Eminem: 10 Most Overrated Songs

An abysmal ten from the legendary Eminem.

By Callum Marsh /

In his outrageous, bedazzling and exceedingly controversial career, Eminem has penned well over 250 tracks and has a plethora of feature credits to his name. So, understandably, a catalogue containing that much music entails that not everything in his glittery repertoire is exactly going to be gold.

Advertisement

When at his best, Eminem is an unstoppable force of lyrical magnificence, as much as he is a provocateur for maliciousness, and just like everybody in the 313, a lot of us have followed him for quite some time.

Despite this, even the most faithful of Slim supporters have to admit that sometimes, the former phenom had definitely led them down an arduous culdesac.

Whether it's the road to recovery, a relapse that made us want to kamikaze ourselves, or a revival that should've remained incapacitated, to put it lightly, these songs have either retrospectively lost their charm or veraciously failed to amuse, intrigue or immerse as much as initially anticipated.

"And let's clear this up too. I ain't got no beef with him either. He used to be like a hero to me."

10. Fall

While the lyrical content is fine - even quite sharp at times - the hype surrounding this track was simply unjustified. Which is something that could easily apply to the album it came from too.

Advertisement

After Slim's last few mediocre efforts didn't necessarily bomb commercially but failed to resonate with the average consumer as well as the loyalest of fans, he released the Kamikaze album. An album that was slated to be a return to form for the fallen giant, and this song essentially acted as a proverbial middle finger to those who slated him in reference to the foregone albums.

As mentioned previously, the song itself isn't too bad. It's technically well written. Eminem's flow is typically rhythmic and the subject matter is something that more than elicits the reactionary song. The only reason it has just scraped its way onto this list is because of the ridiculously overzealous reaction the public had to it.

When Eminem starts throwing shout outs to Logic, Hopsin and J. Cole, everybody collectively lost their mind(s) and of course, the internet had a lot of fun speculating whether this could be a precursor to future collaborations between Em and the others in question. It eventually did with Logic, but yet again, that wasn't exactly Eminem before him and his party days had all pretty much parted ways.

9. River

If you strip this song of the one element that makes it work, then Ed Sheeran would've missed out on a substantial amount of profit and Eminem would've been left with a song that makes him sound like nothing more than an irredeemable misogynistic !*$% who contradicts himself with every bar. Honestly, the veteran has fewer bars than a decimated prison in this song and his declining skill is very prevalent here.

Advertisement

The incredulous subject of this song alone is enough to turn some people off, or it would be if it was written by a majority of other artists, as Eminem has proven time and time again that he can take the most sinister or sadistic of ideas and turn it into a bonafide hit. He's kind of like the rapping alternative to Trey Parker, but unlike his counterpart, this song - about him forcing a woman to get an abortion - is just offensive with nothing to say.

When he has something that may sound profound or intelligent, he completely debauches the delivery. The listener already knows quite early on just what the song is about and then he undermines and utterly destroys his message with lines like "And you don't f**k with no man's girl, even I know that".

Apparently you don't, Em. That's exactly what you've done and now she's pregnant, you fool.

8. Just Lose It

It was easy to see why Eminem went on what was supposed to be a permanent hiatus following the release of his not so seminal album Encore during the mid-2000s. If the song FACK didn't prove that Eminem was quickly running out of ideas, then this one definitely does. Just Lose It commercially exceeded expectations and even reached number one in a few countries despite its lacklustre lyrics and lack of a chorus, but just to clarify, Eminem was completely untouchable within the zeitgeist at this time. He could've recorded a three minute long fart and it would have sold.

Advertisement

He might as well have.

Just Lose it is an appropriate title, because it sounds like it entails Eminem's inner tumultuous feelings at the time. Even if it was a cathartic release of inhibitions that the rapper felt at that point, he could've done a lot better than this.

