Fans have taken their fiction in amazing and surprisingly lucrative directions. Some have been modified and outsold their famous source material. There are now authorized distribution services for fan fiction derived from certain intellectual properties. Some mainstream authors have admitted they habitually write fan stories or got their start doing so. In short, fan fiction is proving a surprisingly legitimate art form. And like all art forms, it generates a lot of creepy content. It doesn't matter if the source material is horrifying itself or innocuous enough for children, some creep has come along and turned it into the stuff of nightmares. Usually he or she did it intentionally. In fact writers of this type that want to scare people seem to prefer using children's entertainment for their unsettling scenarios. The characters will be especially unsuited to function under horrific conditions and the creepiness stands out in sharper relief when put in a pleasant setting. Read on if you dare!
10. The Contract
Fanfic Of: House Plot: Dr. Gregory House is forced to sign a contract written in blood. It stipulates that he is to allow himself to be tortured however and whenever an anonymous villain chooses. Any attempt to tell anyone of the contract will result in the death of House or someone close to him (the other party ultimately turns out to be a wealthy politician with connections to the crime world as the reason he's able to pull this off). House's constant anxiety and anger at being a torture toy alienates all his coworkers and when his coworker Wilson is murdered, he is framed and sent to prison. Commentary: The Contract's 41,000 word obsession with seeing Gregory House suffer is itself quite disquieting, but writer DIYSheep's obsession with insisting the story is actually a profound piece of art by dressing it up with flowery language is truly unpleasant. But worse is that apparently The Contract managed to attract a devoted and active fanbase since it was written in 2006. So many spinoffs and expansions were written, all about House being tortured, that the "Contractverse" stretches out to a staggering million words. Sure, Gregory House was always meant to be a prickly character, but a surprising number of fans were apparently gleefully imagining Hugh Laurie being cut and beaten while watching the show. Read It Yourself (NSFW)
9. Axis Powers Hetalia Episode 23.5
Fanfic Of: Hetalia: Axis Powers Plot: A kid is watches a bootleg DVD of the strange but popular cartoon Hetalia: Axis Powers (a show where the nations of the world are represented by apparently quite dense single humans named for the countries they represent. For example, because Italy's military had a reputation for performing ridiculously incompetently during WWII, the character Italy is a comical blunderer). He finds a surprising, unfamiliar episode 23.5 on the disc. In the episode Japan, Germany, and Italy are stranded on an island. Driven to desperation by hunger, Germany and Japan try to drown Italy and prepare him for eating. To their surprise, Italy wakes up in the middle of being prepared. After some struggle, Italy accepts his fate with a smile. No answers are forthcoming as to where this macabre episode came from. Commentary: Hetalia was always a story in pretty questionable taste for how it portrayed WWII in such a ridiculous, barely satirical manner that was rather flippant about the horrors inflicted by the Axis. Despite that, the descriptions of realistic gore in the story and the idea of anyone waking up to find they're being eaten alive are likely to overwhelm any feelings of righteous indignation you might feel over the premise of the cartoon. Still, author Kyokoon64 does lend the story of the evil episode of this anime an air of mystery and doesn't overdo the gore enough for it to become tedious. Read it Yourself (NSFW)
8. NES Godzilla Creepypasta
Fanfic Of: Godzilla Monster of Monsters Plot: A guy named Zachary is playing this 1986 game. Initially the game just seems to have some odd glitches and characters from the Godzilla franchise that curiously didn't appear until after the game was released. But as he keeps playing, aspects of the game get worse and worse. The game itself seems more aware and more dangerous than Zachary ever would have thought possible. Commentary: Despite the ridiculous premise, username Cosbydaf is able to sell it through his careful pacing, inspired horror imagery, and exceptional illustrations. Readers were particularly fond of the villain "Red," whom manages to look a bit creepy even rendered in 8-bit in a game full of monsters. It should be noted that a good many readers had issues with the ending of the story. So much so that Cosbydaf decided to write a parody ending, which is never a good sign. However, he has also begun a sequel which addresses (and retcons) some of the issues that fans had with the original tale, though the tone of it is meant to be more weird than the original story. Read it YourselfRead the Sequel Yourself
7. Dipper Goes To Taco Bell
Fanfic Of: Gravity Falls Plot: When Dipper goes to Taco Bell, eating a taco naturally gives him the runs. In the bathroom stall he cuts and bleeds out. Then his sister goes in, finds him, and dies too. An employee goes in, finds the bodies, and decides the only way to dispose of them is to process them for taco meat. Commentary: Remember how in the previous entry I complimented the story's pacing, imagery, and all that? None of that applies here. This is merely a vile story that goes so far over the line it starts to become funny, but then it just becomes revolting again. With that in mind, it's hard to quantify its literary value. Believe me, the above description is an extremely sanitized version of this story. If you do decide to read it, it will be difficult to not imagine the author creating this story and get some goosebumps. That is, if you're not too busy vomiting. Read it Yourself (NSFW. Also, don't. Just don't.)
