10 Rarest Albums In Existence
Money talks…
Whether you’re scrolling through eBay or the crates at your local charity shop, you’re on the lookout for that prized record to expand your collection. Mind, you’d be lucky to find a first or second edition of ‘The Dark Side of the Moon’ at the local market. Maybe at one time but now it’s well-known the profit some old albums can generate.
Rare records vary with genre and age. For what their value is, some have permanent worth whilst others differ depending on noteworthy events, release date anniversaries and trends in music. Vinyl has undergone a huge resurgence in recent years, which makes the already valuable even more valuable. The rarest vinyl now is more for collecting than listening. The ones valued highest often go for thousands and sometimes millions of dollars - not because of the sound they produce on a turntable but because they are artefacts in the history of music.
Hard-to-find records go for a lot. The very first pressing of Led Zeppelin’s first album sold for £7,100 in 2013. A first pressing of the Sex Pistols’ second single God Save The Queen, that made the British establishment aghast and stirred the tabloids into a frenzy so much so worried record executives quickly withdrew it from sale, sold for £6000 in 2015. Just 1000 copies of Joy Division's first EP were made in 1977, ones with controversial covers featuring a member of the Hitler Youth banging a drum and which were hand-folded by Joy Division themselves. That makes them worth up to £4700.
But that’s nothing on the following 10 super scarce and super valuable records elusively hiding in a handful of lucky collections somewhere.
10. Bob Dylan – ‘The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan’ - $35000
This folk/blues gem is regarded as one of the greatest records of all time, propelling Dylan with songs like ‘Don't Think Twice, It's All Right’ to critical and commercial success.
The original Freewheelin’ record is a rarity for collectors and connoisseurs. The reason being, for still unclear reasons, just before the album’s release four songs were replaced with four newly recorded songs.
Many believe this was because television censors would not let Dylan play live one of the songs, ‘Talkin’ John Birch Blues’, on the Ed Sullivan Show (because of possible defamation against John Birch Society members) so Columbia Records pulled it from the album. Others believe the four new tracks that were recorded were simply too great to be left off the monumental record – including Dylan classics like ‘Girl From The North Country’ and ‘Masters of War’.
New records were pressed with new artwork and Columbia was quick to release that version. However in a turn of events, one pressing plant didn’t get the heads up they were being replaced so a small number of the original copies got made and shipped. Few of the originals with the four withdrawn songs have been revealed over the years. One of them that had though sold for $35000.
If you ever come across this record in a charity shop, desperately look for a cover that has a ‘Stereo/360° Sound’ logo and a sticker that reads ‘Singing His Sensational Hit, Blowin' in the Wind’. Because if you do, you’ll made a considerate profit.
9. Tommy Johnson: 'Alcohol and Jake Blues' - $37,100
Rare blues records usually go for hundreds to thousands of dollars. More so if they’ve managed to somehow stay in respectable condition after nearly a century of being made.
What you have to factor into why these blues records are so rare and expensive is that there are no master recordings that you can make duplicates out of now. The masters were destroyed years back, with no way of bringing them back. So when you find one of these blues records out in the wild, especially the Paramount delta blues records, it’s like finding the five-leaf clover of music.
'Alcohol and Jake Blues' by Tommy Johnson - one of the most influential blues artists in Mississippi in the 1920s and 1930s – is thought to have only two copies left in existence, the discs being particularly brittle due to age.
One person who owns a copy, John Tefteller, called it a “holy grail” for blues collectors. John’s collected blues records for more than 40 years and has one of the deepest collections in the world, expanding it further in 2013 when he bid in an auction for Alcohol and Jakes Blues, going as far as $37,100 to get his hands on it.
8. Aphex Twin – ‘Caustic Window’ - $46,300
Near 25 years ago, pioneer of experimental techno Aphex Twin had the intention of releasing album Caustic Window but abandoned plans to do so and left test-pressings with few people. One of those few people put their pressings on Discogs for sale in 2014. So a group of fans led by James Thomas went to Kickstarter to raise money so fans could buy the record collectively and digitally distribute it. The Kickstarter was a success, with 4124 backers raising $67,424.
The collective then auctioned off the physical record, selling it on eBay to Minecraft creator Markus “Notch” Persson for $46,300, with a portion of the profits going to charity.
“Persson’s a really cool guy, and didn’t even consider the charity aspect when buying it, but was really happy to hear that half is going to charity. He’s been an Aphex fan since he was young,” Thomas revealed. “My daughter was blown away that the guy who made the game she endlessly plays bought a record off her dad for 46K.”
