10 Rock Artists That Ripped Off Other Bands
The Art of Musical Plagiarism.
Any musician's goal tends to be staying true to yourself. No matter how much the world around you might change, you always try to find the ideal version of your own sound that will hopefully resonate will people all around the world. As the phrase goes though, while smart people may borrow, it takes a true genius to outright steal.
Throughout rock history, there have been thousands of artists who openly wear their influences a little too close to their sleeve. Whether it be for a few lines of a song or in the entire construction of the band, these acts have been able to make their millions by just doing what their heroes did before them. It's not like these musicians aren't aware of it either, with some deliberately putting in references to their favorite bands for the sole purpose of stirring the pot with both their fans and critics.
Though this might not have taken as much thought as just making your own music, there's something to admire in wearing your influences without a trace of cynicism. Love them or hate them, these acts knew that their greatest strengths had already been done. From working out the bugs to building an empire of plagiarism, here are the riffs that might sound a little too familiar.
10. Good Charlotte
At the start of the '00s, the pop punk explosion was firmly underway. While the darker side of the rock scene was turning to nu metal or garage rock, acts like Blink-182 and Sum 41 were all over MTV with their candy-fied version of the typical rock and roll formula. Though you could call it derivative in some places, Good Charlotte were the one act who didn't mince words about their influences.
Starting with their debut, these brats out of Maryland had a few tricks up their sleeve with their psuedo-gothic look, but that all changed with the Young and the Hopeless. Compared to the other acts at the time like Simple Plan, Charlotte's lineage could be traced back to Green Day, with riffs that sounded like they could have have been a mid-tier Dookie B-side. Even Joel Madden changed up his vocal style to have just a little more whine to fit the Billie Joe Armstrong model.
So did they succeed? Well, for a little while. Though the Young and the Hopeless sold like gangbusters at the outset, it didn't last long when Green Day's American Idiot reinvented the pop punk formula and left their competition in the dust. Even though the Anthem might give a nostalgia buzz to pop punk fans these days, why would you take the discount version when Green Day proper is doing more interesting stuff?
9. Cheap Trick
Ever since the end of the '60s, it seems that every record company wanted to find their version of the Beatles. Though the Fab Four may have rewritten the rules on what constitutes a good rock band, there's no real way that you can capture that same kind of magic twice. Then again, Cheap Trick did give it their best shot to make their Liverpool heroes proud.
Across their discography, these Rockford misfits have made an entire career out of deconstructing Beatles melodies. From the tuneful way that they write their riffs down to the way the harmonies overlap on top of each other, there is definitely something that always reminds you of the Fab Four, especially in the Revolver/Rubber Soul era. It also doesn't help when you listen to Robin Zander's vocal style, which somehow sounds like a complete hybrid of John Lennon and Paul McCartney's vocals.
Those comparisons didn't really hurt them in the long run though. As they progressed through each album, the sound of the band eventually got a lot more raw, setting the stage for what became known as power pop later down the line with The Cars and The Jam, even leading them to collaborate with Beatles producer George Martin. While there might be some questionable similarities here and there, it's a pretty high accolade when you're called "The American Beatles."
8. Megadeth
There's no set formula for how you rip off someone that came before. While some may just take bits and pieces of their influences and wear them like a costume, others might just outright copy every single thing about their favorite bands in the hope that their audience won't spot the difference. However, is it really ripping off when you're stealing from yourself?
In the grand scheme of things, Megadeth has carved out their own identity as one of the Big 4 of Thrash, but their connection with the biggest of the Big 4 can't really be denied. Given that Dave Mustaine was once a member of Metallica, you can definitely find bits and pieces of their classic songs laced throughout Megadeth tunes. While Mustaine is perfectly within his right to use material that he actually wrote, it gets a little awkward when you have two thrash classics with the same exact riffs.
