Fans love to imagine their favourite band as a tight-knit gang of best friends all in it together until the end, but how much of that is reality? Not much. The chances of getting four, five, or six band members to stick together through thick and thin across multiple decades is more difficult than anyone really appreciates. Being part of a band - especially a successful one - is more like a marriage (and look how many of those fail), only with a half dozen parties involved instead of just two. Oh, and a house and a whole lot of joint bank accounts, like many a marriage it's easy for bands to often become completely dysfunctional. For every U2 out there, there's a Nine Inch Nails - but you can't really even count NIN, given it's just Trent Reznor and whoever he feels like touring with any given year. Still, there are plenty of others that are actually bands (or at least were bands when they started) and who haven't gone through immense tragedy, whilst having a revolving door policy on membership. Some of these have managed to continue playing at a top level, while others have faltered - some worse than other, but all of them need a road map to figure out who's who at this point.
13. Black Sabbath
Coming in at thirteen (coincidentally the title of their most recent album) is the legendary Black Sabbath, who, with the exception of Bill Ward's absence from the current line-up, have been relatively stable in recent years. What took place before recent years is another matter. Of course, we all know that Ronnie James Dio replaced Ozzy Osbourne as lead singer for a while, and was quite successful in doing so, cementing a piece of rock history for himself in the process. However, through the 80s and 90s, Black Sabbath included the likes of Tony Martin, Ian Gillan, Glenn Hughes, and Ray Gillen on vocals. Not to mention Vinny Appice and Eric Singer on drums for a while, and Dave Spitz on bass (as well as several others). In fact, the only constant in Black Sabbath over the years, besides change, has been Tony Iommi. He has remained with the band since day one, whilst in total, twenty-two people have been part of Sabbath not counting session players!
12. AC/DC
Bon Scott isn't the only member AC/DC has lost over the years, only the biggest and most tragic. Of course, last year, the band lost Malcolm Young to illness (reportedly early onset dementia). Prior to that, the band had been stable for a time, but early on, it had enough membership swaps to have the official band member count clock in at twenty-one, and that's without session players being counted in the mix. Then there's the up-in-the-air status of Phil Rudd, who was charged in 2014 with attempting to hire someone for a murder (as you do) and drug charges. The murder charge was quickly dropped, but Rudd is still fighting the drug charges and not currently touring with the band, who have re-hired former drummer Chris Slade - Rudd's original replacement when he left the band previously.
11. Warrant
While they're a long way removed from their "Cherry Pie" days, Warrant actually are still around - sort of. They last toured, without late lead singer Jani Lane, in support of the 21st anniversary of Cherry Pie. Robert Mason has been on vocals for the band since 2008. Lane died in 2011 of acute alcohol poisoning. Prior to his passing, however, the band had become a revolving door act with twenty three members, additional session and touring musicians taking the number upwards of fifty, not to mention "Jani Lane's Warrant" in 2006, which saw Lane tour with his own version of Warrant - leading to legal action from the rest of the original band to stop him from doing so.
10. Anthrax
Anthrax, one of the "big four" of Thrash Metal, have long lived in the shadow of the other three, namely Metallica, Megadeth, and Slayer. While very successful in their own right, Anthrax has never really broken into the mainstream, and over time, have had their ups and downs - in success and membership! Over the years they have featured twenty-two different members officially in the band, including vocalists Joey Belladonna and John Bush. Scott Ian has been the only constant, though Charlie Benante has been on drums since the early 80s. Belladonna, meanwhile, has left and rejoined the band a couple of times.
9. Megadeth
It's (jokingly) called MegaDave for a good reason! When Dave Mustaine was dismissed from Metallica in the early 1980s, he opted to go out and found his own band, Megadeth. While never achieving the success of Metallica (who still had a couple of Mustaine's compositions on their early albums), Megadeth managed to reach impressive heights, most notably the early 90s album Countdown to Extinction. Considered one of the "big four" bands of thrash metal, Megadeth ensured that Mustaine was not just a footnote in musical history as "that guy kicked out of Metallica" - but recognizing who is in the band with him often requires a map and photo album to keep track of. Over the years Megadeth have had twenty members plus a handful of session players, proving it might just be MegaDave after all. However, recently founding bassist David Ellefson returned to the fold to continue with the new album.
