10 Rock Albums That Artists Regret Making
Songs We Don't Want To Be Seen With.
You can't really recognize incredible music unless it's in hindsight. For as much as a catchy tune might last you through the summer, the idea of having music that sticks to you only holds up if it resonates every time you hear it. Though these songs may have felt right for the time, the musicians in question have revisited these records with a slightly bitter taste.
While most musicians stand by their old work as something special, these records have practically been given the critical clubbing before the critics even got to it.
No matter how much time these artists spent trying to hone their craft, most of them stand by their opinion that these records are either outright crap or nowhere near as good as they could have been. What makes it all the more laughable is when you realize that the albums in question are often monumental releases.
While there's occasionally some crap sprinkled in, a lot of these records are some of the artists' best work, only to left out to dry whenever they bring it up in everyday conversation.
For as much as we may love to blast these records from time to time, just make sure that the people who made it aren't within earshot when you're doing it.
10. Power Windows - Rush
Most bands who dominated the '70s didn't really have the smoothest of transitions into the next decade. Once the focus shifted to the MTV era of videos, the likes of acts like Styx and Ted Nugent were starting to look all the more passe with each passing day. Though Rush managed to walk the line fairly well, Power Windows is the result of going just a little bit too far over the line.
It's not like Rush hadn't dabbled in electronic music before this though, with synths being a prominent part of their sound since A Farewell to Kings. Since it was the mid '80s though, this is where everything and the kitchen sink is brought into the mix, with Mystic Rhythms being the only thing that could be called a single from the record. While Neil Peart and Geddy Lee were still willing to go down this road, these songs ended up hitting a sour note with Alex Lifeson.
With his signature guitar wails being pushed further and further into the background, Lifeson has always had a tense relationship with this record, oftentimes fighting with the rest of the band as to why he was looking for a different place when the keyboards were taking over. Despite returning to the loud guitars a few years down the road, Power Windows is still a powerhouse of a record if you're willing to look for a nice '80s throwback.
9. Neighborhoods - Blink-182
There were probably a lot of pop punk fanboys that almost had a heart attack when Blink-182 finally announced their reunion. Since the first iteration of Blink fell out pretty badly after their self-titled album and the massive plane crash Travis Barker was involved in, it felt like the era of All the Small Things was dead in the water. Though things seemed to be looking up on Neighborhoods, this is the album we all like to pretend doesn't exist.
For as much as Blink would have liked to have gotten their act together for a new record, it's clear that there are some conflicts of interest based on the first few tracks alone. While songs like Up All Night and Heart's All Gone have some of that snotty punk rock spirit that we've always known Blink for, Tom DeLonge's attention to detail ends up steering them more towards Angels and Airwaves than pure punk.
It didn't even sound like the actual recording sessions were all that fun either, as both parties talked about recording in completely different locations, leaving most of the songs not so much being written as much as they were assembled. Neighborhoods might stand out as one of the more unique directions of Blink's career, but a punk album without any real heart and soul isn't going to reach classic status any time soon.
8. And Justice for All - Metallica
The end of 1986 really was a make or break moment for Metallica. Ever since losing Cliff Burton in a tragic bus accident, many were wondering whether they could continue on with newcomer Jason Newsted providing the signature low end. Though Newsted certainly rose to the challenge, you wouldn't have been able to tell if you listened to And Justice For All.
Out of all the classic thrash records of Metallica's '80s period, this stands out as one of the most drastic left turns from a purely sonic perspective. Whether it was intentional or not, part of the hazing of Newsted found its way into the final mix, with the bass being almost inaudible throughout the entire record. While not knocking it, James Hetfield has gone on record saying that the mix could have certainly benefited from some greater low end.
This is also one of the most technically proficient records in Metallica's discography, which turned out to be both a positive and a negative. Despite being able to play a million notes per second, the sheer length of these tracks eventually led to Metallica making a complete left turn towards simpler material on the Black Album just a few years later. Even though Justice may hold a special place in the hearts of metal fans, it's hard not to see it as the beginning of the end in retrospect.
7. One By One - Foo Fighters
From day one, nothing has really come easy for the Foo Fighters. Even the conception of the band back in the mid '90s was nearly a miracle, with Dave Grohl creating the entire blueprint for the band on a whim to get over the death of Kurt Cobain. Once you reach the big time though, things might start to unravel just a little bit.
After the care-free joy that came with There is Nothing Left to Lose, the band found themselves helpless when Taylor Hawkins nearly died of a drug overdose midway through the tour. Looking to blow off steam before making the next record, Grohl decided to play in Queens of the Stone Age for a while, which left the rest of the band feeling left in the dust. When Grohl finally re-entered the fold, things erupted just before going into recording.
Picking up the pieces for One by One, Grohl still has some harsh feelings associated with the songs on this record, as they remind him of the rough time it took to get there. While tracks like All My Life and Times Like These remain concert staples to this day, Grohl has said that the rest of the record almost feels half-conceived, possibly because the guys were at odds during the recording. Despite the Foos' music being relatively fun to listen to, this is still one of the most painful records they had ever made.
6. Ten - Pearl Jam
At the start of the '90s, the rock industry was about to be flipped on its head. Once Nirvana started the ball rolling with Nevermind, the alternative nation was about to take over the mainstream, with Pearl Jam's Ten being not far behind. For as much as songs like Black and Jeremy still resonate with fans around the world, this is the one album that the members still can't listen to.
This comes more down to a production issue than anything else. While many of these songs have become staples of PJ's live set over the years, Eddie Vedder has been vocal about how he hates the way the record was mixed, thinking it sounded far too radio-friendly to be taken seriously. It's not hard to see where he's coming from either, with the massive drum sound of the record having much more in common with arena rock than the indie style they were shooting for.