6. Ben Drowned
Fanfic Of: The Legend Of Zelda: Majora's Mask Plot: Username Jadusable (also the username of the author) stops at a garage sale where an elderly fellow sells him a copy of The Legend Of Zelda: Majora's Mask. On the cartridge is a game file labeled BEN, which seems to contain a number of very unpleasant glitches and unsettling components. When he transfers some of the data from the cartridge to his computer to share it online and prove his story, Jadusable soon learns there's a hostile, manipulative intelligence that's now on his computer that goes by the name of Cleverbot, and it might not just be AI. Commentary: Begun in September 2010, BEN DROWNED is essentially the first internet video game horror story to gain much attention. While the story has many of the positive attributes in common with NES Godzilla Creepypasta, the real standout is the character (if you can call it that) of Cleverbot. Cleverbot isn't related to the website. Hell, it isn't clear exactly what Cleverbot is. Nevertheless its conversations with the discombobulated protagonist are understated and sadistic enough that it seems a credible threat even without any clear ability to inflict physical harm. Additionally instead of just doing sprite edits like the ones done for NGC, Jadusable created videos of the creepy glitches described in the story to offer it more credibility. They're all completely SFW but the way bodies of the sprites are modified, the abrupt cuts, and the distorted music all make for a much more disquieting experience than anything to do with a story about a haunted video game cartridge should be able to provide. Here's a sample video:Read it Yourself
5. Bad Ends
Fanfic Of: Avatar: The Last Airbender Plot: Bad Ends isn't so much a single story as a series of eleven very short stories unified by a morbid theme. Basically every plot point in the show where one of the characters was seriously in danger but got bailed out before they experienced lasting harm has been changed for the worse. Commentary: Imagine if instead of being a cartoon suitable for Nickelodeon, Avatar: The Last Airbender had been written by a particularly grim parody of George R. R. Martin. Seriously, even the edgy comedians at Robot Chicken wouldn't write fates for the characters like many of these. Author Shadow Wasserson seemed to be making a sincere effort over two years to write these stories with taste and tact. He isn't graphic in describing violence for the most part and tries to rely more on suggestion than bloodthirsty descriptions of harm. But the idea is so pointless and repetitive that you have to question why he bothered to do the same thing over and over again, particularly with some of the taboos that get broken. And yet almost none of these outcomes are worse than the 2010 movie The Last Airbender being made. Read it Yourself (NSFW)
4. The Challenge Of The Superfriends: The End
Fanfic Of: DC's Superfriends Plot: The Legion of Doom has gotten in touch with monstrous beings from another dimension. Instead of assisting Luthor and company in their schemes, the Legion is taken prisoner and biologically altered in rather frightening ways while the Superfriends respond to this interdimensional terror Commentary: With his story at 139,000 words in length, author Denizen1 takes his time building up to and doing the horrific scenes of comic book villains being changed in grisly ways. In incidents like Chapter 15, the character of Scarecrow gets his face pecked off by a crow. The detail and description is quite vivid. And that's one of the milder fates suffered in this story. If you want some socially redeeming value, perhaps the whole thing could be interpreted as a deconstruction of the whole idea of making comic characters darker and edgier. Maybe it's even a criticism of the idea of enjoying watching bad guys being punished, with how drawn out and tortuous some of the fates in it are. Although if you're looking for creepy fanfics, you probably weren't in the first place. Read it Yourself
3. Cupcakes