The Swedish video game programmer and designer is an avid electronic music enthusiast, being a notable fan of EDM DJs like Skrillex and Deadmau5.
“It’s a very stupid way to spend money,” Persson admitted. “But why not? People say, ‘You should invest it.’ So I can get more money to put in a pile? At least if you spend it, it goes back and does something, maybe.”
7. The Beatles – ‘Till There Was You’ - £77,500
To give you a clue as to how valuable anything Beatles related is, a lock of John Lennon’s hair that a German hairdresser kept as a memento after giving John a haircut, once sold at auction for $35,000.
With that understanding you can see why a rare Beatles record would go for a sizeable amount of money. One of those records is ‘Till There Was You’, which Beatles historian Mark Lewisohn described as one of the "rarest and most collectable of all Beatles records.”
For years it belonged to Gerry And The Pacemakers pianist Les Maguire, since The Beatles manager Brian Epstein gave him the disc back in 1963. It was originally given to producer George Martin at EMI in an effort to snag a record deal for the four lads from Liverpool in the early '60s.
Characterised again as a ‘holy grail item’ by the BBC, the 10-inch record includes the tracks ‘Till There Was You’ and ‘Hello Little Girl’ and features Epstein’s own handwriting. It was mislabelled by Epstein as ‘Til There Was You’ which was credited to ‘Paul McCartney & The Beatles’. Hello Little Girl meanwhile, believed to be the first song written by John Lennon, was also mistitled as ‘Hullo Little Girl’ and credited to ‘John Lennon & The Beatles’.
Maguire stated it was the disc “that sparked the Beatles’ success.” It’s hard to argue; within months the band scored that record deal with EMI and produced their debut album. Beatlemania was born. Maguire had the disc locked away, wrapped and concealed in paper, in his attic for more than 50 years. He told how the record is "a special piece” and “It's no good to me so I've given it to my granddaughter, who is hoping to buy a house after passing her accountancy exams." She should have no issues there given it went for £77,500 at auction in 2016.
6. The Beatles – Yesterday And Today - $125,000
George Harrison once called this “the definitive Beatles collectible.”
Another Beatles rare record that scored a huge price tag at auction was the vintage ‘Butcher Album’. If you’re wondering why it’s nicknamed the Butcher Album, just look at the artwork. It’s a bizarre sight. The album, which came out in 1966, immediately created huge notoriety and backlash for the band, due to its cover with Paul, John, George and Ringo covered in bloody raw-meat and baby-doll parts. You have to factor in at the time The Beatles were still considered sweethearts amongst the public and not the psychedelic free spirits they’d later evolve into.
“My original idea for the cover was better – decapitate Paul,” John Lennon once joked when discussing Yesterday and Today. The adverse public reaction prevented the original pressing from ever reaching the shelves in most stores, with it being recalled shortly after going on sale. American department store Sears sold the album for just one day before removing it completely (before it was replaced with artwork of the four band members posed around an open trunk).
A seller, who bought it from Sears the one day they had it on their shelves, sold it for a staggering $125,000 in 2016. Another copy of it, this one though signed and doodled on by John Lennon, went for the same price of $1250,00 at auction in 2017. That this one didn’t beat the 2016 one in price gives you a hint of how valuable this record actually is.
5. The Quarrymen – ‘That'll Be The Day’/’In Spite Of All The Danger’ - £200,000
3/4 of The Beatles' first recording is another Fab Four rarity. A cover of Buddy Holly’s ‘That’ll Be The Day’ and an original song written by Paul and George called ‘In Spite Of All The Danger’ is the only copy of the studio recording with the earliest incarnation of The Beatles.
The Quarrymen essentially evolved into The Beatles over time. Recorded on 12 July 1958 as a five-piece – John Lennon on guitar/vocals, Paul McCartney on guitar/vocals, George Harrison on guitar, John "Duff" Lowe on piano and Colin Hanlon on drums – they coughed up 17 shillings and sixpence for the recording. It was only ever produced for demo purposes with only one disc originally being made.
Cased in a plain white sleeve, the record was handed back and forth between members when The Quarrymen split-up, with it ending up in the possession of Lowe. It’s been valued at the staggering price of £200,000.
McCartney would later buy the record back from Lowe, then taking it to Abbey Road Studios to restore the record’s sound quality and make copies as Christmas gifts for the other Beatles and friends and family. These copies of the record are also hugely valuable, each of them worth £10,000.
4. Elvis Presley – ‘My Happiness’ - $300,000
The record is monumental because it gives fans a glimpse at Elvis’ talent at the earliest stage of his career. It’s a one-of-its-kind record.
