10 Hidden Gems From Edinburgh Festival 2019

Here are all the funny bits the critics missed.

By Jane Frost /

Every year, literally thousands of hopeful performers descend upon the Edinburgh Festival, along with thousands more tourists and art lovers hoping to see something special.

Advertisement

The costs of performing in Edinburgh can be astronomical. Many performers save up all year or put themselves into debt just to pay for accommodation alone. That’s before you look at the cost of paying for advertising or hiring a PR to secure you interviews and reviews.

Some performers reap the rewards of this investment with stacks of glowing reviews, award nominations, even TV deals. With so many performers vying for attention though, loads of brilliant performers get lost in the shuffle. Especially if they can’t afford to compete in the PR arms race.

With that in mind and with the fringe wrapped up for another year, here, in no particular order, are ten shows that managed to wow us in Edinburgh this year despite mostly flying under the radar.

You might have missed these guys even if you did make the trip to the Fringe this year, but don’t make the same mistake if they turn up to perform somewhere near you in the near future!

10. Tom Toal - Mediocre Boy

Gentle storyteller Tom Toal complains in his show this year that he’s been suffering from writer’s block. Don’t be fooled: this is a show brimming over with ideas and jokes.

Advertisement

One of the brains behind the After All This Time, Always Podcast, Toal is a warm and inclusive performer with an easy charm.

His show this year is inspired by the Sarah Hagi quote, “Lord grant me the confidence of a mediocre white man.” From there, Toal spirals off into all sorts of observations and anecdotes both about his own lack of confidence and the sometimes underserved confidence he observes in those around him.

Mediocre Boy is a show at its most engaging when it broaches the subject of parenthood. Toal obviously delights in his daughter and his role as a father. At the same time however, he’s anxious not to screw her up, to politely paraphrase Philip Larkin, another of the show’s references.

9. Sons And Co. - Let’s Get Tough

The misleadingly named Sons and Co. are sketch duo Fiona Simpson and Imogen Edmundson. The two play a classic double act dynamic, with Simpson the self-proclaimed “sexy one” and Edwards her put upon sidekick.

Advertisement

The show is filled with wilfully silly sketches with simmering tensions between the two escalating across the hour. The show is a self defence manual for those of us who need defending from colleagues, family and friends.

Highlights include Edwards playing the pair’s male friend Paul, a cipher for toxic masculinity and a “massive fool.”

The show hits it peak with Simpson forcing Edmundson into a practice date with an audience member. It’s a masterclass on how to do crowd work that heaps faux-embarrassment on the act themselves and spares the audience member any humiliation.

Both stand up comedians in their own right, Sons and Co. make for a delightfully entertaining pair. This debut show is hopefully just the start of a fruitful collaboration.

8. Kate Smurthwaite - Bitch

A savvy, intelligent show about the consequences of being a woman in the public eye with opinions, Bitch is Kate Smurthwaite's fifteenth Edinburgh show - and it is incredible.

Advertisement

As the audience files in, Kate has a slideshow playing every YouTube comment containing the word "bitch" that was left on just one of her public appearances. Each slide is shown for four seconds. To see all of them, you would have to arrive 25 minutes early; a sobering thought.

This is a show that pulls absolutely no punches – and yet, Kate is blisteringly funny, making you gasp, recoil and guffaw in equal measure. As well as reclaiming the word 'bitch', the show is gilded with hilarious stories from her dating life, anecdotes (and invitations to the protests) from her work with asylum seekers, and an explanation of why people who order takeaway breakfasts have caused Brexit.

7. Martin Pilgrim - I Write Jokes Not Tragedies

Martin Pilgrim is something of a joke machine. You only need to check out his twitter feed to see how prolific he is at coming up with smart, intricately worded one-liners.

Advertisement

Many shows at the Fringe see people going on some sort of personal journey, having revelations about themselves or experiencing personal growth. Martin Pilgrim has tried and frankly mastered that style in the past. You can see for yourself as his whole 2017 show Sadulthood is available to watch on Youtube.

This year however he decided to turn away from long form narrative or emotional heft, instead focusing on just relentlessly pursuing the funny. The result was one the single funniest shows at the Fringe this year with wall to wall gags delivered in Pilgrim's diffident, downbeat style. Few comedians working today can match his gag rate in terms of both quantity and quality.

6. Ignacio Lopez - EspañYOLO

As Edinburgh shows go, EspañYOLO might be the very definition of a hard sell. Ignacio Lopez freely admits that the idea of an hour of comedy about Spanish history won’t do much to pique the interest of the average Brit.

