10 Rock Bands That Almost Killed Each Other In The Studio

Metallica and The Beatles' greatest hits nearly never happened after these fights turned ugly.

By Tim Coffman /

Making an album should always feel like a labor of love for the musicians involved. Though it can be a bit difficult capturing the final take of your songs, it should never diminish the idea of creating the best piece of musical art that you can. At the same time, getting the results doesn't always mean you're on the best of terms by the end.

Advertisement

Across every style of rock music, people have gone into the studio and left very different people. Whether it was the gruelling task of getting it down on tape or the external drama creeping onto the studio floor, these artists really had their work cut out for them when putting these things together. In the process, fists would fly, words would be exchanged, and occasionally instruments would be broken in the process.

What's even more troubling is having the producer in the middle of things, who either acts as the moderator of the madness or adds to it in order to get just the right magic they want onto the final mix. It paid off in the long run though, with most of these culminating in the best work these acts have ever made. It's not for the faint of heart, but nothing in rock and roll really is.

10. Vol. III The Subliminal Verses - Slipknot

After the early '00s, Slipknot seemed to have done the impossible. By not compromising their sound and getting even heavier with age, they blew their competition out of the water and were catapulted to the kings of the metal scene almost overnight. However, going through the touring and album lifestyle is bound to take its toll sooner or later.

Advertisement

Coming off of the audible beating of Iowa, Vol. III shows Slipknot at one of the most fractured points in their career. While the Iowa tour itself wasn't really a walk in the park, their decision to lock themselves away in the Houdini mansion was a headtrip, with members getting loaded on drugs when trying to come up with new material. It also didn't help that Rick Rubin's involvement was a bit lax for Corey Taylor's taste, saying that Rubin hardly ever showed up for the real nitty gritty details.

However, the experimentation in the studio ended up paying off, with Taylor getting sober during the process and coming through with some of the 9's most recognizable hooks on songs like Duality and Vermilion. This was even the album that earned these masked freakshows a Grammy for the single Before I Forget. At a time when band morale was at an all-time low, the fact that Slipknot hunkered down and brought everything to the table on Vol. III is what helped them to survive going forward.

9. One By One - Foo Fighters

The Foo Fighters have got to be one of the most easygoing bands in the history of rock and roll. From their straight ahead bangers to the open-hearted ballads they put on their records, it's almost difficult not to have a good time when listening to Dave Grohl spark up his musical fire. You say that now though...the early '00s were a completely different story.

Advertisement

After Grohl, Nate Mendel, and Taylor Hawkins made There Is Nothing Left To Lose as a trio, the sessions for their next album One by One were a disaster. Taking to the road after getting guitarist Chris Shiftlett, Hawkins overdosed on one of the tour dates and was hospitalized for days in a coma. Once he came to and everyone reconvened at home, Grohl decided to cool out by playing with Queens of the Stone Age, which created a lot of bad blood between him and Hawkins.

By the time they actually got around to making a Foos' record, the energy was so tense that the group's future almost ended on tour. Though Hawkins and Grohl eventually settled their differences, they had to end up starting from scratch and throw away nearly $1,000,000 worth of material to start again. Given the nightmare it took to create, One by One is the sound of the Foos at odds, doing everything they can to build themselves back up.

8. Brand New Eyes - Paramore

It's hard not to see Paramore as a vehicle for Hayley Williams at the best of times. Though the sound of Williams solo sounds very different than her main outfit, the raw talent and songwriting expertise on every one of their albums feels like an extension of her soul. Then again, when one member starts getting too much attention, some bruised egos tend to boil over.

Advertisement

After coming off of the mammoth album Riot and having respectable hits like Misery Business, the brothers Farro started to really butt heads with the rest of the group over their future direction, which turned into open hostility when they actually went to play their instruments. As such, most of Brand New Eyes' pop direction almost feels like a way to cover up the inner turmoil that's happening on the surface.