Fanfic Of: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Plot: Rainbow Dash (the jock of the show's main ensemble) visits the bakery Pinkie Pie (the party character) works at when Pinkies alone. Rainbow is given a drugged cupcake and wakes up strapped to a slab in a room Pinkie Pie has decorated with organs made to resemble party balloons, streamers, etc. Pinkie herself is in a dress made of patches of skin from other horses. Dash is mutilated, gutted, and then killed by her cheerful friend in a prolonged manner presented with very graphic detail. Commentary: Cupcakes may well be the most viral fanfic that has never been professionally published. There are countless dramatic readings, several comic illustrations, and people have even done cosplays of it. On top of all that, it's been animated time and again. Not bad for a story written in six hours which the author thought was a botched job because he didn't include enough humor to offset the horror. Of the animations, by far the most fun and professional one is by MisterDavey. It's good enough that when he jokingly claimed that he is an animator at Hasbro, people bought it: NSFW:The most disturbing animation by far is an unfinished cartoon by Suppa. Despite the less-than-polished animation, the sound mixing and voice acting by Vannamelon more than makes up for it. It's also pretty much the only serious adaptation, with just about every other making a point of including the comedy that Sprinkles (the author) failed to include in his version. NSFW:Read it Yourself (NSFW)
2. My Little Dashie
Fanfic Of: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Plot: An everyman in a generic rundown city finds a box with the living cartoon character Rainbow Dash in it as a foal. He raises her as his own "daughter" and fifteen years later the other cartoon characters come to bring them to her animated home world. Commentary: What, no gore, monsters or torture? No content that would be generally considered NSFW? Not even anything that would be considered a horror trope? Not only all that, but the story's actually meant to be a heartwarming tale? How can it possibly be included here? The nameless protagonist is why. It's not made explicit in the story, but there are many parts sprinkled throughout which make him seem like a loathsome sociopath. Describing how his neighborhood is full of litter, he says he doesn't see the point in picking it up if the other "people" don't bother to maintain it, with people actually in quotes like his neighbors are a bunch of potential subhumans. Later on, after an incident where he has an argument with Rainbow Dash, he describes that as the worst day of his life, even worse than "the day of (his) parent's deaths." At the beginning of the story he describes how when he watched the cartoon he would try to reach his way into "that beautiful world... only to be stopped by my computer screen." He's clearly not a very well-balanced person, and yet the story unironically treats their relationship like a beautiful thing sadly cut short. That's much more creepily revealing than all the intentional horror in the other entries on this list. Unfortunately many of the fans of My Little Pony saw this creepy person as identifiable, and so it became one of the other most viral stories on the internet. Bronies were practically tripping over each other to make movies where they told the world that they were that guy. To date only one has actually finished theirs and failed to remove the creepy aspects of the main character:Read it Yourself
1. Agony In Pink
Fanfic Of: Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Plot: The villain Lord Zedd discovers torture manuals for the KGB, CIA, and so on which merge into a sentient being named Tortura. They then kidnap the Pink Ranger and at length graphically torture her to death. Commentary: Way back in 2000, Agony in Pink managed to achieve media mainstream attention by being reviewed by the Australian Broadcasting Authority and subsequently causing the site to be banned on that continent. It also is the most unsettling entry on this list because since it was written in 1995 it predates the idea of intentionally bad stories or a troll fics (like the aforementioned Cupcakes) as a popular internet concept by some years. The author The Dark Ranger was sufficiently pleased with the attention his story received that he released a Special Edition of the story where he fixed the grammatical and spelling errors, included illustrations, and added commentary. One of the most notable things about that edition is that Dark Ranger bothered to tell readers that the story was about the Pink Ranger being tortured to death, not the actress Amy Jo Johnson who played her. He claimed to be disturbed that some readers did not make that distinction. Which just goes to show, even people with torture/murder fetishes can be disturbed by some stuff on the net. Read it Yourself (NSFW) DId you enjoy these stories? Are there any you feel should have been included? Let us know in the comments below!