Advertisement

However, those who took a chance on this show will have been glad they did. Many of the facts and stories about Spain are genuinely fascinating with Lopez demonstrating a depth and breadth of knowledge on the subject. Crucially, however, the Spanish comic is also a talented writer and performer, able to deftly sprinkle well crafted jokes throughout.

One stand out routine involves a Spanish WW2 spy double crossing Hitler. It’s inherently amusing stuff but Lopez elevates the story to another level with his quick and generous wit.

The BBC Sesh star has racked up over 10 million views online so you can expect to see more from this gifted stand up.

5. Lubna Kerr - Where Are You Really From?

Making her debut show this year, Lubna Kerr is the newest act on this list, but a very promising and exciting new voice.

Advertisement

Ostensibly, this is a show about xenophobia, as summed up by the title - as a Scottish-Pakistani woman Lubna tells us about how she often gets asked the dreaded "But where are you REALLY from?" by strangers. But in fact, this is not a show that dives deep into the weighty issue of institutionalised racism in British society. Instead, Lubna chooses to look at it in a more positive light; it's a question whose roots are "What connections exist between us?", and she cheerfully compares it with equivalents from across Scottish and Pakistani culture.

It's a warm, funny, and inclusive show that believes everyone is looking for ways to connect with each other, and that we're all the same in the end.

4. Phil Cooper - Hamsters In Colour

One giant leap for mankind? A Valleys astronaut would’ve been WAY too chill for that ?

Posted by BBC Sesh on Thursday, 18 July 2019

There's a very faintly deranged edge to Phil Cooper, and not because he's a 'wacky' or surreal comedian. There's a beautiful sense of innocent, child-like wonder to the man that makes you question if he's the sort who, if left unattended for too long, might genuinely try to press items of silver jewellery against the family labrador *just in case* it had turned into a werewolf without him noticing.

Advertisement

This year, he's on form - after inheriting a house from his grandfather in South Wales, he's been trying to renovate the property while reflecting on the ways in which the two of them are similar to one another, and the ways in which they had nothing in common. What begins as a simple reflection on the relationship between a man and his late grandfather, though, becomes a wider exploration of generational differences, including how fashions in comedy itself have changed. This is warm, clever comedy at its best.

3. Chris Chopping - The Artist Currently Known As Chris Chopping

When you go to any lengths to learn Welsh ?

Posted by BBC Sesh on Friday, 26 July 2019

Chris’ show this year is a unicorn – an hour about the difficulties of being a lonely man trying to date that doesn’t blame women for having standards while claiming to be a nice guy. Instead, this well-crafted hour of comedy looks at incel culture, and the toxic misogyny that sees adult men accuse women of sleeping with literal dogs rather than admit that they themselves maybe aren’t that much of a catch.

Advertisement

Chris has a deft touch with his material, managing to neither become preachy, nor to overstep his social boundaries (he makes it clear several times that his perspective is a very privileged one, being as he's not on the receiving end of the breathtaking sexism he's highlighting). He also keeps the punchlines coming thick and fast, meaning the audience is constantly entertained. It’s an informative and eye-opening show – it’s also very, very funny.

2. Becky Brunning - Bloom

Becky Brunning is a quirky, offbeat comedian which might disguise just how much craft and skill lies behind her off kilter performances.

Advertisement

There is, however, no way to disguise how funny those performances are. The title may well be alluding to something else but Brunning is a talent very much in bloom this year.

In this, her third solo show, the West Country comic talks about how she got “accidentally gay-married” and is now feeling the pressure of a biological clock ticking down.

Engaging and smart, Brunning handles her tale’s emotional beats with a deft self assurance and maintains a lightness of touch where others might be heavy handed.

Brunning is still best known for her performance in ITV’s hit show Broadchurch and her acting ability is there in the nuances of her comic delivery. Surely her reputation as a comic will only grow to match her successes in the acting world.

1. Steffan Alun - You Can’t Escape Free Stand Up

This is Steffan’s fourth solo show, and the fourth year in a row he's intentionally kept to 40 minutes to avoid reviewers coming ("I've seen what happens when you get reviewers," he tells us knowingly at the start. "Your audiences come with Expectations. Not having that.") You have to wonder, though, just how many more times he can get away with this before reviewers come anyway.

Advertisement

The topic this year is his ill-fated attempt to have a real job in an escape room, an irreverent and charming tale – but it’s undercut by the revelation that he was also bullied this year for, among other things, his sexuality. With that sort of premise, this could have been a fairly heavy and uncomfortable show, but as ever, Steffan is witty, cheerful and intelligent, giving his subject matter all due deference while never losing the good mood of the room - or the laughs.

Advertisement