While songs like the Only Exception definitely have an optimistic outlook on love, the rest of the record has a bit of a different tune, with Ignorance possibly being about the dissolution of the group and Turn It Off practically sending off this lineup by saying "before it gets any better, we're heading for a cliff." On the other hand, people actually related to the raw wounds on display here, with Brand New Eyes being considered a high point in the group's catalog. The Farro brothers may not have lasted for too long afterward, but what everyone put into this recording is timeless.

7. Vitalogy - Pearl Jam

Pearl Jam were never meant to be the biggest band in the world. Though songs like Alive and Daughter might work well in massive stadiums around the world, the amount of attention never sat well with these pretty reserved guys from the Northwest. After coming off of two blockbuster albums with Ten and Vs. and finally becoming on par with his hard rock heroes, Eddie Vedder went into the Vitalogy sessions with an axe to grind.

Advertisement

Before even going into the studio, there were tensions within the group, as they started a vendetta against Ticketmaster and struggled to find a way to get the best prices for their fans. On the other hand, the clash between Vedder and drummer Dave Abbruzzese resulted in the drummer being fired shortly after the album was finished. You can definitely hear that turmoil on display on tracks like Bugs and Pry To, but the rest of the album may be the greatest Pearl Jam record ever made.

Although Vedder may have been largely AWOL, the more radio-friendly stuff has aged gracefully, from the balladry of Nothingman to the absolute punk juggernaut Spin the Black Circle. Even though some stuff like Tremor Christ does happen from time to time, you have other tracks like Better Man and Corduroy that lift your spirits all over again. Considering the hell going through this album, Vitalogy should have been what broke up the band, and yet they came out with what may be their most eclectic album of the '90s.

6. 1984 - Van Halen

When you're talking to any rock fan about Van Halen, chances are they'll bring up either Eddie himself or David Lee Roth. Throughout their '80s run, both Roth and Van Halen were able to act as virtual co-frontmen of the group, with Roth being the mascot/party animal and Eddie being the mad scientist wowing crowds with his guitar tapping. However, when you've been playing the same riffs over and over, you're bound to want to branch out a little more.

Advertisement

Even though the formula put forth on albums like Van Halen I and Women and Children First were pretty much air-tight, Eddie's accentuations with the keyboards started to really creep in on 1984. Despite Roth wanting the uncut rock and roll of previous outings, this is where Eddie put his foot down and insisted to have keyboards as the dominant instrument on tracks like Jump.

Given the chances for this to be considered a sellout, this ignited the fire all over again for Van Halen, with keyboard cuts like I'll Wait being balanced perfectly with riff-heavy tracks like Panama and Hot For Teacher. Then again, the turmoil did boil over once VH went on tour, with Roth quitting and moving onto his solo career shortly afterward. The internal tensions might not have been able to keep these hard rock giants together, but if you have to go out with a bang, you can't really do much better than this.

5. Rumours - Fleetwood Mac

At the start of the '70s, Fleetwood Mac had really come a long way since their origins in the '60s. Beginning as a typical blues rock outfit on their first albums with Peter Green, their latest incarnation with Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks gave them overnight success off the strength of Rhiannon and Landslide. All you had to do was make something that could top it...while everyone hated each other. Good luck.

Advertisement

Adding insult to injury, the Mac was in the process of falling apart when Rumours got started, with Buckingham and Nicks ending their relationship and John and Christine McVie getting a divorce during the album's production. It starts to sting even more when you realize that these songs are pretty much a document of those dark times, with Buckingham's Go Your Own Way being a scolding revenge song at Nicks and Songbird being Christine's peaceful heartache towards her former lover.

Going through a barrage of alcohol and cocaine in the process, each of these tracks turned into radio gold once they hit the airwaves, with almost every single cut becoming a radio favorite over the next few years. The Mac may have left this outing with their hearts in shreds, but when you actually sit down and listen to the music, they seemed to capture a bit of beauty no one could have imagined.

4. Born To Run - Bruce Springsteen

By the time Bruce Springsteen got around to making his third album, he had really put himself through the musical ringer. While albums like Greetings From Asbury Park and The Wild The Innocent and The E Street Shuffle had done well enough, the comparisons to Bob Dylan and the lack of single material put a mantle of pressure on the Boss that he didn't really need. With no real buzz outside of critical circles, Born to Run was bound to be the last ditch effort for success or the moment Springsteen fell into obscurity.