The Michael Jackson jokes were outdated even then, the juvenile humour and straight up offensive punchlines with neither no setup nor commentary felt tired and contrived and the biggest offender, the chorus - or lack thereof - was just Eminem saying Just Lose It with a couple of seconds of screaming proceeding it. It was painfully unfunny and listening to it today is as monotonous as it is unnecessary.

7. Beautiful

This song feels like it should've been the B-side to When I'm Gone, but with that songs flawless depiction of a man struggling to cohere to the most important facet of his life, his family, and announcing his retirement in hopes of repairing what was broken in his personal life, Beautiful feels like the aftermath of trying to repair both his rap career and the aforementioned, with the song severely suffering as a result.

Advertisement

The most depressive melody, lyrics and idea for a song which unfortunately nestles into the mind of listeners due to its fairly catchy hook, Beautiful is an amalgamation of all of Eminem's worst qualities.

The self-loathing, the hopelessness in his voice, and the idea that nothing will bring him happiness in life other than the rap career that he's slowly falling away from is just spirit-crushing. It's so disheartening to fans to know that the same guy who was once making songs like The Real Slim Shady and Without Me could fall this far down the spiral. Even Like Toy Soldiers - which was a song about gang violence and the resulting deaths of those around Slim - was not anywhere near as depressing as this.

6. Love The Way You Lie

For a long time this was Eminem's biggest hit, but eventually the juggernaut had to die and like the old saying goes, the bigger they are, the harder they fall. Eminem's career didn't distinctly decline immediately after, but the signs of regression were certainly creeping in in the shady aftermath that ensued.

Advertisement

The song certainly deserves praise for tackling something so heinous as domestic abuse and many people probably prospered from hearing this, based on that alone, it is a song that has more of a reason for existing than most of the shovelware excreted onto the market these days and is excruciatingly crucial to our societal progression. The only problem, though, is that it feels like the same old song and dance regurgitated from a multitude of Eminem's previous works. We all know his parable about Kim. Probably more than we do our own extended families at this point, and not only does he refuse to breathe new life into a dwindling storyline, but the amount of effort put into it is laughable.

The Skylar Grey written hook is extremely memorable and even influential to a degree, but other than "Life is no Nintendo game" and "I guess that's why they call it window pane", "I'm her Superman, with the wind in his back, she's Lois Lane" - which do not actually all appear in the same verse and are all awful lyrics by the way - show Eminem utilising a very subjugated rhyme scheme.

Does anyone actually remember his verses?

5. Venom

It may seem unfair to hold a soundtrack song to the same standards as Eminem's own personal catalogue of work, but in a world where we've had Celine Dion's My Heart Will Go On, Whitney Houston's I Will Always Love You and even the eponymous Eminem's Oscar-winning "Lose Yourself", Venom is simply just a load of overblown noise with Eminem occasionally chiming in to utter a few passive connotations.

Advertisement

Just like Fall, Venom released on Eminem's less than stellar Kamikaze album and ironically, mimicking the motion picture it starred in, it was another over-hyped hit that didn't deserve the praise it received. The song itself, while not exactly alleged to be one of Eminem's most masterful works, proves almost immediately that it will not be, as the chorus or hook - if you can call it either of those - just sounds like Eminem making a lot of strange noises while infrequently saying Venom in a whiny voice.

The spotlighted component called into question is yet again the lyrics, some of the lyrics in his other songs have been loosely attached to what precedes or proceeds them, but in Venom, it's written like an editor had just undergone laser eye surgery with varying results of success. L-l-lick a salad bowl and Edgar Allan Poe, just simply do not go together, no no no.

Rectified.

4. Berzerk/Walk On Water/Darkness

If the music industry handed out Golden Raspberry awards, then it wouldn't be an exaggeration to say that you're looking at three prime candidates with these egregious, mark missing singles.