8. Guns N' Roses
Admit it, you expected this one to be higher. Yet despite being something of a revolving door from the start when it comes to membership (founding guitarist and namesake Tracii Guns never even made it to the first record, nor did the late Ole Beich, the band's first bassist), Guns N' Roses have had something of a stable line-up since the mid-aughts, with only one notable change since 2006 or so. The most tumultuous period, of course, came after the implosion of the early 90s line-up: drummer Steven Adler (who had replaced Rob Gardner early on) was kicked out of the band due to substance abuse issues prior to the release of the Use Your Illusion albums, and founding guitarist Izzy Stradlin left before touring for that album even ended. After the final release featuring lead guitarist Slash, 1994's cover of The Rolling Stone's Sympathy for the Devil, the floodgates opened for a time - out were Slash and later Duff, in were a number of guitarists, and The Replacements' Tommy Stinson. The only constants were singer Axl Rose and keyboardist Dizzy Reed (UYI onwards). Stinson is now the third longest-serving member in band history. In recent years, both Izzy Stradlin and Duff McKagan have played shows with the band again, with Slash the only notable band member yet to return, at least part time, to the fold.
7. The Misfits
Seminal punk outfit The Misfits continue to tour, but to many older fans the band's line-up would be barely recognizable. The band was founded in 1977 by Glenn Danzig, then disbanded in 1983, though they would go on to become very influential after the breakup, and Danzig would find success with Samhain and solo. However, a legal battle with Danzig saw bassist Jerry Only and his brother Doyle take over the name in the mid 90s. In total between the two periods, there have been twenty members, including a Ramone - Marky Ramone on drums. Oh, and that doesn't count temporary and session members!
6. Iron Maiden
666 might be the number of the beast, but over 20 is where Iron Maiden sits as far as members to have played in the band - and that number fails to take into account touring musicians. Notable membership changes over the years have included multiple singer swaps, with Blaze Bailey filling in for the legendary Bruce Dickinson for most of the 90s. Prior to Dickinson, who joined in 1981, vocal duties were covered by Paul Day, Dennis WIlcock, and Paul Di'Anno (who was the first vocalist to actually record with the band). With all the turmoil it's a wonder that Maiden have been as successful as they have been. Up the irons!
5. King Crimson
The original prog rock band, King Crimson formed all the way back in 1968, with guitarist Robert Fripp the only member to stay the course since day one. Currently on their eighth lineup, the band has had no fewer than twenty-one members over the years, however that's not counting session and temporary players, which would take the band's count all the way up to thirty-five! That's a lot of changes for a band that, while not the most famous on this list, was extremely influential to the progressive rock and metal acts that followed it.
4. Fleetwood Mac
Fleetwood Mac comes in, officially, at a slim, trim sixteen members - but that's only counting "official" members and not the massive amount of touring and session players that more than doubles that number! The band, which had hits with Albatross early on and songs like Dream and Don't Stop with Stevie Nicks (who joined in 1974, well after Albatross), also had some further membership confusion in the mid 70s, when a "fake" Fleetwood Mac began touring featuring precisely zero members who were every officially with the band. "Fake" Mac came to be when the band's manager, Clifford Davis, claimed he owned the Fleetwood Mac name, and in essence assembled a scab band to tour in their place. "Members" were told that Bob Welch and John McVie had quit the group and that Mick Fleetwood would be joining them, but soon after the truth became apparent, and the plug was quickly pulled. Thankfully, things are a little more sane today.
3. Whitesnake
With a staggering forty official members in the band over the years, Whitesnake have almost become a rock n' roll punchline, but were still considered relevant enough to make VH1's Top 100 Rock Bands of all time. Formed by David Coverdale in 1978 after his departure from Deep Purple, he would go on a number of hiatuses and once folded the band completely for several years - meaning the time window in which those forty members, including Steve Vai, Vivian Campbell and many others - came and went was even shorter! Still not done with the revolving door process, Whitesnake's most recent lineup change came in August 2014 when former Nightwish guitarist Joel Hoekstra joined the band.
2. Iron Butterfly
The psychedelic rockers behind In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida got back together recently and put out a new album in 2014, marking yet another return for Iron Butterfly. And with over sixty members plus session players having come and gone over the years, you might not recognise them! Back in 1966, the band was formed with Doug Ingle, Jack Pinney, Greg Willis, and Danny Weis. How many of those are in the band's current lineup? Exactly zero, though drummer Ron Bushy joined shortly after the band formed, and current vocalist/guitarist Mike Pinera has been there since 1969. The remainder of the band, however, all joined in 2014 or later, with the exception of keyboardist Martin Gershwitz who joined in 2005.
1. Pigface
You might not know who Pigface are, and it might be a bit of a cheat including them here as they're not the most famous band around, but they have had a quite ridiculous amount of membership changes, with a number that is completely astronomical in terms of band members: over 100. The band was born out of industrial pioneers Ministry by Martin Atkins, who was touring with the band, and William Rieflin, Ministry's regular drummer at that point. Pigface can really be though of as more of a collaboration, having seen the likes of Trent Raznor (early in his career), Danny Carey, Flea, and Wayne Static among its ranks, but it is actually signed to a label, and has put out six albums since 1991, with 2009's 6 as its most recent. Are there any we missed? Let us know in the comments!