Advertisement

Though the results of the title track sound absolutely mind blowing today, it was one hell of a hard road getting there, with the E Street Band being pushed to the very brink. Outside of touring night after night, the sessions for the album became painstaking, as Springsteen worked himself down to a nub trying to achieve the perfect version of each song.

Despite initial plans to just put out a live album, Born to Run turned into an experience put to music, as the listener is transported to the Jersey boardwalks, looking for any means of escape from their dismal little existence. Whereas Springsteen may have been known as the new Dylan before this, this is the record that had the poetry, power, and heart of rock and roll and squeezed into one beautiful 40 minutes of music.

3. The Black Album - Metallica

With years of hindsight, it seems that Metallica fans still haven't come to a consensus about the Black Album. Despite this being the thrash metal legends' breakthrough to the masses, other purists still can't listen to this record, complaining that it was the moment that the band sold out. Though the music itself may have been a lot more simple, getting the result onto the tape was a totally different story.

Advertisement

As Bob Rock stepped up as the new producer, the push and pull between Lars Ulrich and James Hetfield started to reach an all time high. Documented in the Year and a Half of Metallica, the two co-captains of the group were not on the best of terms, with one instance where Hetfield said "if you want to hear it with vocals, GO SING IT." That's not even getting to the torture that happened on the Unforgiven, where Rock heckled Kirk Hammett until they got just the right solo they were hoping for.

While three of the members got divorced during the making of this record, it turned into one of the greatest victories in metal history, with hits like Sad But True and Nothing Else Matters culminating in one of the biggest tours the rock world had ever seen. After years of being the world's greatest underground metal band, these torturous sessions built up classic material whose heaviness hasn't dulled a bit.

2. Pyromania - Def Leppard

As Def Leppard came off of their album High N Dry, they were at a bit of a crossroads in their sound. Originally thrown in with the New Wave of British Heavy Metal, this new look was a much more polished affair that sounded like a pop flavored version of AC/DC. Producer Mutt Lange thought they could reach even bigger though, resulting in their first huge mainstream success with Pyromania.

Advertisement

While this album is absolutely perfect for what it is, Mutt's workman like mentality was more than Leppard could handle at the best of times. The original clash actually ended in guitarist Pete Willis being fired from the group, with Phil Collen brought in to play leads. On the other hand, not everyone was at the top of their game, with Joe Elliott comparing singing his vocal harmonies as akin to being on the frontlines in the Army.

One of the most difficult dustups happened with Rick Allen though, who blew up after his request to listen to the track was answered with "when I want your opinion Rick, I'll ask you for it." The actual album though turned into just the right kind of tunes to expose kids to the heavier side of rock, with down and dirty riffs laced with the same vocal layering you'd find on a Queen record. Once this started gaining traction, it was only a matter of time before Leppard became one of the biggest hard rock bands in the world.

1. The White Album - The Beatles

It was not necessarily the best time to be a Beatle at the end of the '60s. Despite coming out with some of the most impressive musical statements of all time on Sgt. Peppers and Revolver, the death of long time manager Brian Epstein marked the beginning of the end for the Fab Four. Though they tried to remedy that with a trip to India to study meditation, the White Album does show the uglier moments of the group's final days.

Advertisement

From the getgo, the Fabs were all on completely different creative wavelengths during the making of this record, with Lennon and McCartney writing their own distinctive songs without consulting each other. As such, most of this record runs like a bunch of solo material thrown onto a double album, with everyone at odds with each other's approaches to the songs. Things ended up getting so ugly that McCartney actually recorded a number of his tracks completely by himself with no input from his bandmates.

Then again, the White Album turned into one of the most enduring pieces in the Beatles' catalog, with classics like Blackbird, Dear Prudence, and George Harrison coming into his own as a songwriter on While My Guitar Gently Weeps. Sure, this album does have its sore spots, but this might be the most human record that these lads from Liverpool have ever made.

Advertisement