Advertisement

Berzerk. One only wonders whether berserk was how Eminem was feeling when penning this poor track. Eminem's music normally has a ton of content to decrypt, but Berzerk doesn't even sound like it belongs to the same artist's repertoire. It's overdeveloped, unpolished and maybe even unfinished. It's worst offence, though, is that it is an absolute chore to listen to.

Walk on Water just immediately flat lines from its opening line. The opening line, which is the most lazily sung piece of music by Beyonce in her entire career, combined with the worst chorus in Eminem's library which isn't only boring, it's straight up insulting to fans who expect at least adequate music from the pair. This song is just abysmal from start to finish and feels like it was written by a 10-year-old. Avoid at all costs.

Darkness is undoubtedly the best of these three, with little resistance from the other two. The only reason that Darkness appears here is that despite Marshall having the best of intentions at heart, the entire song - and the video that accompanies it - just come off as an insensitive chance to reiterate a real-life tragedy to generate currency. It feels gross for Eminem to attempt pulling off something this sincere when he used to drop lines like "I take seven kids from Columbine, stand 'em all in line, add an AK-47, a revolver, a nine"

3. Godzilla

Felling like the spiritual successor to Rap God, a song which is a feat that can only be impressive the first time round due to it leaning far too heavily on Eminem's skill rather than the songs resplendent non-sequiturs that admittedly do work, but just don't adhere to structural songwriting, Godzilla is just a rinse and repeat of the former and a very soulless one at that.

Advertisement

The only real uniqueness this song imbues is the feature artist - Juice WRLD - who does a commendable job and throws down one of his best verses before his unfortunate, untimely death.

Outside of the aforementioned, there really isn't anything to grasp on to here. There's no message, nothing interesting or remotely clever and more than anything it revokes the tendencies that made everyone fall in love with Eminem in the first place, shamelessly hiding behind the moniker of another auspicious franchise, probably because a new Godzilla film was on the horizon and a quick Google search for the bestial reptile would've led people to realise that Eminem has a new song out.

2. Space Bound

The titular Space Bound, just like the album it was featured on, is an overrated, too tonally serious and overall pleasure devoid, embarrassing amplification of nothing but sheer misery from a once highly admired musician. Obviously in Eminem's decadent, vastly decorated career, it's assured that at least a few songs would considerably slip away from his high standards, but this one simply didn't even deserve the airplay it received at the time. It shouldn't have even been released as a single, never mind charted.

Advertisement

The song is the atypical sort of rap song, which should be an indication of the mundanity to come as Eminem didn't make average rap music until then. The productions fine, not sumptuous but competent. The lyrics, contrarily, are laughable.

With the now infamous - "Cause I've been treated like dirt befo' ya And love is evol. Spell it backwards, I'll show ya." - exemplifying one of, if not, Eminem's biggest blunder, as well as being one of the most witless lines in all of music. It's hard to believe it came from the same brain as Stan, Business and The Real Slim Shady.

You can get away with rhyming oranges and syringes Mathers, but love is not evil backwards sir.

1. Not Afraid

I'm not afraid, to take a stand.

Advertisement

... Against what exactly? No one knows.

The emptiest, most hollow excuse of a single ever released by Eminem proved that the once revered mastermind of the rude lucrative lyrics can no longer embellish the title or put the youth in hysterics.

Although Crack a Bottle was in actual fact his comeback song, this one was touted as his full return to the mainstream and upon hearing it, if this was all he was bringing to the table going forward, then maybe a hunger strike was starting to look increasingly appealing.

On surface level, the song is clearly an allegory that references at least one aspect of how Eminem's life has been going since his short retirement, but it's never exactly clear what he's eluding to. It doesn't encapsulate a feeling through its overbearing overtones of dramatisation, instead the song really suffers from sounding like it belongs to an early 2000s Marvel movie.

What was clearly supposed to be an effort that packed with impact came across as an exercise in tedium and borderline genericism. Proving that just like sleeping dogs, the giants that bear the same restraint can awaken once again, but sometimes it's best to leave them to rest.

Advertisement