10 Rock Bands That Had More Than One Lead Singer
Two voices for the price of one.
The frontman role is a hard burden for any musician to carry. Sure, it might seem fun to lead the sing-alongs with your band night after night, but the idea of being the de facto leader of the group can tire even the most determined musical minds.
Even though many bands get by with just one guy up front, the smart ones spread the lead lines out to every one of their members. Whereas some bands are known for just having the one guy up front pumping out the hits, these bands have had plenty of songs where another member steps up to have a turn on the mic. But what constitutes having two lead singers?
For the ground rules, it has to be a musician who has more than one solo vocal performance to their name and works in tandem with the other singer. While someone like Keith Richards has taken his fair share of lead vocals on Stones records, the slipshot delivery doesn't warrant him a spot alongside Mick Jagger's snide delivery. Whether it's from the beginning of rock music or the new school of musical democracy, these are just a handful of bands who spread the vocal love across their catalog.
10. Blink-182
Pop punk tends to get a lot more hate than it is really deserves. Whereas some of the more cringey nostalgia acts like Simple Plan and Good Charlotte had their fair share of sore spots, groups in the genre's inception like Green Day and Weezer helped us move out of the doom and gloom we were getting after years of importing our music from the grungy Northwest. It may have been a little sophomoric at the best of times, but Blink-182 were the angsty bros you didn't realize you wanted.
Despite the more laughable memes that have come from songs like All the Small Things, these California brats' real appeal came from the fact that they had almost two separate frontmen. With the god amongst drummers Travis Barker letting his music do the talking, both Tom Delonge and Mark Hoppus offered two different sides of the teenage demographic, whether it be Delonge's delightful nasal whine or Hoppus' more subdued and thoughtful delivery.
Even when Tom decided to part ways to chase aliens, the arrival of Matt Skiba brought an even greater tinge to the group's usual formula, complete with a set of pipes that were as unnervy as they were passionate. Blink-182 might be a band that you remember blaring at the gym of your middle school, but when playing off one another, the vocal chemistry was actually fairly legit.
9. The Eagles
The entire rock universe has a bit of a love-hate relationship when it comes to The Eagles. Though their songs have been lauded as some of the greatest stand-alone singles in the rock canon, the loveable wacky persona of Joe Walsh has been upended by the snobbishness of someone like Don Henley far too many times to count. Despite the miles of baggage you have to go through to enjoy this band, their vocal game was always on another level.
For any normal rock band, Henley's croon would pretty much be all you need, which possessed the vocal grit and smoothness to sing both R&B and hard rock tunes in equal measure. Henley did share though, with Glenn Frey's easy-breezy vocals adding a bit of a folksy vibe to acoustic tunes like Lyin' Eyes. Those two songwriters could be more than any band could ask for, but these California rockers were almost spoiled by good singers, with both Randy Meisner and Timothy B. Schmit having just the right high voice to soar above the frontmen when singing harmony.
While Joe Walsh doesn't possess nearly the same amount of vocal power in his delivery, the goofball character he brings across in his performance gives him one notch above your average joker who tries to play rockstar for a day. The Dude might like to think otherwise, but when it comes to the raw execution of fantastic singing, you can't really do much better than these guys.
8. Genesis
Whenever you talk about prog, Genesis is the one band you turn to when you need the real head-y music. At a time when King Crimson was the baseline for the more complex sides of rock and roll, the work that these musical headcases made with Peter Gabriel was much more advanced than your everyday rock song, with tracks that would seem to go on for nine hours if they weren't careful. A musical mind as sharp of Gabriel's was so bright that the band didn't even realize they had two phenomenal singers for the price of one.
After Gabriel's departure in the mid '70s to pursue other musical ventures, these prog giants went through one singer after another before letting Phil Collins step up to the mic. Though Collins is notoriously blamed for "ruining" the band with later pop songs like That's All and Invisible Touch, his actual vocal delivery has been stellar throughout every album he's worked on.