While the initial point may have been to make a harder-edged version of his Metallica material, Mustaine's way of recontextualizing his own licks have led to amazing material all its own. For as much as Hangar 18's main lick may be indebted to Metallica's the Call of Ktulu, you aren't going to mistake one for the other any time soon. Whether it's because of bad blood or just recycling old ideas, Mustaine's penchant for Metallica licks is rarely ever a bad thing.
7. Creed
The arrival of grunge was exactly what the rock world needed at the turn of the decade. As the rest of the rock scene was getting bogged down by the third and fourth generation of hair metal bands, these newer acts coming from Seattle were bringing an authenticity back into rock and roll that hadn't been seen in a while. At the same time, it only takes a little while for a record label to come out with ten carbon copies of the same thing.
On the surface though, Creed doesn't necessarily have anything in common with the grunge acts of old. Sure, their tunes may have had a few slower riffs and a back to basics approach to rock and roll, but you weren't going to really mistake Mark Tremonti for any other guitarist in the metal scene. No, the real copycat all comes down to the way Scott Stapp sings.
Though Stapp's lyrical style may be solely indebted to Christian rock, it's clear that he has gone to the Eddie Vedder school of vocal singing, with a yarl that sounds incredibly fake coming out of his mouth. Whereas Eddie's voice felt like a natural extension of his soulful lyrics, this just feels like a Christian rock singer being re-packaged as grunge music. This wasn't the first instance of copycatting in the post grunge world, but it does feel like the cheapest in retrospect.
6. Greta Van Fleet
Rock and roll as a whole would be in a very different place had it not been for Led Zeppelin. After coming out of the British Blues boom in the '60s, Zeppelin created some of the most essential riffs in the history of rock, setting the standard for what was considered heavy music. It's virtually impossible to make songs that classic and not influence people...it's just how much influence though.
Though countless bands have borrowed a page or two from Zeppelin's playbook, Greta Van Fleet is where it starts to get a little questionable as to the influence. On the surface, the music that these kids are making is fine for what it is, with riffs that feel like they're pulled straight out of the '70s. On the other hand, the way that Jake Kizka pulls from Robert Plant makes it feel like they're putting on a rock and roll costume rather than actually writing riffs of their own.
This continues a long line of bands who have tried to crib from Zeppelin, but this one does feel like the most shallow defacing of Jimmy Page's legacy. It's also never a good thing when you put on a record and think, "wow, I wish I were listening to Zeppelin IV right now." While these kids still may have a bright future ahead of them, they're going to need to seriously reinvent their sound if they want to stay relevant on the rock scene.
5. Aerosmith
After the British Invasion, thousands of American bands were looking to mine their own version of rock and roll. Since the British kids were already co-opting the styles of blues from the American South, it was only a matter of time before America answered back with bands of their own. Though Aerosmith was known as one of the first real success stories, they did get a little bit of clapback for being a bit too derivative.
As these Bad Boys From Boston were trying to make a name for themselves off the strength of their first album, there were people lining up to call them a second rate Rolling Stones. While the differences between Aerosmith and the Stones seem like night and day now, they did have a decent argument back in the day, with Steven Tyler and Joe Perry having the same dynamic and even sharing a passing resemblance to Mick Jagger and Keith Richards.
Hell, even the more classic Aerosmith songs of the time like Mama Kin and Same Old Song and Dance were incorporating horns the same way the Stones had started doing on albums like Exile on Main Street. Aerosmith did eventually get their own sound by incorporating some blues boogie into the mix, but at this stage, they still had a hard road ahead of them if they wanted to be taken seriously.
4. Bruce Springsteen
Over the years, Bruce Springsteen has pretty much invented his own genre from the ground up. From the middle class stories he puts throughout his music to the way he uses his E Street Band as an instrument unto itself, the Everyman attitude from the Boss has become synonymous with what became known as heartland rock. Not many people were feeling that kind of energy in the beginning though.
