that raw emotion. If you work that into a song, that's everlasting.
7. Don't Look Back In Anger - Oasis
In Noel Gallagher's own words, Don't Look Back In Anger has seemed to take on a life of its own as the years go by. Whereas it used to be one of the many fantastic Oasis songs released in the '90s, the song has become almost synonymous with unbridled joy and hope, as evidenced by the thousands of people singing it in the street in the wake of the Manchester bombings. When you put the Chief in front of a crowd though, he all but disappears on the chorus.
Performing now in a different key than it used to be back in the '90s, the acoustic setting of this new version is a lot more tender than it was before, going from confrontational to almost comforting in a way. As the song washes over you though, Noel always gives up when the refrain comes around, as the sing along from the crowd is so overpowering that it all but drowns him out.
If anything though, this feels like the entire context of the song has come full circle in the world of Noel Gallagher. With Oasis being in the rearview and the days of slogging the old guard are out the window (for the most part), this song feels more like a message of hope than anything else. That angry young man may have had some anger in the early days, but once this song starts, everything starts to fade away.
6. Nutshell - Alice in Chains
All of the diehard grunge fans knew that we couldn't count on Alice in Chains for much longer after Jar of Flies. As great as some songs like No Excuses were, it was abundantly clear that Layne Staley was falling prey to his heroin addiction and was not going to make it out to the other side. So when we actually managed to see footage of him performing the song, it practically felt like a ghost coming back from the brink.
After declining to play MTV Unplugged time and time again, the idea to go on as a band was one of the most bittersweet feelings any '90s kid could have imagined. Although it was amazing to see Jerry Cantrell and the gang getting up their with no hassle and just start right into the song, you can tell that Layne was in a bad way and trying desperately to hold it together that night.
Then again, the same pain that he was going through is what made this track so spellbinding to look back on. With the acoustic guitars out in full and the spotlights on, this is the raw and wounded version of Layne, singing with no transparency about how he's going to be on his way out fairly soon. Addiction is a cruel mistress, but it's nice to at least preserve the times when there was a little bit of hope.
5. Wait and Bleed - Slipknot
NOTE: SHOULD BE SPIT IT OUT, NOT WAIT AND BLEED.
Anyone who's thinking about going to a Slipknot show should really know what they're getting themselves into. Though the 9 lunatics from Iowa have been known to kick the snot out of themselves onstage from time to time, it's almost quaint compared to the gigantic moshpits that happen throughout the entire show. When you're in that chaos, there's pretty much no way the energy could be higher, but Corey Taylor found a way on Spit it Out.
On the actual record, this is still a decent enough Slipknot song, bringing with it a lot of anger and some of the more playful attempts at rap that Corey has attempted. When we get to that breakdown in the concert, everyone better be ready to unleash on Corey's command.
As the drums are keeping everything rolling and the riff plays underneath, Corey has been known to instruct the entire crowd to get as low to the ground as they possibly can so that they can all mosh when the riff kicks back in. Once Corey sees that everything's ready, he tears through the final verse of the song, building up to the loud command to "JUMP THE F*CK UP," which gives way to what he describes as the sight of an ocean of people erupting in front of him. This might be the closest that metal has come to absolute mayhem in a crowd, but there's no shame in getting this rowdy for a band like the Knot.
4. While My Guitar Gently Weeps - Rock and Roll Hall of Fame
Any band who even tries to cover a Beatles song live is pretty much tempting fate. The Fab Four have already created some of the most perfect rock and roll that will ever exist, and even they didn't think to actually perform their songs live, opting to just stick to the studio for the back half of their career. You're going to need something special to pull it off, and it turns out George Harrison's masterpiece just needed a slight shade of Purple.
Paying tribute to Harrison after getting into the Hall, a masterclass of musicians went onstage to perform a version of While My Guitar Gently Weeps, with Tom Petty subbing in on vocals. Even with the king of heartland rock on the mic and Eric Clapton just off to the side, Prince absolutely steals the show from the moment he tears into his solo, with a massive amount of energy and some of the flashiest guitar playing that he has ever done.
Since Prince has always been known as a showman, this is the kind of solo that has all of his trademarks, always bringing in some insanely fast runs without feeling the need to play too many notes to compensate for paying tribute to a musical god. Much like the Beatles had done before him, Prince proved with this solo that he was one of the true musicians who had the gift of melody running through his veins.
3. I Want You To Want Me - Cheap Trick
If you had listened to the first handful of Cheap Trick records, you would have a hard time grasping on what they truly wanted to be. Although we know them today as some of the greatest power pop musicians of the '70s, the first few records ranged from songs that had a ton of intensity to something like I Want You to Want Me, which plunked away on a honky tonk piano on the studio cut. While they may have been going nowhere in the States, the band pretty much trademarked the 'big in Japan' tag once they pulled into Budokan.
When they got in front of the millions of screaming fans in that historic stadium, the schmaltzy piano work was out the door, having been replaced with Rick Nielsen's screaming guitar, which went over a lot better. Considering this was one of the single biggest shows that the band had played up until this point, you can hear them putting everything into the performance, with Robin Zander having a lot more urgency in his voice and the entire song being almost too fast for its own good.
By the time you actually hit the chorus of "didn't I see you crying," you can hear the entire crowd acting like an instrument in the mix, singing the song back to the band perfectly on beat. Cheap Trick might not consider themselves to be the best players or anything, but when you put them onstage together, you're in for one of the most amazing concert experiences of your life.
2. Creeping Death - Metallica
Metallica is one of the few bands that still manages to live and die based on how well they can kill it onstage. Though they may not be as savage as they were back in the day, this was the archetype garage band that was supposed to relentlessly tour for the rest of their lives without a care in the world. And when you've actually seen them in concert, you'd better be ready for when Creeping Death kicks in.
In stark contrast to the other metal bands that sing about demons, the subject of this song comes from the most macabre parts of Scripture, with James Hetfield personifying the spirit of death coming over Egypt to kill the first born Pharaoh's son. Although Hetfield may be known as the riff lord for most of the fans, the breakdown riff by Kirk Hammett is what truly gets heads banging in concert.
When Hetfield starts the chant of "DIE BY MY HAND," you can feel the entire mood shift in whatever arena you're in, with the entire crowd chanting along to the "DIE" chant along with him. As much as Metallica has been accused of selling out time and time again, there's a reason why this song is still the crowned jewel of their live show. When you find yourself chanting along with that song, you know that the music is about to take you to hell and back.
1. We Will Rock You - Queen
Really...would you expect anyone else at the top spot here? Throughout their career, Queen managed to prove time and time again why there was no one else who could touch them in a live setting, with Freddie Mercury transforming himself into one of the greatest frontmen of all time whenever he took to the stage. The musicians may be good, but it's even better when you have a song where you can engage the crowd.
Though the original version of We Will Rock You has the same kind of principle of using just handclaps to drive the beat of the song, you can practically feel the Earth shake beneath your feet when you see this performed live. As Roger Taylor lays out the basic beat, the energy from the crowd is enough to carry the entire song on its own, as Freddie mans the microphone and holds the audience in the palm of his hand.
For all of the people that question the hype surrounding Queen as a live band, just take a look at their performance at Live Aid where they play this song, with the entire crowd singing the chorus and Freddie acting almost like an Olympic level trainer trying to get the absolute best out of the crowd. Some bands might improve their songs live by adding different arrangements. Some do it by getting the crowd involved in some way. Queen...they were able to make the song better live in the most elemental way possible.