Even when working outside the confines of Genesis, both Gabriel and Collins have flexed their chops in solo careers, where they continue to push the boundaries of where their music can go, whether it's through activism in Gabriel's case or on the stage with Collins. Genesis might not be as active as they were in their prime, but as long as one of these men are at the front, you won't need to worry about any diminishing returns.
7. The Who
It seems strange talking about the two singers in The Who when you take into account that Roger Daltrey... well... exists. Ever since he first graced the stage as part of the Mod scene, Daltrey's unshakeable wail has been the calling card for these rock legends, with a tone that has as much muscle as it does heart. Daltrey may be the soul of the band, but he is far from the only face at work on the band's classics.
Across the group's run in the late '60s and early '70s, some of their most memorable cuts have been made by both Pete Townshend and John Entwistle. On the surface, it's perfectly within Townshend's rights to sing songs that he actually composed, but when you hear the voice he's working with, it's much more suited to the slower ballads than the rip roaring performances you get out of Daltrey. Though Townshend may be the primary songwriter, each one of Entwistle's contributions are amazing on their own, as he brings a certain ruggedness to his songs like My Wife or Boris the Spider.
I will contest that Keith Moon does have a fair share of vocals on Who records, but his often piss-takes on songs are a bit too hilarious to actually be taken seriously. Rather than settle behind the one great singer in the band, the alternating microphone on Who songs gives the band much more character than most of the other high-profile acts of the late '60s.
6. Queen
It's almost comical thinking of Queen without Freddie Mercury up front. Even though there may have been competent singers alongside Mercury, who really needs them when you have one of the greatest frontmen in rock history right there at your disposal? However, the rest of the band members' voices are much more integral to the sound of Queen than most fans realize.
There's no disputing that Freddie has the most powerful voice out of them all, but the real character comes in with Roger Taylor. Across nearly all of the group's records, Taylor has at least one song where he belts out a more bluesy vocal, along with providing nearly all of the high harmonies to carry Freddie's melodies. Though Brian May's voice simply can't compete with his colleagues, his contributions to Queen from a vocal perspective brings a humanity to the band, be it on '39 or the breakdown of I Want It All.
Each of these men work so well on their own, but the way they constructed their vocals to symphonic perfection across every one of their albums set the bar for what was expected out of a professional pop singer. Unless you're one of like... the three people who haven't heard of this band, you're pretty safe no matter which member steps up to the front.
5. Oasis
There was pretty much no way of escaping Oasis if you grew up in the mid '90s. As the afterglow of grunge came and went, these Mancunian hopefuls became one of the biggest bands on the planet thanks to the one-two punch of Definitely Maybe and What's the Story Morning Glory?. It would have been good enough to have Liam Gallagher barking out the group's hits, but Noel Gallagher ended up getting in on the action a lot more often than not.
Though Liam's internal swagger is beyond reproach, the soulful tone of Noel's voice offers a much gentler approach to the songs he takes on. Whereas Liam's mix of punk-meets-Beatles works wonders on rockers like Headshrinker or Supersonic, you practically can't hear songs like Don't Look Back In Anger any differently unless they are belted out by Noel every single night.
After coming out of his shell on the second album, Noel quickly became a vocal force all his own, with almost every album growing to a practical even split between the two behind the mic. The Gallaghers were always known as the larger than life personalities of Oasis, so it was only fitting that by the time they broke in 2009, they had both grown accustomed to taking center stage whenever the time called for it.
4. System of a Down
System of a Down was a shimmer of light hanging across the nu metal scene. Whereas most bands were content to just count their money and complain about being rich and famous, these Californian headcases were writing scathing indictments of the governmental system that educated listeners and excited them at the same time. It's hard to carry subject matter that heavy, so System stepped up to the plate with two disparate vocalists.