While albums like Greetings from Asbury Park did fairly well and even garnered some decent reviews, a lot of the press had something different to say about Springsteen's delivery. Across each of his songs, Springsteen would incorporate stories with stark imagery, characters that are down on their luck, and metaphors that took a little more time to process than your average pop single. It was a winning formula for sure, that is if you forget the fact that Bob Dylan had been doing the same thing since the '60s.
Though the critics may have been rapturous at the beginning, the tag of being a new Dylan was never something that set well with Springsteen, not really wanting to be the voice of a generation like his idol was. That all changed with Born to Run, whose cinematic scope and iconic characters gave Springsteen a sound all his own. While it may have been any songwriter's dream to be compared to Dylan, it was a dream that the Boss didn't want to live in for very long.
3. Muse
At the start of the '00s, rock and roll didn't really sound that original anymore. While acts from the pop punk and nu metal genres were still gracing the charts, you could still trace their lineage back to bands that were doing the same thing for the past decade. Even with Muse rising to prominence as the return of stadium rock, you could still see their influences seeping through the mix.
With just a passing glance, you can easily see the influence of a band like Queen in their delivery, given Matt Bellamy's penchant for writing gargantuan riffs and a booming voice akin to Freddie Mercury's. On the other hand, there's no question that these guys really wanted to be Radiohead in the early days, with albums like Showbiz and even bits of Origin of Symmetry having Jonny Greenwood-like guitar lines and Bellamy's falsetto being more in line with that of Thom Yorke.
However, things have started to branch out for Muse over the years, as they have transitioned into their space age rock with ease, even incorporating a few metal licks into the mix on tracks like Stockholm Syndrome and Citizen Erased. It may have taken them a while to get their sound down, but you might still be able to hear bits and pieces of Muse's heroes showing a little too much.
2. Rush
There's probably a rule somewhere that prog rock bands have to try to be original at every turn. I mean, it's in the name of the genre that these acts are designed to push the boundaries of what rock and roll can do in their own unique way. However, that doesn't always apply when these acts are just getting started.
While Rush remains one of the most popular acts in the history of prog rock, their debut album tells a bit of a different story. Without Neil Peart in the group just yet, their sound is pretty much a run of the mill trip through blues rock and early heavy metal, with a sound that may have been compared to something like Blue Cheer or Humble Pie. Once you hear everyone play together though, it's clear that these guys really wanted to be Led Zeppelin in the early days.
From the larger than life riffs from Alex Lifeson to Geddy Lee's soaring voice, it's clear that tracks like Working Man were designed to piggyback off of the standards that Zeppelin started in the early days. At the same time, the lack of drum presence from John Rutsey doesn't really come close to the mammoth power of John Bonham. Though Neil Peart may have helped steer them in the right direction on Fly By Night, they definitely had a lot of work to do to come up with something original.
1. Oasis
The tail end of the '90s truly belonged to Britpop. After the grunge scene left most of the rock crowd feeling sad and depressed by the end of the song, this throwback to the early days of rock and roll ended up being just what fans needed to pick themselves off their feet. It's one thing to draw influence from the '60s...it's something else entirely to just outright plagiarize.
While Oasis were the Britpop poster children from the very beginning, it was absolutely clear that they wanted to be the Beatles from the very beginning. On one hand, you had Liam Gallagher's vocals, which just sounded like a more snide version of what John Lennon would have done. On the other hand, you had his brother Noel's songwriting, which would often devolve into Beatles parody right out of the gate. Look no further than songs like Don't Look Back in Anger and She's Electric, whose melodies feel like they're lifted verbatim from Imagine and While My Guitar Gently Weeps respectively.
Whereas other bands may deny these influences, Oasis have always owned up to their inspiration, even going so far as to lace Beatles song titles into the lyrics, from "yellow submarine" in Supersonic to "the long and winding road" in My Big Mouth. Though the Gallagher Brothers may go on and on about being the greatest band in the world, it's abundantly clear who they really think the greatest band in the world is when you hear their music.