‘My Happiness’ is the first song Elvis ever recorded, back in 1953 at Sun Records. Presley’s friend Ed Leek claimed to have given the singer $4 to fund the session. Elvis left Sun with the record in tow and took it to Ed’s place to listen to as Elvis’ family amazingly didn’t own a record player at the time. Presley left the record at Ed’s, never collecting it.
Ed kept it in a safe for six decades. After he passed, his niece inherited it and contacted Graceland, the museum and tourist attraction that was Elvis’ home, to auction it off. It sold for an astounding $300,000 on what would have been Elvis’ 80th birthday.
It seems anything Elvis touched in his lifetime has value to it. At the same auction, scarves worn by Presley at concerts, gold necklaces with the initials TCB (short for his slogan ‘Taking Care of Business’), prescription sunglasses, his first driver's license, a custom designed watch and the jacket he wore in the Viva Las Vegas film were all for sale too.
3. The Beatles – ‘White Album’ – $790,000
Why $790,000 for a copy of the ninth and only double album by The Beatles? The album had a plain white sleeve and has no graphics or text other than the band's name but each unit of the White Album came with its own serial number on the front. The one that went for $790,000 had #0000001 as its serial number. Before bidding it had a pre-auction estimate of $40,000 - $60,000, a price tag that was quickly exceeded during bidding.
The first four pressings of the album belonged to a different Beatle. #0000001 was rumoured to belong to John Lennon for the longest time, who Paul claimed “shouted the loudest” for it. It was later revealed it was actually Ringo who was in possession of it. He kept it in a London bank vault for over 35 years.
Starr said “We used to play the vinyl in those days. We didn’t think, ‘We’ll keep it for 50 years and it will be in pristine condition.’ Whoever gets it, it will have my fingerprints on it.”
Copy No. 0000005 sold at an auction in 2008 for a little less than $30,000. Next time you’re rifling through your grandparents’ record collections, start fiercely scouring the front for #0000006.
2. John Lennon & Yoko Ono – ‘Double Fantasy’ - $1.5 million
If you need evidence of an album that critically isn’t considered great, yet is still one of the most sought records in existence, then look no further than ‘Double Fantasy’.
It’s a morbidly depressing piece of memorabilia due to the circumstances leading to its high value. It’s the copy that John Lennon autographed for his murderer Mark Chapman hours before being gunned down by him in 1980. The copy also has Chapman’s forensically enhanced fingerprints and police evidence marker. It’s an incredibly eerie relic in music. Its value is only enhanced by the pictures that circulated in the press after the murder of Lennon personally signing the album for Chapman.
It was found behind a plant box by a maintenance man outside the Dakota Building home of Lennon, after he was fatally shot, and used as a crucial piece of evidence in the trial. It was later returned to the maintenance man after the trial as a thank you. A lifelong Beatles fan, the maintenance man stored the album under his bed for 18 years before he sold the album to a private collector in 1999. It was up for sale again in 2017, this time with an asking price of $1.5 million.
1. Wu-Tang Clan - Once Upon a Time in Shaolin – $2 million
Wu-Tang Clan de facto leader RZA on ‘Once Upon a Time in Shaolin’: "I definitely read every article about it. It’s kind of crazy. The record has become an entity, very different from a lot of albums. It’s like the Mona Lisa. It’s got its own folklore."
Looking to do something different with their next record in 2015, RZA and the Wu-Tang Clan revealed they would only create one copy of OUATIS and sell it to whoever the highest bidder was. Streaming had already taken over the music industry, and this was Wu-Tang’s way of creating something entirely individual and tangible that would only age better with time.
Originally, the Clan tried to enforce a rule that the buyer couldn’t release the album to the public for at least 88 years after purchase, but eventually eased off, granting total freedom to the buyer. Meaning if the buyer wanted to release it on YouTube for free, they could. Or even take a sledgehammer to it.
The Wu-Tang Clan sold the 31-track, 128-minutes long album at auction, destroying all duplicates afterwards. The only two people who had heard it in full at that point were RZA and his co-producer. Speculation grew on who bought the record, many believing it was Quentin Tarantino, friend/mentor of RZA.
Later than year it was identified the eventual buyer as Turing Pharmaceuticals CEO Martin Shkreli, who had paid $2 million. Martin was well-known in the media and detested for raising the price on a drug to treat the disease cystinuria and later becoming more despised for again raising the price from $13.50 to $750 for each pill to treat the Aids related toxoplasmosis .
In a weird turn of events, the feds now have the Wu-Tang album after they seized Shkreli’s assets when he was convicted of security fraud in August 2017.