Working almost like dual guitar players, the vocal team of Serj Tankian and Daron Malakian made for some of the most epic vocal performances of the nu metal genre, from the operatic singing of Question! to the beautiful harmonies at the tail end of Chop Suey!. Contrary to the typical lead singer dynamic, Malakian and Tankian sound almost nothing like each other, which gives each of their respective songs their own character.
While Serj's voice is much more nasally focused and eerily precise, Daron's more sophomoric vocal approach brings the perfect balance of angry and psychotic to every trade off they put on record. These kind of vocal styles could sound absolutely dreadful on paper, but whenever they're set to the ringing discord of nu metal guitars, Tankian and Malakian end up being exactly what you need.
3. Alice in Chains
There wasn't much focus on vocal technique in the early days of grunge. With the dubious exception of Soundgarden belter Chris Cornell, bands like Mudhoney and Nirvana had vocalists that had a lot of character in their voice but no real technical expertise to really bring them over the top. Vocals may have been an afterthought in the rainy city of Seattle, but Alice in Chains turned it into another world overnight.
While AIC's riffs were the draw for many mainstream metal fans, what really separated them from the pack was the harmony work going on between Layne Staley and guitarist Jerry Cantrell. Growing up singing in choir at school, Cantrell always found the perfect melodic lines to go with the song, whether it was the counterpoint on Man in the Box or the close opening vocals of Rooster. Even when Layne was falling apart due to drug problems, Jerry was still able to carry the band on songs like Heaven Beside You.
As opposed to other grunge titans relying on a bunch of effects pedals, the dual vocal work by both of these men held your attention just as much as any guitar solo could. Even though Layne isn't with us anymore, there will always be some spiritual energy in every one of Alice in Chains' early vocal showcases.
2. Linkin Park
In the early days of nu metal, it always felt like you got short changed in the vocal department. Even though it was exciting to hear guys like Jonathan Davis or Zack de la Rocha get busy behind a mic, the singing parts of their songs paled in comparison to the more seasoned rap verses they would spit. The rest of the nu metal scene didn't do much better, but a funny thing happened with Linkin Park at the turn of the century.
After the colossal success of Hybrid Theory in 2000, people were just starting to realize what they had on their hands here. Instead of one commanding vocal presence, Linkin Park offered the best of both worlds by combining the rap verses of Mike Shinoda with the metal vocals of Chester Bennington. That way, even if you couldn't get down with the more hip hop influenced vocals, there was another guy waiting just around the corner to blow you away with the hook line.
Even when the nu metal tag started to fade, this vocal tandem found more ways to stretch themselves, with Shinoda trying his hand at singing on some tracks and Bennington dialing in a more intense approach on tracks like Given Up and Blackout. Linkin Park might be looked at as the lighter side of nu metal, but the undeniable chemistry between Shinoda and Bennington is what helped put the sounds of detuned guitars and angsty vocals back on the charts.
1. The Beatles
Most rockstars can only hope to have a great frontman. No matter how many times you try your hand at singing your songs, it won't make any difference to the public unless you have the right person out front to deliver it to legions of fans. A good frontman can take you anywhere, but the Beatles ended up having four different lead singers among their ranks.
As opposed to the early days of rock and roll with the main star out front, the Fab Four always worked well playing off each other's vocal styles, with John Lennon's powerful croon set up against the loverboy charm of Paul McCartney. In addition to just being tremendous singers, each member had a versatility in their voice, from McCartney's mix of elegant ballads and hard rock fury to Lennon running the gamut between avant garde surrealism and perfect pop tendencies.
A duo of that caliber would be good enough, but the addition of George Harrison gave an intellectual side to the group's material, with songs like Here Comes the Sun and Something feeling much more mature than your typical rock love song of the day. The Liverpool moptops even found time for Ringo Starr to have a crack on the mic, where his loveable charm gets a chance to shine on songs like With a Little Help From My Friends. The Beatles had enough songwriting power for four different groups, but when they actually came together, it was enough to shape the face of rock as we knew it.