Then again, that same kind of production is what made the record explode across the world, becoming the calling card for what grunge would become later down the road. At the same time, this did introduce us to the signature baritone style which would become abused to death as well with acts like Godsmack and Puddle of Mudd. A bit of a mix blessing...but not bad by any stretch of the imagination.
5. Relationship of Command - At the Drive In
At the Drive In is probably the closest thing that the rock world has to a form of controlled chaos. Though it's easy to categorize their style as post-hardcore, their first taste of success with Relationship of Command feels like it's on the verge of anarchy at any second. For as much as this record might be a bludgeoning to your skull though, the mastermind behind it all still has yet to revisit it over the years.
Ever since its release, Omar Rodriguez Lopez has been incredibly harsh towards the way Relationship of Command turned out, singling out Andy Wallace as the reason why it sounds the way it does. Although Wallace is a brilliant mixer and has worked on thousands of amazing rock albums, Lopez has gone on record saying that Wallace's sweetening of the mix ruined the songs, making them sound far too clean when compared to the original.
It feels weird hearing that though, considering songs like Arcarsenal and One Armed Scissor sound like they have the potential to either fall apart or completely explode from one moment to the next. Maybe this was just the proof of concept though, with Lopez later going on to throw everything and the kitchen sink into the mix with the Mars Volta. While this may be the candified version of At the Drive In, most bands would kill to sound this feral on record.
4. Be Here Now - Oasis
There comes a point in most artists' careers when they hit the sweet spot of their songwriting. For as much time as you may spend honing your chops, these are normally the times when everything is at full capacity, where lyrics and melodies flow out of you through pure osmosis. When you're up that high though, no one really thinks of what's it like coming back down.
Instead of just refining their sound even further, Be Here Now by Oasis is the moment where everything came crashing down for these lads from Manchester, with Noel Gallagher throwing everything at the wall to see what stuck. Though there are the makings of good Oasis songs in here, the sheer length of the tunes as well as the countless amounts of overdubbing make the whole thing feel like a bloated mess than a rock and roll record.
As time has gone on, it doesn't even look like Noel can defend the record anymore either, even saying about how the songs were garbage not even a decade after the record had been made. Although there have been remixes of the album that have cut down on the song lengths, no real edit can hide the more uninspired moments on every song. For as much as this was supposed to be the start of a new era for Oasis, this ended up putting the final nail in the coffin for Britpop.
3. Pinkerton - Weezer
After the massive success of Weezer's blue-colored debut, they were in a bit of an awkward position. Despite having more attention than any potential rock star could have hoped for, Rivers Cuomo never really anticipated his band taking off that quickly. Though he managed to work through the pain on Pinkerton, Cuomo has done nothing but bad mouth his open-hearted sophomore album for years now.
While it may have been torn to shreds in its time, Pinkerton has held up as one of the crown jewels in Weezer's discography, going so far as to be in competition with their debut as one of their best. Then again, it's not hard to see why Cuomo might have some problems with it. Across every single one of these tracks, the songs range from noisy in places to being way too personal than Cuomo probably wanted to, from the teenage fan love letter in Across the Sea to the therapeutic refusal to talk to girls on El Scorcho.
Even though most fans appreciate his honesty on this record today, Cuomo has likened this record to puking your guts out at a party and realizing how embarrassing it was after the fact. Pinkerton might not be a perfect record from cover to cover, but there's probably never been a rock record that has been bad mouthed so much and doesn't deserve it.
2. Nevermind - Nirvana
Any rock band looking to actually make a dent in the cultural zeitgeist owes at least some debt of gratitude to Nevermind by Nirvana. Arriving like a bolt of lightning in 1991, the strength of songs like Smells Like Teen Spirit and In Bloom blew the remaining stench of hair metal off the map and announced the return of a more natural form of rock and roll. If you asked the author though, Nevermind is one of the worst things that the band had ever made.
Almost as soon as Nirvana hit it big, Kurt Cobain was already calling attention to how horribly the record was mixed, thinking it was way too mainstream compared to their earlier work on Bleach. When looking for someone to mix the record, Cobain suggested Andy Wallace, who had worked with Slayer in the past, only to be horrified when he heard the radio-friendly flair of songs like Come As You Are.
Up until his death, Cobain was still conflicted about his feelings toward his smash record, thinking it sounded closer to something by Motley Crue than anything remotely punk rock. While he's entitled to his opinion, there's probably no chance you'd hear Motley Crue ever writing something with as much thunder as Stay Away or Breed. For as many problems as Cobain may have had with it, something tells me that he would feel differently if this weren't the album that made him an international superstar.
1. Let It Be - The Beatles
No artist wants to put out something that they aren't proud of. If you're willing to put actual time and effort into your craft, you always want to try and put every piece of your soul into everything your audience hears. Even though you might fall short sometimes, Let It Be by the Beatles stands as the one record that didn't even want to get made.
After the White Album left the Fab Four at odds with each other, Paul McCartney's idea for a return to roots record turned into a disaster, with no one really on the same page for a majority of the sessions. With George Harrison nearly quitting the band in protest, the group reassembled at Abbey Road Studios to make one last record, which turned into Abbey Road just a few months earlier.
They still owed their record company one more record though, which led to Let It Be getting released bare, with Phil Spector coming in to sweeten up some of the mixes. While the Fabs were already feuding before, this was where it got really nasty, with John Lennon praising the mixes and McCartney sending off a letter to the staff of Abbey Road Studios to never tamper with his songs without his permission ever again. For a band that was all about peace and love, this is what happens when the business side of the industry brings out the worst in the artist.